Unfair Dismissal · year
2023
1969 cases
Bus driver (over 30 years' service) v Midland Red South Ltd
A bus driver with over 30 years' service was awarded £25,000 after his employer repeatedly allocated shifts that did not meet his disability-related needs, causing him to soil himself at work.
Won · £25,000 · Dec 2023Won£25,000Dec 2023Work coach (2 years' service) v Department for Work and Pensions
An employment tribunal struck out a work coach's direct sex discrimination claim after she was dismissed for unauthorised searches, but allowed her discrimination arising from disability claim to proceed.
Partial · Dec 2023Partial—Dec 2023EFL Teacher (18 years' service) v Golders Green College & School of English Ltd
An EFL teacher with 18 years' service was constructively dismissed after her employer unilaterally imposed a zero-hours contract and refused union representation. The tribunal awarded £39,208.47.
Won · £39,208 · Dec 2023Won£39,208Dec 2023Installations Manager (20 years' service) v Park Lane Windows Ltd
A long-serving installations manager was constructively dismissed after being demoted twice without consultation. The tribunal awarded £24,331.
Partial · £24,331 · Dec 2023Partial£24,331Dec 2023Trade Promoter (20 years' service) v Korea Trade Investment Promotion Agency
The tribunal found the dismissal was procedurally unfair, but refused to award any compensation because after-dismissed evidence showed the employee had sought a secret commission from a customer.
Partial · Dec 2023Partial—Dec 2023Bus driver (13 years' service) v London Central Bus Company Ltd
A bus driver with 13 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after driving onto a pavement to overtake another bus. The tribunal rejected claims of race and religious discrimination.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Social worker (15 years' service) v Northern Care Alliance NHS Foundation Trust
A black social worker with 15 years' service lost her claims of race discrimination and constructive dismissal after an altercation with a white colleague. The tribunal found no evidence of stereotyping or unfair treatment.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Depot Infrastructure Technician (12 years' service) v Govia Thameslink Railway Limited
A depot technician with 12 years' service was dismissed after reversing a work van into a tree and attempting to repair the damage himself. The tribunal upheld the dismissal, finding it was for misconduct, not because of his protected disclosures.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Business Development Manager (6 years' service) v Mabey Hire Ltd
A Business Development Manager who resigned after his employer changed his commission scheme lost his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the commission was never contractual and the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee v Giuseppe Of Belgravia Limited
A former employee was unfairly dismissed but received only limited compensation because the tribunal found he would have been fairly dismissed a month later when the workplace closed. Total award: £12,419.29.
Partial · £12,419 · Dec 2023Partial£12,419Dec 2023Janitor (6 years' service) v Gentoo Group Ltd
A janitor with six years' service was fairly dismissed after CCTV and fob data showed he spent extended periods away from his post. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Senior HR Manager - Employee Relations v National Highways Ltd
A senior HR manager who resigned after accepting a higher-paid job failed to prove constructive unfair dismissal or discrimination. The Birmingham tribunal found no breach of contract by National Highways Ltd.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Housekeeping Assistant (2 years' service) v Athlone House Limited
A housekeeping assistant's unfair dismissal claim was struck out because UK sanctions on the company's owner made it illegal to pay her. The tribunal said the claim had no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Primary school teacher (19 years' service) v Trafford Council and The Governing Body of Kings Road Primary School
A primary school teacher with 19 years' service was unfairly dismissed for 'irretrievable breakdown' after she raised a grievance alleging race discrimination. The tribunal also found she was victimised.
Won · Dec 2023Won—Dec 2023Former employee (15 years' service) v Greggs plc
A former employee of Greggs plc who resigned after grievances were not upheld had her unfair dismissal claim dismissed because she presented it 26 days after the three-month time limit.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Before and after school club leader (2 years' service) v The Governing Body of St Michael’s Church of England School Middleton
A before and after school club leader who refused to attend work during the pandemic claiming serious and imminent danger has lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found her belief was not reasonable given the school's risk assessments.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee v Kings College London Florence Nightingale Faculty of Nursing, Midwifery and Palliative Care
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Kings College London was struck out because they did not have the required two years' service. Their discrimination claims were dismissed after a hearing.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Care home manager (7 months' service) v Porthaven Care Homes No2 Ltd
A care home manager who claimed he was automatically unfairly dismissed for raising concerns about resident safety lost his case. The tribunal found the decision-maker did not know about the disclosures and dismissed him for genuine belief in gross misconduct.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023General Manager (13 years' service) v Inspectorate Limited t/a Roch NDT Services
A General Manager with 13 years' service resigned claiming constructive dismissal after a dispute over a promised reward for a business sale. The tribunal rejected his claim but awarded £326.41 in unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £326 · Dec 2023Partial£326Dec 2023General administrative and sales assistant (3 years' service) v Mr John Kittelsen t/a Speedwell Cars
A father who told his daughter 'I don't have a job for you, in fact I hope I never see u again' in a WhatsApp message was found to have unfairly dismissed her. The tribunal awarded £13,977.58.
Won · £13,978 · Dec 2023Won£13,978Dec 2023Fish tank maintenance worker (3 years' service) v Glassbox Trading Limited T/a Aquatechniques
A fish tank maintenance worker who contracted a rare bacterial infection from work was not unfairly dismissed – the tribunal found he agreed to end his employment after being offered a different role with lower pay.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee v Mammoet UK Limited
A former employee's claims for constructive unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and age discrimination have been struck out after repeated failures to comply with tribunal orders and participate in hearings.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Former employee v South Coast Skips Limited (in Creditor’s Voluntary Liquidation)
A former employee was unfairly dismissed, wrongfully dismissed without notice, and discriminated against on grounds of sex. The tribunal awarded £16,208.68, including an uplift for the employer's failure to follow the ACAS code.
Won · £16,209 · Dec 2023Won£16,209Dec 2023Band 6 Care Co-ordinator/Community Psychiatric Nurse (15 years' service) v South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust
A Black African community psychiatric nurse with 15 years' service was found to have been discriminated against when two white female colleagues were appointed to a specialist lead role he was qualified for. The tribunal upheld his claims of direct race and sex discrimination and harassment.
Partial · Dec 2023Partial—Dec 2023Primary school teacher (2 years 6 months' service) v Diocese of Southwell and Nottingham Multi Academy Trust
A primary school teacher who exchanged personal messages with a vulnerable pupil via Class Dojo over the summer holidays was fairly dismissed. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Managing Director (3 years' service) v AP Drinks Ltd (now Wellness Capital Ltd)
A managing director's employment was found to have transferred to the buyer of his insolvent employer's intellectual property and goodwill, even though production stopped for six months.
Partial · Dec 2023Partial—Dec 2023Holistic Assessor (4 years' service) v Royal British Legion Industries
A Holistic Assessor with 4 years' service was fairly dismissed after scoring lowest in a redundancy selection matrix. The tribunal found the process was reasonable despite the employee's concerns about the criteria.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee v Miss Sparkles 2 You Ltd
A former employee with less than two years' service had her unfair dismissal claim struck out, but won £340 in unauthorised deduction and breach of contract claims.
Partial · £340 · Dec 2023Partial£340Dec 2023Healthcare assistant (1 year 6 months' service) v Barchester Healthcare Limited
A healthcare assistant who waited over two years to bring a whistleblowing and discrimination claim after his dismissal had his case dismissed as out of time. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable to have presented the claim within the statutory time limit.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Former employee v Zhero Limited
A tribunal granted an employer's late application to defend a claim but ordered it to pay costs for unreasonable conduct, while dismissing a wasted costs application against its former representative.
Partial · Dec 2023Partial—Dec 2023Lead Software Consultant (6 years' service) v ICT Infotech Ltd
An employment tribunal struck out a Lead Software Consultant's whistleblowing detriment and automatically unfair dismissal claims, leaving only an ordinary unfair dismissal claim to proceed. The tribunal also refused the employer's bid to strike out the remaining claim due to the claimant's conduct.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Counter Assistant (9 years' service) v My Plaice Gorleston Limited
A counter assistant who resigned after receiving a written warning for sickness absence lost her unfair dismissal claim, but was awarded £4,777.50 for unpaid holiday pay over nine years.
Partial · £4,778 · Dec 2023Partial£4,778Dec 2023Part-time takeaway worker (2 years' service) v Crispy Cod Ketley Ltd
A part-time takeaway worker was unfairly dismissed by text message after complaining about undercooked chicken. The tribunal awarded £14,628.50 in compensation.
Won · £14,629 · Dec 2023Won£14,629Dec 2023Area manager (3+ years' service) v Hamble Foods Limited
An area manager was unfairly dismissed after editing a timesheet, but the tribunal found the investigation was flawed and the disciplinary process lacked proper notice. He was awarded £8,026 after reductions for contributory conduct and a Polkey finding.
Partial · £8,026 · Dec 2023Partial£8,026Dec 2023Former employee v C H Latham, The Baker Limited
A former employee has won £4,467.57 after their employer failed to respond to an unfair dismissal and breach of contract claim, leading to a default judgment.
Won · £4,468 · Dec 2023Won£4,468Dec 2023Former employee v Munro Leisure Investments Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims have been struck out after he failed to attend a preliminary hearing and did not comply with tribunal orders to provide evidence.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Machine Room Manager (8 years' service) v UHV Design Limited
An Employment Tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a Machine Room Manager with 8 years' service who admitted physically blocking a subordinate during a workplace argument. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee v Gateshead Health NHS Foundation Trust
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Gateshead Health NHS Foundation Trust was struck out after he failed to comply with tribunal orders and did not respond to correspondence. He was ordered to pay £187.50 in costs.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Gymnastics coach v Friendship Society Limited
A gymnastics coach was automatically unfairly dismissed after asserting her right to a written contract and payslips. The tribunal awarded £56,202 including compensation for unlawful wage deductions.
Won · £56,202 · Dec 2023Won£56,202Dec 2023Approved Mental Health Professional (agency worker) v North Yorkshire Council
An Approved Mental Health Professional who withdrew from work citing serious danger lost his whistleblowing and health and safety detriment claims. The tribunal found his concerns did not amount to a protected disclosure or a reasonable belief of imminent danger.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Fraud consultant (4 years 10 months' service) v Lloyds Bank Plc
A fraud consultant with epilepsy lost his disability discrimination and constructive dismissal claims against Lloyds Bank because he filed them too late. The tribunal also found the claims lacked merit.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Graduate trainee accountant (11 years' service) v PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
A graduate trainee accountant who resigned after being invited to a disciplinary meeting for unauthorised absence failed to prove constructive unfair dismissal. The tribunal found the employer's conduct did not breach trust and confidence.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee (3 years' service) v Advanced Plant Hire Ltd
A former employee with three years' service was unfairly dismissed after his site closed and the employer failed to follow any redundancy process. The tribunal awarded over £44,000 in compensation.
Won · £44,297 · Dec 2023Won£44,297Dec 2023Head of Finance and Information Systems (11 years' service) v Grimsby Cleethorpes and Humer Region YMCA
A tribunal has ruled that a YMCA's request for a senior manager to return to blended working did not breach her contract, dismissing her claim for constructive unfair dismissal.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Packing and Logistics Operator (11 years' service) v Mexichem UK Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a packing operator with 11 years' service who left work early without authorisation and was found to have been dishonest about his start time. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Senior Contracts Attorney v Calabrio UK Limited
A senior contracts attorney lost her bid for interim relief after the tribunal found her redundancy was decided before she made protected disclosures about sanctions risks. The claim was dismissed.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Former employee v Remembrance Group Ltd (In Voluntary Liquidation)
A former employee who was owed wages, holiday pay and notice pay has been awarded £18,318.14 after their employer entered voluntary liquidation and did not defend the claim.
Partial · £18,318 · Dec 2023Partial£18,318Dec 2023Former Uber driver v Uber London Limited
A former Uber driver who waited four years to bring an unfair dismissal claim had it dismissed as out of time. The tribunal ruled it was reasonably practicable for him to have claimed within three months of his engagement ending.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Cleaning operative (1 year 4 months' service) v C&D Cleaning Services Limited
A cleaning operative who filed two unfair dismissal claims after the three-month deadline has had both claims dismissed. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for him to have filed in time.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Chief Executive Officer (3 years' service) v Marval Software Limited
A chief executive who lived in Poland and worked remotely for a UK software firm had his unfair dismissal claim thrown out because the tribunal lacked territorial jurisdiction.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Former employee (17 months' service) v Goldman and Fine Group Ltd
A former employee with less than two years' service had her unfair dismissal and unpaid wages claims dismissed after the tribunal found the pay arrangement was tainted by illegality.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Commodities inspector (consultant) v DRUM Risk Limited
A commodities inspector who never set foot in Great Britain for work has had his unfair dismissal, unlawful deductions and breach of contract claims thrown out. The tribunal ruled it had no jurisdiction because the rights he relied on did not apply to him.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Former employee v Plau Bistro Limited (in Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation)
A former employee of Plau Bistro Limited was automatically unfairly dismissed after asserting a statutory right following a TUPE transfer. The tribunal awarded £2,396.23 for unpaid wages, holiday pay, and notice pay.
Won · £2,396 · Dec 2023Won£2,396Dec 2023Programme Manager (3 years' service) v JC Bamford Excavators Limited
A programme manager with dyslexia who resigned after an informal performance improvement plan and a partially upheld grievance has lost her constructive dismissal and disability discrimination claims.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee v Mitie Ltd
A Watford tribunal found Mitie Ltd unfairly dismissed a former employee but reduced his basic award by 70% for his own conduct and made no compensatory award due to a 100% Polkey reduction. He received £1,298.10.
Partial · £1,298 · Dec 2023Partial£1,298Dec 2023Former employee v T. Cribb & Sons Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed because she presented it 12 days after the three-month deadline. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for her to have claimed on time.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Care Assessment Officer v AMG Consultancy Services Ltd
A care assessment officer who was told she was 'so bipolar' and had her role changed with less than 24 hours' notice has been allowed to add protected disclosure claims to her constructive dismissal case.
Partial · Dec 2023Partial—Dec 2023Administrative Officer (Civil Service) v Ministry of Justice (HMCTS)
An Administrative Officer who resigned after just seven weeks with the Ministry of Justice lost her claims of constructive unfair dismissal and disability discrimination. The tribunal found her employer had acted reasonably throughout.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023HR Business Partner (1 month's service) v KBox Global Ltd
An HR Business Partner who raised concerns about a flawed redundancy process was dismissed after just one month. The tribunal awarded £74,540 after striking out the employer's response.
Won · £74,540 · Dec 2023Won£74,540Dec 2023Labourer (construction) v Ardmore Construction Limited
A construction labourer who alleges he was subjected to monkey chants and racist abuse can proceed with his claim after the tribunal refused to strike it out, despite his late compliance with orders.
Remitted · Dec 2023Remitted—Dec 2023Supply teacher v Ravenscroft Park Preparatory School
A tribunal allowed a supply teacher to amend her disability discrimination claim to include victimisation, and later granted an anonymity order after initially refusing it.
Remitted · Dec 2023Remitted—Dec 2023Mental health practitioner (15 years' experience) v Cardiff Mind Limited
A mental health practitioner with 15 years' experience was unfairly dismissed when her fixed-term contract was not renewed while she was on long-term sick leave. The tribunal awarded £33,443.28.
Won · £33,443 · Dec 2023Won£33,443Dec 2023Project Manager (10 years' service) v Morrison Energy Services Limited
A project manager with 10 years' service was fairly dismissed for redundancy after failing to attend a competitive interview. The tribunal rejected claims that his role as an employee representative or his grievances were the real reason.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Deputy Customer Services and Housing Options Manager (16 years' service) v London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth
A deputy manager with 16 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct over visitor parking permits. The tribunal found the process unfair and awarded £35,318.56, but rejected her whistleblowing claim.
Partial · £35,319 · Dec 2023Partial£35,319Dec 2023Medical secretary (5 years' service) v Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a medical secretary who made racist comments about a colleague's appointment, finding the NHS trust acted reasonably.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee (31 years' service) v Wolseley UK Limited
A tribunal has ruled that Wolseley UK Limited fairly dismissed a long-serving employee by reason of redundancy, rejecting claims of age discrimination, harassment, and victimisation.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee v Amey Services Limited
A former employee who sent threatening emails to colleagues and called a witness a liar outside the tribunal room had his unfair dismissal claim struck out. The tribunal said a fair trial was no longer possible.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Former employee (funeral director, 31 years' service) v Estate of D B Roberts t/a Gwyn Jones Funeral Directors
An employment tribunal has ruled that a funeral director with 31 years' service was not a disabled person under the Equality Act, dismissing his disability discrimination claims.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Office manager (1 year 8 months' service) v Reactive Solutions FM Limited
An office manager with retinal dystrophy was awarded £44,489 after her employer failed to implement recommended equipment and training from Access to Work. The tribunal found the delay was a failure to make reasonable adjustments.
Partial · £44,489 · Dec 2023Partial£44,489Dec 2023Former employee v SFF Realisations 2022 Limited (formerly Sheringhams Fine Foods Ltd) (in creditors voluntary liquidation)
An employment tribunal dismissed a former employee's unfair dismissal claim after he failed to attend the final hearing for the third time and had not engaged with the claim for over a year.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Former employee v Ian Henery Solicitors Ltd
A former employee of Ian Henery Solicitors Ltd was initially found to be unfairly dismissed for raising health and safety concerns, but the unfair dismissal judgment was later revoked. The tribunal confirmed wrongful dismissal and awarded £3,336 in total.
Partial · £3,336 · Dec 2023Partial£3,336Dec 2023Former employee (housing officer) v Equans Regeneration Limited
A former housing officer's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims were struck out after she repeatedly failed to serve a witness statement, despite extensions and warnings. She was also ordered to pay £3,870 in costs.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Kitchen/Production Manager (2 years' service) v Jam’n’vegan
A kitchen manager with two years' service was unfairly dismissed when her employer made her redundant without any consultation or warning. The tribunal awarded £4,809.49 in compensation.
Won · £4,809 · Dec 2023Won£4,809Dec 2023Station Support Assistant (approx. 5 years' service) v London North Eastern Railway Limited
A station support assistant lost his unfair dismissal claim after 20 months off work. The tribunal found the initial decision to dismiss was premature, but the appeal corrected the flaw.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Business Development Manager (2 years 4 months' service) v Angry Creative (UK) Limited
A tribunal found that a Business Development Manager was unfairly dismissed because the real reason was his grievance, not redundancy. The case highlights the risks of dismissing a worker who has raised concerns.
Partial · Dec 2023Partial—Dec 2023Staff nurse (Band 5, previously Band 6 secondment) v Lewisham and Greenwich NHS Trust
A tribunal has dismissed all claims brought by a Band 5 staff nurse against Lewisham and Greenwich NHS Trust, including constructive dismissal, whistleblowing detriment, and discrimination on grounds of race, age, and religion.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023PCV driver (5 years' service) v National Express Limited
A PCV driver who failed three breath alcohol tests was unfairly dismissed due to a flawed appeal, but the tribunal found she would have been dismissed anyway and reduced compensation by 75% for contributory conduct.
Partial · £3,682 · Dec 2023Partial£3,682Dec 2023Post 16 Outreach Learning Mentor (14 months' service) v Achieving for Children Community Interest Company
A tribunal dismissed claims of disability discrimination and constructive unfair dismissal brought by a learning mentor with dyslexia and anxiety/depression, finding the employer acted reasonably throughout.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Stores person (2 years' service) v Amey Services Limited
A stores person who resigned after a security breach investigation lost his constructive unfair dismissal claim because he had accepted a new role before quitting.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Kitchen Porter (22 years' service) v Marriot Hotels Ltd
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a kitchen porter with 22 years' service after he whispered 'I wish I could impregnate you' to a colleague, following a previous warning about inappropriate comments.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Croupier (6 years' service) v Aspers (Stratford City) Limited
A croupier with six years' service resigned after his employer failed to deal with his grievance for over a month and left him without a line manager for weeks. The tribunal awarded £16,345.60.
Partial · £16,346 · Dec 2023Partial£16,346Dec 2023Former employee v Guardian Industrial (UK) Ltd
A former employee with a disability was awarded £3,892 after his employer demanded daily site diaries to verify attendance at medical appointments. The tribunal found this amounted to victimisation and unfavourable treatment arising from disability.
Partial · £3,893 · Dec 2023Partial£3,893Dec 2023Branch Care Manager (18 months' service) v MIDSHIRES CARE LTD T/A HELPING HANDS HOME CARE
A Branch Care Manager's claim for direct race discrimination and victimisation was dismissed because she presented it 28 days late. The tribunal refused to extend time, finding no just and equitable reason.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Consultant Clinical Scientist Head of Service (23 years' service) v Nottingham University Hospital NHS Trust
A consultant clinical scientist with 23 years' service resigned after a 'retire and return' scheme reduced her role. The tribunal struck out her breach of contract and age discrimination claims, but allowed her unfair dismissal claim to proceed.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Former employee v Stonewater Ltd
A former employee won her unfair dismissal claim against Stonewater Ltd but was awarded no compensation because she suffered no financial loss as a result of the dismissal.
Partial · Dec 2023Partial—Dec 2023Managing Director (5 years' service) v Panache Leasing Ltd
A managing director who was dismissed for alleged threats and misappropriation of funds without any investigation has been awarded £53,212.50 after the tribunal found the dismissal unfair. The High Court had previously found no evidence of fraud or dishonesty.
Won · £53,213 · Dec 2023Won£53,213Dec 2023Night concierge (5 years' service) v POD Group Services Ltd
A night concierge who resigned after a TUPE transfer, claiming his overtime, sick pay and holiday entitlement were cut, has lost his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found no such cuts were made.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Consultant ophthalmologist (8 years' service) v University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay NHS Foundation Trust
An NHS consultant who stopped on-call duties and refused to engage with his clinical lead was fairly dismissed for a breakdown in trust and confidence, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee v CSH Surrey
A former employee's disability discrimination claim against the CEO of CSH Surrey was struck out after she failed to particularise any specific allegations against him. The tribunal found the claim had no reasonable prospects of success.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Assistant Practice Manager / Practice Secretary (14 years' service) v Dr Sarah Harding and Dr Catriona McNicol T/A Park Edge Practice
A GP practice assistant manager with 14 years' service resigned after learning of a proposed new role, claiming constructive dismissal. The tribunal rejected her claim, finding no breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Front of house worker (11 years' service) v L&M Coventry Limited
A front of house worker at a pub/restaurant was unfairly dismissed after 11 years' service. The tribunal awarded £10,800 in compensation, including basic award and notice pay.
Won · £10,800 · Dec 2023Won£10,800Dec 2023Meter reader (16 years' service) v Morrison Data Services Ltd
A meter reader who was dismissed while on long-term sick leave after a motorbike accident has won his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claim. The tribunal found that Morrison Data Services Ltd failed to obtain an up-to-date occupational health report before deciding to dismiss.
Won · £16,505 · Dec 2023Won£16,505Dec 2023Tutor (3 years' service) v The Trustees of Al Madaar (a charity)
A tutor with three years' service was unfairly dismissed when her employer wrongly believed she had resigned. The tribunal awarded £1,499.54 for breach of contract and unlawful deduction of wages.
Partial · £1,500 · Dec 2023Partial£1,500Dec 2023Nursery worker v Monkton Under 5 Playgroup
A nursery worker was unfairly dismissed and subjected to disability discrimination by Monkton Under 5 Playgroup. The tribunal awarded £27,676 in compensation, including £16,200 for injury to feelings.
Won · £27,676 · Dec 2023Won£27,676Dec 2023Pharmacist (20 years' service) v Whittington Health NHS Trust
A pharmacist with 20 years' service was unfairly dismissed by Whittington Health NHS Trust after being refused an extension to her notice period while hospitalised with a sickle cell crisis. The tribunal found indirect disability discrimination and a failure to make reasonable adjustments, awarding £16,884.
Partial · £16,884 · Dec 2023Partial£16,884Dec 2023Attendance Officer (10 years' service) v Wokingham Borough Council and LDBS Frays Academy Trust
A tribunal has ruled that an Attendance Officer with 10 years' service was fairly dismissed by Wokingham Borough Council and LDBS Frays Academy Trust following a redundancy selection process, rejecting claims of race discrimination and unfair dismissal.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Static Maintenance and Electrical Engineer (1 year 7 months' service) v Birdsall Services Limited
A static maintenance engineer with under two years' service could not bring an unfair dismissal claim, but the tribunal awarded £803.88 in unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £804 · Dec 2023Partial£804Dec 2023Former employees v Ideal Shopping Direct Ltd (in voluntary liquidation) and Ideal World Ltd
Two employees were unfairly dismissed and awarded £25,000 in damages after their employer failed to transfer them under TUPE regulations. The tribunal also made a protective award of 90 days' pay for failure to consult.
Won · £25,000 · Dec 2023Won£25,000Dec 2023Former employee v Away Resorts Limited
A former employee's breach of contract claim against Away Resorts Limited was struck out as out of time. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for him to present the claim on time, despite his son's hospitalisation and home flooding.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Managing Director (1 year 1 month service) v Inglis Jane Limited
A managing director with a six-month notice period was dismissed by email after raising concerns about unpaid expenses and pension contributions. The tribunal awarded £25,000 for wrongful dismissal but rejected his protected disclosure claim.
Partial · £25,000 · Dec 2023Partial£25,000Dec 2023Former employee v The Restaurant Group PLC
A former employee who failed to attend hearings and ignored tribunal orders had his unfair dismissal claim struck out. The tribunal also noted he had less than two years' service, which normally bars such claims.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Bus driver (6 years' service) v London United Busways Ltd
A bus driver with 6 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after refusing a breath alcohol test following an at-fault collision. The tribunal also dismissed his discrimination and victimisation claims.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Global Governance Risk and Compliance Manager (20 years' service) v GlaxoSmithKline Services Unlimited
A Global Governance Risk and Compliance Manager with 20 years' service was unfairly dismissed and discriminated against after GlaxoSmithKline failed to make reasonable adjustments for her hand disability. The tribunal awarded £24,785 for injury to feelings.
Partial · £24,785 · Dec 2023Partial£24,785Dec 2023Pre-assessment Nurse (14 months' service) v Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust
A pre-assessment nurse who carried out paid Botox procedures while signed off sick was fairly dismissed for misconduct. The tribunal rejected her claims of disability discrimination and victimisation.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Production operative (1 year 9 months' service) v Bravo FB Limited (trading as Fox’s Biscuits)
A production operative who was dismissed while on sick leave for plantar fasciitis and depression lost her unfair dismissal claim because she had less than two years' service. All disability discrimination claims were also dismissed.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee v OCS Group UK Ltd
A former employee's claim for unfair dismissal and race discrimination failed due to time limits, but the tribunal awarded £243.54 for unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £244 · Dec 2023Partial£244Dec 2023University academic (teacher and researcher in Medieval and Early Modern English Literature) v University of Leicester
A University of Leicester academic was unfairly dismissed when the university failed to properly consult on redundancy selection after changing its proposal to retain a permanent post. The tribunal awarded £72,487.50 in compensation.
Partial · £72,488 · Dec 2023Partial£72,488Dec 2023Former employee v Garbett Butchers Ltd
A former butcher won £11,871 after his employer failed to pay notice, holiday pay, or a redundancy payment and did not attend the tribunal hearing.
Won · £11,871 · Dec 2023Won£11,871Dec 2023Assistant Playground Leader and SENCO (26 years' service) v Crossways Playgroup (an unincorporated association)
A tribunal refused a committee member's application to file a late response in a redundancy claim brought by an assistant playground leader with 26 years' service. The case will now proceed to a remedy hearing.
Partial · Dec 2023Partial—Dec 2023Former employee v Secretary of State for Justice
A former employee who claimed he was victimised for leaving work to take a COVID-19 test had his case struck out for being out of time and having no reasonable prospect of success. He was also ordered to pay £50,186.50 in costs.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Hairdresser (9 years' service) v Langley & Brading Ltd
A hairdresser's unfair dismissal claim was struck out because she presented it too late, despite her premature baby and autism. The tribunal found no reasonable prospects of showing it was not reasonably practicable to claim earlier.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Former HGV driver v George Walker Transport Manchester Limited
A former HGV driver's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claim was dismissed after he continued using abusive language, breaching an unless order. His application to set aside the order was refused.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Head of Trade and Data (over 5 years' service) and Head of Finance (over 7 years' service) v Hallett Retain Services Ltd (in voluntary liquidation)
Two former employees who brought claims for unfair dismissal, discrimination and redundancy had their cases thrown out after failing to attend the final hearing or provide any evidence.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Site Manager (8 months' service) v Petrogas Group UK Limited
A site manager who was dismissed after just eight months had his unfair dismissal claim struck out for lack of qualifying service. His race discrimination claims were allowed to proceed but subject to a £100 deposit order.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Firefighter (5 years' service) v Avon Fire and Rescue Service
A firefighter with five years' service was constructively dismissed after being subjected to sex discrimination, harassment, and victimisation by colleagues. The tribunal upheld her claims and awarded a basic award of £2,284.
Won · Dec 2023Won—Dec 2023Former employee (business service consultant) v UK Direct Business Solutions Limited
A former business service consultant's direct sex discrimination and bonus claims were struck out, but her sexual harassment and harassment related to sex claims will proceed to a final hearing.
Partial · Dec 2023Partial—Dec 2023Former employee v Scope it Ltd
A tribunal dismissed a former employee's unfair dismissal claim after he failed to attend the final hearing, telling staff that caring for his wife after a car crash was more important than the case.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Catering manager (16 years' service) v Serco Ltd
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a catering manager who was found guilty of gross misconduct for stealing tea bags and bullying a colleague, ruling that Serco Ltd's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Car valet (6 years' service) v Southern Car Sales Limited
A car valet with six years' service was unfairly dismissed after using foul language towards a colleague, but the tribunal awarded no compensation because his conduct wholly caused his dismissal.
Partial · £0 · Dec 2023Partial£0Dec 2023Legal services provider (locum lawyer) v Hogan Lovells International LLP
A locum lawyer's claim for automatic unfair dismissal over alleged whistleblowing was struck out because the disclosure came months after his engagement ended. He was also ordered to pay £8,000 in costs for unreasonable conduct.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Compliance Director (4 years' service) v Goldenway Global Investments (UK) Limited
A Compliance Director who reported money laundering and unauthorised directors to the FCA was dismissed four days later. The tribunal found the dismissal was automatically unfair and awarded over half a million pounds.
Won · £564,672 · Dec 2023Won£564,672Dec 2023Former employee v Anderbury Ltd
A former employee was unfairly dismissed and denied proper notice pay and annual leave. The tribunal awarded £8,000 after finding the employer failed to follow a fair process.
Partial · £8,000 · Dec 2023Partial£8,000Dec 2023Part-time Fitness Instructor (8 years' service) v Greenwich Leisure Ltd
A tribunal found that Greenwich Leisure Ltd unfairly dismissed an 8-year employee during pandemic redundancies, due to flawed selection criteria and a lack of consultation.
Partial · Dec 2023Partial—Dec 2023Former employee v NHS Blood and Transplant
A former employee was unfairly dismissed after NHS Blood and Transplant failed to investigate allegations and later refused a £40,000 settlement offer. The tribunal awarded £96,447.50 in compensation and £8,012.40 in costs.
Won · £96,448 · Dec 2023Won£96,448Dec 2023Restaurant server (9 months' service) v London XXI Limited t/a ME London
A restaurant server with less than two years' service had his unfair dismissal claim struck out after he failed to attend hearings or comply with tribunal orders. The tribunal also dismissed his race discrimination claim due to unreasonable conduct.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Former employee v Senol & Senol Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed for lack of continuity of employment, and his race discrimination claim was thrown out as out of time. Other claims were struck out for failing to actively pursue them.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Security officer (6 years' service) v CIS Security Ltd
A security officer with six years' service was unfairly dismissed after a back injury. The tribunal also found that CIS Security Ltd failed to make reasonable adjustments and discriminated against him arising from his disability.
Partial · Dec 2023Partial—Dec 2023Site Manager (2 years' service) v GreenSquareAccord Limited
A site manager with two years' service was fairly dismissed for redundancy after a trial period in a lower-paid role was deemed unsuccessful. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Legal secretary (trainee) v AD (deceased)
A trainee legal secretary who was assaulted by her employer and made protected disclosures has won claims of unfair dismissal, sex discrimination, harassment and victimisation. She was awarded £28,986.85.
Partial · £28,987 · Dec 2023Partial£28,987Dec 2023Former employee (11 years' service) v Motus Commercials Limited
A tribunal dismissed all claims from a former employee with 11 years' service and a clean disciplinary record, finding his misconduct dismissal fair and not discriminatory.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee v Park Holidays UK Limited
A former employee's claims of automatic constructive unfair dismissal and sexual orientation harassment were struck out after he presented his claim nine months late, despite having initially filed on time but without an ACAS certificate.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Former employee v London & Quadrant Housing Trust
The tribunal struck out all remaining claims brought by a former employee against London & Quadrant Housing Trust after she failed to provide required details, despite having dyslexia.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Former employee v George Thompson Limited
A former employee won a constructive unfair dismissal claim after her employer made unauthorised deductions from wages and failed to pay holiday entitlement. The tribunal awarded over £10,000, including a basic award and penalties for missing written particulars.
Won · £10,474 · Dec 2023Won£10,474Dec 2023Registered Manager (domiciliary care) v Allwell Care Company Ltd
A registered care manager with emotionally unstable personality disorder was harassed by his employer through a derogatory 'chimp' comment, a push, and a detrimental reference. The tribunal awarded £22,966.72.
Partial · £22,967 · Nov 2023Partial£22,967Nov 2023Electrical engineer (probationary employee, less than 3 months' service) v Integral UK Ltd
An electrical engineer dismissed during his probationary period for poor performance and a safety incident failed to prove race, age or disability discrimination. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Teaching Assistant (2 years 7 months' service) v Calcot Services for Children Limited
A teaching assistant who pulled a young person's hood and took them to the floor in a ground hold was fairly dismissed for misconduct, the tribunal has ruled. The claim for race discrimination also failed.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Shift Leader (17 years' service) v Tesco Stores PLC
A shift leader with 17 years' service had his unfair dismissal claim struck out after he failed to provide a witness statement, disclosure, or a schedule of loss, and did not engage with the respondent or the tribunal.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Chef (3 years' service) v Farmhouse Kitchen Huntleys Limited
A chef was automatically unfairly dismissed when her employer fired her by message after she requested time off for pregnancy-related bleeding. The tribunal awarded £18,479 for unfair dismissal, discrimination, and unauthorised deductions.
Won · £18,479 · Nov 2023Won£18,479Nov 2023PCV bus driver (18 years' service) v Abellio London Limited
An 18-year bus driver was sacked for gross misconduct after CCTV showed him using a mobile phone while driving. The tribunal upheld the dismissal but awarded £1,019 for unpaid wages and holiday pay.
Partial · £1,019 · Nov 2023Partial£1,019Nov 2023Warehouse operative (32 years' service) v Bapp Industrial Supplies (Huddersfield) Limited
A warehouse operative with 32 years' service was fairly dismissed after failing to contact his employer for nearly a month. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Agency worker (customer service advisor/analyst) v Supply Chain Coordination Limited (1), Unipart Group Limited (2)
An agency worker who claimed unfair dismissal, sex discrimination and equal pay against the end-user and hirer lost all claims after the tribunal found he was not an employee of either respondent.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former child actor v The Walt Disney Company Limited
An 11-year-old's unfair dismissal claim against Disney was struck out because it was filed over 10 months after the deadline. The tribunal said it was not just and equitable to extend time.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Pharmacy Dispensary Technician (6 years' service) v JCL UK Limited
A pharmacy dispensary technician with fibromyalgia and other conditions lost her constructive unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims after the tribunal found she did not share her adjustment passport with her new employer following a TUPE transfer.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Healthcare assistant (6 years' service) v University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust
A healthcare assistant who was dismissed for persistent short-term absences after her employer made reasonable adjustments has lost her unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims. The tribunal found the NHS Trust acted fairly.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Assistant Branch Manager (28 years' service) v Howarth Timber and Building Supplies Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of an assistant branch manager with 28 years' service who was absent for 10 months with anxiety. The employer had offered multiple adjustments but the claimant insisted on a customer ban.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Media Sales Operator (10 years' service) v Discovery Communications Europe Limited
A Media Sales Operator with 10 years' service had his unfair dismissal and discrimination claims struck out after repeatedly failing to comply with tribunal directions. The tribunal awarded costs against him.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee v Mold Systems EU Limited (In Administration)
A former employee won a protective award of 90 days' pay after his employer made him redundant without any consultation. The company was in administration and did not attend the hearing.
Partial · Nov 2023Partial—Nov 2023Former People Advisor (2 years' service) v London Borough of Hounslow
A former People Advisor who resigned after her employer failed to respond to her redundancy request for 39 days has been allowed to pursue claims for a redundancy payment and constructive unfair dismissal.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Workshop Administration Assistant (18 months' service) v Everyman Motor Racing Activities Limited
A workshop administration assistant who faced repeated deductions for alleged vehicle damage and a penalty notice clause has been awarded £4,104.95 by an employment tribunal.
Partial · £4,105 · Nov 2023Partial£4,105Nov 2023Operational Support Grade (OSG) at HMP Garth (2.5 years' service) v The Secretary of State for Justice
An Operational Support Grade at HMP Garth who resigned after alleging bullying and poor complaint handling lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer acted reasonably and the complaints were not formal grievances.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v University of Bradford
A former employee of the University of Bradford had his unfair dismissal claim struck out because he had less than two years' service. His harassment and disability discrimination claims were also struck out for procedural failures.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Support worker (6 months' service) v South Gloucestershire Council
A support worker with depression was dismissed after six months' sick leave. The tribunal upheld the dismissal, finding the council acted reasonably and proportionately.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Data Partnerships Manager (2 years' service) v Appscatter Limited (in creditors' liquidation)
A Data Partnerships Manager was dismissed without notice on the day his employer announced a TUPE transfer. The tribunal awarded £11,670 for breach of contract and £7,423 for failure to inform and consult.
Won · £11,670 · Nov 2023Won£11,670Nov 2023Branch Manager (8 years' service) v VP Plc (1) and Brandon Hire Station Limited (2)
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a branch manager who used 'dump codes' to circumvent the company's asset tracking system, rejecting his claims of unfair dismissal and whistleblowing.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v Navaratna South Indian Restaurant Ltd.
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Navaratna South Indian Restaurant Ltd. was struck out after she failed to attend a hearing and did not comply with case management orders. No compensation was awarded.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee (annual salary £75,000 plus car allowance) v Synpower Merchant Services Limited
A former employee has been awarded £10,125.26 after his employer made an unauthorised deduction from his wages, failed to pay accrued holiday pay, and withheld statutory redundancy pay.
Won · £10,125 · Nov 2023Won£10,125Nov 2023Former CEO and entrepreneur v Print .Inc Group Limited
A former CEO who founded the business could not show he was an employee of the transferor company, so his unfair dismissal claim was struck out for lack of continuous service.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Sales Executive/Administrator (2 years 9 months' service) v Forest Master Limited
A sales executive with a clean record was given a final written warning for baseless dishonesty allegations and had commission withheld. The tribunal found he was constructively unfairly dismissed.
Won · Nov 2023Won—Nov 2023Former employee v RR Swami Ltd
A former employee has been awarded £12,503 after an employment tribunal found she was unfairly dismissed, not given notice, and had wages unlawfully deducted by RR Swami Ltd.
Partial · £12,503 · Nov 2023Partial£12,503Nov 2023Former employees (telemarketing business) v Phonetic Group Limited
Former telemarketing employees lose protective award and unfair dismissal claims after a TUPE transfer from a company in creditors' voluntary liquidation, but win compensation for failure to consult.
Partial · Nov 2023Partial—Nov 2023Former employee (pregnant, dismissed after disclosing pregnancy) v ALM Electrical Solutions Ltd
A Birmingham tribunal found that ALM Electrical Solutions Ltd dismissed a pregnant employee shortly after she disclosed her pregnancy, fabricating a redundancy reason. The claimant was awarded over £25,000 for injury to feelings and losses.
Partial · £25,631 · Nov 2023Partial£25,631Nov 2023Head of School (development role, 8 years' service) v Initio Learning Trust (formally Wimbourne Academy Trust)
A tribunal found that a school trust failed to make reasonable adjustments for a head of school with depression and anxiety, by not providing timeframes for a disciplinary process or reviewing her suspension. Her constructive dismissal claim was rejected.
Partial · Nov 2023Partial—Nov 2023Former employee v Grikis Ltd
A former employee who was dismissed while pregnant after raising health and safety concerns has won her claims for pregnancy discrimination and unfair dismissal. The East London Employment Tribunal awarded her £43,153.60 in compensation.
Won · £43,154 · Nov 2023Won£43,154Nov 2023Support Manager (2 years' service) v Atamis Ltd
A Support Manager who resigned after her role was changed and workload reduced lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Café Manager (17 years' service) v Sam Turner & Sons Limited
A café manager with 17 years' service was unfairly dismissed when her employer failed to inform her of a sales assistant vacancy during redundancy consultation. The tribunal awarded £560.28 after applying a 66.7% Polkey reduction.
Won · £560 · Nov 2023Won£560Nov 2023Customer Care Assistant / Lead Customer Host (10 years' service) v First Greater Western Limited
A Customer Care Assistant with 10 years' service was unfairly dismissed after being accused of breaching a COT3 settlement agreement. The tribunal awarded £9,074, but applied a 50% Polkey reduction.
Won · £9,074 · Nov 2023Won£9,074Nov 2023Electrician (2 years' service) v Thames Spark Group Limited
An electrician who raised asbestos safety concerns was dismissed for alleged expense fraud. The tribunal found the dismissal was tainted by whistleblowing and awarded nearly £20,000.
Partial · £19,804 · Nov 2023Partial£19,804Nov 2023Skilled mechanical maintenance fitter (22 years' service) v Vauxhall Motors Ltd
Three skilled maintenance fitters with up to 25 years' service were unfairly dismissed by Vauxhall Motors after a flawed investigation into an anonymous letter about overtime. The tribunal rejected claims of whistleblowing or union-related automatic unfair dismissal.
Partial · Nov 2023Partial—Nov 2023Former employee v Bridge Medical Solutions Ltd
Two former employees of Bridge Medical Solutions Ltd have won their claims for automatic unfair dismissal after being sacked for making protected disclosures. The tribunal awarded a total of £27,286 in compensation.
Won · £27,286 · Nov 2023Won£27,286Nov 2023Cleaner (7 years' service) v Michael Cottington and Irene Cundliffe sued as Committee Members of the Golborne Bowling Club
A cleaner was unfairly dismissed when a bowling club committee decided to let her go without notice or any redundancy procedure. The tribunal awarded £7,252 in compensation, including an ACAS uplift for failing to follow the statutory code.
Won · £7,252 · Nov 2023Won£7,252Nov 2023Sales assistant (former nurse) v Irvings Butchers Limited
A former nurse turned sales assistant who was placed on furlough during the pandemic due to shielding advice has lost her disability and age discrimination claims against Irvings Butchers Limited.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v UK Cleaning Contracts Limited
A cleaner was dismissed while pregnant, without a maternity risk assessment. The tribunal awarded £9,107.40, including £7,500 for injury to feelings.
Won · £9,107 · Nov 2023Won£9,107Nov 2023Warehouse operative (6.5 years' service) v WM Morrisons Supermarket Ltd
A warehouse operative with 6.5 years' service was dismissed for capability after a year of sick leave for depression. The tribunal upheld the dismissal, finding the employer acted reasonably despite not waiting the 4-5 weeks suggested by occupational health.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Dental lab manager (9 years' service) v The Town Hall Group Ltd
A dental lab manager with nine years' service was constructively unfairly dismissed after his employer cut his hours from 43 to 18 per week without any consultation. The tribunal found the employer's conduct amounted to a repudiatory breach of contract.
Won · Nov 2023Won—Nov 2023Project Engineer (1 year 9 months' service) v Armour Home Electronics Limited
A tribunal struck out a project engineer's unfair dismissal, sexual orientation discrimination, and wrongful dismissal claims after he was sacked for sending a confidential email to colleagues. His sex discrimination claim survived but required a £200 deposit.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Accounts Manager (3 years' service) v G. & M.J. Crouch & Son Ltd
A tribunal upheld one claim of direct sex discrimination after an accounts manager was told a client 'likes pretty women', but dismissed her constructive dismissal and other claims.
Partial · Nov 2023Partial—Nov 2023Support worker (16 years' service) v Craegmoor Healthcare Company Limited
A support worker with a clean record was fairly dismissed for failing to document a resident's coffee burn, the Leeds Employment Tribunal has ruled. The tribunal rejected claims of race discrimination and victimisation linked to a 2015 claim.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v Velocity Delivery Services Limited
A former employee who had worked for Velocity Delivery Services Limited for less than two years had their unfair dismissal and redundancy claims struck out, but was awarded £1,985.61 for an unauthorised deduction from wages.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee v Priory Group Partnerships in Care Ltd
A former employee's claims for constructive unfair dismissal, direct discrimination and victimisation were dismissed after the tribunal revoked a default judgment and found the discrimination claims were brought too late.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023HGV Class 1 Night Driver (10 years' service) v Maritime Transport Limited
An HGV driver with 10 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after a member of the public complained he was watching videos on his phone while driving. The tribunal struck out his unfair dismissal claim as having no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Senior Internal Auditor (1 year service) v Costain Engineering and Construction Limited
A tribunal has ruled that a senior internal auditor with one year's service was not automatically unfairly dismissed for taking time off to care for his seriously ill father. The claim was dismissed.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Carer (4 years' service) v Evergreen Homecare Services Ltd (formerly SureCare Barnet Ltd)
A carer who brought a second, materially identical unfair dismissal claim after her first was struck out and she was ordered to pay £20,000 costs has been ordered to pay a further £6,000 for vexatious conduct.
Lost · £6,000 · Nov 2023Lost£6,000Nov 2023Registered Nurse (dementia ward) v The Royal Star and Garter Homes
A tribunal dismissed all claims by a dementia ward nurse who resigned after suspension, finding no link between his protected disclosure and the employer's actions.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Clinical Support Worker (19 years' service) v Chelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
A tribunal awarded a statutory redundancy payment of £2,077.16 to a Clinical Support Worker with 19 years' service, finding that his refusal of an alternative role was not unreasonable.
Partial · £2,077 · Nov 2023Partial£2,077Nov 2023Night Care Assistant (5 years' service) v Adara Healthcare Limited
A night care assistant with five years' service was unfairly dismissed after being seen asleep on duty, because her employer did not hold a disciplinary hearing before sacking her. The tribunal awarded £962.79, reduced by 75% for her contributory conduct.
Won · £963 · Nov 2023Won£963Nov 2023Former employee v The Energy Comparison Service Limited (in creditors voluntary liquidation)
A former employee was awarded over £37,000 after colleagues repeatedly called him 'old man' and 'grandpa', and the company made unauthorised deductions from his wages and failed to pay holiday pay.
Won · £37,874 · Nov 2023Won£37,874Nov 2023Former employee v The Langley Hall Primary Academy Trust
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was thrown out because he contacted ACAS one day late and submitted his claim about a week outside the time limit. The tribunal found no evidence to extend time.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Solutions engineer (3 years 8 months' service) v Singletrack Systems Limited
A solutions engineer who resigned after a performance improvement plan and grievance process lost his constructive dismissal claim because he stayed in the job too long after the alleged breaches.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Senior Events & Operations Co-Ordinator (6 years' service) v Heritage Venues Limited
A senior events co-ordinator who returned from maternity leave to work part-time was selected for redundancy in a 'pool of one' while full-time colleagues doing the same job were retained. The tribunal found unfair dismissal, indirect sex discrimination and part-time worker detriment.
Won · Nov 2023Won—Nov 2023Insurance broker employee (7 years' service) v Verlingue Limited
An insurance broker who resigned 5 months after a flawed disciplinary hearing lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim because the tribunal found she did not resign in response to the breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Furniture installer (4 months' service) v Atic Group Ltd
A furniture installer who was dismissed shortly after asking for a phone mount and charger to navigate safely lost his unfair dismissal claim when the tribunal revoked an earlier interim relief order and later dismissed the case.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Panel beater (3 years' service) v LSJ The Car Body Repair Specialist Limited
A Watford tribunal has ruled that a panel beater with three years' service was fairly dismissed when his employer, a four-person car repair shop, made him redundant as the only employee at risk. The decision highlights how small employers can follow a lighter process.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v Dunton Environmental Limited
A former employee who claimed disability discrimination based on ADHD had her claim dismissed after the tribunal found she had not proven she had the condition on the balance of probabilities.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Assistant Practitioner (22 Jan 2019 – 17 Dec 2020) v Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust
A tribunal dismissed a former NHS assistant practitioner's racial harassment claims, finding the allegations were not supported by evidence and were brought too late. The claimant was ordered to pay £5,000 costs for unreasonable conduct.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023HGV driver (5 years' service) v Armstrong Logistics Ltd
An HGV driver who resigned after a short delay in payment for three days' work lost his constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found he acted prematurely before the employer's conduct became repudiatory.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v Paragon Network Services Limited (Previously Core Network Services Limited)
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim faced a setback when the tribunal granted the employer extra time to respond, due to an incorrect address on the claim form.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee v North East Autism Society
Two former employees of North East Autism Society who refused the Covid-19 vaccine had their unfair dismissal and discrimination claims struck out after failing to attend a preliminary hearing and comply with tribunal orders.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Enquiry unit advisor (2 years' service) v Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy
An enquiry unit advisor who sent threatening WhatsApp messages and emails to his line manager was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected claims of disability discrimination.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Restaurant general manager (10 years' service) v Chicken Cabins Ltd
A restaurant general manager who resigned after a disciplinary process and alleged race discrimination has lost his claims of constructive dismissal and race discrimination at the Leeds Employment Tribunal.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Dental nurse v KDPG Limited
A dental nurse who resigned after securing another job failed to prove she was constructively dismissed or that her employer discriminated against her. All claims were dismissed.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Broadband Technical Support Team member (part-time, evening shifts) v EE Limited
A tribunal found that EE Limited unfairly dismissed a broadband technical support worker with panic disorder after it refused to wait a week for her to return to work, and also discriminated against her because of her disability.
Partial · Nov 2023Partial—Nov 2023NHS employee v Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust
An NHS employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims were dismissed, but the tribunal refused the Trust's application for costs, finding she had a genuine belief in her case and did not act unreasonably.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v Selfridges Retail Ltd
A tribunal struck out a deaf former employee's disability discrimination claim after she failed to comply with directions and attempted to add new claims that went beyond her original ET1.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee v Asda Stores Ltd
A former employee succeeded in her unfair dismissal claim against Asda Stores Ltd, but her age discrimination and harassment complaints were dismissed. She was awarded £27,924.06.
Partial · £27,924 · Nov 2023Partial£27,924Nov 2023Mailman/driver (32 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A mailman with 32 years of unblemished service was unfairly dismissed by Royal Mail after a customer complaint about a duplicate barcode. The tribunal found the investigation and disciplinary process flawed, and reduced compensation by 20% for his own conduct.
Won · Nov 2023Won—Nov 2023Food sales assistant (3 years' service) v Garden Market Butchers West Brom Ltd (in voluntary liquidation)
A food sales assistant dismissed by a butchers that went into liquidation has won £12,651 for unfair dismissal, redundancy and wrongful dismissal after the tribunal found the employer failed to follow proper procedures.
Won · £12,651 · Nov 2023Won£12,651Nov 2023Former employee (Natural Justice Administrator, 4 months' service) v GTEP Administration Limited
A former employee with only four months' service successfully claimed unpaid notice pay and a quarterly bonus after a restructuring meeting led to his dismissal. The tribunal awarded £3,423 in total.
Partial · £3,423 · Nov 2023Partial£3,423Nov 2023Recruitment coordinator (former employee) v Lifeways Community Care Limited
The tribunal dismissed claims of constructive unfair dismissal and breach of contract for non-payment of a discretionary bonus, finding no repudiatory breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Live-in carer (32 years' caregiving experience) v Mr Mark Sutton
A live-in carer with 32 years' experience won a whistleblowing detriment claim after raising safety concerns, but her constructive dismissal claim failed. She was awarded £1,775.
Partial · £1,775 · Nov 2023Partial£1,775Nov 2023Registered mental health nurse (2 years 9 months' service) v Cygnet NW Limited
A registered mental health nurse who alleged race discrimination and harassment by Cygnet NW Limited has had all his claims dismissed by the Sheffield Employment Tribunal.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v Fenco Ltd t/a Homesafe Housing
A former employee was automatically unfairly dismissed after making a public interest disclosure. The tribunal also found she was owed unpaid salary, holiday pay, and expenses, awarding a total of £4,619.01.
Partial · £4,619 · Nov 2023Partial£4,619Nov 2023Former employee v Openwork Limited
The employment tribunal struck out all three claims brought by a former employee against Openwork Limited after he failed to pay a deposit order. The tribunal also refused his applications for an extension of time and reconsideration.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee v Fox Networking UK Ltd
A former employee who was dismissed without notice after less than two years' service had their unfair dismissal claim struck out, but won £1,514 for notice and holiday pay.
Partial · £1,514 · Nov 2023Partial£1,514Nov 2023Headteacher (17 years' service) v Arbor Academy Trust
A headteacher with 17 years' service was unfairly dismissed after tapping her 3-year-old son's hand to get his attention. The tribunal awarded £102,328.80, reduced by 20% for contributory fault.
Won · £102,329 · Nov 2023Won£102,329Nov 2023Shift Team Leader (9 years' service) v Britvic Soft Drinks Limited
A shift team leader with 9 years' service resigned after being placed on a performance improvement plan, but the tribunal dismissed all claims, finding no breach of contract and serious credibility problems with his evidence.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Warehouse first line manager (3 years' service) v DHL Services Limited
A warehouse first line manager with three years' service at DHL Services Limited resigned after a flawed grievance process. The tribunal upheld his claim for constructive unfair dismissal.
Partial · Nov 2023Partial—Nov 2023Business Support Coordinator (2 years' service) v Royal Mail Property and Facilities Solutions Limited
A Business Support Coordinator with two years' service was fairly dismissed after failing to engage with his employer's sickness absence process. The tribunal also awarded £1,771 for unauthorised wage deductions.
Partial · £1,771 · Nov 2023Partial£1,771Nov 2023Delivery and Collection Manager (2 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A black Caribbean delivery manager was unfairly dismissed and racially stereotyped after a returned iPhone went missing. The tribunal found Royal Mail's investigation was flawed and the claimant was treated less favourably than a hypothetical white comparator.
Won · Nov 2023Won—Nov 2023Former employee v Sainsbury’s Supermarkets Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Sainsbury’s was struck out after she failed to attend the final hearing and did not provide a witness statement as ordered. The tribunal refused her application for reconsideration.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Customer Service Representative (5 years' service) v Liverpool Victoria Financial Services Ltd
A customer service representative who resigned claiming constructive dismissal after a cleaner's complaint and a failed grievance has lost her case. The tribunal found no fundamental breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Clerical Officer (5 years' service) v Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust
A clerical officer with five years' service was fairly dismissed after repeatedly refusing to attend investigation and disciplinary meetings. The tribunal rejected her unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Cook (22 years' service) v KZ Catering Ltd
A cook employed for 22 years claimed unauthorised deductions after his hours were cut from 30 to 6 per week. The tribunal dismissed the claim, finding no deduction occurred because he was paid for all hours worked.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v Environment Agency
A former employee's unfair dismissal, sex discrimination and whistleblowing claims were thrown out after he presented them almost six years after his employment ended. The tribunal also ordered him to pay £400 in costs.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Trainee car sales executive (2.5 months' service) v Bristol Street First Investments Limited
A trainee car sales executive with 2.5 months' service failed to prove he made a protected disclosure when his father sent an email to the CEO alleging fraud. The tribunal found the email was not a disclosure by the claimant and was not in the public interest.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Project Manager (2 months' service) v Phoenix Social Enterprise Ltd
A tribunal ruled that a Project Manager who worked for just two months at Phoenix Social Enterprise Ltd was a worker, not an employee, meaning she can claim unpaid wages and holiday pay but not unfair dismissal.
Partial · Nov 2023Partial—Nov 2023Reception Manager (1 year's service) v Mr Paul Watson
A reception manager who resigned after disputes over pay and deductions lost his constructive dismissal claim. The tribunal found no fundamental breach of contract and no link to proposed paternity leave.
Partial · £931 · Nov 2023Partial£931Nov 2023Former employee v Ideal Shopping Direct Limited (in voluntary liquidation)
A former employee was awarded £37,178 after an employment tribunal found she was discriminated against because of her pregnancy and unfairly dismissed by reason of redundancy.
Won · £37,179 · Nov 2023Won£37,179Nov 2023Graphic Designer (15 years' service) v Embrace Education Limited
A graphic designer with 15 years' service was dismissed by text message during the first lockdown. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair but rejected age discrimination claims.
Partial · Nov 2023Partial—Nov 2023Trainee solicitor (1 year 3 months' service) v Sterling Lawyers Limited
A trainee solicitor who sent 106 confidential client emails to her personal address was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal ruled. Her claims of whistleblowing and pregnancy discrimination were rejected.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v UK Windows & Doors Group Limited (In Administration)
A former employee was unfairly dismissed by UK Windows & Doors Group Limited. The tribunal increased compensation for the company's failure to follow the ACAS Code but reduced it due to the employee's own blameworthy conduct.
Won · £24,517 · Nov 2023Won£24,517Nov 2023Former employee v Cardiff & Vale University Local Health Board
An employee with a mental health disability lost all claims of unfair dismissal and discrimination after the tribunal found the health board's absence management process was reasonable.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v Nuffield Health
A former employee's disability discrimination claim against Nuffield Health was struck out after he failed to actively pursue it for eight months, despite being given extra support due to his autism.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee v Brian Colledge
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after he and his son repeatedly failed to attend hearings and did not comply with tribunal directions.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Security officer (5 years' service) v Corps Security (UK) Limited
A security officer who resigned after a disciplinary process was started following a two-hour absence from her post has lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer's conduct, including minor pay issues and a request for an occupational health assessment, did not amount to a repudiatory breach of contract.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Managing Director (31 years' service) v EMKA (UK) Limited
A managing director with 31 years' service was unfairly and wrongfully dismissed after being told his employment was ending at a hotel meeting, with no prior investigation or disciplinary process. The tribunal awarded £61,625.82.
Won · £61,626 · Nov 2023Won£61,626Nov 2023Security guard (3 years' service) v Mitie Ltd
A security guard who lost most of his sight was unfairly dismissed and discriminated against by Mitie Ltd, which failed to consider reasonable adjustments or a vacant role he suggested.
Won · Nov 2023Won—Nov 2023Paramedic (22 years' service) v South Western Ambulance Service NHS Foundation Trust
A paramedic with 22 years' service lost his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims after the tribunal found his employer acted reasonably in dismissing him for ill-health when his own psychiatrist said he was permanently incapable of working.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Warehouse operatives v Euro Car Parts Ltd
Two warehouse operatives had their automatic unfair dismissal claims for whistleblowing struck out because the alleged breaches happened before they made their protected disclosure. The tribunal said the claims had no reasonable prospects of success.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Care home employee v Abbey Grange Care Home Ltd
A care home employee was unfairly dismissed and had wages unlawfully deducted. The tribunal awarded £6,108 for breach of contract and unauthorised deduction, with a remedy hearing for unfair dismissal still to come.
Partial · £6,108 · Nov 2023Partial£6,108Nov 2023Former employee v Your Local Hadfield Ltd
A former employee was unfairly dismissed by the new employer that took over the business, and awarded £34,485 for unfair dismissal, breach of contract, and unauthorised deductions from wages.
Won · £34,485 · Nov 2023Won£34,485Nov 2023Care assistant (2 years 6 months' service) v The Royal Star & Garter Homes
A care assistant was unfairly dismissed after his employer relied on a vaccination deadline that had already been extended. The tribunal awarded £12,137.94.
Won · £12,138 · Nov 2023Won£12,138Nov 2023Agency caretaker (13 days' service) v Future Academies
An agency caretaker who worked for only 13 days at Pimlico Academy lost his claims of direct and indirect discrimination over keys, phone use, and prayer breaks. The tribunal found no less favourable treatment.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v A&A Enterprises London Ltd
A former employee who signed a settlement agreement and later brought new claims had her case struck out as an abuse of process. The tribunal found she had mental capacity when signing.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Healthcare Consultant (6 years' service) v BUPA Insurance Services Ltd
A healthcare consultant with 6 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct following four customer complaints about his attitude. The tribunal also rejected his claims of race discrimination and victimisation.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Chartered Surveyor (self-employed consultant) v Clements Agency Limited
A chartered surveyor who worked for Clements Agency Limited for nearly 30 years on a self-employed basis had his claim for unfair dismissal and discrimination struck out. The tribunal found he had no reasonable prospect of proving he was an employee.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee v Qioptiq Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Qioptiq Limited was dismissed after he submitted it nearly two months late and failed to provide medical evidence for the delay despite multiple opportunities.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Emergency Medical Technician 1 (15 years' service) v North West Ambulance Service NHS Trust
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of an EMT with 15 years' service who used the n-word about a black colleague on two occasions, finding the employer's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023General Manager (charity founder) v Like U CIO
A general manager who resigned over a hostile working environment was later dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal found he was wrongfully dismissed but his whistleblowing claim failed because it was brought too late.
Partial · Nov 2023Partial—Nov 2023Deputy Design Director (5 years' service) v Greenland (United Kingdom) Investment Limited
A deputy design director who brought claims of unfair dismissal, discrimination, harassment, victimisation, and unlawful deduction from wages after being made redundant has lost all her claims at the London Central Employment Tribunal.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Senior nurse (3 years' service) v Barchester Healthcare Ltd
A tribunal struck out a senior nurse's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims because she filed them more than four years after the deadline, despite knowing the time limits.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Taxi driver (2 years 9 months' service) v Uber Britannia Limited
A taxi driver who waited over six months to bring his claim after Uber deactivated his account has had his case thrown out by the Nottingham tribunal for being well outside the three-month time limit.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee v The Bowness Pudding Company Limited
A former employee of The Bowness Pudding Company Limited was unfairly dismissed and awarded £11,934.76 after the company failed to follow the ACAS Code of Practice and did not provide a written statement of employment terms.
Won · £11,935 · Nov 2023Won£11,935Nov 2023Director of Strategy (3 years' service) v Soldo Software Ltd
A director of strategy who was the only person in her redundancy pool lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer acted reasonably in a genuine redundancy situation.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Security Officer (17 years' service) v Bouygues E&S Solutions Limited
A security officer who refused to carry out hand sanitiser checks was unfairly dismissed due to a flawed investigation, but his 75% contribution and a 90% Polkey reduction meant he received only £5,281.
Partial · £5,281 · Nov 2023Partial£5,281Nov 2023Housing Officer (agency worker, 1 month service) v Central Bedfordshire Council
A housing officer who worked for Central Bedfordshire Council for just one month via an agency had her claims of whistleblowing detriment and harassment related to disability and transgender status dismissed by the Watford Employment Tribunal.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Head of Workforce Development and Engagement (resigned) v North Tees and Hartlepool NHS Foundation Trust
A head of workforce development who resigned alleging constructive dismissal and whistleblowing had her claims struck out after she repeatedly failed to comply with case management orders and stopped engaging with the tribunal.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Dump truck driver v Stevens Equipment Rental Limited
A dump truck driver on a zero-hours contract claimed he was unfairly dismissed after being removed from a client site, but the tribunal found he resigned. His claim failed.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023HR professional (many years' service) v Eurochange Ltd
An experienced HR professional's claims of constructive unfair dismissal and disability discrimination will proceed to a full hearing after the tribunal refused to strike them out, though deposit orders were made.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Production operative (13 years' service) v Cranswick Convenience Foods Ltd
A production operative with 13 years' service was dismissed for capability due to ill health after a telephone meeting. Most of her claims were struck out as out of time, but one disability discrimination claim will proceed.
Partial · Nov 2023Partial—Nov 2023Kitchen porter v Boiler & Company UK Limited
Two kitchen porters successfully claimed unauthorised wage deductions of £480, but their unfair dismissal claims were thrown out due to insufficient service.
Partial · £480 · Nov 2023Partial£480Nov 2023Independent clerk to school admission appeals panels v Royal Borough of Greenwich
A long-serving independent clerk who worked for Royal Borough of Greenwich for 28 years was found to be a worker rather than an employee, meaning her unfair dismissal claim could not proceed. Her remaining claims for holiday pay and expenses were also dismissed as too late.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Engineer / Salvage Buyer (18 years' service) v 4th Dimension Innovation Ltd (Group)
An engineer with 18 years' service resigned after his request for a four-day week was refused. The employment tribunal found his employer had reasonable cause and dismissed the claim.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Care worker (5 years' service) v 1st Grade Care Ltd
A care worker on a zero-hours contract was constructively and unfairly dismissed after her employer suspended her without pay and failed to respond to her grievance. The tribunal found a fundamental breach of trust and confidence.
Won · Nov 2023Won—Nov 2023CAD/CAM Designer and Machinist (17 years' service) v Arrow Precision Manufacturing Ltd
A CAD/CAM designer with 17 years' service lost his constructive dismissal claim after being laid off for four weeks without pay. The tribunal found he had accepted a 2018 contract with a lay-off clause by his conduct.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Property Operations Manager (self-employed) v Holborn Assets Insurance Brokers LLC
A property operations manager who worked from home for a Dubai-based firm was found by the tribunal to be self-employed, not an employee or worker, meaning his claims could not proceed.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee v Serco Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims were struck out after they failed to attend hearings, comply with case management orders, or contact the tribunal for over six months.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Hairdresser (2 years 5 months' service) v Layla's Lengths Limited
A hairdresser with over two years' service was dismissed by text message after a dispute over taking a half day. The tribunal awarded £4,778 for unfair dismissal and unpaid wages.
Won · £4,778 · Nov 2023Won£4,778Nov 2023HGV driver (night driver, 12 years' service) v Walon Limited t/a BCA Automotive
Four HGV night drivers with up to 12 years' service were unfairly dismissed when their employer assumed their jobs would transfer to a new contractor under TUPE, but the tribunal found no organised grouping existed.
Won · Nov 2023Won—Nov 2023Manager (6 years' service) v Stapletons (Tyre Services) Limited
A manager with six years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed investigation into password sharing and order deletion. The tribunal awarded £5,552 but reduced compensation because he contributed to his own dismissal.
Won · £5,552 · Nov 2023Won£5,552Nov 2023Former employee v AM Construction and Engineering Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was thrown out because he relied on the Citizens Advice Bureau to submit his claim, but the three-month deadline had already passed.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee v Esto Es Espana Ltd
A former employee of Esto Es Espana Ltd had their unfair dismissal claim thrown out because they had worked for less than two years. However, they were awarded £953 for unauthorised wage deductions, breach of contract, and unpaid annual leave.
Partial · £953 · Nov 2023Partial£953Nov 2023Customer service assistant (3 years 8 months' service) v Trenitalia C2C Limited
A customer service assistant who tried to strike a teenage customer with an open hand was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal ruled. His race discrimination claims against third-party security guards were also dismissed.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Assistant headteacher (12 years' service) v YY
An assistant headteacher with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after sending a sexual message to a child under duress from a coercive partner. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Casual worker (10 days' service) v JAVA Art Limited
A casual worker who responded to a Facebook post for help unloading a container has won a claim for unpaid wages, holiday pay, and failure to provide a written statement. The tribunal awarded £1,306.
Won · £1,306 · Nov 2023Won£1,306Nov 2023Former employee (25 years' service) v Advisory Conciliation and Arbitration Service
A former employee with 25 years' service lost his constructive dismissal claim against ACAS after resigning over parking arrangements following an office move. The tribunal found the employer had acted reasonably.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee (10 days' service) v MacBeattie Recruitment Ltd t/as ROC Recruitment
A tribunal dismissed a former employee's race discrimination claim after she filed it two weeks past the extended deadline, finding no credible reason for the delay and describing the claim's merits as weak.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee v The A&S Leisure Group Ltd (t/a Napoleon’s Casino Bradford)
A tribunal struck out a former employee's claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination after she admitted inappropriate touching, failed to attend hearings, and ignored tribunal communications.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee (redundant) v Clements Limited (in Administration)
A tribunal awarded 90 days' pay to 15 employees dismissed without any consultation when Clements Limited went into administration.
Won · Nov 2023Won—Nov 2023Former employee v McFarlane Telfer Ltd
A former employee has been awarded £26,554 after the tribunal found McFarlane Telfer Ltd unfairly dismissed them, though a 15% reduction was applied for contributory conduct.
Won · £26,554 · Nov 2023Won£26,554Nov 2023Healthcare assistant (3 months' service) v Gain Healthcare Limited
A healthcare assistant who was dismissed without notice after just three months has been awarded £480 in notice pay. The tribunal rejected his other claims for automatic unfair dismissal, sex discrimination, and breach of contract.
Partial · £480 · Nov 2023Partial£480Nov 2023Night care assistant (3 years' service) v Runwood Homes Ltd
A night care assistant who was found asleep on three occasions was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal also rejected his claims of discrimination and whistleblowing detriment.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Regional Manager (care homes, probationary period) v Sanctuary Care Limited
A regional manager dismissed during her probationary period for capability reasons lost her claim that she was automatically unfairly dismissed for whistleblowing. The tribunal found her protected disclosure played no part in the decision.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Registered Manager (later HR, Compliance and Finance) v Riann Care Limited
A registered manager who resigned after her employer restricted her system access following a protected disclosure was not constructively dismissed, the tribunal ruled, but she won £1,309.52 for an unlawful wage deduction.
Partial · £1,310 · Nov 2023Partial£1,310Nov 2023Former employee v Cinzia Morris and Ian Morris
A former employee's race and religion discrimination claims were struck out after she failed to provide a properly constructed amendment despite a tribunal order. Her solicitor's last-minute postponement request was refused.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Senior Lecturer v Teesside University
A tribunal struck out a Senior Lecturer's unfair dismissal and race discrimination claim after he failed to attend a preliminary hearing and did not comply with orders to explain his absence. His application to reconsider was refused.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Service host (22 years' service) v Asda Stores Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld Asda's dismissal of a service host with 22 years' service after CCTV showed her taking coins and bags for life without paying. The tribunal found the decision was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v T33 Holdings Ltd
A former employee of T33 Holdings Ltd has been awarded £34,597.88 after the tribunal found the company made unauthorised deductions from wages, failed to pay notice pay, and unreasonably failed to comply with the ACAS Code of Practice.
Partial · £34,598 · Nov 2023Partial£34,598Nov 2023Senior Customer Advisor (16 years' service) v EE Limited
A senior customer advisor with 16 years' unblemished service was dismissed for gross misconduct after creating two accounts for one customer. The tribunal upheld the decision, finding the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Bureau operator (19 years' service) v Thales DIS UK Limited
A bureau operator with 19 years' service had his claims for breach of contract and discrimination thrown out because they were lodged over four years after his dismissal.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Senior hairdresser (12 years' service) v Razors Edge Group Limited
A senior hairdresser with 12 years' service who resigned after her employer refused her GP-recommended phased return of two days a week has been awarded £13,699 for constructive unfair dismissal and failure to make reasonable adjustments.
Partial · £13,699 · Nov 2023Partial£13,699Nov 2023Former employee v Keepmoat Homes Ltd
A tribunal dismissed a former employee's claims for unfair dismissal, breach of contract and unlawful deductions because they were presented one day late, and it was reasonably practicable to file on time despite dyslexia and Covid-19.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee v Oxleas NHS Foundation Trust
A former employee agreed to a judgment by consent to settle an unfair dismissal claim, but later challenged the recoupment of £16,000 in jobseeker's allowance. The tribunal refused to reconsider.
Settled · £16,887 · Nov 2023Settled£16,887Nov 2023Former store manager v Co-operative Group Limited
A former store manager's unfair dismissal claim against Co-operative Group Limited was struck out after he failed to provide a witness statement or attend the final hearing.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Office Manager (5 months' service) v Trustmark Plans Limited
An office manager with just five months' service was sexually harassed by a colleague and then dismissed using fake disciplinary records. The tribunal awarded £39,662.92.
Partial · £39,663 · Nov 2023Partial£39,663Nov 2023BSL Communicator/Instructor (12 years' service) v Myerscough College Further Education Corporation
A BSL communicator with 12 years' service lost her constructive dismissal claim after the tribunal found that an out-of-office reply, which delayed her grievance appeal outcome, was not a breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Care home manager (3 years' service) v HC One Limited
A care home manager with lupus who resigned after the Covid vaccine mandate was introduced has lost her constructive unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Cleaner (evening, 6 hours/week, 3 years' service) v Razors and Blades Limited
A part-time cleaner who was dismissed after asking to be furloughed has won her unfair dismissal claim after her employer failed to submit a response to the tribunal.
Partial · £2,720 · Oct 2023Partial£2,720Oct 2023Duty manager (39 years' service) v Harlech and Ardudwy Leisure
A duty manager who resigned after her employer imposed split shifts and reduced hours without consultation, and then failed to address her grievance for over a month, has been awarded £10,683.75 for constructive unfair dismissal.
Won · £10,684 · Oct 2023Won£10,684Oct 2023NHS employee v Wirral University Teaching Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
An NHS employee who withdrew an earlier tribunal claim cannot re-litigate the same factual allegations in a later constructive dismissal case, the Midlands West Employment Tribunal has ruled.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Chartered physiotherapist (Head Sports Physiotherapist, 5 months' service) v Barnet Football Club Ltd
A head sports physiotherapist was constructively dismissed after being investigated and having her grievance rejected following her pregnancy disclosure. The tribunal awarded £18,152.48.
Partial · £18,152 · Oct 2023Partial£18,152Oct 2023Procurement Director (9 years' service) v Northern Housing Consortium Ltd
A procurement director who resigned after raising concerns about commission on expired contracts has lost her tribunal claims for constructive unfair dismissal, whistleblowing detriment and disability discrimination.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Facilities Manager (6 years' service) v Marsh Farm Futures
A facilities manager with dyslexia and heart failure was unfairly dismissed after his employer turned a redundancy process into a disciplinary hearing. The tribunal found the process was a sham and the real reason was a breakdown in trust and confidence.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Former employee v Samuel Smith (Southern)
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Samuel Smith (Southern) has been struck out for failing to comply with tribunal orders and not actively pursuing the case.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Brand Manager (14 years' service) v Canners & Packers International Limited
A brand manager with 14 years' service was told she might lose her job, found a new role and left. The tribunal ruled she resigned, not that she was dismissed.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Administrator (4+ years' service) v Criteria Internet Services Limited
An administrator who was constructively dismissed and then pursued self-employment as a specialist exercise instructor had her compensation reduced because she did not look for similar office roles. She was awarded £10,261.74.
Won · £10,262 · Oct 2023Won£10,262Oct 2023Former employee v CL Davies Leisure Limited
An employment tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal claim after the former employee failed to attend the hearing and did not provide sufficient medical evidence to explain her absence.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Regional Manager (10 years' service) v POhWER
A regional manager with 10 years' service was fairly dismissed after admitting she had not been following the employer's safeguarding policy for external reporting in secure settings.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee v G4S Facilities Management (UK) Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after emails purporting to withdraw it were sent from her husband's email account. The tribunal refused her application to reconsider, finding her hacking allegation improbable and unsupported by evidence.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Former employee v Just Paper Tubes Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out as out of time after she emailed her ET1 form and failed to read the tribunal's automatic reply stating that claims cannot be accepted by email.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Former employee v LHR Airports Limited
A former employee who threatened to reveal damaging information unless his claim was settled has been ordered to pay £750 costs after withdrawing his claim minutes before a hearing.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Operations Manager (24 years' service) v DPD Group UK Ltd
An operations manager with 24 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after making unauthorised manual carded entries and giving incorrect explanations. The tribunal rejected both his unfair and wrongful dismissal claims.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Senior Bookseller (13 years' service) v Waterstones Booksellers Limited
A senior bookseller with 13 years' service was unfairly dismissed after being summarily dismissed during an investigation meeting. The tribunal awarded £11,471.80, including a 12.5% uplift for failing to follow the ACAS Code.
Partial · £11,472 · Oct 2023Partial£11,472Oct 2023Team manager (8 years' service) v SER Staffing Limited
A team manager with eight years' service was constructively dismissed after his employer removed all managerial duties for over 10 months and then disciplined him for swearing. The tribunal awarded £18,923.
Won · £18,924 · Oct 2023Won£18,924Oct 2023Course Leader for Sport (23 years' service) v New City College Limited
A tribunal found that New City College unfairly dismissed a course leader with 23 years' service after a flawed investigation into misconduct during the pandemic. The claimant was awarded £53,256.95 including a 20% ACAS uplift.
Partial · £53,257 · Oct 2023Partial£53,257Oct 2023Asbestos supervisor (7 years' service) v Safe Strip UK Limited
An asbestos supervisor unfairly dismissed for redundancy was awarded £3,298 after a 75% Polkey reduction. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair but applied a large reduction for the chance of fair dismissal.
Partial · £3,298 · Oct 2023Partial£3,298Oct 2023Self-employed contractor (via personal service company) v Caudwell Properties (CP109) Ltd
A self-employed contractor who provided services through his own limited company was not an employee and therefore could not bring an unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal dismissed the claim.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Consultant Obstetrician and Gynaecologist (9 years' service) v West Hertfordshire Hospitals NHS Trust
An employment tribunal has dismissed all claims by a consultant obstetrician and gynaecologist who argued she was unfairly dismissed for whistleblowing and race discrimination, upholding the NHS trust's decision to dismiss her on capability grounds after a coroner found her account of a baby's death unreliable.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Care assistant (live-in carer) v Lovingangels Care Limited
A live-in care assistant was unfairly dismissed after her role ended when the care recipient moved into a care home. The tribunal found the employer failed to consider furlough and conducted a rubber-stamp appeal.
Partial · £9,378 · Oct 2023Partial£9,378Oct 2023Former employee v The Bull (Colchester) Ltd
Two former employees of The Bull (Colchester) Ltd were awarded over £5,000 after the pub failed to pay their final wages, holiday pay, and notice pay, and did not provide written employment particulars.
Partial · £5,032 · Oct 2023Partial£5,032Oct 2023General Assistant (4 months' service) v Durham Indoor Bowling Club Community Association Limited
A general assistant who walked out of his shift twice and claimed he was dismissed for whistleblowing has lost his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the real reason was his conduct, not any protected disclosure.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Shunter (HGV driver, 2 years' service) v Moran Logistics Ltd
A shunter with two years' service was unfairly dismissed after an accident while 'buddying up' — a practice that was custom and practice at the site. The tribunal found procedural flaws and pressure from senior management made the dismissal unreasonable.
Won · Oct 2023Won—Oct 2023Care home manager (9 years' service) v Prime Care (UK) Ltd t/a Sylvan Home Care Service
A Liverpool tribunal ruled that a care home manager with nine years' service was unfairly dismissed for smoking in the office, finding the real reason was antagonism after she raised a grievance. She was awarded £3,854.25, reduced by 50% for contributory fault.
Partial · £3,854 · Oct 2023Partial£3,854Oct 2023Pharmacy Manager (15 years' service) v Bestway Panacea Holdings Limited
A pharmacy manager who resigned after his employer reduced hours based on computer modelling has lost his constructive dismissal claim. The tribunal found no fundamental breach of contract.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee v Aurora Lighting UK Ltd
A tribunal refused an employer's application for a deposit order against a former employee whose unfair dismissal claim was filed one day late, finding he had reasonable prospects of arguing the effective date of termination was after the transfer date.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee v Rob Wyman Homes Limited
A former employee who sought £1,550 in costs after the respondent delayed disclosure by a week has had his application refused. The tribunal found the conduct was not unreasonable.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Maintenance worker (11 years' service) v City Care Partnership Limited
A maintenance worker with 11 years' service resigned after his employer investigated and responded to his grievance. The tribunal found the process was fair and dismissed his constructive unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee v Office Holdings Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was thrown out after she failed to attend a preliminary hearing, despite being warned that the hearing would proceed in her absence.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023CASS CF10 & Senior Risk Manager (12 days' service) v Global Prime Partners Ltd
A senior risk manager who worked for Global Prime Partners Ltd for just 12 days had her unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims thrown out after the tribunal ruled she was not an employee and her discrimination claim was over three years late.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Research Assistant (12 years' service) v Newcastle University
A research assistant with 12 years' service lost her claim for unfair dismissal, whistleblowing detriment and disability discrimination after the tribunal found her redundancy was genuinely due to loss of funding.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee v Blinds Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out because they had worked for less than two years. Their breach of contract claim also failed, but they were entitled to £90.28 holiday pay.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee v Ministry of Justice
A former employee was allowed to amend her claim to add details to a failure to make reasonable adjustments claim, but her attempt to add new claims of direct sex discrimination and harassment was refused by the tribunal.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Production operative (6 years' service) v Jaguar Land Rover Limited
A production operative with six years' service was unfairly dismissed and discriminated against due to disability-related sickness absence. The tribunal awarded £147,572.75 in compensation.
Won · £147,573 · Oct 2023Won£147,573Oct 2023Client Account Manager (4 years' service) v NSL Limited
A Client Account Manager with 4 years' service was fairly dismissed for redundancy after refusing to attend selection interviews and declining an alternative role. The tribunal upheld the dismissal by a majority, finding the redundancy genuine and the process reasonable.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Sales Administrator (11 years' service) v Launch Tech UK Limited
A Sales Administrator with 11 years' service resigned after a workplace argument and poor communication, but the tribunal found no fundamental breach of contract or discrimination.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Swimming teachers v Achieve Lifestyle Ltd
A tribunal found that Achieve Lifestyle Ltd unfairly dismissed two swimming teachers after a dispute over furlough pay, and failed to make reasonable adjustments for one teacher with breast cancer.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Train driver (5 years' service) v London Underground Limited
A London Underground train driver with five years' service was unfairly dismissed and discriminated against after being sacked for long-term sickness despite occupational health and a specialist both saying he could return with adjustments.
Won · Oct 2023Won—Oct 2023Head of Maintenance (4 years' service) v Roehampton University
A tribunal has dismissed a head of maintenance's constructive unfair dismissal claim against Roehampton University, finding that the employer's handling of workplace incidents did not breach the implied term of trust and confidence.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Driver Installer (4 months' service) v A&J Sectional Buildings Ltd
A driver installer who was dismissed after challenging his pay rate has been allowed to pursue an automatically unfair dismissal claim, despite having less than two years' service.
Remitted · Oct 2023Remitted—Oct 2023General Manager (17 years' service) v Bestway Wholesale Limited
A General Manager with 17 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after his IT account was used to raise fraudulent credit notes worth £32,000. The tribunal found the dismissal fair and rejected all other claims.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee (22 years' service) v Optim Management Ltd
A former employee with 22 years' service was unfairly dismissed after being given just one week's notice. The employer failed to attend the hearing or provide a reason, resulting in a £25,055 award.
Won · £25,056 · Oct 2023Won£25,056Oct 2023Civil Enforcement Officer (parking warden) (12 years' service) v NSL Limited
A civil enforcement officer with severe dyslexia was unfairly dismissed after GPS data appeared to contradict his patrol records. The tribunal found procedural failings and indirect disability discrimination, awarding £17,126.
Partial · £17,127 · Oct 2023Partial£17,127Oct 2023Former employee v Mitchells & Butlers Retail Ltd.
An employment tribunal struck out a former employee's unfair dismissal claim after she failed to comply with any part of a case management order, leading to cancellation of the full hearing.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Former employee v Blamire Bakery Limited
A former employee of Blamire Bakery Limited has won her claim for unfair and wrongful dismissal after being made redundant without proper process. The tribunal awarded £11,960.28.
Won · £11,960 · Oct 2023Won£11,960Oct 2023Operational Postal Grade employee (19 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
An employment tribunal has ruled that Royal Mail fairly dismissed a 19-year employee after magic mushrooms were found with his locker key fob, despite his later retraction of an admission.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Medical Lead (GP) v Practice Plus Group Health and Rehabilitation Services Ltd
A tribunal found that a GP with bipolar disorder and severe neck pain was constructively dismissed and discriminated against after her employer failed to provide a suitable chair and mouse, and treated her negatively in a performance meeting.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Software engineer (India-based) v Alten Limited
An Indian-based software engineer who worked for an Indian subsidiary of Alten Limited has had his unfair dismissal and discrimination claims dismissed because the UK tribunal lacked territorial jurisdiction.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Nursery Chef (10 months' service) v Once Upon a Time Day Nurseries Limited
A nursery chef who was dismissed after raising concerns about nursery practices failed in her whistleblowing claims but succeeded in recovering £276.49 that her employer deducted from her wages for outstanding nursery fees without her written consent.
Partial · £276 · Oct 2023Partial£276Oct 2023Recruitment agency worker (1 year 7 months' service) v Pertemps Recruitment Partnership Ltd
A recruitment agency worker who resigned after a return-to-work meeting could not bring an unfair dismissal claim because he had less than two years' service and presented his claim too late.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Lunchtime supervisor (20 years' service) v Diocese of Ely Multi-Academy Trust
A lunchtime supervisor with 20 years' service resigned claiming constructive dismissal but filed her claim 117 days late. The tribunal dismissed the claim for lack of jurisdiction and struck out discrimination claims as having no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Call centre agent (10 months' service) v Salim Algunaidi
A call centre agent with learning difficulties failed to prove that his managers discriminated against him. The tribunal dismissed claims of failure to make reasonable adjustments and harassment.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee v Acton Vale Community Association
A former employee has won her claim for constructive unfair dismissal and breach of contract for notice pay against Acton Vale Community Association. A remedy hearing will determine compensation in January 2024.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Estate agent employee v Staton’s Estate Agents LLP
An estate agent with Crohn's disease was constructively dismissed and discriminated against after her employer sidelined her due to her disability. The tribunal awarded £46,652.74.
Partial · £46,653 · Oct 2023Partial£46,653Oct 2023Customer Service Manager (6 years' service) v Ladbrokes Betting and Gaming Limited
A Customer Service Manager with 6 years' service was constructively dismissed after being repeatedly overlooked for increased hours while a colleague was given a 30-hour contract. The tribunal found direct disability discrimination and unfair dismissal.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Customer Adviser (22 years' service) v Boots Management Services Ltd
A customer adviser with 22 years' service was unfairly dismissed by Boots after a redundancy exercise that failed to properly explore alternative roles. The tribunal upheld the unfair dismissal claim but dismissed race-related complaints.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Former employee v Beaver-Visitec International Limited
A former employee's harassment and victimisation claims against her employer were deemed in time if there was conduct over a period, but time was extended for a harassment claim against the individual manager.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Store Assistant (20 years' service) v Sainsbury’s Supermarkets Ltd
A Sainsbury's store assistant with 20 years' service was fairly dismissed after refusing to accept a change to her working hours as part of a business reorganisation. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Science Director (7 years' service) v O3Biotech Limited
A science director who was dismissed after a colleague reported smelling cannabis in his company car has lost his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Shop assistant (20 years' service) v Mehat Six Bells Limited
A shop assistant who worked for 20 years without pay, then for below the National Minimum Wage, has won her constructive dismissal claim. The tribunal found she was subjected to detriments for asserting her right to be paid.
Won · Oct 2023Won—Oct 2023Machine tool maintenance technician (11 months' service) v Cosworth Ltd
A machine tool maintenance technician with 11 months' service was refused interim relief after being dismissed for unauthorised absence. The tribunal found he did not have a 'pretty good chance' of proving his whistleblowing claim, but allowed the case to proceed to a full hearing.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Bar worker (2 years' service) v David Brooker
A bar worker who was paid £400 a week for variable hours was underpaid the National Minimum Wage by over £2,600. The tribunal also awarded £800 for failure to provide written particulars.
Partial · £3,402 · Oct 2023Partial£3,402Oct 2023Civil engineer v 2010 OPTICS LTD (in Creditors Voluntary Liquidation)
A civil engineer who was dismissed without notice and not paid his final wages, holiday pay, or notice pay has been awarded £5,819 by an employment tribunal. The employer had since gone into liquidation.
Won · £5,819 · Oct 2023Won£5,819Oct 2023HR and Recruitment Coordinator (3 years' service) v Oyster Bay Systems Ltd
An HR and Recruitment Coordinator won her constructive unfair dismissal claim after her employer failed to deal with her grievance and sent mixed messages that destroyed trust and confidence. The tribunal awarded £15,195.90.
Won · £15,196 · Oct 2023Won£15,196Oct 2023Former employee v Mazars LLP
A former employee won claims of constructive unfair dismissal and disability discrimination against Mazars LLP after the firm failed to make reasonable adjustments and subjected him to harassment.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Commercial Manager (2 years' service) v T&R Direct Insurance Limited
A Commercial Manager who was shouted at and demeaned after returning from depression-related sick leave was constructively dismissed. The tribunal awarded £56,542 for unfair dismissal, disability discrimination and harassment.
Won · £56,542 · Oct 2023Won£56,542Oct 2023Former employee v C A Leith (Opticians) Limited
A former optician employee's disability discrimination claims were dismissed because they were filed too late. The tribunal refused to extend the time limit, finding it was not just and equitable to do so.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Sales assistant (7 months' service) v Electronic Wholesale Suppliers (Guildford) Limited
A sales assistant who was dismissed for unauthorised absence the day after submitting a fit note for mixed anxiety and depressive disorder has won a disability harassment claim. The tribunal awarded £22,178.95.
Partial · £22,179 · Oct 2023Partial£22,179Oct 2023Non-registered vaccinator (supplied by Bank Partners to UCLH) v Anonymous respondent
A tribunal dismissed claims of disability discrimination and harassment by a vaccinator with borderline personality disorder who was sent home from work due to concerns about her emotional stability and medication status.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee (3 years' service) v Areaworks Group Limited (in voluntary liquidation)
A former employee was unfairly dismissed after making a protected disclosure about health and safety. The tribunal awarded over £50,000, including a 25% uplift for the employer's failure to follow the ACAS Code of Conduct.
Partial · £50,312 · Oct 2023Partial£50,312Oct 2023Passenger Assistant (3 years 6 months' service) v Elizabeth Abbots T/A Ladybirds Travel
A tribunal found a passenger assistant with sciatica was not disabled at the time of her dismissal, because her symptoms had not lasted 12 months and there was no evidence they would. The disability discrimination claim was dismissed.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Former employee (12 years' service) v Sovereign Housing Association Ltd
A housing association was found to have constructively dismissed a long-serving employee after mishandling his grievance. The tribunal awarded over £11,000 in compensation, including a basic award of £6,096 and a compensatory award of £1,073.
Partial · £11,233 · Oct 2023Partial£11,233Oct 2023On Train Technician (health and safety critical role, 8 years' service) v Network Rail Infrastructure Limited
An On Train Technician was unfairly dismissed after testing positive for cocaine metabolite from coca tea, but the tribunal reduced his compensation to nil because he was wholly to blame for failing to research the product.
Partial · £0 · Oct 2023Partial£0Oct 2023Former employee v Conwy County Borough Council
An employment tribunal refused to strike out Conwy County Borough Council's response despite persistent delays in providing a List of Issues and disclosure, finding a fair trial was still possible.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Production Manager (23 years' service) v Northern Joinery Limited
A production manager with 23 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after an investigation into missing scrap wood sale proceeds, the tribunal ruled, despite errors in the employer's spreadsheet evidence.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Shift Manager (5.5 years' service) v Lidl Great Britain Ltd
A Lidl shift manager who admitted lone working and asking colleagues to remain in store after clocking out was fairly dismissed, the tribunal ruled.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Business development manager (commission-based) v Member Benefits Limited
A business development manager who worked on a commission-only basis has been awarded £1,214.50 in unpaid commission after the tribunal found she was a worker, not an employee.
Partial · £1,215 · Oct 2023Partial£1,215Oct 2023Sales & Customer Service Supervisor (Felton, 18 years' service) and Sales & Customer Service Assistant (Smith, 7 years' service) v Britannia Driving School Limited
Two employees who claimed constructive dismissal and unfair dismissal against Britannia Driving School Ltd had their claims dismissed after the tribunal found a TUPE transfer had already moved their employment to another company.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Community development worker (4 months' service) v The Complete Care Group Limited
A community development worker with four months' service was dismissed for missing a shift. The tribunal found the reason was absence, not her protected disclosures.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee (6 years' service) v Causeway Heating Services Limited
A former employee with six years' service won £26,374 after resigning when he discovered the grievance appeal handler was a friend of his employer. The tribunal found the employer breached the ACAS Code and made unauthorised deductions.
Won · £26,374 · Oct 2023Won£26,374Oct 2023Team Member (36 years' service) v BT Plc
A team member with 36 years' service resigned after performance concerns were raised following a new ticketing system. The tribunal dismissed her constructive dismissal claim but awarded £306.40 for unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £306 · Oct 2023Partial£306Oct 2023Night shelf stacker (12 years' service) v Tesco Stores Limited
A Tesco employee with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to scan and pay for items on multiple occasions while using the Scan as You Shop service. The tribunal found Tesco's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Senior management team (CEO, Finance Director, Commercial Director, Operations Director, Acting Managing Director) v Futurama Limited (in administration)
Five senior managers were summarily dismissed for gross misconduct without any investigation or appeal. The tribunal found the dismissals unfair and wrongful, and awarded unpaid wages, holiday pay, and notice pay.
Won · Oct 2023Won—Oct 2023Former employee v Shaw Trust Ltd
A former employee's breach of contract claim against Shaw Trust Ltd was dismissed because he filed his claim one day late, despite receiving advice from ACAS and an independent advisor who failed to mention the time limit.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Finance Manager (11 years' service) v Heritage Oil & Gas Limited
A finance manager who lived and worked in Uganda and Nigeria for over a decade failed to bring his unfair dismissal and discrimination claims in the UK. The tribunal ruled his employment lacked a sufficient connection to Great Britain.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Barrister (criminal defence) v Stonewall Equality Limited
A barrister who was investigated by her chambers after tweeting about gender critical beliefs has been awarded £22,000 for direct discrimination and victimisation.
Partial · £22,000 · Oct 2023Partial£22,000Oct 2023Driver v Conexim Solutions Ltd
An employment tribunal struck out a driver's unfair dismissal and age discrimination claims after he failed to attend a case management hearing and did not comply with orders to provide details of his case.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Teacher of Welsh as a second language (17 years' service) v Vale of Glamorgan Council
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a Welsh teacher with 17 years' service after a lengthy capability procedure, finding that the employer made reasonable adjustments and acted fairly.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Driving examiner (14 years' service) v Driving & Vehicle Standards Agency
A driving examiner with 14 years' service was dismissed for taking photos of a colleague's personal data. The tribunal found the dismissal fair and rejected all claims of discrimination and whistleblowing detriment.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023NHS employee v Leicestershire Partnership NHS Trust
An NHS employee who tried to amend her claim three years after presenting it, adding new disability discrimination and whistleblowing allegations, has been refused by the tribunal due to the balance of hardship favouring the trust.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Playgroup employee v The Committee of Pevensey and Westham Playgroup
A playgroup employee's constructive dismissal claim was struck out after she failed to respond to a strike-out warning, ending a case that had already been delayed by a police investigation.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Security guard (6 years' service) v Bidvest Noonan (UK) Ltd
A security guard who worked only six shifts in 12 months was fairly dismissed for lack of availability, but the tribunal awarded him £790.70 for unpaid notice and holiday pay.
Partial · £791 · Oct 2023Partial£791Oct 2023Former employee v Duchy Farm Kennels Ltd
A former employee of Duchy Farm Kennels Ltd was awarded £17,570.97 after being unfairly dismissed by redundancy, with the tribunal also finding unauthorised wage deductions, unpaid holiday pay, and failure to provide written particulars.
Won · £17,571 · Oct 2023Won£17,571Oct 2023Senior employee (local government) v Liverpool City Council
A senior local government employee's constructive dismissal claim against Liverpool City Council was struck out after he admitted the employer's conduct was not calculated to destroy trust and confidence.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Former employee v Premier EA and FS Ltd
A former employee of Premier EA and FS Ltd has been awarded £58,077 after the tribunal found she was subjected to pregnancy and maternity discrimination, victimisation for raising grievances, and detriment for making protected disclosures, culminating in her unfair dismissal.
Won · £58,077 · Oct 2023Won£58,077Oct 2023Head of Policy and Participation (3 years' service) v The Royal Society for the Encouragement of Arts, Manufactures and Commerce
A head of policy was automatically unfairly dismissed after giving a newspaper interview criticising her employer's approach to union recognition. The tribunal awarded £6,959 in basic award.
Won · £6,959 · Oct 2023Won£6,959Oct 2023Former employee v Strong Maker Limited
Two former employees of Strong Maker Limited were awarded over £20,000 in total after the tribunal found they were unfairly and automatically unfairly dismissed, with a 25% uplift for the employer's failure to follow the ACAS Code of Practice.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Former employee v Auxilium Developments Limited
A former employee who worked for less than two years had their redundancy and unfair dismissal claims struck out, but won £2,691 for unauthorised wage deductions and unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £2,691 · Oct 2023Partial£2,691Oct 2023Gas engineer (6 years 9 months' service) v Plus Dane Housing Limited
A gas engineer who resigned while being investigated for working for another employer while off sick has lost his constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal also ordered him to repay £2,837.10 in sick pay.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee v Groeneveld UK Limited
A former employee who resigned and claimed constructive dismissal over part-time worker rights and national minimum wage issues has had all her claims dismissed by an employment tribunal.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Locum Clinical Neuropsychologist (fixed-term contract) v The Disabilities Trust
A locum clinical neuropsychologist's claim for unfair dismissal after sending a 'Letter of Concern' about a former colleague's dismissal has been struck out. The tribunal found the letter was not a qualifying protected disclosure.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Security guard (short service) v Lionhart Security Services Limited
A security guard with only weeks of service was dismissed after being accused of taking items without permission. The tribunal rejected his claims of protected disclosure detriment and notice pay, but awarded £627 for missing written particulars.
Lost · £627 · Oct 2023Lost£627Oct 2023Barber's assistant (2 years 6 months' service) v Mr Panayiotis Andreou Chimonides t/a Cutthroat Kings Barbers
A barber's assistant who was dismissed by text message while on sick leave has won £16,840 in compensation for unfair dismissal, unpaid wages, holiday pay and sick pay.
Won · £16,840 · Oct 2023Won£16,840Oct 2023Family Support Worker (14 years' service) v Leeds City Council
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a family support worker with 14 years' service who began a personal and later romantic relationship with a service user, finding the council's decision was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Dog walker/day care worker (5 years' service) v Look Who’s Walking Limited
A dog walker who worked set hours for five years was found to be an employee, not a self-employed contractor, and awarded over £11,700 for unfair dismissal and age discrimination.
Won · £11,707 · Oct 2023Won£11,707Oct 2023Former employee v Ocado Central Services Ltd
A former employee with a disability succeeded in a reasonable adjustments claim after Ocado failed to implement a phased return to work recommended by occupational health. The tribunal awarded £8,271.35, including £5,000 for injury to feelings.
Partial · £8,271 · Oct 2023Partial£8,271Oct 2023Kitchen porter/general assistant v Bartlett Mitchell Limited
A tribunal refused to order a claimant's representative to pay wasted costs, despite the claimant withdrawing all claims the day before the final hearing, because the respondent could not prove improper conduct.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee v Shire Oak International Ltd
Two former employees had their claims dismissed and the employer's response struck out after both sides repeatedly failed to attend hearings and comply with tribunal orders.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Registered manager (2 years' service) v Laniwyn Care Services Ltd
A registered manager was unfairly dismissed after being told by text to attend a Zoom meeting where she was given two weeks' notice for redundancy. The tribunal found no genuine redundancy and awarded £14,153.
Won · £14,153 · Oct 2023Won£14,153Oct 2023Former employee v Amazon UK Services Limited
A tribunal ruled that a former Amazon employee with tendonitis, polyarthritis and cervicalgia was disabled under the Equality Act, despite the employer's occupational health reports suggesting otherwise.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Global IT Finance Planning and Analysis Manager (5 years' service) v Walgreens Boots Alliance Services Limited
A tribunal dismissed a manager's race and sex discrimination claims because they were presented too late, finding that separate promotion decisions were not part of a continuing act and that it was not just and equitable to extend time.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Production operative (10 months' service) v GI Recruitment Limited
A production operative who reported sexual harassment but was later dismissed for gross misconduct after leaving work early without clocking out has lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Director (solicitor, 2 years' service) v Duncan Lewis Solicitors Limited
A director with extreme fatigue was dismissed for unauthorised absence without any medical evidence or occupational health referral. The tribunal found unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Teaching Assistant (5 years' service) v Lancashire County Council
A teaching assistant with anxiety and depression failed to prove that a council's refusal to let his mother represent him at a disciplinary appeal was a failure to make reasonable adjustments. The tribunal dismissed the claim.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023CEO (6 years' service) v Penny Post Credit Union Limited
A CEO with six years' service was unfairly dismissed after his employer abandoned a redundancy process and pursued gross misconduct allegations to avoid paying his 12-month contractual notice. The tribunal awarded £73,816.91.
Won · £73,817 · Oct 2023Won£73,817Oct 2023Business manager (8 years' service) v Bristol Street First Investments Limited
A business manager with 8 years' service resigned after being invited to a second disciplinary hearing for underperformance. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence and dismissed his constructive unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Security supervisor (22 years' service) v Bidvest Noonan (UK) Limited
A security supervisor with 22 years' service was fairly dismissed for a fundamental breakdown of trust and confidence after he repeatedly emailed senior management and a client threatened to cancel its contract. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Youth Services Manager (2 years' service) v Queen’s Crescent Community Association
A tribunal has dismissed a youth services manager's claim that she was automatically unfairly dismissed for whistleblowing, finding that her concerns about financial mismanagement were not protected disclosures.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Relief pharmacist (11 years' service) v Boots Management Services Limited
A relief pharmacist with 11 years' service was subjected to racial harassment by colleagues and then constructively dismissed after his employer mishandled his grievance. The tribunal awarded £45,263.11.
Partial · £45,263 · Oct 2023Partial£45,263Oct 2023Client Services Director (2 years 7 months' service) v Send DM Limited
A Client Services Director who resigned over unpaid sick pay and a claimed promotion of a male colleague has lost her constructive dismissal and sex discrimination claims. The tribunal found no fundamental breach of contract.
Lost · £269 · Oct 2023Lost£269Oct 2023Delivery driver v Euro Car Parts Limited
A delivery driver with ADHD was dismissed for persistent lateness while on a final warning. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination, finding the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee v First Greater Western Ltd
A tribunal found that a former employee had conducted litigation unreasonably but refused to strike out her claim, allowing it to proceed to a final hearing despite delays and disputes over the list of issues.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Customer Support Officer (15 months' service) v Driver & Vehicle Licensing Agency
A Customer Support Officer with long COVID and diabetes was dismissed after 8 months' absence. The tribunal rejected his disability discrimination claims, finding the DVLA acted reasonably.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Finance Manager (7 years' service) v SSCP Spring Bidco Limited t/a Outcomes First Group Limited
An Employment Tribunal has dismissed all claims of maternity discrimination, harassment, victimisation and unfair dismissal brought by a Finance Manager who was made redundant shortly after returning from maternity leave.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Finance and commissioning officer (18 years' service) v Hertfordshire County Council
A finance and commissioning officer with 18 years' service was constructively dismissed after Hertfordshire County Council unfairly re-graded her role and failed to properly consider her grievance. The tribunal awarded £66,476.86.
Won · £66,477 · Oct 2023Won£66,477Oct 2023Technical Services Manager (5 years' service) v Incentive Facilities Management Limited
A Technical Services Manager was fairly dismissed after bypassing an overheat stat on an air handling unit and swearing at a colleague. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Senior doctor (consultant cardiac surgeon) v Liverpool Heart and Chest Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
A consultant cardiac surgeon who presented his unfair dismissal claim five months after the deadline was refused an extension. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for him to have claimed in time, despite his health issues and lack of awareness of the time limit.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Former employee v Invicta Care and Training Ltd.
A Watford tribunal found Invicta Care and Training Ltd. unlawfully deducted wages and failed to pay holiday pay and notice pay, awarding the former employee £4,924.02.
Won · £4,924 · Oct 2023Won£4,924Oct 2023Part-time band 4 endoscopy scheduler (9 years' service) v Medway NHS Foundation Trust
A part-time endoscopy scheduler with 9 years' service lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim after the tribunal found no fundamental breach of contract by Medway NHS Foundation Trust.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Hair stylist (3 months' service) v Hair at Two Ten Limited
A hair stylist who worked for just three months at a salon without a written contract has been found by an employment tribunal to be an employee, not self-employed, paving the way for her discrimination and pay claims.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Evidence and Evaluation Lead (fixed-term contracts from 2018 to 2021) v Secretary of State for Health and Social Care
A tribunal has allowed a fixed-term employee to amend his claim to add further particulars of less favourable treatment, despite the application being made just days before the hearing.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Personal Banker (8 years' service) v Santander UK Plc
An employment tribunal has dismissed a personal banker's claims of constructive unfair dismissal and disability discrimination against Santander UK Plc, finding that the final straw she relied on was innocuous and that earlier alleged breaches were not linked to her resignation.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Driver Technician (Tanker Driver) (3 years' service) v Fuels Transport and Logistics Ltd
A tanker driver who resigned after alleging bullying and harassment lost his constructive dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer's grievance investigations were adequate and there was no breach of trust.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023HR Officer (24 years' service) v London Borough of Haringey
A long-serving HR officer who resigned after a nine-month disciplinary investigation has lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal ruled she had affirmed her contract by waiting over seven months to resign.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Paramedic (27 years' service) v London Ambulance Service NHS Trust
A London Ambulance Service paramedic who was dismissed for bullying colleagues after failing a mask fit test has lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer's investigation was thorough and the decision reasonable.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Head of People Services (4 months' service) v Chief Constable of Merseyside Police
A Head of People Services with only four months' service was dismissed for lack of suitability during her probation. The tribunal found no link between her protected disclosures and the dismissal, rejecting claims of automatic unfair dismissal and detriment.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Sales commission agent (employment status disputed) v S & H Wholesale & Distribution t/a Max Distribution Ent Ltd
A sales commission agent who brought claims against five different employers had most of his case struck out because the claims were out of time and he failed to provide required details. The tribunal also found he lacked the two years' service needed for an unfair dismissal claim.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Former employee v Carter Technical Mouldings Ltd
A former employee won £7,881 after their employer admitted the claim of unfair dismissal and related claims. The tribunal awarded redundancy pay, notice pay, and holiday pay.
Won · £7,881 · Oct 2023Won£7,881Oct 2023Associate Chief Pharmacist Clinical Lead (Band 8C, 2 years 9 months' service) v The Queen Elizabeth Hospital King’s Lynn NHS Foundation Trust
The tribunal rejected a constructive unfair dismissal claim by an Associate Chief Pharmacist, finding the Trust had not breached the implied term of trust and confidence.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Apprentice beauty therapist (aged 17, less than 3 months' service) v Miss Gemma Boardman trading as House of GB
A 17-year-old apprentice beauty therapist who complained about not receiving rest breaks was dismissed during her trial period. The tribunal found the real reason was a stock incident, not her complaints, so the dismissal was fair.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Pre-school practitioner v St Mark’s Pre-School
A pre-school practitioner who claimed she was dismissed for whistleblowing lost her case after the tribunal found her disclosures did not tend to show health or safety endangerment.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Project manager (21 years' service) v Greenhey Industrial and Marine Engineering Limited
A project manager with 21 years' service was fairly dismissed after a listening device was found in his boss's office, with wires leading to his desk. The Liverpool tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee (less than 2 years' service) v Baxi Heating UK Ltd
A former employee with less than two years' service had her unfair dismissal complaint struck out by the tribunal. Other discrimination claims remain pending.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Nurse (3 years 3 months' service) v Quality Care Management Ltd
A nurse who was dismissed for gross misconduct in 2021 waited over two years to bring her claim. The tribunal refused to extend time, striking out both her unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Former employee v Independent Office for Police Conduct
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against the Independent Office for Police Conduct was thrown out at a preliminary hearing because she had not worked there long enough to qualify for protection.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023CSS General (20 years' service) v Yodel Delivery Network Limited
A tribunal dismissed unfair dismissal and wage claims from a CSS General with 20 years' service because he waited over five months to contact ACAS, even though he continued to receive salary after dismissal.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Contracts and Procurement Lawyer (agency worker) v London Borough of Waltham Forest
An agency Contracts and Procurement Lawyer lost her race discrimination, harassment and victimisation claims against the London Borough of Waltham Forest. The tribunal also ordered her to pay costs for pursuing claims with no reasonable prospect of success.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Sterile Cleaning Supervisor (former employee) v Mitie Ltd, GlaxoSmithKline Services Unlimited, Draefern Ltd t/as GI Group
A former sterile cleaning supervisor had her disability discrimination claim against an employment agency struck out after she could not identify any discriminatory act by the agency.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Faculty Manager (23 years' service) v Canterbury Christ Church University
A tribunal found that Canterbury Christ Church University unfairly dismissed a faculty manager and discriminated against her because of her disability when it decided she was not appointable to a new role due to her ill health. She was awarded £32,684.
Won · £32,684 · Oct 2023Won£32,684Oct 2023Process Controller / Vessel Controller (25 years' service) v The Felixstowe Dock and Railway Company
A process controller with 25 years' service had his harassment claim struck out as too old, and his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims dismissed after a full hearing. The tribunal found the dismissal was fair and any discrimination was justified.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Assistant Officer (HMRC) v Commissioners for HM Revenue & Customs
An HMRC assistant officer's claim that her flexible working application was unreasonably refused has been dismissed by the Newcastle Employment Tribunal. The tribunal found the employer properly considered the request and rejected it on the permitted ground of detrimental impact on quality.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023SHEQ Advisor (probationary employee) v SMS Connections Ltd
An employment tribunal refused interim relief to a probationary SHEQ Advisor who claimed she was automatically unfairly dismissed for raising fire safety concerns. The tribunal found she did not have a pretty good chance of proving the email was the principal reason for her dismissal.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Maths teacher (3 years' service) v Summit Learning Trust
A maths teacher with three years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after sharing his personal mobile number and a test paper with a student, and sending over 50 emails to students outside school hours. The Employment Tribunal upheld the dismissal.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Cook (22 years' service) v KZ Catering Ltd
A cook who claimed unauthorised deductions from his wages after being paid only statutory sick pay had his claim dismissed. The tribunal found the employer had discretion over contractual sick pay and had exercised it lawfully.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Paralegal/caseworker (1 year 10 months' service) v Khans Solicitors
A paralegal with six disabilities was unfairly dismissed after asserting her right to be paid and asking for reasonable adjustments. The tribunal awarded £109,020.64.
Won · £109,021 · Sept 2023Won£109,021Sept 2023Job applicant (employment status disputed) v General Mills UK Limited
An employment tribunal struck out a claim after the claimant accused the respondent of orchestrating her eviction, finding the allegations scandalous and vexatious.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee v Fyfe Mcdade Ltd
A former employee was unfairly dismissed after Fyfe Mcdade Ltd applied an unreasonable disciplinary procedure. The tribunal awarded £2,373.20, reduced by 50% for the employee's own conduct.
Partial · £2,373 · Sept 2023Partial£2,373Sept 2023Pastry chef (zero-hours contract) v Damask Catering Limited
A pastry chef on a zero-hours contract claimed she was verbally dismissed during a 10-minute meeting, but the tribunal found no dismissal took place and struck out her claims.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee v Beechwood Property Services Ltd
A former employee who was sacked for alleged dishonesty over a positive Covid-19 test in Cameroon lost his unfair dismissal claim but won £1,536.60 for wrongful dismissal. The tribunal found the dismissal was procedurally fair but the employer failed to give proper notice.
Partial · £1,537 · Sept 2023Partial£1,537Sept 2023Former employee v London Borough of Newham
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was thrown out because he contacted ACAS two days after the three-month deadline, even though he read his dismissal email the day after it was sent.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Front-of-house staff (16-year-old student, less than 5 months' service) v Smart NYD Ltd t/a New York Diner
A 16-year-old front-of-house worker was dismissed three days after her mother confronted the manager about sexual harassment by a chef. The Manchester tribunal awarded £13,886 for victimisation.
Partial · £13,886 · Sept 2023Partial£13,886Sept 2023Senior Legal Counsel (2.5 years' service) v R&F Properties QS (UK) Co Ltd
A senior legal counsel who contacted CMS directly about an alleged conflict of interest was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal awarded £1,871.46 for unpaid notice and holiday pay.
Partial · £1,871 · Sept 2023Partial£1,871Sept 2023Insurance Account Handler (16 years' service) v Eden Insurance Services Limited
An insurance account handler with 16 years' service succeeded in her equal pay and constructive unfair dismissal claims after her employer failed to address a pay gap with a less experienced male colleague doing like work.
Partial · Sept 2023Partial—Sept 2023Gymnastics coach (3 years' service) v Daniel May
A gymnastics coach who was dismissed by email with immediate effect citing redundancy was awarded £2,230 for unauthorised wage deductions and failure to provide written particulars. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair.
Partial · £2,230 · Sept 2023Partial£2,230Sept 2023Technical Fire Consultant/Sales Representative (11 years' service) v Intumescent Systems Ltd
A technical consultant with 11 years' service was unfairly dismissed after his employer stopped paying him because his side business installing the company's products was too successful. The tribunal awarded £23,673.75, with a 20% uplift for ignoring the ACAS code.
Won · £23,674 · Sept 2023Won£23,674Sept 2023Restoration technician (5 years' service) v Restoration Force Limited
A restoration technician who left work early and then behaved aggressively during an investigation meeting was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v CH Hydraulics Limited t/a Pirtek Ellesmereport
A former employee who resigned after losing a bonus was awarded £18,731 for constructive unfair dismissal. The tribunal found the employer's conduct amounted to a fundamental breach of contract.
Won · £18,731 · Sept 2023Won£18,731Sept 2023HGV driver (Tramper) v RT Keedwell Group Ltd
An HGV driver with COPD who resigned after his employer refused to furlough him in November 2020 has lost his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims. The tribunal found the employer correctly interpreted the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme rules.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Office administrator v Manceps Limited
An office administrator dismissed during her probation period failed to convince a tribunal that her refusal to sign a loan document was a protected disclosure. The interim relief application was refused.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Commissioning Director (24 years' service) v Bradbury House Limited
A tribunal ruled that a commissioning director with 24 years' service remained an employee even after switching to a consultancy agreement via his own limited company.
Won · Sept 2023Won—Sept 2023Former employee v International Procurement and Logistics Ltd
A former employee who brought claims of unfair dismissal, disability discrimination and holiday pay arrears has been ordered to pay £4,490 in costs after failing to attend hearings and ignoring a Calderbank offer.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Account Manager (19 years' service) v 52 Street Events Supplies Ltd
An account manager with 19 years' unblemished service was summarily dismissed by email while on maternity leave, with no investigation or disciplinary hearing. The tribunal awarded £37,310.
Won · £37,310 · Sept 2023Won£37,310Sept 2023LSE Fellow (teaching role, 3 years' service) v The London School of Economics and Political Science
An LSE Fellow who alleged sexual harassment by a student and then never returned to work has lost his unfair dismissal, disability discrimination and victimisation claims. The tribunal found his allegations were dishonest and made in bad faith, and ordered him to pay the LSE's costs on an indemnity basis.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v Highams Park Academy Trust
A former employee's claims of constructive dismissal and discrimination were struck out after she failed to attend a preliminary hearing and did not provide a witness statement as directed.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Subject Leader English as an Additional Language (21 years' service) v St Augustine’s Federated Schools: CE High Schools
A Subject Leader with 21 years' service was fairly dismissed when her school restructured its EAL department. The tribunal found the consultation and consideration of alternative roles were reasonable.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Chef de rang (4 years' service) v The Clock House Restaurant Ltd
A chef de rang received £4,682 after his employer miscalculated his furlough pay. The tribunal found the restaurant had used the wrong reference salary but rejected his constructive dismissal claim.
Partial · £4,682 · Sept 2023Partial£4,682Sept 2023IT and Comms Manager (1 year 2 months' service) v The Charles Kalms, Henry Ronson Immanuel College
An IT manager with 14 months' service was fairly dismissed for gross negligence after a sophisticated cyber-attack. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim, finding the school's decision within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Deputy Manager (3 years' service) v Really Flexible Care Ltd
A deputy manager with three years' service was unfairly dismissed after her employer relied solely on a council safeguarding report without conducting its own investigation or disciplinary hearing. The Watford tribunal awarded £26,926.
Won · £26,926 · Sept 2023Won£26,926Sept 2023Deputy Chairman, Group Finance Director and Group HR Director (21 years' service) v Dextra Group PLC
A senior executive who resigned after a difficult board meeting failed to prove constructive unfair dismissal. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence despite 11 alleged incidents.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employees v Disclosure and Barring Service
A tribunal struck out all claims brought by four former employees of the Disclosure and Barring Service, finding their conduct of the litigation was so unreasonable that a fair hearing was no longer possible.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Support worker (3 years' service) v Acorn Care Home
A support worker who missed the three-month deadline to bring an unfair dismissal claim because her legal representative failed to act in time has had her case dismissed. The tribunal ruled it was reasonably practicable for her to have filed on time.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Boatman (16 years' service) v Trevor Symes
A boatman with 16 years' service was unfairly dismissed when his employer sent a text message saying there was no work. The tribunal awarded over £17,600 in compensation, including an ACAS uplift.
Won · £17,673 · Sept 2023Won£17,673Sept 2023Minibus driver (17 and 26 years' service respectively) v Hallmark Connections Limited and First Choice Mini-Bus Service Limited
Two long-serving minibus drivers were found to have been automatically unfairly dismissed when a school transport contract was awarded to a new provider who refused to take them on. The tribunal awarded a total of £47,584.72.
Won · £47,585 · Sept 2023Won£47,585Sept 2023Former employee (15 years' service) v Crystal Clear Designs and Signs Ltd
A former employee with 15 years' service was constructively dismissed after a campaign of race harassment. The tribunal awarded over £34,000 including £21,000 for injury to feelings.
Won · £34,281 · Sept 2023Won£34,281Sept 2023Firefighter (18 years' service) v Royal Berkshire Fire Authority (also known as Royal Berkshire Fire and Rescue Service)
An employment tribunal has ruled that Royal Berkshire Fire Authority fairly dismissed a firefighter who pleaded guilty to 12 firearms offences, rejecting claims of race and disability discrimination.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Wedding events manager (Mrs Brake) and Facilities and land manager (Mr Brake) v Axnoller Events Ltd (1), The Cheddington Court Estate Ltd (2), Dr Geoffrey Guy (3), Mr Russell Bowyer (4)
A married couple who worked as wedding events and facilities managers were fairly dismissed after a heated meeting where the husband shouted at the company owner. The tribunal rejected claims of unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and whistleblowing detriment.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Law Enforcement Officer (4 years' service) v London Borough of Newham
A law enforcement officer with four years' service was fairly dismissed by redundancy and his claims of race and age discrimination, harassment, and victimisation were dismissed by the tribunal.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee (5 years' service) v PYD Packaging Limited
A former employee with 5 years' service was unfairly dismissed during a redundancy process and awarded over £10,000 for unpaid notice, holiday pay, and ACAS code breach.
Partial · £10,082 · Sept 2023Partial£10,082Sept 2023Security guard v Seal Security UK Ltd
A security guard who was dismissed after being found asleep during his shift at Bloomberg LLP has lost his claims for unfair dismissal and discrimination. The tribunal found the employer acted reasonably and the discrimination claims had no merit.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023HGV driver (11 years' service) v Lomas Distribution Limited
An HGV driver with 11 years' service resigned after a heated exchange about a recurring vehicle fault. The tribunal ruled he was not dismissed, rejecting his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A former Royal Mail employee's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after he and his union representative failed to attend the first hearing. The judgment was later revoked due to the rep's family bereavement, but the claim was ultimately rejected on its merits.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former postal worker (OPG, 8 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A former Royal Mail employee who was dismissed for gross misconduct claimed his application for a seasonal role was rejected because of his earlier discrimination complaints. The tribunal disagreed, finding the rejection was automatic and unrelated to any protected act.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee (shop worker) v Ms M. Harvey T/A The Pickle Barrel
A former shop worker's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after the tribunal struck out the employer's response for failing to comply with case management directions for over two years.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v Walkdens Newsagents Limited
A former employee of Walkdens Newsagents Limited has been awarded £25,931 after the tribunal found they were unfairly and wrongfully dismissed, and that the employer made unauthorised deductions from wages and failed to pay holiday pay.
Won · £25,931 · Sept 2023Won£25,931Sept 2023Former employee v Norse Commercial Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after a full merits hearing, but a preliminary hearing over a mistaken dismissal date nearly cost him £850 in wasted costs.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Trainee Project Manager (apprentice, 1 year 4 months' service) v Gloster MEP Limited
A trainee project manager who was dismissed after complaining about underpayment of the National Minimum Wage lost his claim for automatic unfair dismissal. The tribunal found the real reason was performance and conduct issues.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v The Blurt Foundation CIC (in creditors’ voluntary liquidation)
A former employee won automatic unfair dismissal and pregnancy/maternity discrimination claims after The Blurt Foundation failed to respond. The tribunal awarded £15,093.21, including an uplift for breaching the Acas Code.
Won · £15,093 · Sept 2023Won£15,093Sept 2023Team Leader (16+ years' service) v ISS Facilities Services Ltd
A team leader with 16+ years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after three colleagues saw an indecent video of child abuse on her phone. The employment tribunal upheld the dismissal as fair.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Nursing Assistant (18 years' service) v University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
A tribunal struck out an unfair dismissal claim by a nursing assistant with 18 years' service after she failed to comply with orders, including providing a witness statement. No compensation was awarded.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee v Autosparx Limited
A former employee was unfairly dismissed after her employer failed to prove a genuine redundancy exercise. The tribunal awarded £1,921.85 in compensation.
Partial · £1,922 · Sept 2023Partial£1,922Sept 2023Former employee v Works Manager Guarantee Laundries Ltd
A former employee who sent abusive emails to the tribunal and swore at the employment judge has had his discrimination claims struck out for unreasonable conduct.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Asbestos removal workers (former employees) v Kaefer Limited
A group of former asbestos removal workers had their claims against three companies struck out after the tribunal found there was no TUPE transfer of their employment.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Trailer loader (4 years' service) v Fleet Express and Logistics Ltd
A trailer loader was unfairly dismissed after threatening to knock out his supervisor, but the tribunal found the process flawed because the employer failed to preserve CCTV evidence and delayed the appeal until the footage was lost. He was awarded £2,743 after a 75% reduction for his own conduct.
Won · £2,743 · Sept 2023Won£2,743Sept 2023Former employee v Baber Khan
A former employee won over £29,000 for constructive unfair dismissal and wrongful dismissal, but her claims of detriment and automatic unfair dismissal for protected disclosure were dismissed.
Partial · £29,257 · Sept 2023Partial£29,257Sept 2023Chef (35 years' service) v Mr F Sanjoori and Chateau Napoleon Restaurant
A chef who worked for 35 years was made redundant without any consultation or notice when his restaurant closed. The tribunal awarded £17,766 in redundancy and notice pay, but reduced compensation for unfair dismissal by 100% because the business was bound to close.
Partial · £17,766 · Sept 2023Partial£17,766Sept 2023Former employee v Sapphire Accounting and Randstad Construction Agency
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after he failed to attend a preliminary hearing and did not provide evidence to show his claim was filed in time.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Project Manager (3 years' service) v Equans Fabricom UK Limited
A project manager who resigned after his employer changed working practices to recover overpaid offshore allowance has lost his constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal also ordered him to repay £10,056.85.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Security Patrol Officer v Pace Security Services Limited
A tribunal dismissed claims that a security officer was left out of furlough and overlooked because of his race, but awarded £984 for unpaid holiday accrued during sickness.
Partial · £984 · Sept 2023Partial£984Sept 2023Former employee v GI Group Recruitment Ltd and BMW (UK) Manufacturing Ltd
A former agency worker's claims of disability discrimination against GI Group Recruitment Ltd and BMW (UK) Manufacturing Ltd were dismissed after the tribunal found he was not an employee and his complaints were not well founded.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Delivery driver (8 years' service) v Totalserve (Wholesale) Ltd
A delivery driver who claimed unfair dismissal after driving through flood water has been ordered to pay £8,779.50 in costs. The tribunal found he acted unreasonably by continuing his claim after receiving a Fire Service report that contradicted his key argument.
Lost · £8,780 · Sept 2023Lost£8,780Sept 2023EMEA Regulatory Exam Management and Oversight – Senior Analyst (7 years' service) v Citibank N.A.
A senior analyst with 7 years' service was fairly dismissed after submitting an expense claim that included his partner's meals and then denying it during investigation. The tribunal upheld Citibank's decision.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Senior Lecturer (14 years' service) v University of the Arts London
A senior lecturer with 14 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after developing a romantic relationship with a student. The tribunal rejected his claims of unfair dismissal and race discrimination.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Recruitment assessor (worker status) v College of Policing Limited
A recruitment assessor who claimed unfair dismissal lost his case after the tribunal ruled he was a worker, not an employee, because the College of Policing had no obligation to provide work and he could refuse assignments.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Lead learning support assistant (11 years' service) v The Windsor Forest Colleges Group
A tribunal struck out a constructive dismissal claim presented five months after resignation and ordered the claimant to pay £1,013.48 in costs. The earlier age discrimination claim survived a strike-out application.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee (5 years' service) v Open GI Ltd
A tribunal found that Open GI Ltd unfairly dismissed a disabled employee after he attended his manager's home with white spirit, but awarded no compensation due to his conduct. The employee received £2,805 for injury to feelings on a related discrimination claim.
Partial · £2,805 · Sept 2023Partial£2,805Sept 2023Customer Service Assistant (13 years' service) v London Underground Ltd
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a London Underground customer service assistant with 13 years' service, finding that the employer acted reasonably despite not carrying out a recommended risk assessment before termination.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Motor mechanic (3 years' service) v JDH Motor Repairs Limited
A motor mechanic with three years' service was unfairly dismissed after being told 'I think it's time you went' and 'There's no time like the present'. The tribunal found the employer's Facebook advert for a replacement on the same day confirmed the dismissal.
Won · Sept 2023Won—Sept 2023Community Staff Nurse (10 years' service) v Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust
A community staff nurse who resigned after her NHS trust failed to contact her about redeployment during long-term sickness has won her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal awarded £41,935.
Partial · £41,935 · Sept 2023Partial£41,935Sept 2023Digital Delivery Manager v Institute of Physics
A Digital Delivery Manager with multiple sclerosis was fairly dismissed for redundancy, the tribunal ruled, finding a genuine redundancy situation and fair process despite disability discrimination claims.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Restaurant manager (6 months' service) v 11 Berkeley Street Ltd T/a Jeru Restaurant
A restaurant manager with six months' service who reported mouse droppings and chef misconduct was not automatically unfairly dismissed, but won £3,201 for unpaid tronc and holiday pay.
Partial · £3,201 · Sept 2023Partial£3,201Sept 2023Family law solicitor (self-employed consultant, 11 years' service) v Sinclairslaw Ltd
A family law solicitor who claimed Sinclairslaw Ltd failed to respond to her email because of her age or sex has lost her discrimination claim. The tribunal found the non-response was an innocent oversight.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former dog trainer (Head Trainer/Puppy Manager, later Assistance Dog Trainer) v Hypo Hounds
A tribunal found that a dog trainer was unfairly dismissed after his employer withdrew a zero-hour contract offer when he joined a trade union, but the decision to dismiss was made before he joined.
Partial · Sept 2023Partial—Sept 2023Store Manager (7 years' service) v Smyths Toys UK Limited
A store manager who resigned after claiming her employer refused annual leave and a five-day week to rest a foot injury has lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v Freespee Limited
The tribunal dismissed a former employee's application for specific disclosure of documents, ruling that a foreign qualified in-house lawyer had capacity to give legal advice and that the dominant purpose of the communications was legal advice.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Head Butler & Valet (6 years' service) v Shenton Properties Ltd
A head butler with six years' service lost his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims after a tribunal found his redundancy was genuine and fairly handled.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Business consultant (8 months' service) v Eunisure Limited (in voluntary liquidation)
A business consultant who was refused homeworking after training has won £5,130 for unpaid commission, holiday pay and notice pay, but her claim of associative disability discrimination was dismissed.
Partial · £5,130 · Sept 2023Partial£5,130Sept 2023Office Manager (3 years' service) v Bartco Ltd
A Reading tribunal found that Bartco Ltd unfairly dismissed its office manager after a flawed investigation and pre-determined decision, awarding £11,932.17.
Partial · £11,932 · Sept 2023Partial£11,932Sept 2023Former employee v North Norfolk District Council
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against North Norfolk District Council was struck out after he issued proceedings over 16 months after the time limit expired. The tribunal rejected his argument that his dyslexia and ACAS's failure to explain the time limit made it not reasonably practicable to claim in time.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee (makeup specialist) v Makeup Specialists Limited
A makeup specialist was automatically unfairly dismissed because of her pregnancy. The tribunal awarded over £40,000 including an ACAS code uplift and injury to feelings.
Won · £40,465 · Sept 2023Won£40,465Sept 2023Property Maintenance Manager (2 years' service) v Melin Homes Ltd
A property maintenance manager who was dismissed after less than two years' service following bullying complaints has lost his claims of unfair dismissal, age discrimination and trade union detriment. The tribunal found the dismissal was fair and not motivated by age.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Road sweeper (19 years' service) v Veolia ES (UK) Limited
A tribunal struck out a road sweeper's unfair dismissal claim because his lay representative deleted a WhatsApp message and failed to disclose other relevant documents, making a fair trial impossible.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee (Lead Country Accountant, 4 years' service) v Venator Materials UK Ltd
A former employee's claims for unfair dismissal, race discrimination and whistleblowing detriment have been struck out after he repeatedly failed to comply with tribunal orders and did not attend hearings.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Access Resources Integrated Services Support Officer v London Borough of Enfield
A tribunal struck out a former support officer's unfair dismissal claim against London Borough of Enfield after he failed to confirm whether he wished to pursue it and did not attend hearings.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee v BAE Systems (Operations) Limited
A former employee's whistleblowing detriment claims against BAE Systems have been partially struck out as out of time, but her constructive dismissal and some other claims can proceed.
Partial · Sept 2023Partial—Sept 2023Former employee v HFD Limited
A former employee who submitted an unfair dismissal claim and then cut all contact has had his case struck out and been ordered to pay £723.80 in costs.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee v Italian Catering Concept Ltd
A former employee's constructive unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after neither he nor his former employer, now in liquidation, attended the final hearing or provided any evidence.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee v Serco Limited
A former employee of Serco Limited had their unfair dismissal claim struck out because they had worked for less than two years. The tribunal confirmed the two-year service requirement applies to constructive dismissal claims too.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Installation engineer (5 years' service) v ABS Installations Limited
An installation engineer who used his employer's credit card to fuel his personal car on three occasions was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Social worker (12 years' service) v Rotherham Metropolitan Borough Council
A social worker with 12 years' service had her unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims dismissed after she failed to comply with a deposit order and an unless order. Her application to set aside the dismissal was refused.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Warehouse operative (12 years' service) v Regional logistics company
Employer dismissed a long-serving warehouse worker after eight months of sickness absence without obtaining an up-to-date medical report. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair.
Won · £18,450 · Sept 2023Won£18,450Sept 2023Former employee v Wales England Care Ltd
A former employee's pregnancy-related unfair dismissal claim against Wales England Care Ltd was allowed to proceed after the tribunal identified the correct employer, dismissing claims against a dissolved company and a liquidated one.
Remitted · Sept 2023Remitted—Sept 2023Commercial Service Manager (22 years' service) v Denbighshire County Council
A 22-year council employee who set up a private company without telling his employer was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal ruled.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v APT Health and Safety Training Solutions Ltd
A former employee was unfairly dismissed by reason of redundancy and denied proper notice, winning a basic award of £1,346.15 and damages of £1,800 for breach of contract.
Partial · Sept 2023Partial—Sept 2023Sales Assistant (5 years' service) v H & M Hennes & Mauritz UK Limited
A sales assistant who relocated from Milton Keynes to Bournemouth was fairly dismissed after H&M tried but failed to find her a suitable transfer. The tribunal rejected her unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v Jet2.com Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Jet2.com was struck out after he failed to comply with case management orders, and his application to set aside the Unless Order was dismissed.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee v Hydegate Pet Resort Ltd
A former employee was unfairly dismissed after the employer failed to follow a fair procedure. The tribunal awarded a 20% uplift for breaching the ACAS Code and confirmed one month's notice pay.
Won · Sept 2023Won—Sept 2023Estate agency employee v Farrell Heyworth Limited
An estate agency employee who mistakenly emailed her claim form to ACAS instead of the tribunal has been given permission to proceed with her constructive unfair dismissal claim, even though it arrived five days after the deadline.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v Vibrant Energy Matters Ltd
A former employee has won her harassment and victimisation claims after her employer forwarded her emails alleging sex discrimination to the person she complained about, who then called her. She was later dismissed.
Partial · Sept 2023Partial—Sept 2023IT Business Partner (10 years' service) v Transport for London
An IT Business Partner with 10 years' service was unfairly dismissed by Transport for London after the tribunal found the real reason was poor performance, not a breakdown in relationships. Compensation will be reduced by 35% due to her own conduct.
Partial · Sept 2023Partial—Sept 2023Sales Progressor (2 years 7 months' service) v Paradigm Housing Group Limited
A tribunal has rejected claims of unfair dismissal, pregnancy discrimination and sex discrimination brought by a Sales Progressor who was dismissed after a performance improvement plan that began shortly after her miscarriage.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Personal Assistant (6 months' service) v Club19 Limited
A tribunal rejected a wrongful dismissal claim from a PA with six months' service who was summarily dismissed after blocking her manager on WhatsApp and returning the business phone unattended. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Sales consultant / casual worker v ABM Aviation UK Limited
A sales consultant who refused to participate in the final hearing and repeatedly failed to comply with case management orders had his unfair dismissal and discrimination claims struck out. Costs orders totalling £5,548 were made against him.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Support Worker (3 years 6 months' service) v Just One Health & Social Care Ltd
A support worker who raised her voice at a vulnerable adult was unfairly dismissed after her employer relied on undisclosed witness statements. The tribunal awarded £12,108, reduced by a third for her own conduct.
Won · £12,108 · Sept 2023Won£12,108Sept 2023Former employee v Together Stronger (South Wales) Ltd.
A former employee with less than two years' service won over £11,000 after being constructively dismissed and discriminated against due to his disability. The tribunal found the employer made unauthorised deductions and failed to provide a written statement of employment particulars.
Partial · £11,014 · Sept 2023Partial£11,014Sept 2023Beer delivery van driver (9 months' service) v Forest Road Brewing Company Limited
A beer delivery driver with only nine months' service was automatically unfairly dismissed after repeatedly raising health and safety concerns about overloaded vans. The tribunal awarded £9,436.63 in compensation.
Won · £9,437 · Sept 2023Won£9,437Sept 2023Former employee v London Borough of Lambeth Council
Two former employees had their unfair dismissal claims automatically struck out after failing to comply with an Unless Order. The tribunal refused reconsideration, and the claims were ultimately dismissed.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Coach driver (3 years' service) v Seaward Travel Ltd
A coach driver who repeatedly raised concerns about diesel fumes in his minibus and resigned after a poorly handled disciplinary meeting has won his claim for constructive unfair dismissal.
Partial · Sept 2023Partial—Sept 2023Technician (6 years' service) v Crossroads Group Limited
An employment tribunal has ruled that a technician with an inguinal hernia, prolapsed disc and nerve damage was disabled under the Equality Act from June 2022. The decision clears the way for his claims of disability discrimination and failure to make reasonable adjustments.
Partial · Sept 2023Partial—Sept 2023Customer Service Adviser (2 years' service) v Lloyds Bank plc
A customer service adviser with 2 years' service was constructively unfairly dismissed after Lloyds Bank failed to carry out a pregnancy risk assessment or provide a supportive chair, and mishandled her grievance. The tribunal upheld her pregnancy discrimination and unfair dismissal claims.
Partial · Sept 2023Partial—Sept 2023Former employee v Shane Finnegan t/a Harp Renewables Ltd
A former employee who could not bring an unfair dismissal claim due to short service was awarded over £21,000 for unauthorised wage deductions, breach of contract, and unpaid annual leave.
Partial · £21,375 · Sept 2023Partial£21,375Sept 2023Data Protection Officer (9 months' service) v The Veterinary Defence Society Limited
A Data Protection Officer who alleged he was dismissed for making protected disclosures saw his claim struck out after failing to comply with tribunal orders. His interim relief application was dismissed for not meeting the high threshold of a 'pretty good chance' of success.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee (kitchen designer) v Leighton Buzzard Self Storage Ltd t/a Cinch Self Storage
A former kitchen designer's constructive unfair dismissal claim was thrown out after he filed it four months late, with the tribunal finding he could have acted sooner despite seeking advice.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Customer Service Adviser (4 years' service) v BSH Home Appliances Limited
A customer service adviser with functional neurological disorder lost his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims. The tribunal found the employer's process was fair and the dismissal justified.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee (technician) v Gi Group Recruitment Ltd
A tribunal struck out a former technician's race and religion discrimination claims as out of time and without reasonable prospects. A deposit order was made for a constructive unfair dismissal claim.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Client care associate (6 years' service) v Shred-it Ltd
A client care associate with six years' service was dismissed for aggressive behaviour and unauthorised absences while on a final written warning. The tribunal upheld the dismissal, finding the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Voting and Engagement Analyst (6 months' service) v Federated Hermes Limited
A fixed-term employee who knew the deadline but delayed because he was unhappy with his draft claim form had his unfair dismissal and discrimination claims thrown out by the tribunal.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Self-employed DJ v Chelmsford Hotels Limited
A DJ who provided services to a hotel for six years was found to be self-employed, not a worker or employee, and his unfair dismissal claim was dismissed.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Business Development Manager (3 years' service) v Siemens Healthcare Ltd
A Business Development Manager who resigned claiming constructive dismissal due to race discrimination lost his case. The tribunal found Siemens Healthcare Ltd had genuine, evidence-based performance concerns and had not breached the implied term of trust and confidence.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023HGV driver (3 years' service) v Sepco International Limited
An HGV driver who refused a route in anger and left work was unfairly dismissed when his employer treated it as resignation without a disciplinary hearing. The tribunal found the dismissal procedurally unfair, but will apply significant reductions for his conduct.
Won · Sept 2023Won—Sept 2023Bus driver (7 weeks' service) v Abellio London Limited
A bus driver with only 7 weeks' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after using his mobile phone while driving. The tribunal struck out his unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Smart Meter Installer (11 months' service) v Morrison Data Services Limited
A smart meter installer with chronic migraines was dismissed after three months' absence. The tribunal found he was disabled but that the employer acted reasonably and did not discriminate.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Area manager (8 years' service) v H B Pizza Ltd (In Creditors Voluntary Liquidation)
An area manager with 8 years' service resigned by email after his grievance was rejected. The tribunal found he was not constructively dismissed because the employer's conduct did not amount to a fundamental breach of trust and confidence.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Accounts Manager (2 years 10 months' service) v First Call Contract Services Limited
An accounts manager who suffered a miscarriage and lost her husband in quick succession was unfairly dismissed by First Call Contract Services Limited. The tribunal awarded £72,948.30 for unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and indirect sex discrimination.
Won · £72,948 · Sept 2023Won£72,948Sept 2023Health Visitor (39 years' service) v Cwm Taf Morgannwg University Local Health Board
A health visitor who resigned after delays in occupational health referrals, expenses, and grievance handling has lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer's failings did not amount to a fundamental breach of contract.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Food Technology Technician (12 years' service) v South West Essex Community Education Trust Limited
A Food Technology Technician with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed for capability after a long-term sickness absence, the tribunal ruled, finding the employer had properly considered redeployment and made reasonable adjustments.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v British Telecommunications plc
A tribunal struck out a former employee's claims because they were presented five months late, and refused to extend time even after the employee submitted additional medical evidence.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Postal worker (19 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A postal worker with 19 years' service was fairly dismissed for sending unsolicited items including scissors and a Hi Vis jacket to colleagues. The tribunal upheld Royal Mail's decision, finding the employer acted within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Shift manager (4 years 9 months' service) v One Stop Stores Limited
A shift manager who gave ice cream to a school and charity without approval was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected his claims of unfair dismissal and race discrimination.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Security Officer (1 year 9 months' service) v Alpha Response (2004) Ltd t/a Red Support Services
A security officer who tried to add two new protected disclosures to his unfair dismissal claim 16 months after presenting his claim was refused by the tribunal, which found it was reasonably practicable to have included them earlier.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Pharmacy Assistant (12 years' service) v Bestway Panacea Holdings Limited
A tribunal rejected claims of constructive unfair dismissal and race discrimination brought by a pharmacy assistant after her annual leave requests were refused and her grievance was not upheld.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Deputy General Manager - Operations (12 years' service) v Artionis (UK) Ltd
A deputy general manager with 12 years' service failed to prove constructive dismissal after her employer changed her role while she was on maternity leave. The tribunal found the employer's actions were reasonable and most claims were brought too late.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Responsive repairs plumber (6 years' service) v Coalo Limited
A plumber with six years' service was awarded £134,411 after his employer failed to implement occupational health recommendations, cut his sick pay, and ignored his grievance. The tribunal found constructive unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Partial · £134,412 · Sept 2023Partial£134,412Sept 2023Police officer (18 months' service) v British Transport Police Authority
A police officer with PTSD who was dismissed after a domestic violence allegation has lost his disability and sex discrimination claims. The tribunal found the misconduct panel's decision was not influenced by his disability.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Solicitor (5 years' service) v Bishop Lloyd & Jackson Solicitors Limited
A housing solicitor was unfairly dismissed when her employer failed to properly consider a possible secondment at a sister firm. The tribunal found a 85% chance that consultation would have led to an alternative role.
Won · Sept 2023Won—Sept 2023Food Technology Teacher (4 months' service) v Cavendish Learning Limited
A tribunal struck out Cavendish Learning Limited's response after repeated failures to comply with case management orders, leaving the claimant's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims undefended.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Forensic Custody Healthcare Professional (2 years' service) v Mountain Healthcare Limited
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a forensic custody nurse who could not kneel to perform CPR due to bilateral knee replacements. The employer was found to have acted within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v John Lewis plc
A former employee of John Lewis plc who was dismissed for unauthorised absence and failure to follow reporting procedures has lost her unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims. The tribunal also ordered her to pay £13,250 in costs.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v Portobello House Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims were struck out after the tribunal found they were presented too late, even though she had started early conciliation.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Drayman (beer delivery driver) (9 months' service) v Forest Road Brewing Co Ltd
A beer delivery driver who repeatedly wrote 'overweight' on his delivery manifests was unfairly dismissed for raising health and safety concerns. The tribunal awarded £6,297 in compensation.
Won · £6,297 · Sept 2023Won£6,297Sept 2023Production Team Member (2 years' service) v Bighams Ltd
A production worker with a final written warning for threatening behaviour was fairly dismissed after shouting at a colleague. The tribunal also ordered Bighams Ltd to pay £648.96 for unpaid holiday.
Partial · £649 · Sept 2023Partial£649Sept 2023Firefighter (8 years' service) v London Fire Commissioner
A firefighter with 8 years' service lost his claims of victimisation, harassment, constructive dismissal and direct discrimination against the London Fire Commissioner. The tribunal found no unlawful treatment and dismissed the direct discrimination claim as out of time.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023University academic (disabled employee) v University of the West of England
A university academic with Parkinson's disease was allowed to pursue her unfair dismissal claim 10 days late after the tribunal found it was not reasonably practicable to file on time due to her disability and IT problems.
Partial · Sept 2023Partial—Sept 2023Security Operations Manager (14 years' service) v Mitie Limited
A Security Operations Manager with 14 years' service was fairly dismissed after taking two bicycles from lost property without permission. The tribunal rejected his claims of unfair dismissal and race discrimination.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v Italia2U Limited
A former employee of Italia2U Limited won over £11,700 after the company failed to respond to their tribunal claim, resulting in a default judgment and a remedy hearing.
Won · £11,759 · Sept 2023Won£11,759Sept 2023Process Technician (32 years' service) v Massmould Limited
A process technician with 32 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after kicking and throwing his bump cap towards a colleague. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v Epsilon Ten Limited trading as Oxto Energy Storage
A former employee with less than two years' service successfully claimed £13,389.33 in unpaid wages, pension contributions and annual leave after his employer failed to pay him for months and did not attend the tribunal hearing.
Partial · £13,389 · Sept 2023Partial£13,389Sept 2023Assistant team manager and duty manager (8 years' service) v John Lewis Plc
An assistant team manager with eight years' service was fairly dismissed after CCTV showed him pushing, grabbing and kicking members of the public. The tribunal rejected his claims of disability discrimination and unfair dismissal.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee (2 years' service) v BLE Lighting and Power Ltd
A former employee with two years' service won £2,575.34 in unfair dismissal compensation after losing his company car, even though he found a higher-paying job. The tribunal awarded £4,000 for the car benefit, reduced by 75% for contributory fault.
Won · £2,575 · Sept 2023Won£2,575Sept 2023Field services engineer (17 years' service) v Elopak UK Limited
A field services engineer with 17 years' service was constructively dismissed after his employer failed to fully reimburse his fuel costs and mishandled his grievance. The tribunal found a breach of trust and confidence.
Won · Sept 2023Won—Sept 2023General manager (3 years' service) v Minories M Limited (in voluntary liquidation)
A general manager who resigned after his grievance was assigned to the manager he complained about, and who was then suspended pending disciplinary proceedings, has won his constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal awarded £4,354.33.
Partial · £4,354 · Sept 2023Partial£4,354Sept 2023Former employee v PMP Recruitment Limited
A former employee of PMP Recruitment Limited succeeded in claims of direct discrimination and harassment on grounds of age, race, and sex, and was awarded over £19,000 in compensation.
Partial · £19,310 · Sept 2023Partial£19,310Sept 2023Former employee v Kelvedon Auto Spares 87 Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was thrown out after he failed to attend the final hearing and had already asked to cancel it. The tribunal also found the claim was presented out of time.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Nurse (care home) v Alliance Care (Dales Homes) Limited
A care home nurse who claimed race discrimination after receiving a final written warning for a fire safety breach has had his claim dismissed. The tribunal found no less favourable treatment compared to other staff.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Process and Technical Manager (11 years' service) v Slicker Recycling Limited
A tribunal dismissed a claim for unfair dismissal and discrimination after the claimant presented his case one day late and failed to attend hearings or provide any explanation for the delay.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee (less than 1 year service) v Churston Court Inn Ltd
A tribunal has awarded nearly £30,000 to a pregnant employee who was dismissed by text message after complaining about derogatory comments and a failure to provide support with lifting.
Won · £29,796 · Sept 2023Won£29,796Sept 2023Head of E-Commerce (8 months' service) v Mibelle Ltd
A tribunal found that a Head of E-Commerce with 8 months' service was genuinely redundant, rejecting claims that her dismissal was linked to her pregnancy. She succeeded only on a claim for unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · Sept 2023Partial—Sept 2023Former employee v Circle Wood Ltd
A tribunal struck out a former employee's claim that she was discriminated against because of her caring responsibilities for her disabled mother, ruling that section 15 of the Equality Act does not cover discrimination by association.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee (10 years' service) v National Westminster Bank Plc
A former employee who settled her unfair dismissal claim and signed a withdrawal agreement could not bring a second claim about a detrimental reference or reopen the original case. The tribunal struck out the claim for lack of jurisdiction.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employees (affected by TUPE transfer) v B&W Machinery Ltd (In Creditors Voluntary Liquidation)
Four former employees of B&W Machinery Ltd were awarded over £22,000 after the company failed to inform or consult them about a TUPE transfer before entering liquidation.
Won · £22,022 · Sept 2023Won£22,022Sept 2023Trader (7 years' service) v EDF Trading Limited
A trader with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed by EDF Trading Limited after a flawed investigation into an alleged leak of confidential information. The tribunal found the dismissal procedurally unfair but rejected his whistleblowing claim.
Partial · Sept 2023Partial—Sept 2023Shop Assistant (9 years' service) v Tarsaim and Mandeep Sandhu t/a Station Stores
A shop assistant with nine years' service was unfairly dismissed after using the Post Office till for a personal transaction. The tribunal found the investigation was insufficient and the dismissal procedurally unfair.
Won · Sept 2023Won—Sept 2023Agency worker (2 days' service) v PMP Recruitment Limited
An agency worker who suffered a back injury on his second day was awarded £1,500 of a promised £3,000 signing bonus after the tribunal ruled the time off counted towards the 45-day qualifying period.
Partial · £1,500 · Sept 2023Partial£1,500Sept 2023Probation Services Officer (trainee Probation Officer) v The Secretary of State for Justice
A Probation Services Officer who resigned after sending an email to a service user's MP and raising a grievance about her line manager has lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Senior delivery, operations and support engineer (8 years' service) v BT PLC
An employment tribunal has rejected claims of unfair dismissal, race discrimination and victimisation brought by a BT engineer dismissed for breaching IT policies, but upheld claims for unpaid overtime and holiday pay totalling £4,666.81.
Partial · £4,667 · Sept 2023Partial£4,667Sept 2023Territory sales executive (16 years' service) v ATN Marketing Limited
A territory sales executive with 16 years' service was unfairly dismissed for poor performance without any prior warnings or fair procedure. The tribunal awarded £33,819 in compensation, including a 25% uplift for failing to follow the ACAS Code.
Won · £33,819 · Sept 2023Won£33,819Sept 2023Product Manager (7 years 9 months' service) v Vodafone Group Services Ltd
A product manager with over seven years' service resigned claiming constructive dismissal after his role was redefined under a new operating model. The tribunal found no breach of contract.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Deputy Principal (14 years' service) v The Shared Learning Trust
A deputy principal with 14 years' service was unfairly dismissed after the trust failed to tell her the purpose of a redundancy consultation meeting. The tribunal awarded no compensation, however, finding she would have been dismissed anyway.
Partial · Sept 2023Partial—Sept 2023Railway employee (20 years' service) v London North Eastern Railway Limited
A tribunal ordered a railway company to reinstate a 20-year employee after unfair dismissal. When the company failed to comply, it was ordered to pay over £78,000 in compensation.
Won · £78,943 · Sept 2023Won£78,943Sept 2023Lead Engagement & Core Production Officer (local authority) v Mosses Community Association Limited (in Voluntary Creditors Liquidation)
A local authority employee was awarded £15,483 after her employer's response was struck out for failing to comply with case management orders, leaving the tribunal unable to hold a fair hearing.
Partial · £15,484 · Sept 2023Partial£15,484Sept 2023Academic Manager (overseas, Qatar) v BAE Systems plc
An Academic Manager working in Qatar for a BAE Systems subsidiary failed to establish that her employment had a sufficiently close connection to Great Britain. The tribunal struck out her claims of unfair dismissal, sex discrimination and whistleblowing.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Seasonal groundsman (14 months' service) v Lickhill Manor Ltd t/a Lincomb Lock Caravan Park
A seasonal groundsman who was dismissed while signed off sick lost his disability discrimination and unfair dismissal claims after the tribunal found he was not genuinely unable to work due to his disability but was instead pursuing his own private businesses.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Clinical director lead veterinary surgeon v Medivet Group Limited
A veterinary surgeon who claimed disability discrimination over her dismissal lost her case because her employer did not know and could not reasonably have known she was disabled due to hypothyroidism.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Long-Term Delivery Postperson (17 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Limited
A postman with 17 years' service was fairly dismissed after a member of the public reported him drinking alcohol from a can and driving away. The tribunal found Royal Mail's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Porter (9 years' service) v Mitie Limited
A hospital porter with nine years' service was fairly dismissed for pushing a security guard who challenged him for not wearing a face mask. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision, finding the dismissal within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee (design and printing company) v SP Group Ltd (In Administration) and Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy
A tribunal has awarded 221 former employees of SP Group Ltd a protective award of 90 days' pay after the company made them redundant without any collective consultation when it went into administration.
Won · Aug 2023Won—Aug 2023Senior Electrical Engineer/Supervisor (8 years' service) v Bechtel Ltd
An employment tribunal found that Bechtel Ltd unfairly dismissed a senior electrical engineer during a redundancy process, ruling that the selection lacked transparency. The claimant's race, caste, and whistleblowing claims were dismissed.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Former employee v Carisway Facilities Support Ltd (in Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation)
A cleaner was unfairly dismissed when her employer went into liquidation without following any redundancy procedure. The tribunal awarded £14,522 in compensation, reduced by 50% for the chance she would have been dismissed anyway.
Partial · £14,522 · Aug 2023Partial£14,522Aug 2023Security worker v Effective Security Services Ltd T/A Professional Security
A security worker who knew he lacked two years' continuous employment pursued an unfair dismissal claim anyway. The tribunal dismissed the claim and ordered him to pay £8,696 in costs.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee v Woods Catering Staffordshire Ltd (in liquidation)
A former employee with a disability was awarded over £320,000 after an employment tribunal found she was harassed, victimised, and unfairly dismissed by Woods Catering Staffordshire Ltd and its director.
Won · £320,476 · Aug 2023Won£320,476Aug 2023Former employee v Extreme Networks
A former employee of Extreme Networks had all claims struck out after failing to meet the two-year service requirement for unfair dismissal and not complying with tribunal orders.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Technical Development Manager (less than 2 years' service) v Belfield Furnishings Ltd
A technical development manager who believed he was on garden leave had his unfair dismissal claim struck out because he had less than two years' service and the effective date of termination was clear.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Former employee (15 weeks' service) v Rands Farm Equestrian Centre Ltd
A former employee of Rands Farm Equestrian Centre Ltd has been awarded £7,234.51 after the tribunal upheld claims for unpaid wages, holiday pay, and failure to provide pay slips or written employment particulars.
Won · £7,235 · Aug 2023Won£7,235Aug 2023Bus driver (6 years' service) v Bournemouth Transport Limited (in administration)
A bus driver with long COVID was dismissed the day after furlough ended, without waiting for specialist medical input. The tribunal found unfair dismissal and disability discrimination, awarding £2,597.04.
Won · £2,597 · Aug 2023Won£2,597Aug 2023Care worker v Reach Care Services Limited (in Voluntary Liquidation)
A care worker was constructively unfairly dismissed by Reach Care Services Limited, which was in voluntary liquidation. The tribunal awarded £31,222.97 for unfair dismissal and unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £31,223 · Aug 2023Partial£31,223Aug 2023Former employee v Tricrest Homes Limited
A former employee of Tricrest Homes Limited has been awarded over £7,000 after being paid less than female colleagues for the same work, leading to his constructive unfair dismissal.
Won · £7,060 · Aug 2023Won£7,060Aug 2023Former employee (patient transport/administrative role) v Medicare EMS Group UK Limited
A former employee who brought claims for unfair dismissal and pregnancy discrimination had her case struck out after failing to comply with orders and not attending the hearing.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Accessible transport officer (8 years' service) v London Borough of Camden
An accessible transport officer who applied for voluntary redundancy after a restructure has lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the redundancy was genuine and the process fair.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Job applicant (former Band 2 Clerical Supervisor) v Princess Alexandra Hospital NHS Trust
A job applicant with fibromyalgia had his offer withdrawn after requesting part-time hours. The tribunal found direct disability discrimination and awarded £8,067.
Partial · £8,068 · Aug 2023Partial£8,068Aug 2023Former employee v ISWP Support Services Limited
A former employee who resigned after being required to attend a disciplinary investigation meeting following protected disclosures has won claims for detriment, disability discrimination, harassment and victimisation, but her constructive unfair dismissal claim was dismissed. She was awarded £12,822.78.
Partial · £12,823 · Aug 2023Partial£12,823Aug 2023Live-in carer (6 years' service) v The Good Care Group London Limited
A live-in carer with six years' service was fairly dismissed for long-term incapacity, the tribunal found. Her claims of whistleblowing and victimisation were dismissed.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee (32 years' service) v High-Tech Windows Ltd (in voluntary liquidation)
A former employee with 32 years' service was awarded a protective award of 90 days' pay after his employer made him and 20 others redundant without any consultation.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Former employee v Heavenly Body Ltd
A former employee has been awarded £10,282 after her employer, Heavenly Body Ltd, failed to attend hearings or respond to claims of unfair dismissal and pregnancy discrimination.
Won · £10,282 · Aug 2023Won£10,282Aug 2023Former employee v Green and Brown Ltd
A former employee with a dilated right kidney has been found disabled under the Equality Act, allowing his discrimination claims to proceed to a full hearing.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Band 5 Staff Nurse (6 years' service) v Cardiff and Vale University Local Health Board
A Band 5 Staff Nurse was constructively dismissed after making protected disclosures about patient safety and an alleged assault. The tribunal found the Health Board subjected her to detriments including suspension and a flawed disciplinary process.
Won · Aug 2023Won—Aug 2023Former employee v Mrs Victoria Henderson t/a The Spirit Group
A former employee with psoriasis, psoriatic arthritis and type 2 diabetes was dismissed because of her pregnancy and disability. The tribunal awarded £24,626.93.
Won · £24,627 · Aug 2023Won£24,627Aug 2023Former employee v Shaws (Cardiff) Limited (in liquidation)
A former employee of Shaws (Cardiff) Limited won a protective award of £4,142.60 after the company failed to consult about redundancies before going into liquidation.
Won · £4,143 · Aug 2023Won£4,143Aug 2023Former employee v CFE Lighting
A former employee who missed a telephone hearing due to connection problems has had her unfair dismissal claim reinstated after the tribunal granted reconsideration.
Remitted · Aug 2023Remitted—Aug 2023Store Manager (3 years' service) v EE Limited
A store manager who took unauthorised holiday during an iPhone launch embargo was fairly dismissed, the tribunal ruled, rejecting his claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination based on dyslexia.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Support worker (2.5 months' service) v Accomplish Group Limited
A support worker with 2.5 months' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after swearing at a person they supported. The tribunal rejected claims of disability discrimination because the employer did not know of his undiagnosed ADHD.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee v Spicehaart Group Services Limited
A tribunal has dismissed a company's application for a costs order and a wasted costs order against a former employee and her solicitor, finding that the claim was adequately particularised and that neither party acted unreasonably.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee v London Underground Ltd
A former employee of London Underground has won claims of unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and failure to make reasonable adjustments. The tribunal awarded £121,922.59 in compensation.
Won · £121,923 · Aug 2023Won£121,923Aug 2023Manual Handling Equipment Trainer (9 years' service) v DHL Services Ltd
A manual handling equipment trainer with 9 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to carry out practical assessments for two returning employees. The tribunal upheld DHL's decision.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Teaching Assistant (6 months' service) v Knossington Grange School Ltd
A tribunal ruled that a teaching assistant with ADHD, anxiety and depression was disabled at the time of her employment, allowing her disability discrimination claim to proceed.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Former employee (7 years' service) v Equans Services Limited
A former employee with 7 years' service saw his constructive dismissal and age discrimination claims survive a strike-out application, but his disability discrimination claims were dismissed after the tribunal found he was not disabled under the Equality Act.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Former employee v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after she failed to attend a preliminary hearing and did not contact the tribunal. The claim was also presented well out of time.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Occupational Therapy Assistant (Band 3, 3 years' service) v University Hospitals Sussex NHS Foundation Trust
An occupational therapy assistant who missed a promotion opportunity while on sick leave because she did not check her work email has lost her constructive dismissal claim. The tribunal ruled the oversight was unintentional.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Traffic Order/Project Engineer (11 years' service) v London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham
An engineer with 11 years' service resigned by email but the council's IT system quarantined it; the disciplinary hearing went ahead and she was dismissed. The tribunal struck out her discrimination and victimisation claims.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Course instructor (international sailing federation) v World Sailing (UK) Limited
A course instructor who lived permanently in South Africa and worked mainly abroad had his unfair dismissal claim struck out because the Employment Tribunal lacked territorial jurisdiction.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Senior Construction Project Manager (3 years' service) v Ocado Central Services Limited
A senior project manager was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to disclose personal relationships with contractors and allowing a friend to use his work laptop. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee v Sterling Studios Ltd
A former employee with less than two years' service had their unfair dismissal claim struck out, but secured £126.89 in contractual holiday pay.
Partial · £127 · Aug 2023Partial£127Aug 2023Former employee (permanent executive platform secretary, 1976-1983) v Bank of America NA
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Bank of America NA was dismissed as out of time after she presented it nearly 40 years after her employment ended. The tribunal found no reasonable explanation for the delay.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Band 5 community nurse (6 years' service) v Guys & St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust
A Band 5 community nurse with six years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after inappropriate contact with a vulnerable patient, the tribunal ruled.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Groom at a stud farm v Hildare Stud Farm Ltd
A groom who named an individual instead of the employing company on her claim form had her unfair dismissal case struck out as out of time. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable to have brought the claim against the correct employer in time.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Former employee v Collect Investments Limited
A tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal claim after the employee withdrew it, having less than two years' continuous service. The correct employer was identified as Collect Investments Limited, not Selected Property Limited.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Studio sales administrator (3 years 10 months' service) v Fresh Transformations Ltd trading as Fresh Doors
A studio sales administrator was unfairly dismissed when her employer asked for her keys after she refused to attend work during lockdown. The tribunal awarded £723, reduced by 50% for her own conduct.
Won · £723 · Aug 2023Won£723Aug 2023Coroner and Claims Officer (4.5 years' service) v North East Ambulance Service NHS Foundation Trust
An employment tribunal dismissed two whistleblower claims after the claimant repeatedly failed to engage with proceedings and did not attend the final hearing.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023HGV driver v Debach Enterprises Limited
An HGV driver who was dismissed for fuel discrepancies, reinstated on appeal, then resigned was not constructively dismissed. The tribunal also ordered her to pay £21,000 in costs.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Groom (stud farm employee) v Hildare Stud Farm Ltd
A groom who named her employer's directors instead of the company has had her unfair dismissal claim struck out, as the tribunal found it was too late to add the correct respondent.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Production line worker (12 years' service) v Jaguar Land Rover Limited
A production line worker with 12 years' service failed to prove that Jaguar Land Rover victimised him by managing his sickness absence after he brought a sex discrimination claim. The tribunal found the employer's actions were not because of the protected act.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Police Inspector and Chief Inspector (17 years' service) v The Chief Constable of Thames Valley Police
A police inspector who raised concerns about the handling of sensitive health data resigned claiming constructive dismissal. The tribunal found he made protected disclosures, but the treatment he suffered was not because of them.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Post office assistant/shop assistant (26 years' service) v Fabpost Ltd
A post office assistant with 26 years' service was dismissed after her employer sold the shop. The tribunal found a TUPE transfer had taken place, so liability for her claims passed to the new owner and her former employer was not liable.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Contract worker (via employment business) v Express Medicals Ltd
A contract worker's claim of disability discrimination against an employment business and a medical assessment company was struck out after the tribunal found he had not pleaded that either was his employer or principal under the Equality Act.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Train cleaner (21 years' service) v Atalian Servest Limited
A train cleaner with 21 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed investigation into alleged theft of soap, but the tribunal found he actually committed theft, reducing compensation to zero.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Former employee v The High Street Surgery
A former employee of The High Street Surgery won her constructive unfair dismissal claim after resigning due to her employer's conduct. The Watford tribunal awarded £5,687.21 but dismissed her disability discrimination claims.
Partial · £5,687 · Aug 2023Partial£5,687Aug 2023Former employee (rehabilitation sector) v KTB Rehabilitation Ltd
A tribunal extended time for an unfair dismissal claim filed 11 days late, but struck it out for lack of merit. The claimant succeeded only on a breach of contract claim for notice pay, receiving £948.78.
Partial · £949 · Aug 2023Partial£949Aug 2023Pre-school employees (manager and staff) v Management Committee of St Philips Community Centre
Four pre-school employees claimed unfair dismissal after redundancy, but the tribunal first had to decide who their employer was – the management committee, the church council, or individuals.
Remitted · Aug 2023Remitted—Aug 2023Teaching assistant v Hospital and Home Education
A teaching assistant who resigned in September 2021 waited over 11 months to start ACAS early conciliation. The tribunal refused to extend time, dismissing her disability discrimination claim as out of time.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Theatre and Community Centre Manager (18 years' service) v The Dragon Barmouth Ltd
A theatre manager who was dismissed after two long periods of sickness absence lost her claims for unfair dismissal and disability discrimination, but won a small holiday pay award.
Partial · £229 · Aug 2023Partial£229Aug 2023Care home employee v Llysywaun Ltd
A care home employee who was unfairly dismissed for raising food hygiene and safeguarding concerns won her liability case, but the remedy claim was dismissed when she did not attend the hearing.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Bar staff (18 years' service) v Meanwood Conservative Club
An employment tribunal found that Meanwood Conservative Club acted fairly when it dismissed a bar worker with 18 years' service for failing to improve her attitude towards the club secretary, following a final written warning.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Commercial Development Executive (8 years' service) v DPD Group UK Ltd
A commercial development executive with 8 years' service was fairly dismissed after he failed to report three commission overpayments totalling £6,049.83 that he knew he was not entitled to. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Healthcare assistant (probationary period) v Kent and Medway NHS and Social Care Partnership Trust
A healthcare assistant who was dismissed during his probationary period for sickness absence and conduct issues has lost his claims of sex and disability discrimination against Kent and Medway NHS and Social Care Partnership Trust. The tribunal found no unlawful discrimination, failure to make reasonable adjustments, or victimisation.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee v Skins Laser Clinic Ltd
A former employee of Skins Laser Clinic Ltd was awarded over £21,000 after the tribunal found she was not paid for 142 hours of work and suffered race discrimination. The award was increased by 25% because the employer failed to address her grievance.
Won · £21,124 · Aug 2023Won£21,124Aug 2023Project Manager (charity sector, 1 year 5 months' service) v Blackpool Community Homeless Project
A project manager who made six protected disclosures about financial irregularities and safety failings at a homeless charity was automatically unfairly dismissed. The tribunal awarded £5,000 compensation.
Won · £5,000 · Aug 2023Won£5,000Aug 2023Retail Sales Advisor (4 months' service) v Eurochange Limited
A retail sales advisor was dismissed during probation for eight absences, five of which were for childcare. The tribunal found no automatic unfair dismissal because the employer offered reinstatement two days later, which the claimant rejected.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Export clerk (4 years 8 months' service) v UPS SCS UK Limited
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of an export clerk who repeatedly failed to work his contractual hours, finding the employer's decision was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Print manager (12 years' service) v JEM Packaging Ltd
A print manager with 12 years' service was unfairly dismissed after refusing two minor clauses in a new contract. The tribunal found the employer acted unreasonably by treating fire-and-rehire as a first resort. Compensation: £17,749.
Won · £17,749 · Aug 2023Won£17,749Aug 2023Warehouse Team Leader (9 years' service) v Kuehne + Nagel Limited
A warehouse team leader with 9 years' service was fairly dismissed for redundancy after a misunderstanding over an alternative role offer, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee v Greene King Retail Services Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims were struck out after she repeatedly failed to comply with tribunal orders and did not attend the preliminary hearing. She was also ordered to pay £1,000 in costs.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Assistant to business owner (2 years' service) v Dawn Bibby Productions Limited and Miss Dawn Bibby
A tribunal ruled that an assistant to a TV craft business owner was a worker, not an employee, and awarded £7,209 for unpaid holiday pay and pension contributions.
Partial · £7,209 · Aug 2023Partial£7,209Aug 2023Digital Marketing Manager (8 months' service) v Criterion Hospitality Limited
A digital marketing manager with Crohn's and Behcet's disease was unfairly selected for redundancy after his disability-related absences played a role in the decision. The tribunal awarded £26,132.24.
Partial · £26,132 · Aug 2023Partial£26,132Aug 2023Locum consultant (3 years 10 months' service) v Wirral University Teaching Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
An employment tribunal has ruled that an NHS trust fairly dismissed a locum consultant when it decided to recruit only substantive Consultants on the Specialist Register, ending the need for locum cover.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Postal worker (25 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A postal worker with 25 years' service was fairly dismissed after a Facebook post implying managers bully and harass employees. The tribunal found Royal Mail's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Security guard (28 months' service) v Bardwood Support Services Ltd
A security guard who was removed from his assignment and not given any disciplinary process has been found to be an employee and unfairly dismissed. The tribunal also ordered the employer to pay outstanding holiday pay for the full 28 months of service.
Won · Aug 2023Won—Aug 2023Warehouse manager (26 years' service) v Tesco Stores Limited
A warehouse manager with 26 years' service was unfairly dismissed by Tesco for alleged favouritism, but his race discrimination claim failed. The tribunal awarded £2,848.74 in compensation.
Partial · £2,849 · Aug 2023Partial£2,849Aug 2023Bid Manager (12 years' service) v Mears Group plc
A tribunal found that Mears Group plc unfairly dismissed a Bid Manager with spinal injuries and victimised her for raising concerns about reasonable adjustments. She was awarded £964,465.37.
Won · £964,465 · Aug 2023Won£964,465Aug 2023Depot manager (18 years' service) v Concord Lifting Equipment Limited
A depot manager with 18 years' service was unfairly dismissed after his employer relied on a stale theft allegation and denied him the chance to respond. The tribunal awarded £22,000.
Partial · £22,001 · Aug 2023Partial£22,001Aug 2023Maths teacher and KS5 coordinator (2 years' service) v Middlesex Learning Partnership
A maths teacher with less than two years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct. The employment tribunal dismissed his unfair dismissal claim for lack of jurisdiction and found no race discrimination.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Physiotherapist (12 years' service) v Leonard Cheshire Disability
A physiotherapist with 12 years' service who was dismissed for refusing the COVID-19 vaccine without a medical exemption has failed to prove his anxiety amounted to a disability under equality law.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Security Officer (6 years' service) v Alpha Response 2004 Ltd t/a Red Support Services
A security officer with six years' service was fairly dismissed after CCTV footage showed he left his post without authorisation on multiple occasions. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Sign erector (7 months' service) v First Signs Ltd
A sign erector with only 7 months' service was automatically unfairly dismissed after raising road safety concerns about unroadworthy vehicles. The tribunal awarded £9,858.56.
Won · £9,859 · Aug 2023Won£9,859Aug 2023Beauty Consultant (zero-hours contract) v E’Quipe Japan Limited
A Chinese beauty consultant who claimed she was dismissed because of her race after an argument with Arabic customers has had her claim struck out. The tribunal found no link between her treatment and her race.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Customer assistant (7 years' service) v Marks and Spencer PLC
A customer assistant with autism was unfairly dismissed by Marks and Spencer after leaning on a colleague, as the tribunal found the employer failed to consider his condition or obtain updated medical reports.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Heating Sales Advisor (5 years' service) v British Gas Services Limited
A Heating Sales Advisor with five years' service lost his unfair dismissal claim after a tribunal found that British Gas Services Limited followed a fair redundancy process, including collective consultation, objective scoring, and a proper appeal.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Broadcast journalist (5 years' service) v Cable News International, Inc.
A British broadcast journalist who worked for CNN across Asia and London has won the right to bring unfair dismissal and discrimination claims in the UK, after a tribunal ruled she had sufficient connection to Great Britain during her medical leave.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Former employee (director and shareholder) v Purple Dog Company.com Ltd
A former director and employee was awarded £566.49 for unpaid holiday leave but failed to prove constructive dismissal after resigning amid trust issues.
Partial · £566 · Aug 2023Partial£566Aug 2023Former employee v Riverside Surgery
A former employee's claim for automatically unfair dismissal was struck out after she failed to pay a £500 deposit ordered by the tribunal. The GP surgery also won costs of £3,036.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Former employee v Panther Warehousing Ltd
A former employee's disability discrimination claim against Panther Warehousing Ltd was dismissed after she failed to provide evidence of her diabetes and did not attend the hearing.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Former employees (family-run supermarket) v Medsun Food Ltd
Three employees were fairly dismissed for a roof confrontation and assault, but a fourth was unfairly dismissed for taking goods without payment. The tribunal reduced her compensation to zero due to her conduct.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Professional footballer v Queens Park Rangers Football and Athletic Club Limited
A tribunal ruled that a QPR footballer's unfair dismissal claim was brought too late, but allowed his race and harassment claims against the club, manager John Yems and Crawley Town to go forward due to his severe depression.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Lift engineer's mate (5 months' service) v Lift Gear Engineering Limited
A lift engineer who raised safety concerns about unqualified workers was automatically unfairly dismissed. The tribunal awarded £12,609.52, including a 25% ACAS uplift for the employer's failure to follow disciplinary procedures.
Partial · £12,610 · Aug 2023Partial£12,610Aug 2023Former employee v Change Grow Live
A former employee's unfair dismissal, whistleblowing and discrimination claims have been struck out after being brought too late, with the tribunal also citing unreasonable conduct. The respondent was awarded £5,000 in costs.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Former employee v G and H
A former employee won a constructive dismissal and sexual harassment claim after their employer failed to respond to the tribunal claim. They were awarded £8,091.66 in compensation.
Won · £8,092 · Aug 2023Won£8,092Aug 2023Assistant manager (6 years' service) v Ms K Foley Gardner and Mr P Gardner, a partnership
An assistant manager who was placed on garden leave without a contractual clause had his final week's pay unlawfully deducted. The tribunal awarded £538 for notice pay but dismissed his unfair dismissal claim as out of time.
Partial · £538 · Aug 2023Partial£538Aug 2023Geography teacher (7 years' service) v United Learning Trust
A tribunal found that a geography teacher with seven years' service was unfairly dismissed by United Learning Trust after a breakdown in relationships, and that a headteacher victimised him by providing a negative reference. He was awarded £36,677.70.
Partial · £36,678 · Aug 2023Partial£36,678Aug 2023Managing Director (21 years' service) v Robert Woodhead Ltd (in liquidation)
A preliminary hearing determined that a managing director who worked across four group companies was employed only by the first respondent. Claims against the other three were dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Former employees v Richmann Walsh Engineering Limited (In Administration)
An employment tribunal has awarded 90 days' pay to former employees of Richmann Walsh Engineering Limited after the company entered administration without carrying out collective redundancy consultation.
Won · Aug 2023Won—Aug 2023Former employee (12 weeks' service) v James Andrew Prams & Nurseries Ltd
A former employee was awarded over £10,700 after James Andrew Prams & Nurseries Ltd failed to pay redundancy, wages, notice pay and holiday pay following a redundancy dismissal.
Won · £10,715 · Aug 2023Won£10,715Aug 2023Production manager (14 years' service) v Great British Confectionary Group Limited
A production manager with 14 years' service was unfairly dismissed when his employer closed a factory, laid him off indefinitely, and deliberately kept the redundancy count below 20 to avoid collective consultation. The tribunal awarded over £15,000 plus a protective award of £9,000.
Won · £15,243 · Aug 2023Won£15,243Aug 2023Software developer (contractor, 6 weeks' service) v Sky UK Limited
A software developer who raised concerns about multi-user discrimination in a Slack channel has lost his whistleblowing claim after the tribunal found his message did not amount to a protected disclosure of information.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee v Bradley Park Waste Management Limited
An employment tribunal struck out a former employee's unfair dismissal claim after he failed to attend the final hearing and ignored all directions, despite being aware of the hearing date.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Field engineers v Kalamazoo IT Limited
Four field engineers were unfairly dismissed when their employer told them they had transferred to a new contractor under TUPE, but no transfer had occurred. The tribunal awarded over £114,000 in total.
Won · £114,504 · Aug 2023Won£114,504Aug 2023Universal education facilitator (1 year's service) v Turning Point
A tribunal refused to strike out a universal education facilitator's whistleblowing and victimisation claims against Turning Point, but ordered her to pay a £150 deposit for each to proceed.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Security Services Officer / Senior Security Services Officer (15 years' service) v Rochdale Boroughwide Housing Limited
Three long-serving CCTV operatives who refused to apply for ringfenced Community Guardian roles were fairly dismissed by reason of redundancy. The tribunal upheld the employer's consultation process and offer of alternative employment.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee v Firstport Property Services Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Firstport Property Services Ltd was struck out after they failed to provide disclosure despite an unless order. The tribunal also ordered them to pay £500 in costs.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Cleaner (2 years' service) v Atalian Servest Limited
A cleaner who resigned after alleging bullying and harassment by her supervisor has lost her claims for constructive unfair dismissal, race discrimination, and harassment. The tribunal found the incidents were routine workplace disputes, not discrimination.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee v Whitbread Group Plc
A tribunal has dismissed a former employee's claims of constructive unfair dismissal, unpaid wages and race discrimination against Whitbread Group Plc because they were brought too late.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Healthcare assistant (8 years' service) v Medical Services International Limited
A healthcare assistant with fibromyalgia was constructively dismissed after her employer failed to offer a permanent alternative role and ignored her complaints about colleague hostility. The tribunal awarded £41,864.95.
Partial · £41,865 · Aug 2023Partial£41,865Aug 2023Drone pilot / inspection engineer (3 years 10 months' service) v Jackson Electronics Ltd
A drone pilot who resigned after his employer deducted £51.58 for unauthorised overtime has lost his constructive dismissal claim. The tribunal found the deduction was lawful as recovery of an overpayment.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Line operative (24 years' service) v Malcolm Enamellers ACP Limited
A line operator with 24 years' service was unfairly dismissed after refusing to accept new terms and conditions. The tribunal found the process flawed but ruled he would have been dismissed anyway by a later date.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Window fitter (12 years' service) v Car Giant Ltd
Three window fitters lost their jobs during the pandemic but failed to prove unfair dismissal or race discrimination. The tribunal found Car Giant's redundancy process was fair.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee v St John's Nursing Home Limited
A former employee's race and sex discrimination claims were struck out after she and her representative failed to attend a preliminary hearing without explanation. A later bid to reinstate the case was refused.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Security Officer (13 years' service) v Secure Frontline Services Limited
A tribunal found that a security officer with 13 years' service was unfairly dismissed after being sacked by email without any disciplinary hearing, but reduced her compensation to zero because her own conduct contributed entirely to the dismissal.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Plant operator / maintenance worker (chemical effluent treatment plant) v Suez Industrial Water Limited and Airbus Operations Limited
Three chemical effluent plant workers were automatically transferred to Airbus under TUPE when the maintenance contract expired and Airbus took the work in-house. The tribunal declared a service provision change had occurred.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Former Enforcement Officer (10 months' service) v Nuneaton & Bedworth Borough Council
A former enforcement officer with Asperger's and dyslexia was awarded £4,827 after his ex-employer gave a negative job reference because he had brought disability discrimination proceedings.
Partial · £4,827 · Aug 2023Partial£4,827Aug 2023Chief Executive Officer (13 years' service) v Integration Support Services
A tribunal has rejected an unfair dismissal claim brought by a CEO with 13 years' service, finding that the employer acted reasonably in dismissing for gross misconduct following an independent investigation into bullying allegations.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee v DHL Services Limited
A former DHL employee's unfair dismissal claim was thrown out after being filed one day late. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable to submit on time, rejecting ADHD and technical difficulties as excuses.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Administrative Officer (2 years' service) v Brook Street Limited
A tribunal has allowed an administrative officer to amend her disability discrimination claim to include a section 15 claim, while refusing to add new disabilities. The respondent's strike-out applications were largely rejected.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Former employees v Carl's Kitchen Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld claims from four former employees of Carl's Kitchen Limited for unpaid redundancy, unauthorised wage deductions, and missing pension contributions. The company failed to attend the hearing.
Won · Aug 2023Won—Aug 2023Gymnastics coach (3 years' service) v Doncaster Gymnastics Academy Ltd
A gymnastics coach who encouraged gymnasts to leave for a rival club was unfairly dismissed by text message, but her compensation was cut by 75% for her own misconduct. She was awarded £167.08.
Won · £167 · Aug 2023Won£167Aug 2023Weekend Support Worker (2 years' service) v Our Place Schools Ltd
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a Weekend Support Worker who was absent for nearly two years and failed to engage with welfare meetings or provide medical evidence. The employer, Our Place Schools Ltd, was found to have acted reasonably.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee v Worker Bee UK Ltd
A tribunal struck out a former employee's claims against Worker Bee UK Ltd after she failed to comply with multiple orders and did not actively pursue her case, making a fair hearing impossible.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Farm worker (40 years' service) v G.E. Spence and Sons (a partnership)
A farm worker with 40 years' service was sent a P45 in the post while off sick with cauda equina syndrome. The tribunal found he was unfairly dismissed, discriminated against because of his disability, and awarded over £26,800.
Won · £26,811 · Aug 2023Won£26,811Aug 2023Business Development Coordinator (18 months' service) v Garic Ltd
A Business Development Coordinator who resigned after raising GDPR concerns about cold calling lost his claims for whistleblowing detriment and constructive unfair dismissal. The tribunal found no breach of contract or protected disclosure before his resignation.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Shop assistant / supervisor (2 years' service) v Beauty Base Ltd
A shop assistant who took a long holiday after an informal arrangement with his manager was unfairly dismissed for alleged mobile phone use. The tribunal awarded £18,441 after finding the real reason was unknown and the procedure was a sham.
Partial · £18,441 · Aug 2023Partial£18,441Aug 2023Former employee v Walkers Snacks Limited
A former employee with osteoarthritis faced strike-out of one harassment claim but was allowed to proceed with others, including unfair dismissal and disability discrimination, after a preliminary hearing.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Former employee v Department for Education
A former employee who filed eight separate claims against the Department for Education and others has had all claims struck out after the tribunal found his conduct scandalous, unreasonable and vexatious.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Finance and accounting consultant v Ruby Labs Ltd
A finance and accounting consultant who threatened to report his client for tax irregularities unless paid £600,000 has had all his employment tribunal claims dismissed. He was ordered to pay €86,200 in costs.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Care worker (4 years' service) v R2
A care worker with four years' service was unfairly dismissed after an incident with his client. The tribunal found the dismissal procedurally unfair and awarded £2,975 after deductions.
Won · £2,975 · Aug 2023Won£2,975Aug 2023Regulatory Officer (10 years' service) v Environment Agency
A Regulatory Officer with 10 years' service resigned claiming constructive dismissal after her grievance was not upheld. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence and dismissed the claim.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Manager (18 years' service) v Lloyds Banking Group PLC
A manager with 18 years' service was unfairly dismissed and discriminated against for using the full N-word during a race education session. The tribunal found his dyslexia contributed to the error and ordered Lloyds Banking Group to pay over £454,000.
Partial · £454,715 · Aug 2023Partial£454,715Aug 2023Former employee (18 years' service) v Riviera Multimedia Ltd
A former employee with 18 years' service was locked out of her workplace and left unpaid for months. The tribunal awarded her over £26,000 in redundancy, breach of contract, unpaid salary, and holiday pay.
Partial · £26,022 · Aug 2023Partial£26,022Aug 2023Telesales consultant (6 years' service) v Direct Line Insurance Services Ltd
A telesales consultant with menopausal symptoms won £64,645 after her employer failed to make reasonable adjustments and treated her unfavourably due to her disability.
Partial · £64,645 · Aug 2023Partial£64,645Aug 2023Former employee v Kitrinos Healthcare (charity No. 1172586)
A former employee settled her claims for £11,210.89 after the employer conceded unfair dismissal at the final hearing. The tribunal later ordered the employer to pay £6,485.88 in preparation time costs for unreasonable conduct.
Settled · £11,211 · Aug 2023Settled£11,211Aug 2023Sales and Lettings Manager (4 months' service) v Ridgway Property Limited
A sales and lettings manager with four months' service lost her race and sex discrimination claims after the tribunal found the alleged incidents of harassment and discrimination did not happen as described. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee (30 years' service) v Dunwood Specialties Limited
A tribunal found that Dunwood Specialties Limited unfairly dismissed a long-serving employee after failing to follow any disciplinary process, but reduced compensation by 80% because the employee would likely have been dismissed anyway.
Partial · £27,075 · Aug 2023Partial£27,075Aug 2023Level 7 analyst (10 years' service) v Thames Water Utilities Ltd
A level 7 analyst who resigned claiming constructive unfair dismissal and discrimination lost her case after the tribunal found no evidence of less favourable treatment or breach of trust.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Office administrator (4 years' service) v Beaumont and Fletcher Ltd
A tribunal found that an office administrator was constructively unfairly dismissed after her employer included unparticularised criticisms about her appearance and relationships with colleagues in a capability letter. She was awarded £3,497.79, reduced by 75% for contributory fault.
Won · £3,498 · Aug 2023Won£3,498Aug 2023Healthcare assistant (nursing bank) v Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust
A tribunal ruled that a healthcare assistant's left shoulder, lower back and wrist impairments were disabilities, but her premature menopause was not because it only affected her sexual life, not her professional life.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Former ambulance service employee v South Central Ambulance Service NHS Foundation Trust
A former ambulance service employee had her unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims struck out after lodging them over three weeks late. She was ordered to pay £4,305.48 in costs.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Former employee v BUPA Care Homes (ANS) Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against BUPA Care Homes was dismissed because she presented it nearly seven months after her dismissal, well beyond the three-month time limit. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for her to have brought the claim in time.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Casual worker (5 years' intermittent service) v Miracle Art and Inspired Sanity Ltd
A casual worker with Asperger Syndrome failed to prove disability discrimination or harassment, but the tribunal ruled she was a worker entitled to holiday pay.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Former employee v Riverside Dental Spa
A default judgment against Riverside Dental Spa for maternity discrimination was revoked when the tribunal discovered the employer had in fact filed its response before the deadline. The case will now proceed to a full hearing.
Remitted · Aug 2023Remitted—Aug 2023Former employee (security guard) v Wanis Management Services LLP
A former security guard's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after he presented it two months after the deadline. The tribunal ruled it was reasonably practicable for him to have filed on time despite his mental health issues and lack of legal knowledge.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Senior Nurse Practitioner (nearly 10 years' service) v West London NHS Trust
A senior nurse with nearly 10 years' service claimed disability discrimination for generalised anxiety disorder, but the tribunal found he was not disabled under the Equality Act 2010 due to lack of medical diagnosis and limited impact on daily activities.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Rehabilitation Assistant (28 years' service) v Central London Community Healthcare NHS Trust
An employment tribunal has ruled that Central London Community Healthcare NHS Trust fairly dismissed a rehabilitation assistant with 28 years' service after prolonged sickness absence, rejecting claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Community Engagement Officer (agency worker) v Umbrella-Company Limited
An agency worker who claimed she was dismissed for whistleblowing had her interim relief application refused because she could not show a 'pretty good chance' of proving she was an employee of the respondent.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Midwife (22 years' service) v Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust
A Reading tribunal struck out a midwife's discrimination claims against Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust after finding they could not be fairly heard, but allowed her unfair and wrongful dismissal claims to proceed.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Former employee (10 months' service) v Maronsett Limited
A former employee with less than 10 months' service was awarded £1,015.81 after his employer unlawfully deducted holiday pay and wages to cover vehicle damage. His unfair dismissal claim was dismissed for lack of qualifying service.
Partial · £1,016 · Aug 2023Partial£1,016Aug 2023Former employee v Elizabeth Cardy
A former employee's unfair dismissal and redundancy claims were struck out because she had less than two years' service. Her remaining claims were also struck out after she did not attend the final hearing.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Human Resources Business Partner v Romac Logistics Limited
A tribunal has refused an employer's attempt to strike out claims of disability discrimination and victimisation brought by an autistic HR Business Partner who was dismissed after raising concerns about missing right-to-work documents.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Biomedical support worker (5 years' service) v Leeds Teaching Hospital Trust
A tribunal dismissed a biomedical support worker's disability discrimination claims against former colleagues after he failed to attend a public preliminary hearing, despite having previously withdrawn his unfair dismissal claim.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Therapist (self-employed) v The Chief Constable of Greater Manchester Police
A therapist who provided counselling to police staff was found to be self-employed, not a worker or employee, and his claims for unfair dismissal and holiday pay were dismissed.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Spray Operative (Japanese knotweed site technician) v Zirkon Ltd
A tribunal refused to strike out a reasonable adjustments claim brought by a spray operative with mixed anxiety and depression, despite the employer arguing the claim had no reasonable prospects. The employer had already conceded unfair dismissal.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Credit Analyst (2 years' service) v Lawson (Whetstone) Limited
A tribunal refused to strike out a credit analyst's claims of constructive unfair dismissal and religion-based discrimination, finding the claims had reasonable prospects despite missing details.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee v Unique Training Group Ltd
A former employee won over £4,100 in unpaid wages and notice pay, but their unfair dismissal claim failed for lack of two years' service.
Partial · £4,172 · Jul 2023Partial£4,172Jul 2023Lead nurse specialist (4 years 8 months' service) v Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust
A lead nurse specialist was unfairly dismissed by Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust after the trust failed to properly handle her grievance. The tribunal found she had committed gross misconduct but the dismissal was procedurally unfair.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Supermarket Assistant (3 years' service) v John Lewis plc
A supermarket assistant who was dismissed after nearly two and a half years of sickness absence had his unfair dismissal claim rejected because he presented it too late and failed to attend the preliminary hearing.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Agency worker (Housing Officer, temporary cover) v Notting Hill Genesis
An agency worker who was dismissed after taking three days off without permission to care for his son has lost his claims of race and sex discrimination against Notting Hill Genesis.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Bank admin and clerical worker (2 years' service) v University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust
A Birmingham Employment Tribunal dismissed all claims of race discrimination and unfair dismissal brought by a former bank admin worker against University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust, finding her allegations of a racist conspiracy involving over 30 people to be without evidence.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Charity shop manager (4 months' service) v Restore (Cumbria)
A charity shop manager with just four months' service was automatically unfairly dismissed after querying her pay. The tribunal awarded £17,956 in compensation.
Partial · £17,956 · Jul 2023Partial£17,956Jul 2023Associate Land Director (8 years' service) v Thakeham Homes Limited
An associate land director who resigned after his employer refused to pay £12,000 commission he claimed under an oral agreement lost his unfair dismissal claim, but won £2,585 for unpaid wages.
Partial · £2,585 · Jul 2023Partial£2,585Jul 2023Executive Assistant (3 months' service) v Goma Limited T/A Caia
An executive assistant with only three months' service was dismissed after accidentally sending an email calling her boss a 'very difficult boss'. The tribunal found the dismissal was for conduct, not for asserting statutory rights, and rejected her claim for automatically unfair dismissal.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former retail worker v Primark Stores Ltd
A former Primark employee who refused to attend her own unfair dismissal hearing had her claim dismissed under Rule 47. The tribunal also ordered her to pay £400 in costs for unreasonable conduct.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Import coordinator (2 years 11 months' service) v International Forest Products (UK) Limited
An import coordinator who repeatedly stated she could not return to work after maternity and parental leave was fairly dismissed for some other substantial reason. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal and discrimination.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Registered nurse (band 5, 6 years' service) v Tees Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust
A band 5 nurse with six years' unblemished service was fairly dismissed after CCTV showed her dragging a vulnerable patient with learning disabilities along the floor. The employment tribunal rejected her unfair and wrongful dismissal claims.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Bus driver (5 years' service) v Abellio London Ltd
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a bus driver with five years' service who drove through a red light, finding the employer's decision was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Residential Support Worker (11 months' service) v Roundabout Limited
A tribunal dismissed claims of automatic unfair dismissal, pregnancy discrimination, race discrimination and victimisation brought by a Residential Support Worker who was dismissed after breaching Covid protocols. The employer was ordered to pay £1,355.65 for giving only one week's notice instead of four.
Partial · £1,356 · Jul 2023Partial£1,356Jul 2023PE teacher and union representative v The North Huddersfield Trust
A PE teacher and union rep was unfairly dismissed after a breakdown in relationships with school leadership. The tribunal found her suspension and dismissal were acts of victimisation, but reduced compensation by 50% for her own conduct.
Partial · £22,005 · Jul 2023Partial£22,005Jul 2023Residential support worker (nearly 5 years' service) v Evolve Child Care Ltd
A residential support worker who resigned after a co-worker's Alzheimer's joke was not constructively dismissed, the tribunal has ruled. The claim for harassment related to age also failed.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023National Sales Manager (2 years' service in role, 5 years total) v Frontier Therapeutics Limited
A National Sales Manager who resigned after a bonus plan dispute and alleged bullying has lost her claims for constructive unfair dismissal and unlawful deductions from wages. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Health Care Assistant v Principle Care Agency Limited
A health care assistant who worked for a care home that closed and reopened was found to have insufficient continuous service to bring an unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal ruled there was a break in employment.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Former employee v Carbolite Gero Limited
A former employee who resigned and then waited until after his grievance appeal to bring an unfair dismissal claim was too late. The tribunal ruled it had no jurisdiction to hear the claim, which was presented over two months after the three-month time limit expired.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Crane Operator and Warehouse Assistant v Barrett Steel Limited
A crane operator who thought his unfair dismissal claim deadline ran from the appeal outcome lost his case when the tribunal ruled the clock started ticking from the original dismissal letter.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Former employee v Best Time Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Best Time Limited was struck out after she missed the time limit to contact ACAS and failed to explain the delay.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023General Operative (5 years' service) v Amalga Ltd
A general operative who flew to Slovakia while on furlough was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Groom (2 months' service) v Billy Davidson NV Stables Ltd
A groom employed for just two months was awarded £485 after her employer paid her less than the agreed £300 per week. The Teesside tribunal found the employer had made unlawful deductions from wages.
Partial · £485 · Jul 2023Partial£485Jul 2023QA operative (6 years' service) v Curry’s Group Limited
A QA operative with six years' service resigned after his grievance was rejected, claiming constructive unfair dismissal. The tribunal found the employer had reasonable and proper cause for all its actions.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Personal assistant (1 year's service) v Miss S Powell
A personal assistant with less than two years' service was summarily dismissed via WhatsApp after she could not get to work due to heavy snowfall. The tribunal rejected her claim that the dismissal was automatically unfair for health and safety reasons.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Stock Technician (6 years' service) v Stanmore Implants Worldwide Limited
A stock technician with six years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after an unauthorised absence. The tribunal rejected claims of unfair dismissal, age discrimination, and harassment.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee (21 years' service) v Currys plc
A former employee with 21 years' service at Currys plc had her unfair dismissal and redundancy claims initially struck out due to an administrative error. The strike-outs were later revoked, but the unfair dismissal claim was ultimately dismissed.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Train operator (11 years' service) v London Underground Limited
A tribunal found London Underground unfairly dismissed a train operator with 11 years' service for opening doors on the wrong side, but awarded no compensation because a fair process would have reached the same outcome.
Partial · £0 · Jul 2023Partial£0Jul 2023Support Worker in a care home (10 months' service) v The Belsteads Group Ltd.
A support worker who raised COVID-19 safety concerns was put on a performance improvement plan and later dismissed. The tribunal found she suffered detriment for whistleblowing and was discriminated against when pregnant.
Partial · £30,163 · Jul 2023Partial£30,163Jul 2023Carer (4 years 8 months' service) v Miss Gurshital Gill
A carer with nearly five years' service was dismissed by email after reporting a back injury at work. The tribunal found the dismissal procedurally unfair but limited compensation because a fair dismissal would have occurred anyway.
Partial · £1,536 · Jul 2023Partial£1,536Jul 2023Street Scene Worker (3 years 10 months' service) v Halton Borough Council
A Street Scene Worker with disabilities resigned after his employer required a GP fitness letter to return from shielding. The tribunal rejected his constructive unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee (less than 1 year's service) v Mitie Care and Custody Ltd
A former employee who returned to Mitie Care and Custody Ltd after a three-month break was unable to bring an unfair dismissal claim because his continuous service reset, leaving him short of the two-year qualifying period.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Assistant Restaurant General Manager (12 years' service) v Splendid Restaurants (Colonel) Ltd
A 12-year employee who waited until after his internal appeal to bring an unfair dismissal claim was out of time. The tribunal rejected arguments that his wife's stillbirth and his own ignorance of procedure made it not reasonably practicable to claim earlier.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Ward manager (12 years' service) v Cheshire and Wirral Partnership NHS Foundation Trust
A ward manager with 12 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after the trust used CCTV and fob records to investigate her hours. The tribunal found the dismissal fair but awarded £10,269.96 for breach of contract — she should have received notice pay.
Partial · £10,270 · Jul 2023Partial£10,270Jul 2023Healthcare assistant (19 years' service) v Practice Plus Group Health and Rehabilitation Service Ltd
A healthcare assistant with 19 years' service succeeded in a disability discrimination claim after her employer failed to carry out a BAME risk assessment she had requested. The tribunal found the dismissal fair and rejected victimisation claims.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Former employee v FAE Ventures Ltd (T/a FAE Group)
A tribunal initially struck out a former employee's disability discrimination claims for failing to provide a detailed impact statement, but later reinstated them after reconsidering the proportionality of the sanction.
Remitted · Jul 2023Remitted—Jul 2023Driver (11 months' service) v Neil Hadris (Owner, NH Transport Services – Sole Trader)
A driver with just 11 months' service was dismissed without notice via WhatsApp and not paid for his final month. The tribunal awarded £1,812.80 for unlawful deduction of wages and failure to provide written particulars.
Partial · £1,813 · Jul 2023Partial£1,813Jul 2023Apprentice network engineer (4 months' service) v Openreach Ltd
An apprentice network engineer with four months' service failed to prove constructive dismissal after being dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal awarded £225.23 for unpaid wages.
Partial · £225 · Jul 2023Partial£225Jul 2023Bus driver (9 years' service) v Metroline West Ltd
A Watford tribunal found that Metroline West Ltd unlawfully deducted wages by withholding company sick pay from a bus driver who went off sick on the day of a disciplinary hearing. He was awarded £3,012.38.
Partial · £3,012 · Jul 2023Partial£3,012Jul 2023Caretaker (15 years' service) v Islington Borough Council
A caretaker dismissed after 15 months' sickness absence lost his unfair dismissal claim, but was awarded £1,628.02 for unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £1,628 · Jul 2023Partial£1,628Jul 2023Former employee (medical centre) v Dr S Zaidi
A tribunal found that a medical centre employee was disabled from December 2019 due to anxiety and depression, earlier than the employer conceded. The ruling confirms that mental impairments can be 'long-term' even before 12 months have passed.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Sterile specialist (5/6 weeks' service) v Norton Healthcare Ltd t/a Teva Runcorn
A tribunal struck out a sterile specialist's race and age discrimination claims after she admitted posting selfies showing confidential information on social media. The claims had no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Former employee v Warburtons Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims were struck out after he failed to particularize them despite multiple hearings and warnings. The tribunal found no reasonable prospect of success and unreasonable conduct.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Train driver (10 years' service) v Arriva Rail London Limited
An employment tribunal has ruled that Arriva Rail London fairly dismissed a train driver of 10 years who tested positive for cannabis metabolites in a random drug test, rejecting his defence that the result was caused by CBD oil.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Managing Director (19 years' service) v Agra Freeze Limited
A managing director with 19 years' service was constructively dismissed after her employer paid her a bonus £15,975 short of what was owed. The tribunal awarded damages and a 40% Polkey reduction.
Partial · £15,975 · Jul 2023Partial£15,975Jul 2023Former employee v Ontrak Recruitment and Training
A former employee's unfair dismissal and other claims were struck out after the tribunal found he lacked the two-year qualifying service and failed to comply with orders or attend hearings.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Personal assistant (10 months' service) v Martin F George
A personal assistant who resigned and worked her full notice period had her constructive wrongful dismissal claim struck out for having no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Senior Sales Consultant (2 years' service) v Ninety Watches and Jewellery Limited
A tribunal dismissed a former sales consultant's race and religion discrimination claims because they were presented more than six months after her dismissal, and it was not just and equitable to extend time.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Senior Practitioner in Adult Social Care (27 years' service) v Birmingham City Council
Birmingham City Council fairly dismissed a Senior Practitioner with 27 years' service after a 9-month sickness absence for bereavement stress. The tribunal rejected claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Yard Controller (30 years' service) v Abellio East Anglia Limited T/A Greater Anglia
A yard controller with 30 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a 16-second delay in stopping a train due to a radio failure. The tribunal found the employer's investigation was inadequate and the procedure fell outside the range of reasonable responses.
Won · Jul 2023Won—Jul 2023Former employee v Drainforce Rail Ltd
Five former employees of Drainforce Rail Ltd were unfairly dismissed in a redundancy process, but their claims for a statutory redundancy payment failed. The tribunal awarded a total of £23,911.04.
Partial · £23,911 · Jul 2023Partial£23,911Jul 2023Swimming teacher (8 years' service) v Doncaster Culture & Leisure Trust
A swimming teacher with 8 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after telling a 10-year-old pupil 'it looks like you work out'. The Leeds tribunal upheld the employer's decision, citing safeguarding concerns.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Trainee duct fitter (14 months' service) v AV Unibrak South Ltd
A black trainee duct fitter was paid less and given more labouring work than white comparators. The tribunal awarded £27,624 for race discrimination and unpaid wages.
Partial · £27,624 · Jul 2023Partial£27,624Jul 2023Welder (20 years' service) v Silo Services Limited
A welder who resigned after his employer failed to make reasonable adjustments for his heart condition has won his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims. The tribunal awarded £42,334 but reduced compensation because he turned down a job offer the day after leaving.
Won · £42,334 · Jul 2023Won£42,334Jul 2023Commercial Development Director (Investment Management lead) v A&J Wealth Management Ltd
A commercial development director was fairly dismissed when his team was disbanded, despite a misleading statement by a managing director. The tribunal found a genuine redundancy situation and a fair consultation process.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Support worker (10 months' service) v Stori Wales (formerly Hafan Cymru)
A support worker who resigned after reporting a jammed door lock and a blocked fire exit has lost her claim for constructive unfair dismissal. The tribunal found no serious or imminent danger.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee v Gist Ltd
A former employee who missed the deadline for his unfair dismissal claim because he didn't know about the three-month limit was able to proceed with his disability discrimination claim on 'just and equitable' grounds.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Bus driver (3 years' service) v Stagecoach Group Plc
A bus driver with deep vein thrombosis was constructively dismissed after Stagecoach failed to implement occupational health recommendations for shorter routes and breaks. The tribunal awarded £38,794.56.
Partial · £38,795 · Jul 2023Partial£38,795Jul 2023Bus driver (7 months' service) v Diamond Bus (North West) Limited
A bus driver with seven months' service was automatically unfairly dismissed after he raised grievances about unpaid travel time and working time breaches. The tribunal awarded £4,335.28.
Partial · £4,335 · Jul 2023Partial£4,335Jul 2023Farm shop worker (7 years' service) v M.B. Farm Produce Limited
A farm shop worker with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed after initially refusing a suitable alternative role but later changing her mind, only to have her employer ignore her change of heart. The tribunal awarded £7,209.50.
Partial · £7,210 · Jul 2023Partial£7,210Jul 2023Cleaner (2 years' service) v M & I t/a Jetmaid Cleaning Services Ltd
A cleaner with two years' service was dismissed by text message after calling in sick. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair and awarded £8,192.72.
Won · £8,193 · Jul 2023Won£8,193Jul 2023Conveyancing solicitor v A A Holmes Limited
A conveyancing solicitor who resigned after her employer threatened a 25% pay cut without agreement has won £11,657 in notice pay. The tribunal found the employer's unilateral salary reduction was a fundamental breach of contract.
Won · £11,657 · Jul 2023Won£11,657Jul 2023Senior academic (highly qualified, working in a senior position) v QAHE Ltd
A highly qualified academic who failed to provide a supplemental impact statement as ordered by the tribunal has been ordered to pay £1,000 in costs. The tribunal found his conduct unreasonable and that it caused a hearing to be postponed.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Online delivery driver v Sainsbury’s Supermarkets Ltd
A Sainsbury's delivery driver who claimed he was unfairly dismissed for discount card misuse had his case dismissed because he presented his claim two months after the deadline.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Quality Control Technologist (2 years' service) v Wealmoor Limited
A quality control technologist with back pain and depression was unfairly dismissed after his employer relied on a GP report and failed to obtain occupational health advice. Tribunal awards £129,970.
Won · £129,970 · Jul 2023Won£129,970Jul 2023Firefighter (3 years' service) v London Fire Commissioner
A firefighter who waited over a year to bring unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims after his misconduct dismissal had his case struck out by the tribunal as out of time.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Former employee v Real Life Oldham Limited
A tribunal found that a former employee was unfairly dismissed because of her pregnancy, and awarded over £23,800 including £12,000 for injury to feelings.
Won · £23,823 · Jul 2023Won£23,823Jul 2023Former employee (IT professional, £55k salary) v JP Morgan Chase Bank N.A London Branch
A tribunal struck out a former JP Morgan employee's discrimination claim after he inserted a poem into disclosed documents and sent the tampered version to the tribunal. Most allegations were also dismissed as out of time.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Former employee v Mitie FM Ltd
A tribunal struck out one part of a former employee's race discrimination claim because the alleged discriminatory act was carried out by a third party, but allowed other allegations to proceed.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Former employee (3 years' service) v Sage UK Ltd
A former employee's claims of constructive unfair dismissal and pregnancy/maternity discrimination were dismissed after the tribunal refused to extend the time limits, finding the claims were presented too late.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Assistant Head of School / Deputy Designated Safeguarding Lead (6 years' service) v Haggerston School and London Borough of Hackney
An assistant head of school who told his headteacher he was a victim of domestic violence has won his constructive unfair dismissal claim after the school's handling of disciplinary and grievance processes was found to breach trust and confidence.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Window fitter (6 years' service) v Amazing Glazing (Widnes) Limited
A window fitter with six years' service was dismissed by text message claiming the company was going into receivership, but the tribunal found the business continued trading. He was awarded £9,357 for unfair dismissal, notice pay, holiday pay, and an unauthorised deduction.
Won · £9,357 · Jul 2023Won£9,357Jul 2023Deputy Manager (4 years' service) v Mr K M Bowen
A deputy manager who was pushed by her employer during a dispute, then offered a deal to return only to have it reneged on, has won her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal awarded £25,391.35.
Won · £25,391 · Jul 2023Won£25,391Jul 2023Former employee v The CS Group Limited
A former employee with less than two years' service was awarded £3,876 after the tribunal found unauthorised wage deductions and a breach of contract over notice pay. The employer also failed to provide written particulars.
Partial · £3,876 · Jul 2023Partial£3,876Jul 2023Former employee v Financial Ombudsman Service Limited
A former complainant who claimed to be an employee of the Financial Ombudsman Service had all his claims struck out after failing to attend a preliminary hearing and providing no evidence of an employment relationship.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Former employee v Xace Limited
A former employee forgot about an occupational health report and disclosed it late. The employer's application for £12,166 in costs was refused by the tribunal.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Parts Sales Manager (14 years' service) v Chassis Cab Ltd
A tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal claim from a Parts Sales Manager with 14 years' service because he presented it over four months late, ruling it was reasonably practicable for him to have done so in time.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Finance Director (24 years' service) v Artem Ltd
A tribunal found that a finance director with 24 years' service was constructively dismissed and subjected to sex and race discrimination after being passed over for managing director and told her chairman had lost confidence in her. She was awarded £112,007.
Partial · £112,007 · Jul 2023Partial£112,007Jul 2023Former employee v The Beehive (Penrith) Ltd (in voluntary liquidation)
A former employee with less than two years' service had their unfair dismissal claim struck out, but recovered £1,263 in unpaid wages after the employer failed to respond.
Partial · £1,263 · Jul 2023Partial£1,263Jul 2023Night watchman/security (former employee) v JP&S Services Ltd
A former night watchman who waited 10 months to bring an unfair dismissal claim after being sacked while on sick leave has had his case dismissed as out of time. The tribunal refused to extend the deadline, ruling it was reasonably practicable for him to have claimed sooner.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Head of Sales (2 years' service) v Pendragon Plc t/a Stratstone BMW
A tribunal found the dismissal of a Head of Sales was procedurally unfair due to a flawed appeal and inconsistent treatment, but awarded no compensation because of the employee's contributory conduct.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Associate Specialist Cardio-Thoracic surgeon (12 years' service) v Cardiff and Vale University Local Health Board
A Cardiff tribunal dismissed claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination by a surgeon who accessed his ex-wife's medical records without consent over 13 years. The tribunal found he resigned voluntarily and the employer's disciplinary process was fair.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Assistant Store Manager (Makkar, 8 years' service) and Store Manager (Bakiu, 15 years' service) v Neve Jewels Ltd t/a Diamonds Factory
An assistant store manager and a store manager with 8 and 15 years' service were constructively unfairly dismissed after their employer failed to investigate a racist comment, threatened dismissal, and required a diabetic employee to work alone on locked premises. The tribunal found a cumulative breach of trust and confidence.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Former employee (marketing agent through own company) v Vatech Dental Manufacturing Limited
A former employee who worked through his own company before becoming an employee had his unfair dismissal claim struck out because he had less than two years' continuous service as an employee.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Domestic worker (overseas domestic worker visa) v Mr R K Jain
A domestic worker who was paid far below the minimum wage and worked seven days a week had her claims dismissed because they were presented to the tribunal three months late.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Workshop technician v Fact Community Transport
A workshop technician unfairly made redundant was awarded £1,350 compensation after the tribunal applied a 50% Polkey deduction for the chance he would have been dismissed in a fair process.
Partial · £1,542 · Jul 2023Partial£1,542Jul 2023Workshop Planning Co-ordinator (17 years' service) v Jaguar Land Rover Ltd
A workshop planning co-ordinator with 17 years' service failed to prove his redundancy selection was unfair or discriminatory. The tribunal found Jaguar Land Rover's process was reasonable.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee v Norpol Recycling Limited
A former employee who worked for Norpol Recycling Limited for less than two years had his unfair dismissal claim struck out because he did not meet the qualifying period. The tribunal also found his disability discrimination claim was out of time.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Spray operator (10 years' service) v AF Machinery Limited
A spray operator who claimed constructive unfair dismissal and disability discrimination lost all claims at tribunal, which found he resigned to retire to Wales rather than because of any breach by his employer.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Support worker and administrative assistant (1 year 3 months' service) v Flourishgate Care Services Limited
A support worker who was dismissed for gross misconduct after throwing water at a service user has lost her claim that the real reason was whistleblowing. The tribunal found no protected disclosures had been made and the dismissal was solely due to the incident.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Multiskilled operative (11 months' service) v Coastline Housing Ltd
A multiskilled operative who resigned and claimed constructive unfair dismissal for whistleblowing had his claims thrown out because he did not present them in time. The tribunal also rejected his disability discrimination claim for lack of medical evidence.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Former employee v Surrey County Council
A former employee who claimed she was automatically unfairly dismissed for making 11 protected disclosures has been refused interim relief by the tribunal, which found it unlikely she would succeed at the final hearing.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Apprentice (digital marketing) v A & T Trained Dogs Limited
A digital marketing apprentice who was dismissed days after writing to her employer about an unpaid tax rebate has won her claim for automatically unfair dismissal. The Manchester tribunal awarded £3,963.97 in compensation.
Won · £3,964 · Jul 2023Won£3,964Jul 2023Care worker (2 years' service) v Enlightenment Care Services
A care worker who was dismissed after making a protected disclosure has won her automatic unfair dismissal claim after her employer failed to respond to the tribunal claim on time. She was awarded £15,722.
Won · £15,722 · Jul 2023Won£15,722Jul 2023Senior care assistant (2 years' service) v Mr J W Nunn trading as Primrose Lodge
A senior care assistant who resigned after a manager swore at her and a grievance was poorly handled has won her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found a fundamental breach of trust and confidence.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Sales advisor (2 years 7 months' service) v Bellway Homes Limited
A sales advisor who resigned after receiving a final written warning for selling a show-home sofa on Facebook Marketplace has lost her claim for constructive unfair dismissal against Bellway Homes Limited. The tribunal found the employer's disciplinary process was reasonable and no fundamental breach of contract occurred.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee v Trafford College Group
A former employee who resigned and claimed constructive dismissal for whistleblowing and health and safety reasons has lost her case after the tribunal found no evidence of detriment or dismissal for those reasons.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Head of PE Faculty (7 years' service) v Kings Monkton School Limited
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a Head of PE who authorised the use of another pupil's inhaler for a child with severe allergies during an off-site lesson. All disability discrimination claims also failed.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Senior healthcare assistant (3 years' service) v The Spitalfields Practice
A senior healthcare assistant was unfairly dismissed after a breakdown in working relationships, but the tribunal applied a 75% Polkey reduction, awarding £6,975.14 in compensation.
Partial · £6,975 · Jul 2023Partial£6,975Jul 2023Ramp Allocator (23 years' service) v Menzies Aviation (UK) Limited
A ramp allocator with 23 years' service was unfairly dismissed after Menzies Aviation used subjective interview-based selection criteria for redundancy. The tribunal awarded £31,373.68 in compensation.
Won · £31,374 · Jul 2023Won£31,374Jul 2023Assistant Store Manager (4 years' service) v Poundland Limited
An assistant store manager who allowed a colleague to work without clocking in and later falsified time records was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected her claim that lack of training excused the manipulation of the Kronos system.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Taxi driver (school transport driver, 9 years' service) v KingKabs Ltd (formerly Vedamain Ltd)
A tribunal awarded £3,361.96 to a taxi driver who was denied holiday pay and had unauthorised deductions made, but rejected her claims of sex discrimination and detriment for whistleblowing.
Partial · £3,362 · Jul 2023Partial£3,362Jul 2023Engineering team leader (7 years' service) v Swisslog UK Ltd
An engineering team leader's sex discrimination claim was thrown out because it was presented too late, while his constructive unfair dismissal claim also failed on the merits.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee (Project Manager, Surrey Fire and Rescue Service Pensions) v Surrey County Council
A tribunal has struck out a former employee's unfair dismissal claim after he deliberately misled the tribunal about a medical appointment and failed to comply with case management orders.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Team Leader (1 month's service) v Lifeways Community Care Limited
A team leader who resigned after just one month in post lost his claims of constructive dismissal and race discrimination after the tribunal found he had not made a protected disclosure to the CQC.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Team Leader (13 years' service) v Care UK Community Partnership Ltd
A team leader dismissed for failing to complete accident reports was unfairly dismissed because the real reason was his whistleblowing. Tribunal awards £40,670 after 30% reduction for his conduct.
Partial · £40,671 · Jul 2023Partial£40,671Jul 2023Factory manager (3 years' service) v Laporte Industries UK Limited
A tribunal ruled that a meeting between a factory manager and Laporte Industries UK Limited was a genuine without-prejudice negotiation, making it inadmissible in his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Antenatal Education Midwife (3 years' service) v Barking, Havering and Redbridge University Hospitals NHS Trust
An antenatal education midwife with dyspraxia and depression was constructively dismissed after a manager raised multiple criticisms without warning. The tribunal upheld her unfair dismissal claim and one reasonable adjustment claim.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Former employee v Sodexo Limited
A former employee of Sodexo was constructively dismissed and directly discriminated against on grounds of race after the company failed to address concerns raised in her grievance. The tribunal awarded £16,695.13.
Partial · £16,695 · Jul 2023Partial£16,695Jul 2023Kitchen designer (5 months' service) v Wilmslow Kitchen Interiors Limited
A kitchen designer who was dismissed by text message after just five months had her entire claim dismissed because she presented it after the statutory time limit. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for her to have claimed earlier.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Home Care Assistant (5 years' service) v Anchor Hanover Group
A tribunal struck out a home care assistant's race discrimination claim after she failed to pay a £1,200 deposit ordered because her allegations had little prospect of success. The case highlights the risks of bringing claims based on immigration status rather than race.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Customer concierge (9 years' service) v Heathrow Express Operating Company Limited
A customer concierge with nine years' service who was made redundant after refusing a new role has lost his claims for unfair dismissal, age discrimination, and equal pay. The tribunal found the redundancy process was fair.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee (5 years' service) v Entain Marketing (UK) Limited trading as Entain Group
A former employee with five years' service was awarded £4,505 after his employer failed to defend the claim. His discrimination claim was dismissed for lack of evidence.
Partial · £4,505 · Jul 2023Partial£4,505Jul 2023Health Care Support Worker (4 years' service) v Avon and Wiltshire Mental Health Partnership NHS Trust
A Health Care Support Worker with four years' service was fairly dismissed for failing to treat a service user with dignity, the tribunal ruled, rejecting claims of whistleblowing detriment and race discrimination.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Logistics Administrator (8 years' service) v Sample Logistics Ltd
An employment tribunal has dismissed a logistics administrator's constructive dismissal and discrimination claims, ruling that his connection to the UK was insufficient to establish territorial jurisdiction.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Former employee v Mr Marcel Hengst, Nova Status B.V., GOT Technologies (UK) Ltd
The tribunal rejected an employer's bid to overturn a costs order, finding their conduct was unreasonable. A separate claim for extra costs over the reconsideration was also dismissed.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023D&A Analyst (2 years' service) v National Westminster Bank Plc
A tribunal found that National Westminster Bank Plc unfairly dismissed a D&A Analyst for relationship breakdown, but ruled that he would have been dismissed within a month anyway and that his own conduct contributed entirely to his dismissal, resulting in no compensation.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Contract Manager (2 years' service) v British Tourist Authority
A contract manager who was dismissed after returning from maternity leave has been awarded £39,538 after a tribunal found her dismissal was automatically unfair because it was connected to her maternity leave.
Partial · £39,539 · Jul 2023Partial£39,539Jul 2023Trainee bus driver (9 days' service) v Warrington Borough Transport Limited
A trainee bus driver who presented his race discrimination claim one day late has had his case dismissed, with the tribunal refusing to extend time due to a lack of medical evidence explaining the delay.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Former employee (11 years' service) v Catwalk Dogs St Helens Ltd
A former employee with 11 years' service was unfairly dismissed and underpaid the national minimum wage. The tribunal awarded £4,694.53, including an ACAS uplift.
Won · £4,695 · Jul 2023Won£4,695Jul 2023Warehouse operative v Great Bear Distribution Ltd
A warehouse operative who claimed disability discrimination due to PTSD, abdominal pain and a necrotic hip has had her case dismissed after the tribunal found she was not disabled at the material time.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Trainee route setter (2 years' service) v Ascendant Leisure Properties Limited
A trainee route setter who emailed about changing her role was unfairly dismissed when her employer treated it as a resignation. The tribunal awarded £5,597, including an 18% uplift for failing to follow the ACAS Code.
Won · £5,597 · Jul 2023Won£5,597Jul 2023Bus driver (8 years 5 months' service) v Stephensons of Essex Limited
A bus driver with over eight years' service lost his constructive unfair dismissal claim after resigning over a manager's home visit and a historic data breach. The tribunal found the employer's actions were not a repudiatory breach of trust.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Finance director and co-owner v Franklin Funeral Directors
A finance director with complex PTSD has been found disabled under the Equality Act after a tribunal accepted her evidence of substantial and long-term effects on day-to-day activities.
Won · Jul 2023Won—Jul 2023Venue manager (8 years' service) v Sin Bar Ltd
A venue manager with 8 years' service was constructively unfairly dismissed after her employer shouted at her, refused sick pay, and removed her from the bar's Facebook page. The tribunal awarded £8,137.55.
Won · £8,138 · Jul 2023Won£8,138Jul 2023Property Manager (14 years' service) v Southern Housing
A property manager with 14 years' service lost her claims of race discrimination, harassment, victimisation and constructive unfair dismissal against Southern Housing. The tribunal found no evidence of unlawful treatment.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Target Support Worker for BME families (9 months' service) v Home-Start Birmingham North West
A target support worker who alleged race discrimination after being suspended for missed safeguarding concerns lost her claims. The tribunal found the employer's actions were not because of race.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Finance Assistant (4 years' service) v Outstanding Branding Ltd (in Liquidation) and Sandy Branding Ltd
A finance assistant was made redundant without any consultation or selection process after his employment transferred to a new company. The tribunal awarded over £11,000 for unfair and wrongful dismissal and unpaid wages.
Partial · £11,379 · Jul 2023Partial£11,379Jul 2023Relay recovery driver (13 years' service) v Manchetts (Holdings) Ltd
A relay recovery driver with 13 years' service who resigned after being sent on an overloaded job lost his claims for constructive dismissal and disability discrimination. The tribunal found no fundamental breach of contract or failure to make reasonable adjustments.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee v Tesco Stores Limited
A former employee was unfairly dismissed by Tesco, but the tribunal reduced his compensation by 10% because his own conduct contributed to the dismissal. Discrimination claims were dismissed.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Care home worker (5 years' service) v SSL Healthcare Ltd t/a Brookfields Care Home
A care home worker was unfairly dismissed after procedural flaws, but the tribunal found her guilty of the alleged misconduct and reduced compensation to zero.
Partial · £1,482 · Jul 2023Partial£1,482Jul 2023Former employee v Tata Steel UK Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claims were dismissed after his solicitor settled via ACAS. The tribunal rejected his argument that the solicitor lacked authority.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Former employee v Lloyds Bank Plc
A former employee of Lloyds Bank who omitted her full postal address from an online ET1 form had her unfair dismissal claim accepted out of time after the tribunal ruled it was not reasonably practicable to present it correctly.
Won · Jul 2023Won—Jul 2023Car salesman (3 years' service) v Swansway Garages Limited
An employment tribunal dismissed a car salesman's harassment claim after finding that derogatory comments calling him a paedophile were not related to his sexual orientation. The claimant, who represented himself, was unable to link the abuse to a protected characteristic.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Postal worker (21 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Limited
A postal worker with 21 years' service was fairly dismissed for not wearing a seatbelt while sharing a vehicle during the pandemic, the tribunal ruled, rejecting his claim of unfair dismissal.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Caretaker (9 years' service) v Catalyst Housing Limited
A caretaker with 9 years' service had his unfair dismissal claim struck out for being six weeks late, but his disability discrimination claim was allowed to proceed. No compensation awarded.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Former employee v WAC Arts
A former employee's attempt to add a sex discrimination claim based on how her safety concerns were handled compared to a colleague's was refused by the tribunal as out of time and lacking merit.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Managing Director (5 years 8 months' service) v Macom GmbH UK Ltd
A managing director was unfairly dismissed after his bankruptcy triggered a summary dismissal without any investigation or hearing. The tribunal awarded £4,630 but applied a 60% Polkey deduction.
Won · £4,630 · Jul 2023Won£4,630Jul 2023Childcare nursery assistant (3 months' service) v Ms Tika Mesha Williams
A nursery assistant with just 3 months' service was automatically unfairly dismissed after she raised concerns about being paid below the national minimum wage and not receiving rest breaks. The tribunal awarded £5,433.98.
Won · £5,434 · Jul 2023Won£5,434Jul 2023Nursery nurse (2 years 10 months' service) v Foster Park Primary School
A nursery nurse who resigned after receiving a final written warning for refusing to self-isolate despite being advised to do so has lost her constructive unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Community support worker (3 years' service) v London Borough of Brent
A Rastafarian community support worker who refused a PCR test due to his religious beliefs was fairly dismissed for prolonged absence, the Watford Employment Tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee v Cerberus Security and Monitoring Services Ltd
A former employee of Cerberus Security and Monitoring Services Ltd has succeeded in unfair dismissal and victimisation claims after being dismissed for conduct failings. Remedy is yet to be determined.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Former employee v Forefront Utilities Ltd
A former employee who tried to add whistleblowing and harassment claims months after her unfair dismissal claim was struck out for lack of two years' service. The tribunal refused the amendment due to delay and prejudice to the employer.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Early years practitioner (8 years' service) v Hertsmonceux Pre-School Limited
An early years practitioner with 8 years' service was automatically unfairly dismissed after raising concerns about underpayment of SSP and holiday pay. The tribunal found the real reason for her dismissal was her assertion of statutory rights.
Won · Jul 2023Won—Jul 2023Senior Production Manager (4 years' service) v Sophia Webster Limited
A senior production manager who was dismissed after seven weeks of sickness absence lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the small fashion retailer acted reasonably given her lack of engagement.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Regional Sales Manager (3 years' service) v Central Extrusions Limited
A Regional Sales Manager with three years' service was unfairly dismissed after using the word 'spastic' in a conversation about historical language. The tribunal awarded £7,710.31 for procedural failures including a pre-signed dismissal letter.
Won · £7,710 · Jul 2023Won£7,710Jul 2023Former employee v Marks and Spencer plc
A former Marks and Spencer employee had several claims struck out due to lack of reasonable prospect of success, but race and religion discrimination claims survive subject to small deposits.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023HGV driver (4 years' service) v Lindab Limited
An HGV driver who used a company fuel card for his personal vehicle and falsified time sheets was fairly dismissed. The tribunal rejected his claims of race discrimination and unfair dismissal.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Porter (2 months' service) v John Pye and Sons Ltd
A porter who resigned after two months, claiming constructive dismissal for reporting drug use and safety concerns, lost his case. The tribunal found the employer had taken reasonable steps and there was no fundamental breach of contract.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee v The Cultural Bureau of the Royal Saudi Embassy in London
A former employee of the Saudi embassy in London had most of his claims struck out due to state immunity, but his EU-law-based holiday pay claim was allowed to proceed.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Former employee v East Lindsey ITeC Ltd trading as First College
A tribunal struck out an unfair dismissal claim because the employee had less than two years' service and failed to comply with orders or pursue the case for over two years.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Warehouse operative (16 months' service) v GXO Logistics UK Limited
A warehouse operative who resigned after a disciplinary process over a battery fire failed to prove race discrimination, despite the tribunal finding administrative incompetence by the employer.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Board-level Health and Safety Director v Wilko Limited
A tribunal has refused to strike out a whistleblowing claim brought by a board-level health and safety director who alleged he was suspended and denied a bonus after raising concerns about storm risks.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Ambulance Care Assistant (3 years' service) v Medicmart Ambulance Services Limited
An ambulance care assistant who resigned claiming constructive dismissal over a training delay and contract variation has lost her case. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Frames Department Manager (5 years' service) v Scrivens Opticians and Hearing Care Ltd
A Frames Department Manager who resigned after a new Product Manager role was created lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer's actions were not a fundamental breach of contract.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Road marking linesmen v WJ Roadmarkings North Ltd
Two road marking linesmen were fairly dismissed after GPS tracking showed they used a company vehicle to do private work during paid hours. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Project Manager (1 year 8 months' service) v essDOCS EMEA LIMITED
A tribunal found that a manager sharing a picture provided in confidence during a grievance appeal amounted to direct sex discrimination. The claimant was awarded £2,331.98.
Partial · £2,332 · Jul 2023Partial£2,332Jul 2023Site manager (26 years' service) v Tithe Barn Club (Aldwick) Limited
A site manager with 26 years' service was unfairly dismissed for alleged gross misconduct after a breakdown in the relationship between the owner and his son. The tribunal awarded £51,785, including a 25% uplift for failing to follow the ACAS Code.
Won · £51,785 · Jul 2023Won£51,785Jul 2023Production operative v Jaguar Land Rover Limited
A production operative dismissed for gross misconduct after an NHS COVID-19 app self-isolation alert was found to be fairly dismissed. The tribunal ruled the employer's investigation and belief in fraud were reasonable.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee (6 years' service) v Short Richardson and Forth Limited In Voluntary Liquidation
A former employee with six years' service was awarded over £3,600 after their employer made 20 or more staff redundant without any consultation. The tribunal found a protective award of 90 days' pay was justified.
Partial · £3,618 · Jul 2023Partial£3,618Jul 2023Senior Vice-President, Digital Product and Technology (4 years' service) v Dplay Entertainment Ltd
A senior vice-president was unfairly dismissed after his employer refused to reschedule a final redundancy consultation meeting, instead sending a dismissal email when he couldn't attend due to his mother's medical appointment. The tribunal awarded £658.71 in compensation.
Partial · £659 · Jul 2023Partial£659Jul 2023Former employee v Surrey and Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust
Two former employees of Surrey and Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust had their unfair dismissal and discrimination claims struck out after repeatedly failing to provide details of their case, despite multiple extensions and a warning.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Highways Maintenance Operative (5 years' service) v Amey Services Ltd
A Highways Maintenance Operative was unfairly dismissed after admitting to stealing diesel, but the tribunal found the investigation and disciplinary process were procedurally flawed.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Field agent (self-employed) v 360Globalnet Ltd
A self-employed field agent who claimed he was dismissed for whistleblowing lost his case after the tribunal ruled he was a worker, not an employee, and that no protected disclosure had caused detriment.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Finance director (38 years' service) v Implex Consultants Ltd
A finance director with 38 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after taking confidential documents from a locked cupboard to help a family member in a legal dispute with his employer. The tribunal rejected his whistleblowing claims.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Purge and relight engineer (5 years' service) v Network Plus Services Limited
A purge and relight engineer with five years' service was unfairly dismissed after a dispute over whether he was told to return to a work site. The tribunal found the employer failed to consider the possibility of miscommunication and did not interview a key witness.
Won · Jul 2023Won—Jul 2023Part-time Operations Assistant (4 years' service) v Love My Human Ltd
A part-time Operations Assistant with Long Covid was unfairly dismissed when her employer decided to make her redundant before any consultation. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair but applied a 60% Polkey reduction.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Support worker (3 years' service) v Bridge Medical Solutions Limited
A support worker was dismissed by email within an hour of posting a comment on a staff WhatsApp group, after the client's parents threatened to remove the client. The tribunal upheld the dismissal as fair due to third-party pressure and futility of procedures.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Immigration Enforcement Officer (31 years' service) v Home Office
An Immigration Enforcement Officer with 31 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after carrying out unauthorised lookups on a Home Office database, including after a zero-tolerance policy was introduced. The tribunal found the employer's belief in misconduct was genuine and reasonable, despite procedural shortcomings.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee v RSPCA Clywd & Colwyn
A former employee of RSPCA Clywd & Colwyn has won an unfair dismissal claim, with the tribunal awarding £2,324.67 in compensation.
Won · £2,325 · Jul 2023Won£2,325Jul 2023Care home employee v Hilbre Care Ltd (in creditors voluntary liquidation)
A care home employee who was dismissed and subjected to detriments after making a public interest disclosure has been awarded £15,963.47 by the Liverpool Employment Tribunal.
Partial · £15,963 · Jul 2023Partial£15,963Jul 2023Material Flow Manager (4 years' service) v Games Workshop Limited
A Material Flow Manager who resigned after receiving a first written warning for misleading an employee about a promotion and back pay has lost his constructive unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Office Manager (5 years' service) v Astrea Academy Trust
A tribunal struck out an office manager's constructive dismissal claim against Astrea Academy Trust after she failed to provide additional information or a schedule of loss, and did not attend the hearing.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Former employee v Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust
A former employee's unfair dismissal and most disability discrimination claims were struck out after he presented his claim two days late, due to a misunderstanding of the time limit.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Dog Handler (2 years' service) v Global Support Services (UK) Ltd
A dog handler who secretly recorded managers and sent a threatening email was dismissed. The tribunal upheld some claims but found no sex discrimination or whistleblowing victimisation.
Partial · £7,857 · Jun 2023Partial£7,857Jun 2023Parish clerk v Tydd St Mary Parish Council
A parish clerk who resigned and claimed constructive dismissal lost her case because the tribunal found she made no public interest disclosures and no breach of contract by the council.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Senior Social Media Manager (2 years 7 months' service) v Herbalife Europe Limited
A tribunal struck out several race harassment and victimisation allegations from a senior social media manager against Herbalife Europe, ruling they were brought too late. Other claims will proceed to a final hearing.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Senior health care assistant (3 years' service) v Signature Senior Lifestyle Operations Limited
A senior care assistant who shouted at a resident and called her 'stupid', inadvertently recorded on a voicemail, was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected her unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Store manager (21 years' service) v Holland and Barratt Retail Limited
A tribunal has dismissed an unfair dismissal claim by a store manager with 21 years' service who was sacked for overbooking holidays and falsifying time records.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023IT support technician (3 years 6 months' service) v Birmingham City University
An employment tribunal struck out the entire claim of an IT support technician who called counsel 'a retard' and discussed evidence on Twitter during the hearing, ruling his conduct made a fair trial impossible.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Former employee v Holland and Barrett Retail Ltd
A former employee won her unfair and wrongful dismissal claims against Holland and Barrett, but an 80% reduction for contributory conduct cut her compensation to £3,407.
Partial · £3,407 · Jun 2023Partial£3,407Jun 2023Senior manager (6 years' service) v 221B Limited
A senior manager who was summarily dismissed after her solicitor demanded a £500,000 bonus has won her unfair dismissal claim, but the tribunal said she would have been fairly dismissed after a proper process.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Former operative (facilities management) v Ian Williams Ltd
A former operative who resigned after just five weeks with a new employer lost his constructive unfair dismissal claim but won £507 in notice pay after being told to leave immediately.
Partial · £507 · Jun 2023Partial£507Jun 2023Care coordinator (12 years' service) v Rotherham, Doncaster and South Humber NHS Foundation Trust
An employment tribunal ruled that a care coordinator with 12 years' service was disabled by anxiety and depression from August 2021, paving the way for her discrimination claims against Rotherham, Doncaster and South Humber NHS Foundation Trust.
Won · Jun 2023Won—Jun 2023Area sales manager (7 years' service) v Core Communications Retail Limited
An area sales manager with 7 years' service was fairly dismissed after admitting to logging visits that never happened and making cash sales. The tribunal found the employer's decision was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Learning Manager (12 years' service) v Delta Acadamies Trust
A learning manager with 12 years' service had her unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims thrown out by a tribunal because she presented them nearly a month late, despite being aware of the time limit.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Deputy Manager (6 years' service) v Cambian Asperger Syndrome Services Ltd
A deputy manager who refused the Covid-19 vaccine on religious and philosophical grounds was fairly dismissed when his employer had a legal duty to require vaccination. The tribunal ordered him to pay a deposit to continue his claims.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Health Care Assistant (7 years' service) v Guy’s & St Thomas NHS Foundation Trust
A healthcare assistant with 7 years' service was dismissed after 20 months' sick leave due to a work-related arm and neck injury. The tribunal found the NHS trust's decision was proportionate, balancing patient safety and staffing needs.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Part-time lecturer v De Montfort University
A part-time lecturer who waited over a year to bring an unfair dismissal claim after his employment ended due to right-to-work issues has had his case dismissed as out of time.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Sous-chef (2 years' service) v Humble Group Ltd
A sous-chef who resigned after being asked to do so by his employer while on sick leave has been allowed to bring his constructive dismissal and disability discrimination claims out of time.
Remitted · Jun 2023Remitted—Jun 2023Bus operations manager (4 years' service) v Rowgate Group Ltd and CE Jeatt & Sons Ltd
A bus operations manager was unfairly dismissed after recording a colleague dancing to 'The Stripper'. The employer conceded liability and was ordered to pay £52,190.47.
Won · £52,190 · Jun 2023Won£52,190Jun 2023Former employee v Aspinalls Club Limited t/a Crown London Aspinalls
A former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims against Aspinalls Club were struck out after repeated failures to provide required documents and respond to tribunal orders.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Army Reservist v Ministry of Defence
An Employment Tribunal has dismissed age discrimination, whistleblowing and unlawful deduction claims brought by a serving Army Reservist, ruling that the law excludes armed forces members from bringing such claims.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Former employee (cleaner) v Tame Cleaning & Maintenance Ltd
A former cleaner was unfairly dismissed by Tame Cleaning & Maintenance Ltd. The tribunal allowed her late claims because severe depression made it not reasonably practicable to file on time.
Partial · £7,621 · Jun 2023Partial£7,621Jun 2023Deputy Managing Director (15 years' service) v Phase II International Ltd
A deputy managing director with 15 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed misconduct process. The tribunal found the decision-maker had prejudged the outcome, but applied a 50% Polkey reduction.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Senior administrator/manager (17 years' service) v Solos Consultants Ltd
A senior administrator with 17 years' service was dismissed after a family feud made working relationships untenable. The tribunal upheld the unfair dismissal claim but found the reason for dismissal was potentially fair, though the process was flawed.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Former employee (Software and Solutions Developer, 3.5 years' service) v Fujitsu Services Limited
A tribunal found that Fujitsu Services Limited discriminated against a disabled employee by failing to conduct a stress risk assessment, requiring phone sickness reporting, and disclosing information to his mother without consent. The former software developer was awarded £21,572.
Partial · £21,572 · Jun 2023Partial£21,572Jun 2023Spray polisher (5 years' service) v Mowlem and Company (Manufacturing) Limited
A spray polisher with five years' service was unfairly dismissed after his employer refused his proposed phased return following bilateral hip replacements. The tribunal awarded £4,250 but rejected disability discrimination claims.
Partial · £4,250 · Jun 2023Partial£4,250Jun 2023Former employee v Gatwick Construction Limited
A former employee of Gatwick Construction Limited had their unfair dismissal claim thrown out because they had not worked there for two years. Their other claims for wrongful dismissal and unauthorised deductions also failed.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Service Engineer (9 years' service) v AMC XL Ltd
An employment tribunal dismissed a service engineer's claim for constructive unfair dismissal and disability discrimination after he resigned over a PPE dispute and a drug test he failed to complete.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Former employee v Tesco Stores Ltd
A former employee's claim for constructive dismissal and disability discrimination was struck out after she repeatedly failed to comply with tribunal orders to provide particulars of her allegations.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Former employee v Mihomecare Limited
A former care worker succeeded in her unfair dismissal claim against Mihomecare Limited, but the tribunal reduced her compensation to zero because of her own conduct and the likelihood she would have been dismissed anyway.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Warehouse operative (6 years' service) v Tempur UK Ltd
A warehouse operative who resigned after refusing to comply with face-covering and testing rules had his indirect discrimination and constructive dismissal claims struck out after failing to pay a deposit order.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Library volunteer (9 years' service) v Fallowfield Library & Community Resource Centre
A long-serving library volunteer who brought unfair dismissal and discrimination claims was unable to proceed because the tribunal found she was not an employee or worker. All claims were dismissed.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Procurement Support Manager v Thames Valley Housing Association Ltd and Metropolitan Housing Trust Ltd
A Procurement Support Manager dismissed during his probation period lost his claims of race discrimination and failure to make reasonable adjustments. The tribunal found no evidence that his Russian ethnic origin or undisclosed HIV status played any part in the decision.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Office Manager (3 years 7 months' service) v Main Group Services Ltd
An office manager with 3 years 7 months' service was unfairly dismissed after calling her managers 'dickheads' in jest during a heated meeting. The tribunal found the employer's subsequent disciplinary process was contrived and awarded £15,042.81.
Won · £15,043 · Jun 2023Won£15,043Jun 2023Accuracy Checking Pharmacy Technician (12 years' service) v Boots Management Services Ltd
A tribunal allowed a Boots pharmacy technician with 12 years' service to amend her claim to include unfair dismissal, finding the new claim was a relabelling of existing facts.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Senior financial assistant (35 years' service in local government) v Connah’s Quay Town Council
A senior financial assistant with 35 years' service in local government was told she lacked the two-year continuity needed for an ordinary unfair dismissal claim after just one month with a new council. The tribunal dismissed her argument that her contract preserved her previous service.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Personal Relationship Manager (9 years' service) v Lloyds Bank plc
A Personal Relationship Manager with nine years' service was fairly dismissed for deliberately coughing towards a colleague during the pandemic, breaching lone-working rules and lying to his manager. The tribunal rejected all claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Former employee v Sharps Bedrooms Limited
A former employee was unfairly dismissed by Sharps Bedrooms Limited, but received only £1,502.32 after the tribunal found he would have been dismissed anyway if a fair procedure had been followed.
Partial · £1,502 · Jun 2023Partial£1,502Jun 2023Behaviour Lead and Community Liaison (17 years' service) v Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council
A behaviour lead with 17 years' service was unfairly dismissed after her employer relied on outdated medical reports and failed to follow its own sickness procedure. The tribunal awarded £23,222, including £9,000 for injury to feelings.
Partial · £23,222 · Jun 2023Partial£23,222Jun 2023Contract worker (social worker) v ICON Clinical Research Limited
A contract social worker's claim that they were automatically unfairly dismissed for making protected disclosures has been struck out by the tribunal, which found it had no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Care worker (4 years' service) v GGN Limited t/a Golders Green Nursing
A care worker who arranged for a friend to help her look after a vulnerable client during lockdown was unfairly dismissed, but the tribunal reduced her compensation by 70% for the chance she would have been fairly dismissed anyway and by 60% for her own misconduct.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Former employee v Skins Laser Clinic Ltd
A former employee of Skins Laser Clinic Ltd won nearly £19,000 in compensation after the company failed to respond to her tribunal claim, leading to a default judgment for unfair dismissal and race discrimination.
Won · £18,769 · Jun 2023Won£18,769Jun 2023Deputy Chief Executive (12 years' service) v Alice (Relief of Poverty Advancement of Community)
A deputy chief executive with 12 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after claiming nursery fees from the charity she helped establish. The tribunal upheld the unfair dismissal claim but awarded £4,296 for wrongful dismissal and a defective written statement.
Partial · £4,296 · Jun 2023Partial£4,296Jun 2023Former employee v Intimates Lingerie LLP
A former employee who submitted her unfair dismissal claim nearly a year late has been allowed to proceed after the tribunal found she was reasonably ignorant of the correct procedure.
Won · £0 · Jun 2023Won£0Jun 2023Personal support worker (3 years' service) v Mr A Shakespeare
A personal support worker who was dismissed after 18 months' absence due to bowel cancer and a hernia has lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the dismissal was fair, and even if the procedure had been flawed, she would have been dismissed anyway.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Business Coordinator (NHS, 3 years' service) v Bedfordshire Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
A tribunal rejected claims of unfair dismissal and race discrimination by a Business Coordinator who refused a restructured role and went on sick leave. The dismissal for 'some other substantial reason' was fair.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Registered social worker v Trafford Council
A registered social worker who resigned and claimed constructive unfair dismissal after allegedly blowing the whistle has had his claim thrown out. The tribunal found no protected disclosure and no fundamental breach of contract, and ordered him to pay £2,700 in costs.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Accounts Administrator / Finance employee (6 years' service) v Innovation First International (UK) Limited
A tribunal refused to strike out an employer's response despite the claimant's allegations of unreasonable conduct, allowing the case to proceed to a full hearing.
Partial · £951 · Jun 2023Partial£951Jun 2023UNISON branch secretary (full-time release since 1998) v Kirklees Council
A UNISON branch secretary with 49 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after two complaints of bullying and threatening behaviour. The tribunal rejected his claim that he was targeted for trade union activities.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023High value packer (1 year 5 months' service) v Jewellery Quarter Bullion Limited
A high value packer who raised concerns about a colleague's mental health was dismissed for performance issues. The tribunal found the protected disclosure was not the principal reason for dismissal, and the claim was dismissed.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Agency worker (NHS trust placement) v MerseyCare NHS Foundation Trust
An agency worker who spent nearly three years at an NHS trust was unable to bring an unfair dismissal claim because the tribunal found no implied employment contract existed. The claim was dismissed.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Warehouse operative (agency worker) v Taylor Made Golf Limited
A warehouse operative who worked via an agency was not an employee of Taylor Made Golf, but her pregnancy discrimination claim as a contract worker was allowed to proceed despite being nearly a year late.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Beauty Consultant (2 weeks' service) v Elle Beauty Limited t/a Elevatione Time Stops London
A beauty consultant who was dismissed by WhatsApp after just 10 days lost her race discrimination claim but won £382 for unpaid training days and underpayment.
Partial · £382 · Jun 2023Partial£382Jun 2023Bus driver (13 years' service) v Arriva London North Limited t/a Arriva London
A bus driver with 13 years' service was dismissed after being off sick for over a year. The tribunal refused to strike out her remaining claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Civil servant (Higher Officer, Commercial Directorate, HMRC) v HM Revenue and Customs
A long-serving HMRC civil servant who covertly recorded meetings with his manager had his unfair dismissal and whistleblowing claims dismissed after the tribunal found a fair trial was impossible.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Maths teacher (15 years' service) v Ernest Bevin College and London Borough of Wandsworth
A tribunal struck out a maths teacher's unfair dismissal and age discrimination claims after he filed 18 days late and failed to pay a £500 deposit for the weak discrimination claim.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Cabin crew and purser (35 years' service) v British Airways plc
An employment tribunal has upheld British Airways' decision to dismiss a cabin crew member with 35 years' service for gross misconduct after she made racist comments about a doctor and left hospital while self-isolating with suspected COVID-19.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Accounts Manager (15 years' service) v Northern Belle Limited
An accounts manager with 15 years' service was unfairly dismissed when her employer failed to offer her a part-time role that became available during her notice period. The tribunal awarded £250 for loss of statutory rights.
Won · £250 · Jun 2023Won£250Jun 2023Former employee v Riddwood Consulting Engineers Ltd (in voluntary liquidation)
A former employee who made a protected disclosure was unfairly dismissed and suffered detriment. The tribunal awarded over £6,300, including £5,000 for injury to feelings.
Won · £6,302 · Jun 2023Won£6,302Jun 2023Welfare Caseworker (12 years' service) v Luton Irish Forum
A welfare caseworker with 12 years' service lost her claim for detriment and constructive dismissal after the tribunal found that disciplinary proceedings were prompted by her threatening behaviour, not by her protected disclosures.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Former employee v North Rutland Health Partnership
A former employee who withdrew claims against two respondents at a case management hearing failed to have the dismissal judgment reconsidered. The tribunal also dismissed her unfair dismissal claim for lack of jurisdiction but allowed disability discrimination claims to proceed out of time.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Reablement Support Assistant (13 years' service) v Bristol City Council
A Reablement Support Assistant with 13 years' service was dismissed for conduct after a disciplinary hearing she could not attend because the Teams link was sent to the wrong email address. The tribunal found the dismissal substantively fair but procedurally unfair, though no compensation was awarded.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Former employee v Xiamen Ason Products Limited
A former employee who was dismissed without notice by Xiamen Ason Products Limited has been awarded £15,495.72 for breach of contract and failure to provide a written statement of particulars.
Partial · £15,496 · Jun 2023Partial£15,496Jun 2023Golf course manager (5 years' service) v Morecambe Golf Club Limited
A golf course manager who resigned after being called a 'dickhead' by a board member and feeling undermined by the new captain has lost his constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Hotel manager (4 years' service) v Delfino Logic Limited
A tribunal dismissed a hotel manager's claims for unfair dismissal, disability discrimination and unpaid wages because they were presented over a month late. The judge found that his ADHD did not prevent him from bringing the claim on time.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Retail Store Manager (16 years' service) v EE Limited
A retail store manager with 16 years' service was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct after the employer failed to obtain medical advice about her depression and anxiety. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair and wrongful, with compensation reduced by 20% for Polkey and 50% for contributory conduct.
Won · Jun 2023Won—Jun 2023Former employee v ABM Facility Services UK Ltd
An employment tribunal struck out an unfair dismissal claim after the claimant failed to prepare for two hearings and made a last-minute adjournment application based on a minor surgery. The claimant was also ordered to pay £1,000 in costs.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Former employees v TAL Precision Engineering Ltd
TAL Precision Engineering Ltd failed to pay wages for three months, leading to successful claims for unpaid wages, redundancy pay, and constructive unfair dismissal. The tribunal also applied a 25% ACAS uplift for failing to follow statutory procedures.
Won · Jun 2023Won—Jun 2023Warehouse operative and union convener (5 years' service) v DHL Services Ltd
A warehouse operative and union convener was fairly dismissed after falsely claiming to be a union member's representative when calling the employer's solicitors. The tribunal rejected his claims of automatic and ordinary unfair dismissal.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Senior care assistant (18 years' service) v Ascot Care Ltd
A senior care assistant with 18 years' service was fairly dismissed after refusing to complete the government's self-certification form for a medical exemption from Covid-19 vaccination. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal and philosophical belief discrimination.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Deputy Team Manager (social worker, 8 years' service) v East London NHS Foundation Trust
A social worker who resigned claiming constructive dismissal had all her claims struck out after presenting them two weeks late. The tribunal refused amendments and found no reasonable excuse for the delay.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Online Editor (6 years' service) v Al Quds Al-Arabi Publishing & Advertising
An online editor who was paid a monthly retainer and subject to editorial control has been found to be an employee and unfairly dismissed. The tribunal awarded £32,020.80 in compensation.
Won · £32,021 · Jun 2023Won£32,021Jun 2023Security guard (5 years' service) v Embassy of the Kingdom of Bahrain
A security guard with five years' service was dismissed just before his role was outsourced. The tribunal found a TUPE transfer occurred and his dismissal was automatically unfair.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Bus driver (6 years' service) v Abellio London Limited
A bus driver with six years' service was unfairly dismissed while on long-term sick leave for mental ill health. The tribunal awarded £19,580.63 in compensation, including underpaid notice and holiday pay.
Won · £19,581 · Jun 2023Won£19,581Jun 2023Senior Mobility Specialist (14 months' service) v Lets Deel Ltd
A Senior Mobility Specialist who resigned after allegedly being pressured to take on an authorising officer role failed to win interim relief for automatic unfair dismissal. The tribunal found she did not have a 'pretty good chance' of success.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Night Senior Carer (2 years 8 months' service) v Barchester Healthcare Ltd
A night senior carer with over 40 years' experience was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after moving an unresponsive resident before calling 999, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Overseas Detainee Custody Officer (9 years' service) v Mitie Care and Custody Limited
An overseas detainee custody officer who was dismissed after four years of sickness absence had his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims rejected because he presented them too late, despite the tribunal accepting he had a good reason for the initial delay.
Dismissed · £5,499 · Jun 2023Dismissed£5,499Jun 2023Part-time Line Driver (4 years' service) v Manheim Limited
An employment tribunal dismissed all discrimination claims brought by a part-time Line Driver with 4 years' service against Manheim Limited, finding they were brought too late and lacked merit. The unfair dismissal claim was withdrawn.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Former employee (commission-based sales role) v Sera Neon Ltd
A former sales employee's claim for unpaid commission was struck out after she failed to comply with tribunal orders and admitted she had no legal argument to overcome a contractual discretion clause. The tribunal also ordered her to pay £10,000 in costs.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Finance Manager (cruise ship) v Carnival plc (t/a "Carnival UK")
A finance manager who worked on Carnival cruise ships for five years had his unfair dismissal and whistleblowing claims thrown out because his legal employer was a separate Bermuda-based entity, not Carnival plc. The tribunal also found the claims were out of time.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Former employee v Local Plumbers We Care Limited
A former employee was automatically unfairly dismissed after raising health and safety concerns. The tribunal awarded £7,947 including a 25% ACAS uplift after the employer failed to attend the hearing.
Won · £7,947 · Jun 2023Won£7,947Jun 2023Cleaner v Bidvest Noonan (UK) Limited
A cleaner who received a final written warning but was not dismissed brought an unfair dismissal claim 65 days out of time. The tribunal found no dismissal occurred and refused to extend the deadline.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Customer Assistant (8 years' service) v Sainsbury's Supermarkets Limited
A customer assistant with eight years' service who asked to be dismissed on capability grounds lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found Sainsbury's acted reasonably.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Post Office Counter Clerk (3 years' service) v ZCO Ltd
A Post Office counter clerk who refused a split-shift offer after his hours were cut due to COVID-19 has lost his claim for unauthorised deductions. The tribunal held that the employer's contractual mobility and short-time working clauses authorised the reduction.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Payroll clerk/Bookkeeper (10 years' service) v Philips Accountants (Southgate) Ltd
A payroll clerk with a decade of service was dismissed on the same day an incident occurred, without any investigation or prior warnings. The tribunal awarded £10,384.50 for unfair and wrongful dismissal.
Won · £10,385 · Jun 2023Won£10,385Jun 2023Former employee v Euroselect
A former employee's pregnancy discrimination and unfair dismissal claim was thrown out because she lodged her claim without an Acas early conciliation certificate. The tribunal ruled it had no jurisdiction.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Head of Information Systems (13 years' service) v HML Holdings plc
A tribunal dismissed claims of unfair dismissal and sex discrimination by a Head of Information Systems made redundant after a restructure. She was awarded £1,013 for untaken holiday.
Lost · £1,013 · Jun 2023Lost£1,013Jun 2023Former employee v Currys Group Ltd
An unfair dismissal claim against Currys Group Ltd has been struck out after the former employee failed to comply with case management orders, did not contact the tribunal or employer for over four months, and did not attend the hearing.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Former employee v ATL Fulfilment Limited
A former employee's claims for constructive dismissal, disability discrimination and protected disclosure detriment were struck out after she failed to comply with an Unless Order requiring further details of her complaints.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Transport Team Manager (15 years' service) v The Co-operative Group Limited
A Transport Team Manager with 15 years' service resigned after a series of disputes over performance grading and rota changes. The tribunal dismissed his constructive unfair dismissal claim, finding he had affirmed the contract by continuing to work after deciding to leave.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Customer Advisor (72 years old, 5 years' service) v B & Q Limited
A 72-year-old B&Q employee resigned after receiving his rota on the same day he was due to work. The tribunal dismissed his claims of constructive unfair dismissal, age discrimination, and victimisation.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Senior mental health practitioner (26 years' service) v Greater Manchester Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust
A senior mental health practitioner with 26 years' service was constructively dismissed after the trust took nine months to investigate a minor disciplinary matter and failed to handle his grievance promptly. The tribunal found a repudiatory breach of trust and confidence.
Won · Jun 2023Won—Jun 2023Midwife (3 years' service) v York & Scarborough Teaching Hospitals
A midwife with three years' service was constructively dismissed after her employer's failure to properly investigate her bullying complaint. The tribunal awarded £1,717, including an ACAS uplift.
Won · £1,717 · Jun 2023Won£1,717Jun 2023Social Media and Marketing Officer (2 years' service) v Beyond Reflections
A social media officer was made redundant without any prior consultation, and the tribunal found the dismissal procedurally unfair, awarding £640 compensation.
Won · £640 · Jun 2023Won£640Jun 2023Car Body Repairer (4 years 5 months' service) v Car Perfection Carcare Ltd
A car body repairer who reported his employer's broken toilet to the council was told he was sacked. The tribunal awarded him £32,738 for automatic unfair dismissal.
Won · £32,738 · Jun 2023Won£32,738Jun 2023Trainee Nursing Associate (2 years' service) v North West Anglia NHS Foundation Trust
A trainee nursing associate was unfairly dismissed after a disciplinary hearing went ahead while she was signed off sick following her mother's death. The tribunal found the process unfair but awarded no compensation, ruling she would have been dismissed anyway.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Former employee v Société Air France
A former employee's claims for associative race discrimination, constructive unfair dismissal, age discrimination and victimisation were struck out or made subject to a deposit order after the tribunal found they had no reasonable prospects of success.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Sales manager (14 months' service) v Fugro GB Marine Limited
A sales manager who resigned after raising concerns about standard contractual terms lost his unfair dismissal claim when the tribunal found his disclosures were not protected.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Former employee v Just Trays Ltd
A former employee who brought constructive unfair dismissal and other claims against Just Trays Ltd had their case dismissed after failing to attend the final hearing or comply with case management orders.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Food Service Coach (3 years 8 months' service) v Activate Learning
A food service coach who resigned citing racist comments and harassment lost her constructive dismissal and discrimination claims after the tribunal found she had affirmed her contract by continuing to work for 20 months.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Former employee v Footballco Media Ltd
A former employee who resigned claiming constructive dismissal had his claim dismissed because it was filed 12 days late, after his solicitors failed to see the ACAS certificate. The tribunal refused to extend the time limit.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Team Supervisor (17 years' service) v Wilko Ltd
A tribunal found that Wilko Ltd unfairly dismissed a long-serving team supervisor for smoking on company property, but reduced compensation by 50% due to her admitting the misconduct.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Radio Presenter (3 years 9 months' service) v British Broadcasting Corporation
A BBC radio presenter who resigned after a colleague's 'leprechaun' tweet saw all his claims thrown out because he filed his tribunal claim too late, despite receiving incorrect legal advice.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Former employee (6 years' service) v British Airways plc
A former British Airways employee had his unfair dismissal claim thrown out after he failed to attend the final hearing, citing a new job and personal issues. The tribunal also refused the airline's application for costs.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Bid Architect (9 months' service) v ONNEC Group UK Limited
A bid architect with nine months' service claimed his redundancy was a sham to cover up a protected disclosure. The tribunal refused interim relief, finding it unlikely that the principal reason for dismissal was whistleblowing.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Support worker (15-16 years' service) v Future Directions CIC
A support worker who resigned after raising COVID-19 PPE concerns lost her constructive dismissal and whistleblowing claims. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Facilities Maintenance Engineer (6 years' service) v Sefton Metropolitan Borough Council
A facilities maintenance engineer resigned after repeated delays in his capability and grievance processes. The tribunal found a cumulative breach of trust and confidence and awarded £36,896.
Won · £36,896 · Jun 2023Won£36,896Jun 2023Referrals Coordinator (6 years' service) v Moorfields Eye Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
A referrals coordinator resigned claiming constructive unfair dismissal and race discrimination, but the tribunal found no evidence that management style, appraisal grading, or grievance handling were linked to race.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Paramedic (29 years' service) v North East Ambulance Service NHS Foundation Trust
A paramedic with nearly three decades of service was fairly dismissed on capability grounds after a thorough absence management process, the tribunal has ruled. All claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination were dismissed.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Operator in Facilities Management (4 years' service) v Derby City Council
An operator at Derby City Council had her pregnancy discrimination and harassment claims dismissed because they were brought too late, despite the tribunal finding some treatment was unfavourable.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Shift manager (2 years' service) v Lidl Great Britain Limited
A shift manager at Lidl was sexually harassed by a deputy store manager, paid less than male colleagues, and forced to resign. The tribunal awarded £50,884.62.
Partial · £50,885 · Jun 2023Partial£50,885Jun 2023Solicitor (consultant) v Paula Felton t/a Felton Solicitors
A solicitor who alleged his firm was overbilling a client lost his whistleblowing detriment claim. The tribunal found the firm's reasons for ending his contract were genuine and unrelated to his disclosures.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Agency healthcare assistant (agency worker) v Secretary of State for Justice
An agency healthcare assistant's claims against the Secretary of State for Justice were dismissed after the tribunal found it had no jurisdiction over her unfair dismissal claim and her discrimination claims were presented two days late.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Apprentice gas fitter (18 years old, 14 months' service) v DW Gas Services Limited
An 18-year-old apprentice gas fitter has been awarded £5,613 after his employer failed to pay his contractual wages, dismissed him without notice, and never provided written terms or pay statements.
Won · £5,613 · Jun 2023Won£5,613Jun 2023Audit Assistant Manager (2 years' service) v Grant Thornton Business Services
An Audit Assistant Manager with 2 years' service who resigned after being placed on a performance improvement plan has lost his claims of constructive unfair dismissal, race discrimination and whistleblowing detriment. The tribunal found the employer had reasonable cause for its actions.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Carer (2 years 11 months' service) v Paul Jones
A carer who sent a WhatsApp message saying 'I'm done' after a disagreement about self-isolation and pay has lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found no fundamental breach of contract by her employer.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Cleaner (12 years' service) v Whipcoot Developments Limited and Whipcott Getaways Limited
A cleaner with 12 years' service was dismissed on the day her employment transferred to a new company. The tribunal found the dismissal automatically unfair and awarded £3,025.24, including an uplift for ignoring her grievance.
Won · £3,025 · Jun 2023Won£3,025Jun 2023Project Manager (18 months' service) v Lead Digital Limited
A project manager who was subjected to a sexually explicit comment and then dismissed by redundancy won £35,300 after her employer failed to defend the claim. The tribunal awarded £20,000 for injury to feelings and £15,300 for loss of earnings.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Dental receptionist (7 years 5 months' service) v Oasis Dental Care Limited
A dental receptionist with over seven years' service was fairly dismissed after a lengthy performance improvement process. The tribunal found the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Mobile field support driver (10 months' service) v Vorboss Limited
A tribunal ordered a mobile field support driver to pay a £20 deposit for each of her eight sex and race discrimination allegations, finding they had little reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Director and shareholder (co-founder) v Capital Computer Care Ltd
A director and 45% shareholder who received a fixed monthly PAYE payment for over 30 years was found not to be an employee or worker. The tribunal ruled it had no jurisdiction over his unfair dismissal claim, but his age discrimination claim can proceed as an office holder.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Team leader (5 years' service) v CPSL MIND
A tribunal ruled that a team leader with anxiety and depression was disabled under the Equality Act, even though she managed her condition through self-help and avoided regular doctor visits.
Won · Jun 2023Won—Jun 2023Operations and Control Manager (11 years' service) v Santander UK PLC
An operations manager with 11 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed investigation into financial irregularities, but the tribunal awarded no compensation because a fair dismissal would have occurred anyway.
Won · £0 · Jun 2023Won£0Jun 2023Project Coordinator (12 years' service) v London Borough of Southwark
A project coordinator with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed for failing to declare property ownership on a housing application and providing false information about his brother. The tribunal also dismissed his whistleblowing claim and ordered him to pay £5,000 in costs.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Respiratory Research Nurse (Band 6, 3 years 9 months' service) v Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
A respiratory research nurse was unfairly dismissed when her fixed-term contract was not renewed due to financial deficits. The tribunal awarded £11,754 after finding a 50% chance she would have been dismissed anyway.
Partial · £11,754 · Jun 2023Partial£11,754Jun 2023Customer Service Advisor (2 months' service) v Ascensos Limited
A tribunal ruled that a customer service advisor who worked for only two months was not disabled under the Equality Act, dismissing her disability discrimination claims against Ascensos Limited.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Non-practising solicitor v Solicitors Regulation Authority Limited
A non-practising solicitor failed to prove disability and had his discrimination and victimisation claims against the Solicitors Regulation Authority dismissed after the tribunal found it lacked jurisdiction over most allegations.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Warehouse operative (9 years' service) v Fibreline Ltd
A Leeds tribunal dismissed claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination brought by a warehouse operative with chronic back pain, finding that the employer's consultation and medical evidence were reasonable.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Leading Project Geophysicist (4 years' service) v Petrotrace Limited
A 62-year-old Leading Project Geophysicist was unfairly dismissed and subjected to age discrimination after the company's majority shareholder repeatedly called for his replacement with younger employees. The Reading tribunal awarded £340,212.80.
Won · £340,213 · Jun 2023Won£340,213Jun 2023Administrator (10 years' service) v Anglo Israel Association
An employment tribunal has ruled that a small charity's decision to make a long-serving administrator redundant was fair, even though the consultation process was flawed. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Customer service advisor (7 years' service) v Dermalogica UK Limited
A customer service advisor with 7 years' service was fairly dismissed for posting critical comments about her employer on Facebook during the first COVID-19 lockdown. The tribunal found the employer's decision fell within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Accounts and Administrative Assistant (16 years' service) v G Moore Haulage Limited
A tribunal has dismissed claims of unfair dismissal, unlawful deductions, and breach of contract brought by an accounts assistant who resigned through her father and received her P45 without contacting her employer for over two months.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Field Assessor (10 years' service) v Vibrant Energy Matters Ltd
A field assessor with 10 years' service who raised concerns about returning to work during the pandemic has won a victimisation claim against Vibrant Energy Matters Ltd. The tribunal found the company failed to properly handle her second grievance.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Former employee (head chef) v Queens Hospitality Limited
A head chef who was disciplined and dismissed after making a protected equality act complaint has won her victimisation claim. The tribunal also upheld claims for breach of contract and unlawful deduction from wages.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Warehouse picker / Distribution Depot Operative (9 years' service) v Muller UK & Ireland Group T/A Muller Milk and Ingredients
A warehouse picker with nine years' service was fairly dismissed for lifting an empty trolley to chest height as an act of horseplay. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision, finding it within the band of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Managing Director (8 years' service) v Summit Chairs Limited
A tribunal has dismissed claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination brought by a managing director with 8 years' service who was made redundant during the COVID-19 pandemic. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Customer delivery driver (18 years' service) v Tesco Stores Limited
A Tesco delivery driver with 18 years' service was dismissed for failing to attend meetings while on sick leave. The tribunal upheld the dismissal as fair but ordered Tesco to pay £1,398.60 in unpaid notice pay.
Partial · £1,399 · Jun 2023Partial£1,399Jun 2023Operations manager (14 years' service) v V-Tech Ltd
An operations manager with 14 years' service was fairly dismissed when her role became redundant after the business automated processes and hired a head of operations. The tribunal rejected her unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Senior Quantity Surveyor (6 years' service) v NGE Contracting Limited
A senior quantity surveyor with six years' service was unfairly dismissed after his employer called it redundancy but the tribunal found the real reason was conduct or capability. He was awarded £38,225.
Partial · £38,225 · Jun 2023Partial£38,225Jun 2023Sales and Reservations Agent (4 years' service) v Turkish Airlines
A sales agent who photographed a colleague's email and sent it to her husband was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the Reading Employment Tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Former employee v Real Coffee Bag Company Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Real Coffee Bag Company Limited was struck out because she had not worked there long enough. The tribunal also dismissed her other claims after she failed to attend the hearing.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Assistant Service Manager (3 years' service) v BaxterStorey Limited
A tribunal has rejected a constructive unfair dismissal claim from an assistant service manager who resigned after working up to 12-hour days, finding the employer did not require or expect the excessive hours.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Former employee v Chartwell Salon Supply Limited (in compulsory liquidation)
A former employee of Chartwell Salon Supply Limited, which went into compulsory liquidation, has been awarded £10,487 after being dismissed without notice. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair and ordered payment for notice, holiday pay and unpaid wages.
Won · £10,488 · Jun 2023Won£10,488Jun 2023Night shift worker (5 years' service) v Travelodge Hotels Limited
A Travelodge night shift worker of Asian Pakistani ethnicity was awarded £5,705 after the tribunal found the hotel chain failed to investigate his complaint about being sworn at by a manager, amounting to race discrimination.
Partial · £5,706 · Jun 2023Partial£5,706Jun 2023Part 1 Architectural Assistant (4 years' service) v Perpetua in Perpetuum Ltd
A Part 1 Architectural Assistant who resigned after securing a promotion and a new job failed to prove constructive unfair dismissal or race discrimination. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence or less favourable treatment.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Car park enforcement officer (5 years' service) v Salisbury NHS Foundation Trust
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a car park enforcement officer who had been absent for 1,163 days out of 1,992 due to bipolar disorder, finding the NHS trust acted reasonably.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Call handler (14 months' service) v C M Community Care Services Limited
A call handler who resigned after being asked to leave the office during a heated argument lost her claims of constructive dismissal and race discrimination. The tribunal found no dismissal or discrimination.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Deputy manager of a childcare setting (3 years' service) v Lollyday Childcare and Education Services Limited
A deputy manager who resigned after a series of small underpayments has lost her constructive dismissal claim, but won £140 for unpaid wages.
Partial · £140 · Jun 2023Partial£140Jun 2023Former employee v Teleperformance Ltd
A tribunal dismissed all claims from a former Teleperformance Ltd employee because they were presented too late and the claimant did not attend the final hearing or provide any explanation for the delay.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023General Manager (6 years' service) v Mitchells & Butlers Retail Ltd
A tribunal upheld the dismissal of a general manager who stayed drinking after the 10pm COVID curfew and misused staff discounts, but awarded £2,311.72 for unlawful deductions from wages.
Partial · £2,312 · Jun 2023Partial£2,312Jun 2023Community Phlebotomist (11 years' service) v St Helens and Knowsley Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust
An employment tribunal has ruled that St Helens and Knowsley Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust fairly dismissed a community phlebotomist with 11 years' service due to her poor attendance record. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Lecturer in Physiotherapy (probationary period) v Cardiff University
A physiotherapy lecturer who was dismissed during her probationary period for failing a Performance Improvement Plan has lost her claims of unfair dismissal, discrimination, and victimisation against Cardiff University.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Senior Supervisor (3.5 years' service) v Plaza Premium Lounge (UK) Limited
A Senior Supervisor with 3.5 years' service was unfairly dismissed when his employer re-did his performance appraisal without consulting him, then failed to provide evidence of the appeal process. The tribunal awarded £16,211.91.
Won · £16,212 · Jun 2023Won£16,212Jun 2023Former employees (21 claimants) v PARC (Essex) Limited
A tribunal awarded protective awards, redundancy pay, and unpaid wages to 21 former employees of PARC (Essex) Limited after the company ceased operations without any consultation or notice.
Won · Jun 2023Won—Jun 2023Former employee v Whittington Health NHS Trust
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after he deliberately ignored tribunal orders and refused to communicate with his employer, Whittington Health NHS Trust.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Line operator (4 years 8 months' service) v Nestle UK Limited
A line operator with 4 years 8 months' service who resigned after being told a transfer to Halifax could not be guaranteed within 3-4 weeks has lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim against Nestle UK Limited.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Former employees of a garden centre v Adrian Hall Ltd (in Creditors Voluntary Liquidation)
Four employees of Adrian Hall Ltd were unfairly dismissed when the garden centre closed without any consultation. The tribunal awarded £500 each for loss of continuity.
Won · £500 · Jun 2023Won£500Jun 2023Support worker (3 years' service) v Smile Foster Care Limited
A support worker who resigned after her employer rejected her grievance without a meeting has won her constructive unfair dismissal claim, receiving £3,495.67.
Partial · £3,496 · Jun 2023Partial£3,496Jun 2023Former employee v Katie Hillier Limited
A former employee on maternity leave was unfairly dismissed and denied two months' contractual notice. The tribunal awarded £7,229.68 including injury to feelings and corrected a miscalculation on reconsideration.
Partial · £7,230 · Jun 2023Partial£7,230Jun 2023Book-keeper and administrator (5 years' service) v Jewellery Validation Services Ltd
A book-keeper and administrator was unfairly dismissed after her employer used redundancy as a pretext to end her employment following the breakdown of divorce settlement negotiations. The tribunal awarded £8,922.50.
Partial · £8,923 · Jun 2023Partial£8,923Jun 2023Sports Club Managers (5 years' service) v Ilford Sports Club Limited
Two joint managers of a sports club were unfairly dismissed when they were made redundant without any consultation, despite the club's dire financial situation. The tribunal also found they were owed unpaid wages and holiday pay.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Senior driver (18 years' service) v The Embassy of the United Arab Emirates
An employment tribunal dismissed claims of unfair dismissal and racial harassment from two former employees of the UAE Embassy, finding that their discrimination complaints were brought too late and that a redundancy selection based on performance was not tainted by race.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Veterinary receptionist (8 years' service) v Hills Park Veterinary Group Ltd.
An employment tribunal found that a veterinary receptionist with 8 years' service was constructively and unfairly dismissed after enduring a series of sex-related comments and unwanted physical contact from a colleague. The tribunal upheld claims of harassment and sex discrimination.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Senior Sales Ledger Clerk (44 years' service) v Future Publishing Limited
A senior sales ledger clerk who resigned after 44 years, then claimed constructive dismissal due to workload, lost her case. The tribunal found she had already decided to retire and the workload did not drive her resignation.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Branch manager (6 years' service) v Sequence (UK) Limited
A branch manager who resigned claiming constructive dismissal and race discrimination has had all his claims dismissed by an employment tribunal, which also ordered him to repay £17,727.86 in overpaid commission.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Collection and Delivery Driver (3 years' service) v DPD Group UK Limited
A collection and delivery driver with an umbilical hernia and muscle condition was fairly dismissed on capability grounds after his employer exhausted temporary adjustments. The tribunal found DPD Group UK Limited acted reasonably.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Postal worker (2 years' service) v Angard Staffing Solutions Ltd and Royal Mail Group Ltd
A postal worker with multiple sclerosis who swore at a colleague after being asked about his blue badge was fairly dismissed for abusive conduct, the tribunal ruled.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Lead Referral Coordinator (3 years 8 months' service) v Berkshire Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust
A tribunal dismissed all claims by a Lead Referral Coordinator who resigned and alleged constructive dismissal and detriment for raising patient safety concerns at Berkshire Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Accounts and Sales Manager (5 years' service) v Eden Horticulture Ltd
A tribunal has ruled that an accounts and sales manager's anxiety was a disability under the Equality Act, and refused the employer's attempt to strike out the claim.
Remitted · Jun 2023Remitted—Jun 2023Border Force Officer (3 years' service) v Home Office (Border Force (UK))
A Border Force officer with three years' service was fairly dismissed after shouting at managers while under a live final written warning. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal and discrimination.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Care worker (2 years' service) v GP Homecare Ltd t/a Radis Community Care
A care worker who resigned in September 2021 but did not bring her claim until May 2022 had her unfair dismissal and discrimination claims thrown out by the Birmingham tribunal as out of time.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Maintenance Officer (4.5 months' service) v Upwards Care Solutions
A maintenance officer with less than two years' service claimed he was automatically unfairly dismissed for raising fire door safety concerns. The tribunal found the real reason was capability and conduct, and dismissed the claim.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Rebuild Repair Engineer (3 years' service) v Finning (UK) Limited
A Rebuild Repair Engineer was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after improvising a complex lift without proper equipment or training, breaching the company's Lifesaving Rules. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Former employee (7 years' service) v Monster Energy Europe Ltd
A former employee's constructive unfair dismissal and discrimination claims were dismissed because they were presented 5 days late, with no medical evidence covering the relevant period.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Sales Advisor (3 years 9 months' service) v EE Ltd
A sales advisor who resigned after alleging fraud and harassment lost her constructive dismissal and whistleblowing claims. The tribunal found no fundamental breach of contract, and most detriment claims were out of time.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Former employee (34 years' service) v Ministry of Defence
A former Ministry of Defence employee with 34 years' service had his second unfair dismissal claim struck out for being substantially the same as a 2015 claim he withdrew, and for paying a deposit late.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023In-store service advisor (15 years' service) v Currys Group Limited
An in-store service advisor with 15 years' service resigned claiming constructive unfair dismissal after a disciplinary warning and grievance process. The tribunal found no fundamental breach of trust and confidence, and the claim was dismissed.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Funeral service operative (5 years' service) v R Banks & Son Funerals Limited
A funeral service operative with ulcerative colitis lost his constructive unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims after the tribunal found no fundamental breach of contract or discrimination.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Commercial Bodywork Engineer (3 years' service) v Solomon Commercials Ltd
A commercial bodywork engineer who removed a piece of GRP without checking his surroundings, causing a colleague to suffer a fractured orbital bone, was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal found the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023HGV Driver (17 years' service) v Hopkinson Waste Management Limited
A default judgment for unfair dismissal was revoked after the employer argued it had informally requested an extension. The case will now proceed to a full hearing.
Remitted · May 2023Remitted—May 2023Postal worker (Operational Postal Grade) v Royal Mail Group Limited
A postal worker who relied on his trade union's incorrect advice about the time limit for bringing an unfair dismissal claim had his case struck out as out of time. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for him to have presented the claim within the three-month window.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Marex Financial
A former employee was fairly dismissed after entering his workplace out of hours despite a final written warning. A Teams chat showing he planned to evade security was key evidence. The tribunal dismissed his unfair dismissal claim and refused the employer's costs application.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Warehouse operative (7 months' service) v Amazon UK Services Ltd
A warehouse operative who resigned in a phone call but later claimed he had withdrawn his resignation had his unfair dismissal claim struck out. The tribunal found his words were unambiguous and the resignation stood.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Human Resources Advisor (5 years' service) v Southport & Ormskirk NHS Trust
A tribunal found that an NHS Trust unfairly dismissed a Human Resources Advisor who raised concerns about misuse of COVID-19 funds, but awarded only £12,606 after ruling she would have been dismissed anyway.
Partial · £12,606 · May 2023Partial£12,606May 2023Apprentice ground worker (9 months' service) v Morgan Sindall Construction Infrastructure Ltd
An apprentice ground worker with 9 months' service was wrongfully dismissed for misconduct, but the tribunal limited his damages to 10 days' pay because he would have been made redundant within weeks.
Partial · £428 · May 2023Partial£428May 2023Transport Manager (8 years' service) v Polish Village Bread Limited
A transport manager who was summarily dismissed for sending a cancellation email using his boss's name has won his unfair dismissal claim after the tribunal found the employer fabricated the reason. The case settled for £15,000.
Settled · £15,000 · May 2023Settled£15,000May 2023Service colleague (15 years' service) v Asda Stores Ltd
A service colleague with 15 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after making unsubstantiated race discrimination allegations. The tribunal rejected claims of automatic unfair dismissal and victimisation.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023TSU Admin Assistant Support Worker (4 years' service) v University of the West of England
An employment tribunal has dismissed all claims brought by a support worker against the University of the West of England, finding that his dismissal following the expiry of a fixed-term contract and an irretrievable breakdown in the working relationship was fair.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Supply teacher (6 years' service) v Conwy County Borough Council and The Governing Body of Ysgol Nant y Groes
A tribunal dismissed claims for unfair and wrongful dismissal brought by a supply teacher whose role ended when a permanent teacher was appointed. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee (fixed-term contract worker) v University of the West of England
A former fixed-term contract worker lost his whistleblowing detriment claim after presenting it nearly a year late. The tribunal also dismissed all other claims of unfair dismissal and discrimination.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Support worker (fixed-term contracts) v University of the West of England
A support worker who claimed his dismissal was automatically unfair for whistleblowing lost his case after the tribunal found no link between his disclosures and the end of his fixed-term contract.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Nursery Nurse (3 years 10 months' service) v R Ltd
A nursery nurse who was dismissed for breaching confidentiality after discussing a colleague's disciplinary hearing has lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal also rejected her sexual harassment and victimisation claims.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Pub Manager (3 years' service) v Your Friendly Local Ltd
A pub manager was automatically unfairly dismissed and discriminated against after her employer failed to carry out a pregnancy risk assessment, changed her contract, evicted her from tied accommodation, and refused to let her return from maternity leave. The tribunal awarded £40,743.
Won · £40,744 · May 2023Won£40,744May 2023Former employee v Dr French Memorial Home Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Dr French Memorial Home Limited was struck out after she failed to attend a hearing and ignored tribunal orders, even after being given a second chance.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Medrescue 24 Limited
A former employee of Medrescue 24 Limited has won £2,898 after the company failed to attend a tribunal hearing and was found to have made unlawful deductions from wages and not paid holiday entitlement.
Partial · £2,898 · May 2023Partial£2,898May 2023Inventory Operative (5 years' service) v Alloga UK Limited
An inventory operative with five years' service who resigned after a dispute over face masks and a grievance about disability discrimination has lost her constructive dismissal and disability discrimination claims.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee (Border Force officer) v Secretary of State for The Home Department (Border Force)
A former Border Force officer who failed to disclose a previous gross misconduct dismissal on his application was fairly dismissed. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were within the band of reasonable responses.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Driver (delivery driver for online grocery orders) v Tesco Stores Limited
A delivery driver who had carpal tunnel syndrome surgery and returned to work without sickness absence was found not to be disabled. The tribunal dismissed her unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Force Control Room Operator (4 years' service) v Surrey Police
A Force Control Room Operator was fairly dismissed after failing to provide proof of a charity donation from a cake sale, the tribunal has ruled. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Security guard (10 weeks' service) v ESG Security Limited
A security guard who resigned after just 10 weeks has been awarded £5,892 by an employment tribunal for constructive unfair dismissal, including notice pay and pension loss.
Won · £5,892 · May 2023Won£5,892May 2023Senior Employment Consultant (former trade union representative and HR adviser) v Peninsula Business Services Limited
A tribunal dismissed a senior employment consultant's claims that his employer failed to make reasonable adjustments for his dyslexia, and upheld a £430.16 deduction from his final pay for training costs.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Night Shift Postman (34 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A night shift postman with 34 years of service was fairly dismissed for intimidating a colleague, the tribunal ruled, rejecting claims that the process was flawed.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Car mechanic v NK MOT Limited
A car mechanic who was summarily dismissed after a missing tool was found in his toolbox had his unfair dismissal claim rejected because he presented it 17 days after the legal deadline.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Shunter refuelling and refilling buses (16 years' service) v Bidvest Noonan (UK) Limited
A bus depot shunter with 16 years' service resigned after repeated payroll errors. The tribunal found the persistent underpayments were a fundamental breach of contract, making his constructive dismissal unfair.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023Former employee v Peter's Food Services Limited
A former employee who left work because he felt too ill to handle food safely was automatically unfairly dismissed. The tribunal awarded £1,092 in compensation.
Partial · £1,092 · May 2023Partial£1,092May 2023Store manager (4 years' service) v Lidl GB
A store manager with diabetes who resigned after a disciplinary investigation failed to prove constructive dismissal or disability discrimination. The tribunal found Lidl had made reasonable adjustments and had not harassed him.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Store Manager (32 years' service) v Tesco Stores Limited
A Tesco store manager with 32 years' service was fairly dismissed for misconduct after repeatedly opening the store alone and leaving it unsupervised, despite a live final written warning. The tribunal upheld the dismissal, finding it within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee v Staffline Recruitment Limited
A former employee's claim for constructive unfair dismissal against Staffline Recruitment Limited was rejected after the tribunal found he had not actually resigned.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Social worker (9 years' service) v Ealing Council
A social worker who resigned after a supervision session had her constructive unfair dismissal claim thrown out because she waited too long to bring it. Other discrimination claims were allowed to proceed.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Zobra Limited
A former employee won £1,819 after Zobra Limited failed to respond to claims of unauthorised wage deductions, breach of contract and unpaid holiday. Claims for unfair dismissal and redundancy were struck out due to insufficient service.
Partial · £1,819 · May 2023Partial£1,819May 2023Former employee v Department for Work and Pensions
A former employee's claims of disability discrimination and unfair dismissal against the Department for Work and Pensions have been dismissed by the Manchester Employment Tribunal.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Supervisor of Special Services (4 years' service) v Stagecoach South East
A supervisor with depression was unfairly dismissed after posting an offensive tweet while on furlough. The tribunal found Stagecoach failed to consider his mental health before deciding to dismiss.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Senior technician (12 years' service) v Teva UK Limited
A senior technician with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed after failing to lock out a damaged charger, leading to a colleague's electric shock. The tribunal rejected his claims of unfair dismissal and homophobic harassment.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Senior Staff Nurse (20 years' service) v St George's Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
A senior staff nurse with 20 years' service was fairly dismissed after a head injury left him unable to return to work. The tribunal rejected his claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee v David Lloyd Leisure
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against David Lloyd Leisure was dismissed after she failed to attend the hearing and did not respond to tribunal correspondence. The claim also appeared to be out of time.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Professor (University of Oxford) v The Chancellor, Masters and Scholars of the University of Oxford
A University of Oxford professor won his unfair dismissal and age discrimination claims, but was ordered to pay £7,500 in costs after failing to provide remedy disclosure for his £3 million compensation claim.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023Chief Technical Officer (photocatalytic chemistry and nanotechnology R&D) v Environmental Control Coatings Ltd
A chief technical officer who claimed his employment transferred to a new company when his employer ran into difficulties has lost his TUPE claim. The tribunal found no assets, employees or IP had moved.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Warehouse Manager (5 years' service) v Korea Foods Company Ltd
A warehouse manager who resigned after Korean employees who walked out were rehired without his knowledge lost his claims for constructive unfair dismissal and race discrimination. The tribunal found the employer's actions were within its managerial prerogative.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee v Mulberry Homes Property Developments Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was allowed to proceed after the tribunal ruled that his claim form was correctly presented on 20 April 2022, even though it was initially returned for lacking a postcode and resubmitted one day after the deadline.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Head of Sales (3 years' service) v Sequin Art Ltd
A Head of Sales with 3 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a series of conduct allegations, including a joke about a 'drive-by shooting'. The tribunal awarded £27,777.76, reduced by 25% for contributory fault.
Won · £27,778 · May 2023Won£27,778May 2023Mobile Heavy Goods Vehicle Technician (13 years' service) v Enterprise Rent a Car UK Ltd
A mobile technician with 13 years' service was unfairly dismissed after describing a colleague as a 'female Eastern European woman' who 'always makes mistakes'. The tribunal found the employer's investigation was inadequate.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023Fleet Operative-Drayman (7 years' service) v GXO Logistics Drinks Limited (formerly XPO Logistics Drinks Limited)
A fleet operative who was dismissed for using his mobile phone while driving has won his race discrimination and unfair dismissal claims. The tribunal found the dismissal was tainted by race and reduced compensation by 50% for contributory fault.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023Senior Business Development Manager (2 months' service) v The Hut.Com Limited
A senior business development manager dismissed after colleagues discovered her tweets about Islam and hijabs lost her discrimination and unfair dismissal claims. The tribunal ruled her views were not protected philosophical beliefs.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Shop assistant (14 years' service) v Mr K Kandasamy Koneswaran t/a Terry & Kent Newsagents
A shop assistant with 14 years' service was constructively unfairly dismissed after her employer grabbed her face and called her a 'stupid village idiot woman'. The tribunal awarded no compensation as the claimant did not pursue a remedy hearing.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023UK Head of Environment, Health and Safety (EHS) (2 years' service) v Piramal Healthcare UK Limited
A UK Head of EHS resigned after her employer ignored her grievance and threatened sick pay. The tribunal found constructive unfair dismissal and wrongful dismissal, with remedy to be decided.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023HGV driver (1 year 1 month service) v A R Wholesale Ltd
An HGV driver with just over a year's service was dismissed for misconduct. The tribunal struck out his unfair dismissal claim because he lacked the required two years' continuous service and could not identify any statutory exception.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Office Manager (15 years' service) v A1 Taxis Ilford Limited
A tribunal struck out an office manager's unfair dismissal claim because he presented it more than a year after his employment ended by mutual consent, far beyond the three-month time limit.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Al-Khair Foundation
A former employee brought claims for unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and more against Al-Khair Foundation, but all were dismissed as presented too late.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Regional Sales Manager (2 years 7 months' service) v Syspal Ltd
A tribunal found that Syspal Ltd unfairly dismissed a Regional Sales Manager with 2 years 7 months' service because the redundancy selection process was pre-determined and the scoring matrix flawed. He was awarded £32,735 in compensation.
Partial · £32,735 · May 2023Partial£32,735May 2023Former employee v Digital Barriers Services Limited
A former employee's attempt to strike out the employer's response failed because the employer had put forward an arguable defence and had complied with disclosure obligations.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Studio Manager (9 years' service) v Consol Tanning Limited t/a Consol
A tribunal has dismissed an unfair dismissal claim from a studio manager with nine years' service who was sacked for gross misconduct after repeatedly giving free sunbed sessions without authorisation. The employer's investigation and decision were found to be within the range of reasonable responses.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v The Commissioners for HM Revenue and Customs
A former HMRC employee who did not attend his final hearing after three postponement requests were refused has had all his claims dismissed by the Newcastle Employment Tribunal.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Executive Development Consultant (3 years' service) v The Employers Network for Equality and Inclusion
An Executive Development Consultant with multiple sclerosis lost her unfair dismissal and discrimination claims after the tribunal found the redundancy was genuine and fairly handled.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Programme Delivery Manager (9 years' service) v Aster Group
A Programme Delivery Manager with nine years' service resigned during a redundancy consultation and claimed constructive unfair dismissal. The tribunal dismissed her claim, finding that the employer's conduct was not a fundamental breach of contract.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Sales employee (brief period) v Nowy Styl UK Limited
A sales employee who brought a £25,000 commission claim was awarded just £716.40. Both sides' applications for costs were refused.
Partial · £716 · May 2023Partial£716May 2023Wellbeing Worker (21 years' service) v The African Caribbean Care Group
A wellbeing worker with 21 years' service was fairly dismissed after he continued a free meals project with his son, despite a final written warning. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Emergency Medical Technician (6 years' service) v North West Ambulance Service NHS Trust
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of an Emergency Medical Technician who made crude sexual remarks about children and showed colleagues photographs of children in a swimming pool. The employer's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Dispenser (20 hours per week) v Wyncroft Surgery (A Partnership)
A part-time dispenser who raised patient safety concerns about medication mix-ups and sabotage was summarily dismissed. The tribunal refused interim relief, finding she did not have a 'pretty good chance' of proving her dismissal was due to whistleblowing.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Business Intelligence Manager (6 years' service) v Micro Focus Ltd
A Business Intelligence Manager with six years' service has won his unfair dismissal claim after his employer decided his fate before consulting him. The tribunal awarded over £117,000 in compensation and a protective award for failing to collectively consult.
Won · £117,632 · May 2023Won£117,632May 2023Former health and well-being coordinator (28 years' service) v Gateshead Council
A tribunal has dismissed an unfair dismissal claim brought by a former health and well-being coordinator with 28 years' service, because she presented her claim 12 days after the deadline. No compensation was awarded.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Administrator, Office Manager and Business Manager and Compliance Officer (10 years' service) v Peter Radelat t/a PR Employment Law Specialists
An employment law specialist who closed his business due to ill health was found to have unfairly dismissed his administrator of 10 years. The tribunal awarded compensation for the unfair dismissal and failure to provide written particulars.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023Clinical charge nurse (10 years' service) v South West London and St Georges Mental Health NHS Trust
A clinical charge nurse who resigned and later tried to withdraw his resignation lost his constructive unfair dismissal claim after telling the tribunal the only reason he resigned was a good job offer.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Restaurant employee (9 years' service) v Red Fortuna Limited, trading as Ciao Baby Restaurant
A 9-year restaurant employee was unfairly dismissed after raising concerns about furlough fraud, but his claim for automatic unfair dismissal due to protected disclosure failed. The tribunal awarded £6,300 in compensation.
Partial · £6,300 · May 2023Partial£6,300May 2023Site coordinator (13 years' service) v East Riding of Yorkshire Council
A school site coordinator with 13 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after making sexually explicit comments to female colleagues. The tribunal also awarded £10,000 costs against him.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Cleaner and supervisor (3+ years' service) v D Brice and Company Ltd T/A D B Services
A cleaner and supervisor who resigned after a TUPE transfer was awarded £224 for unpaid holiday pay, but her claims for constructive dismissal and race discrimination were dismissed.
Partial · £224 · May 2023Partial£224May 2023Former employee v Caffyns Plc
A former employee's unfair dismissal and whistleblowing claims were thrown out after he presented them nearly six months out of time, with the tribunal finding no reasonable excuse for the delay.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Riley Foods Limited
A former employee won nearly £15,000 after being unfairly dismissed by Riley Foods Limited, with the tribunal adding a 25% uplift for the company's failure to follow the ACAS Code of Practice.
Won · £14,966 · May 2023Won£14,966May 2023HGV driver v Logikal Network Limited
An HGV driver who refused to drive to Stafford because he needed an 11-hour rest break was summarily dismissed without any investigation. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair and awarded £2,179.42, reduced by 50% for the driver's contributory conduct.
Won · £2,179 · May 2023Won£2,179May 2023HR Advisor/Co-Ordinator (6 years' service) v Felixstowe Dock & Railway Company
A tribunal has dismissed an HR advisor's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims because he presented them 12 days late, ruling it was reasonably practicable to have filed on time.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Reckitt
A former employee's claim of constructive unfair dismissal and discrimination against Reckitt was dismissed because she presented her claim over five months after her employment ended, missing the time limit by two days.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Parking Services Manager (6 years' service) v Crawley Borough Council
A Parking Services Manager with anxiety and depression was not disabled under the Equality Act 2010, the tribunal ruled, striking out his discrimination claims.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Co-director and 50% shareholder of training company v Evolving Edge Ltd
A tribunal dismissed a co-director's claims of pregnancy and sex discrimination against her business partner, ruling that the breakdown was a commercial dispute over profit-sharing and share valuation, not discrimination.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Driver (prison service) v Secretary of State for Justice
A prison service driver who claimed he was deterred from raising a grievance and then dismissed due to his depression has lost his disability discrimination claim. The tribunal found no evidence of discrimination.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Security guard (13 years' service) v Kingdom Services Group Limited
A security guard with 13 years' service on the same assignment was awarded redundancy pay after his employer failed to offer suitable alternative work before the assignment ended. The tribunal rejected claims for unfair dismissal and unpaid wages.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Former employee v Bedwellty Park Residential Home Limited
A former employee of Bedwellty Park Residential Home has been awarded £16,439 after the tribunal found she was unfairly and wrongfully dismissed, and that the home made unauthorised deductions from her wages.
Won · £16,439 · May 2023Won£16,439May 2023IVA drafter (9 months' service) v Finance4me Limited (dissolved)
An IVA drafter with CFS/ME lost her disability discrimination claim after the tribunal ruled she did not have a disability under the Equality Act. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Practice Manager (29 years' service) v Duncan Boxwell & Company Limited
A practice manager who resigned after receiving an email mentioning a potential future pay reduction has lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found no repudiatory breach.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Team Lead, Wheelchair Tennis (4 years' service) v ITF Licensing (UK) Limited
A tribunal has ruled that ITF Licensing (UK) Ltd unfairly dismissed a team lead who refused the Covid-19 vaccine, because it did not properly consider whether her duties could be modified. She was awarded £27,465.
Won · £27,465 · May 2023Won£27,465May 2023Senior Campaigner (16 years' service) v Amnesty International Limited
A long-serving Amnesty International campaigner who refused to return to work unless the organisation reversed its decision to reinstate Alexei Navalny's prisoner-of-conscience status has lost her unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee (3 years' service) v Altran UK Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claim survives a strike-out bid, with the tribunal ruling that a fair trial remains possible despite abusive correspondence and procedural delays.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Sales manager (13 years' service) v Alan Howard (Stockport) Ltd
A sales manager with 13 years' service resigned claiming loss of trust and confidence after a sick pay dispute and disciplinary warning. The tribunal rejected his constructive unfair dismissal claim, finding no fundamental breach of contract.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Compliance Engineer (contractor, 7 months' service) v Jaguar Land Rover Ltd
A contractor at Jaguar Land Rover succeeded in claims of sex-related harassment after a male colleague entered her home while she was in the shower and later sent flowers. The tribunal upheld three of five harassment allegations.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Former employee v J D Wetherspoon plc
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against J D Wetherspoon plc was dismissed after a full hearing, despite a tribunal error that nearly struck out the case earlier. The deposit order was refunded to the employer.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Customer Service Assistant (later Train Operator) v London Underground Ltd
A London Underground train operator was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after refusing to provide a hair sample for drug testing, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Production Operative (3 years 10 months' service) v Kettle Foods Limited
A production operative who was dismissed after over a year of sickness absence has had her unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims struck out. The tribunal found she was not disabled and her dismissal was fair.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Shunter (6 years' service) v DHL Services Ltd
A shunter with six years' service was fairly dismissed after driving while using a hand-held phone and breaching a red light. The tribunal rejected claims that the dismissal was linked to earlier health and safety concerns.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Apprentice mechanic (2 years' service) v Thomas Burgess t/a Toms Motors
An apprentice mechanic who was left bleeding after a hand injury, verbally abused, and denied tools has won a constructive unfair dismissal claim against Thomas Burgess t/a Toms Motors. The Manchester tribunal awarded £8,756.61.
Won · £8,757 · May 2023Won£8,757May 2023Former employee v West Midlands Ambulance Service University NHS Foundation Trust
A former employee who failed to attend his final hearing and repeatedly ignored tribunal orders has had all his claims dismissed. The tribunal found no realistic prospect of progressing the case.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Cleaner (4 years' service) v Ms Z Nicholson (trading as "Hestia Cleaning Services")
A cleaner with four years' service was found to be automatically unfairly dismissed when the new cleaning contractor refused to take him on. The tribunal awarded £1,372.
Won · £1,372 · May 2023Won£1,372May 2023Education Coordinator (2 years' service) v Workers Educational Association Ltd
An education coordinator who resigned claiming constructive dismissal lost her case after the tribunal found she had affirmed the employer's breach by continuing to work for more than a year.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Sales assistant (9 years' service) v John Titcombe Limited
A sales assistant with 9 years' service was dismissed on the spot after asking for a chair and reduced hours due to a cycling injury. The tribunal awarded £47,886 for unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Won · £47,886 · May 2023Won£47,886May 2023Former care home bank worker v Willow Tower Opco1 Ltd
A tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal claim from a care home bank worker who refused the COVID-19 vaccine citing veganism, ruling she lacked continuity of service and her belief was not a protected characteristic.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Field Engineer (32 years' service) v Openreach Plc.
A field engineer with 32 years' service was fairly dismissed after falsely reporting his gas detection unit stolen and failing to use it on four jobs. The tribunal upheld Openreach's decision.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee (IT sector, 3 years' service) v IBM UK Ltd
A former IBM employee won permission to amend his race discrimination claim to include the grievance process, but earlier allegations were struck out as out of time.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Stores Assistant/Taping Tool Repair Technician (3 years' service) v Gypsumtools Ltd
A stores assistant who was dismissed after a video accused him of grooming an underage girl has won his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer's investigation was biased and procedurally unfair.
Won · £21,450 · May 2023Won£21,450May 2023Former employee v PJ Southport Limited t/a Papa John's
A former employee won £7,432 in a race discrimination claim after the employer's response was struck out and it failed to attend the hearing.
Won · £7,432 · May 2023Won£7,432May 2023Former employee v Refuel Forecourt Limited
A former employee who resigned from Refuel Forecourt Limited was unable to pursue unfair dismissal due to less than 2 years' service, and her breach of contract claim for notice pay also failed. The tribunal awarded her £10 for unpaid wages.
Partial · £10 · May 2023Partial£10May 2023Night Care Assistant (7 years' service) v Hampshire County Council
A night care assistant with 7 years' service was fairly dismissed for capability due to long-term sickness linked to unresolved grievances about payroll system errors. The tribunal awarded £153.62 for unpaid notice pay but rejected all other claims.
Partial · £154 · May 2023Partial£154May 2023Traffic Engineer (5 years' service) v London Borough of Brent
A traffic engineer with PTSD and chronic pain was fairly dismissed for capability after years of sickness absence and negligible work output, the Watford tribunal has ruled.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee v Kindred (London) Limited
A former employee's whistleblowing unfair dismissal claim was struck out after he repeatedly failed to give specific details of his alleged protected disclosures, despite multiple tribunal orders.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Senior Lettings Negotiator (3 years' service) v HR Lettings Limited
A senior lettings negotiator who resigned after a shouting incident and a moved desk lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence by HR Lettings Limited.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Assistant Store Manager (5 years' service) v Hugo Boss UK Limited
An assistant store manager who resigned claiming constructive dismissal and race discrimination has lost his case. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence and no evidence of discrimination.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Sales and marketing consultant (2 years' service) v Futurelink Employment Services Ltd
A sales and marketing consultant with anxiety was dismissed just before her two-year service milestone after requesting reduced hours. The tribunal found disability discrimination and awarded £36,735.59.
Won · £36,736 · May 2023Won£36,736May 2023Production operative (6 years' service) v Faccenda Foods Limited
A production operative with six years' service was fairly dismissed on capability grounds after nine months' absence due to foot pain. The tribunal rejected claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Global Head of Marketing (2 years' service) v LREsystem Limited
A tribunal found that a medical technology company unfairly dismissed its Global Head of Marketing by making him redundant without consultation, and awarded him £89,013 including £74,800 in unpaid salary.
Won · £89,013 · May 2023Won£89,013May 2023Former employee v Avensis Support Limited
A former employee's whistleblowing unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after he failed to attend a preliminary hearing and emailed the tribunal saying he had a new job and did not want to lose it by being a whistleblower.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former manager v MS and AC Banbury
A former manager's claims for whistleblowing detriment and unauthorised wage deductions were struck out after she presented them late and failed to attend the preliminary hearing.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Ophthalmic technician (Band 3) (1 year 8 months' service) v Moorfields Eye Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
An ophthalmic technician at Moorfields Eye Hospital was subjected to racist accent mimicry and victimised after complaining. The tribunal found she was constructively dismissed as a result of race discrimination and harassment.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023Bar staff (3 years' service) v Mitchells & Butlers Retail Ltd
A tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claim from a bar worker with three years' service because she brought it too late, despite her depression and alcohol misuse.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee (Pension Section, then Disabled Children's Department) v Hampshire County Council
A former employee who signed a COT3 settlement for £7,000 later tried to set it aside, alleging misrepresentation about redeployment rights. The tribunal struck out all claims as an abuse of process.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Nurse (15 years' service) v Oxleas NHS Foundation Trust
A nurse with 15 years' service resigned after her second grievance wasn't progressed for 16 days. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence, dismissing her constructive unfair dismissal claim against Oxleas NHS Foundation Trust.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Telephone operator (taxi firm) v Key Cars (Widnes) Ltd (in Liquidation)
A telephone operator who was dismissed for taking a cigarette break 12 minutes into her shift, while other employees who did the same were not disciplined, has won her claim for automatic unfair dismissal related to pregnancy. The tribunal awarded her £17,003.
Won · £17,003 · May 2023Won£17,003May 2023Occupational Therapy Technical Instructor (2.5 years' service) v South West London and St George’s Mental Health NHS Trust
An occupational therapy instructor who was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct saw his claim dismissed because he presented it too late. The tribunal found he could have brought it in time.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Transport Director (20 years' service) v Kammac Limited
A transport director with 20 years' service lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim after resigning over a sick pay dispute and an investigatory meeting. The tribunal found no repudiatory breach of contract.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee v Plain Jane Limited
A former employee's claim was struck out after her witness statement arrived four minutes late. The tribunal set aside the strike-out, finding she was not at fault and a fair hearing remained possible.
Remitted · May 2023Remitted—May 2023Restaurant employee (4 months' service) v Morgarten Restaurants Ltd
An employee who resigned after four months due to constructive dismissal has been awarded £2,579 for unpaid wages, holiday pay, and notice pay. The restaurant company, now in liquidation, failed to pay her final earnings.
Won · £2,579 · May 2023Won£2,579May 2023Locum physiotherapist (agency worker) v Hywel Dda University Local Health Board
A locum physiotherapist who claimed he was unfairly dismissed had his case thrown out after the tribunal found he was a worker, not an employee, and failed to comply with court orders.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Specialty anaesthetist doctor v Cwm Taf Morgannwg University Local Health Board
A specialty anaesthetist doctor had his race discrimination and victimisation claims dismissed after the tribunal found he missed the time limits and it was not just and equitable to extend time.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Online magazine editor (British citizen, based in Indonesia) v Observatory Southeast Asia Limited
A British citizen who worked remotely from Indonesia for a UK company has won a preliminary ruling that the employment tribunal has territorial jurisdiction over her unfair dismissal and discrimination claims.
Remitted · May 2023Remitted—May 2023Former Grade 7 nurse (cardiovascular health and rehabilitation) v University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
A former Grade 7 nurse failed to prove constructive unfair dismissal after his role was removed in a restructure. The tribunal struck out his claim and refused to add a disability discrimination claim.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Business Analyst / Product Owner (4 years' service) v Bud Systems Limited
A tribunal has ruled that Bud Systems Limited fairly dismissed a business analyst who had been on sick leave for 16 months with anxiety and depression. All discrimination claims also failed.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Postman (5 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A postman with five years' service was unfairly dismissed after Royal Mail's covert monitoring operation was found to have significant deficiencies, including misidentification and procedural unfairness. The tribunal upheld his unfair dismissal claim but rejected an automatic unfair dismissal claim on health and safety grounds.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Former employee v Dannii Matthews Limited
A former employee won £15,298 after being unfairly dismissed by redundancy and having wages unlawfully deducted. The employer failed to present a valid response.
Won · £15,299 · May 2023Won£15,299May 2023Creative Manager (10 years' service) v University of Nottingham
A Creative Manager with 10 years' service was fairly dismissed for redundancy, the tribunal ruled, rejecting claims that the process was discriminatory or procedurally unfair.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee (engineer, 15 years' service) v Transport for London
A former Transport for London engineer had his whistleblowing detriment claim struck out after trying to relitigate a disclosure already decided by a previous tribunal. He was ordered to pay £2,940 in costs for withdrawing the rest late.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Barts Health NHS Trust
A former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claim was struck out after he failed to comply with orders, respond to correspondence, or attend the hearing. The tribunal found his delay was intentional and disrespectful.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Total Support Services Limited
A former employee's claims for unfair dismissal and disability discrimination were struck out for failing to pursue them, but the tribunal allowed her claims for notice pay and holiday pay to proceed as they were undisputed.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Band 6 mental health crisis team worker (3 years' service) v Rotherham Doncaster and South Humber NHS Foundation Trust
A mental health worker's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims were dismissed as out of time after he waited for union assistance before presenting his claim. The tribunal found he could have acted sooner.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Business Development Manager (7 months' service) v Golden Egg Group Limited
Two business development managers who raised concerns about PAYE and payslips were removed from the company WhatsApp group and blamed for contacting HMRC. The tribunal awarded over £15,000 each for injury to feelings, with a 20% ACAS uplift.
Partial · £15,235 · May 2023Partial£15,235May 2023Administrator (5 months' service) v All Techmart UK Limited
An administrator who was sexually harassed by her boss, who sent explicit texts and propositioned her, has been awarded £17,607 by an employment tribunal. The employer failed to defend the claim.
Won · £17,608 · May 2023Won£17,608May 2023Former apprentice electrician v Power Up Manchester Limited
A former apprentice electrician had his unfair dismissal and discrimination claims dismissed after he failed to attend a preliminary hearing and ignored tribunal orders. The employer was awarded £760 in preparation costs.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Consultant Radiologist (2 years 9 months' service) v North West Anglia NHS Foundation Trust
A consultant radiologist who suffered migraines and exhaustion due to overwork and caring responsibilities was found not to be disabled under the Equality Act 2010. The tribunal ruled that his conditions were a normal reaction to his lifestyle, not an impairment with substantial adverse effects.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee (driver/loader, 2 years 5 months' service) v Dacorum Borough Council
A driver/loader with depression was constructively dismissed after Dacorum Borough Council refused to let him work as a loader and later changed his terms. The tribunal awarded £24,324.43.
Partial · £24,324 · May 2023Partial£24,324May 2023Customer advisor (5 years' service) v B&Q Ltd
A customer advisor with depression was dismissed for gross misconduct after a series of incidents with colleagues. The tribunal ruled the dismissal was fair and not discriminatory.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Electrician's mate (4 days' service) v Clearfield Recruitment Ltd
A tribunal dismissed claims of race and disability discrimination brought by an electrician's mate who worked for only four days, after the claimant withdrew most allegations.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Interim contractor (Project Accountant) v The Home Office
An interim contractor who worked for the Home Office for six months had his unfair dismissal claim struck out because he lacked two years' qualifying service. He was also ordered to pay £1,500 in costs after withdrawing his remaining claims on the first day of the final hearing.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee (lorry driver, 18 days' service) v John Lewis Plc
A lorry driver who resigned after 18 days and later worked as an agency driver was unable to claim unfair dismissal due to short service, but his disability and race discrimination claims will proceed to a final hearing.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Sales person (8 years' service) v The Quality Koi Company Limited
An employment tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal, redundancy and notice pay claim because it was presented six days after the deadline, rejecting the claimant's explanation of a postal strike as unsupported by evidence.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Atalian Servest Security Ltd
A former employee's claims for race discrimination and unlawful deduction of wages were dismissed because they were brought too late. The tribunal also refused a reconsideration application.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Associate director/senior project manager and quantity surveyor (5 years' service) v Lucas Lee Ltd
A Leeds tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal claim from an associate director made redundant after his role was restructured. The judge found the employer's consultation and selection process was fair, even though the only alternative roles offered came with a salary cut from £70,000 to £30,000.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee v Just Ask Estate Services Ltd
A tribunal struck out claims for automatic unfair dismissal and race discrimination after the claimant failed to comply with orders and made no contact for over a year.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Whitbread Group Plc
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Whitbread Group Plc was struck out after he failed to attend the final hearing and comply with case management orders, but the tribunal later granted reconsideration and restored the claim.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v PNS Garage Installations Limited
A former employee who was automatically unfairly dismissed and suffered detriment for whistleblowing has been awarded £14,443.27 by an employment tribunal. The respondent, PNS Garage Installations Limited, did not attend the hearing.
Partial · £14,443 · May 2023Partial£14,443May 2023Cleaner (2 years 7 months' service) v Mario Cleaning Services Ltd
A cleaner was unfairly dismissed after being selected for redundancy solely because she asked about taking unpaid leave to care for her ill mother. The tribunal found no chance she would have been dismissed if a fair procedure had been followed.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023Visual Merchandising Team Manager (26 years' service) v Marks & Spencer plc
A Visual Merchandising Team Manager with 26 years' service was dismissed after over six months' absence. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Sales colleague (5 years 9 months' service) v Currys Group Limited
A sales colleague who hid bail conditions for serious sexual offences for over two years was fairly dismissed by Currys Group Limited for loss of trust and confidence. The tribunal dismissed his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Senior sales consultant v Sevco 5075 Ltd T/a FASTSIGNS Hammersmith
A senior sales consultant who was placed on furlough without his knowledge and continued working full-time has won his constructive dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer's actions breached trust and confidence.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Housekeeper (shared domestic arrangement) v Christopher Giddings
A woman who lived in a man's home and performed housekeeping tasks was found not to be an employee or worker, leading to dismissal of her unfair dismissal claim and a costs order of £11,130.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former crew member (6 years' service) v McDonalds
A former McDonald's crew member lost his unfair dismissal claim because he contacted Acas more than three months after the deadline, despite visiting the tribunal earlier. The claim was struck out as out of time.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Postal worker (34 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Limited
A Watford tribunal found Royal Mail unfairly dismissed a postal worker with 34 years' service after a manager used PDA tracking data to investigate him, contrary to a union agreement. The tribunal reduced any compensation by 60% for the employee's contributory conduct.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023Former employees v Cheshiregate Property Services Limited
Two former employees of Cheshiregate Property Services were awarded over £45,000 after the company failed to defend claims of redundancy pay, notice pay, and unpaid wages.
Won · £45,099 · May 2023Won£45,099May 2023Former employee v S.T.A.R Domiciliary Care Ltd
A former employee of S.T.A.R Domiciliary Care Ltd has lost all claims including constructive unfair dismissal, whistleblowing detriment, and religious discrimination after resigning and alleging a breach of contract.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee (zero-hour contract) v Elevate Staffing Ltd
Two zero-hour contract workers won race and sex discrimination claims after a manager made racist comments and a colleague subjected a female worker to sexist verbal abuse. The tribunal awarded a total of £10,728 for injury to feelings.
Partial · £10,728 · May 2023Partial£10,728May 2023Former employee v T4 Trust
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after he presented his claim 15 days after the three-month time limit expired. The tribunal rejected his argument that he relied on advice from his union representative.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Adam Grooming Atelier Ltd
An employer's application for £1,435 in costs was dismissed after the tribunal found the former employee had not acted unreasonably and her breach of contract claim had some prospect of success.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Distribution centre HGV driver (2 years' service) v Tesco Stores Limited
An HGV driver who was dismissed for aggressive behaviour after managers contacted him on his personal smartphone without permission has won his unfair dismissal claim, but lost his whistleblowing case. The tribunal found the dismissal was procedurally unfair.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Executive General Manager (2 years' service) v Eastman Staples Ltd
An executive general manager with two years' service was unfairly dismissed for alleged gross misconduct. The company entered liquidation and did not defend the claim, resulting in a £13,716 award.
Won · £13,716 · May 2023Won£13,716May 2023Passenger Services Duty Officers (long service) v Cobalt Ground Solutions Ltd
Three long-serving duty officers were unfairly dismissed when their employer failed to follow its own grievance policy before making them redundant. The tribunal awarded compensation limited to two months' furlough pay.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Head of Investments (3 years 7 months' service) v Ahauz Ltd.
A head of investments was unfairly dismissed on redundancy grounds. The tribunal awarded £49,992 compensation, noting his reasonable fear of breaching broad restrictive covenants hindered his job search.
Won · £49,992 · May 2023Won£49,992May 2023Lead Design Engineer (12 years' service) v Marshalls Group Limited
A tribunal has ruled that a Lead Design Engineer with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed for redundancy after scoring lowest on a selection matrix. The claim was dismissed in full.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Cleaner (two sites, 11 hours per week) v KGB Cleaning & Support Services Ltd
A cleaner who was made redundant after her employer lost two cleaning contracts had her unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims struck out because she presented them to the tribunal more than three months after her dismissal.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Doctor (NHS trainee) v Health Education England
An NHS trainee doctor who flew to India for his mother's surgery after a tribunal refused to postpone a 35-day hearing had his unfair dismissal claim struck out for unreasonable conduct.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Deputy Manager (18 years' service) v Sense, The National Deafblind and Rubella Association
An employment tribunal has ruled that a deputy manager's eczema and severe allergies amounted to a disability, paving the way for her discrimination claims to proceed.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023Branch manager (15 years' service) v Travis Perkins PLC
A branch manager with 15 years' service was suspended for alleged gross misconduct after handing in his notice. The tribunal found it was a 'witch hunt' and awarded a 25% ACAS uplift for failing to follow the code.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023Tractor operative (1 year's service) v The CGM Group (East Anglia) Limited
A tractor operative who reported unsafe equipment to the Environment Agency and his employer was subjected to detriment and dismissed. The tribunal awarded him £94,838.50 for injury to feelings, unpaid wages, and the employer's failure to provide written particulars.
Partial · £94,839 · May 2023Partial£94,839May 2023HGV driver (21 years' service) v Asda Stores Ltd
An HGV driver who resigned after Asda placed him in a capability process and failed to handle his grievance has been awarded over £163,000 for constructive unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Won · £163,485 · May 2023Won£163,485May 2023Senior Paramedic (18 years' service) v East of England Ambulance Service NHS Trust
An NHS Trust unfairly dismissed a Senior Paramedic with 18 years' service after he reacted to being struck by a patient. The tribunal found the investigation failed to properly assess witness credibility and withheld key evidence, awarding £49,314.66.
Won · £49,315 · May 2023Won£49,315May 2023Fleet and Security Manager (4 years' service) v Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office
A Fleet and Security Manager who worked for the British High Commission in Fiji lost his unfair dismissal claim after the tribunal ruled it had no territorial jurisdiction to hear the case.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023NHS consultant (psychiatrist) v South West Yorkshire Partnership NHS Foundation Trust
A psychiatrist's claim for constructive unfair dismissal against an NHS trust was struck out after she failed to pay a £400 deposit ordered by the tribunal. The claim had previously survived a strike-out application.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Support worker (2 years 6 months' service) v The Disablement Association of Barking and Dagenham
A support worker with osteoarthritis was discriminated against by her employer, a disability charity, which failed to make reasonable adjustments and treated her less favourably than a non-disabled colleague after furlough. The tribunal upheld her disability discrimination claims but dismissed her constructive unfair dismissal claim.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Teacher of maths and computing (5 years' service) v Devonport High School for Girls
A teacher with five years' service was unfairly dismissed after the school failed to properly investigate allegations made by pupils. The tribunal awarded £44,868.
Won · £44,868 · May 2023Won£44,868May 2023Dot Com driver (Tesco) v Tesco Stores Limited
A Tesco Dot Com driver who alleged 17 incidents of discrimination on grounds of race and religion has had all claims dismissed by an employment tribunal.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee v LQS Healthcare Services Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against LQS Healthcare Services Ltd was struck out because they had worked there for less than two years, the minimum qualifying period under UK law.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Warehouse operative (12 years' service) v Stanley Black & Decker Limited
A warehouse operative with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed for grabbing colleagues' private areas. The tribunal found the employer had reasonable grounds for its belief despite the operative's conspiracy claims.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Maintenance technician (3 years' service) v APM Nationwide Ltd
A maintenance technician was unfairly dismissed after being accused of defaming his employer. The tribunal found the investigation was minimal, the outcome predetermined, and the appeal conducted by the managing director's brother-in-law. He was awarded £10,896.94.
Won · £10,897 · May 2023Won£10,897May 2023Optimisation Engineer (2 years' service) v Unipart Group Ltd
An Optimisation Engineer with two years' service was unfairly dismissed after Unipart Group failed to disclose redundancy selection criteria or scores during consultation. The tribunal found the process both procedurally and substantively unfair.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023Casual road safety trainer (22 years' service) v Lancashire County Council
A tribunal ruled that a casual Bikeability trainer who worked for Lancashire County Council for 22 years was not an employee under a global contract, and her unfair dismissal claim was out of time. However, her redundancy payment claim can proceed.
Partial · Apr 2023Partial—Apr 2023Patient Administrator (6 years' service) v Chelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
A tribunal struck out an unfair dismissal claim from a Patient Administrator who was dismissed for allegedly stealing a colleague's bag, after finding CCTV footage left no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Lettings and Sales negotiator (7 years' service) v Holland Properties Ltd
A lettings negotiator with seven years' service was unfairly dismissed after a breakdown in working relationships following a covert recording. The tribunal found the procedure flawed and applied a 10% ACAS uplift.
Partial · Apr 2023Partial—Apr 2023Former employee (4 years' service) v Department for Work and Pensions
A Department for Work and Pensions employee who was sacked for secretly recording colleagues has won his unfair dismissal claim after the tribunal found serious flaws in the disciplinary process. He was awarded £25,788 after reductions for his own contribution.
Partial · £25,788 · Apr 2023Partial£25,788Apr 2023Former employee v Reclamet Ltd
A former employee of Reclamet Ltd settled their unfair dismissal claim for £31,000 after the tribunal found the company breached the ACAS Code of Practice and dismissed without notice.
Settled · £31,000 · Apr 2023Settled£31,000Apr 2023District Nursing Team Leader (16 years' service) v Cardiff and Vale University Local Health Board
A district nursing team leader who raised concerns about inadequate PPE and risk assessments during the COVID-19 pandemic has won her claim for detriment against Cardiff and Vale University Local Health Board. The tribunal found she was isolated from her team and her role was changed after making protected disclosures.
Partial · Apr 2023Partial—Apr 2023Learning and Development Manager (5 years' service) v The Financial Reporting Council
A Learning and Development Manager with 5 years' service was unfairly dismissed after her employer placed her in a redundancy pool of one and made her compete externally for a new role. The tribunal awarded £21,696.25.
Won · £21,696 · Apr 2023Won£21,696Apr 2023Tanker driver (5 years' service) v Hoyer Gas & Petroleum Logistics Limited
A tanker driver was unfairly dismissed after failing to report dropping a hose on her foot, but the tribunal found she would have been dismissed anyway, awarding only £807.
Partial · £807 · Apr 2023Partial£807Apr 2023Tower crane operator (13 years' service) v London Tower Crane Hire and Sales Limited
A tower crane operator who resigned after being removed from a site without explanation and ignored during sick leave has won his constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal awarded £16,724.72.
Partial · £16,725 · Apr 2023Partial£16,725Apr 2023Mechanical technician (1 year 6 months' service) v United Kingdom Atomic Energy Authority
A mechanical technician who raised covid-19 safety concerns was investigated for setting up cryptocurrency miners on site. The tribunal dismissed his whistleblowing claim, finding the investigation was about the miners, not his disclosures.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Warehouse operative (5 months' service) v Lidl Great Britain Limited
A warehouse operative with five months' service who stopped attending work after a child maintenance deduction from his wages was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected all claims of unauthorised deductions and wrongful dismissal.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Business analyst (4-5 years' service) v Barclays PLC and others
A business analyst who resigned from Barclays in April 2021 but did not bring his claim until August 2022 had his case dismissed as out of time. The tribunal found his mental health condition did not prevent him from acting sooner.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Customer Accounts Officer (12 years' service) v Morrison Data Services (Water) Limited
A Customer Accounts Officer with 12 years' service resigned claiming constructive dismissal after a TUPE transfer. The tribunal dismissed both the unfair and wrongful dismissal claims, finding no repudiatory breach.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Employee (12 years' service) v Charles Briggs Ltd
A long-serving employee who holds a philosophical belief in bodily autonomy succeeded in a claim for unauthorised deductions from wages, but his discrimination complaints were dismissed. The tribunal awarded £13,700.18.
Partial · £13,700 · Apr 2023Partial£13,700Apr 2023Former employee v Slough Borough Council
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Slough Borough Council was dismissed after she and her representative failed to attend the final hearing, despite multiple attempts by the tribunal to contact them.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee v Kentucky Fried Chicken Limited
A wasted costs application against a former employee's solicitors was refused because, although their late responses were negligent, the preliminary hearing would have happened anyway.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Solid Surface Fitter (4 years' service) v Howden Joinery Limited
An employment tribunal has rejected an unfair dismissal claim from a solid surface fitter who was dismissed on capability grounds after two years of sickness absence, finding the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Car Parking Manager (10 years' service) v Westfield Europe Ltd
A 10-year employee who resigned claiming constructive dismissal after being furloughed, placed on a performance improvement plan and having his grievance rejected has lost his case. The tribunal found no fundamental breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Estate director (6 years' service) v Waltham Estate Resident Management Limited
An estate director with six years' service resigned after his employer failed to investigate his grievance and made an unsubstantiated fraud allegation. The tribunal awarded £36,087.48 for constructive unfair dismissal, with a 25% uplift for breaching the ACAS code.
Won · £36,087 · Apr 2023Won£36,087Apr 2023Registered manager (7 years' service) v J & Y Webber Services Limited
A registered manager with seven years' service was constructively dismissed after her employer failed to implement a promised Yorkshire Manager role, instead creating a new role that effectively demoted her. The tribunal awarded £14,594.38.
Won · £14,594 · Apr 2023Won£14,594Apr 2023Former employee v Mrs Patricia Bowey
A tribunal granted an extension for a late response from an employer with no legal experience who was ill, accepting the ET3 one working day late due to a communication error by her daughter.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Store manager (Vodafone franchise) v Kotak Communications Limited
A store manager who was off sick for over a year was fairly dismissed on capability grounds, the tribunal ruled, rejecting claims of disability discrimination and unfair dismissal.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee v GXO Logistics Drinks Ltd
A former employee's disability discrimination claim against GXO Logistics Drinks Ltd was struck out after he repeatedly failed to comply with tribunal orders to provide details of his claim. His unfair dismissal claim was also dismissed for lack of jurisdiction due to insufficient service.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee v Mr Anthony Goodrich and Openmart Ltd
A former employee's race and age discrimination claims were automatically dismissed after she failed to comply with an Unless Order, and her remaining claims were struck out for non-compliance and lack of active pursuit.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Customer Assistant (12 years' service) v Marks and Spencer PLC
A customer assistant with 12 years' service resigned after a delay in his grievance response. The tribunal found no repudiatory breach, and his constructive dismissal claim was dismissed.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Senior Healthcare Assistant (5 years' service) v Guys and St Thomas NHS Foundation Trust
A tribunal has ruled that a Senior Healthcare Assistant's opposition to the Coronavirus pandemic and preventative measures like PCR tests and face masks does not amount to a protected philosophical belief under the Equality Act 2010. The claim was dismissed.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Teacher (Course Leader for Ethics and Philosophy, 8 years' service) v Better Futures Multi-Academy Trust
A tribunal found that a teacher's dismissal for gross misconduct after visiting a student's home was fair, but the school breached his contract by dismissing without notice.
Partial · Apr 2023Partial—Apr 2023Science teacher v Enrich Learning Trust
A science teacher who filed her tribunal claim 73 days late has had her unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims dismissed. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for her to have claimed on time.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee v Octo Members Group Ltd
A former employee who lost his sense of taste and smell after a brain injury failed to prove he was disabled, as the tribunal found his symptoms were not likely to last 12 months. His disability discrimination claim was dismissed.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Stable Lass/Work Rider (2 years 8 months' service) v Richard Fulke Johnson and Eve Johnson Houghton T/A Eve Johnson Houghton Racing
A stable lass who signed a settlement agreement under pressure to get an eviction letter has won the right to bring her pregnancy discrimination claim. The tribunal set aside the COT3 agreement on grounds of duress.
Won · Apr 2023Won—Apr 2023Taxi insurance renewals specialist (12 years' service) v Grayson Insurance (Consultants) Ltd
A taxi insurance renewals specialist with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed after his employer found he had fraudulently claimed overtime. The tribunal upheld the dismissal but awarded £1,032 for unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £1,032 · Apr 2023Partial£1,032Apr 2023Healthcare assistant (6 years' service) v Guy's and St Thomas's NHS Foundation Trust
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a healthcare assistant with six years' service who slapped a colleague on the cheek during handover, finding the NHS trust acted reasonably.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Senior customer service adviser (15 months' service) v Saint-Gobain Building Distribution Ltd t/a Jewson
A senior customer service adviser with less than two years' service had his unfair dismissal claim thrown out for being presented 4.5 months late, but his discrimination claims will proceed to a full hearing.
Partial · Apr 2023Partial—Apr 2023Housing Solutions Assistant / Independent Living Prevention and Local Welfare Provision Officer (3 years 7 months' service) v Central Bedfordshire Council
A Housing Solutions Assistant with PTSD was fairly dismissed after a lengthy sickness absence when he refused all redeployment options, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee (school staff) v Al Iman Community Educational Services Ltd.
A school staff member who claimed she was unfairly dismissed after an investigation meeting was found by the tribunal to have resigned voluntarily. Her claim was dismissed and she was ordered to pay £300 in costs.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee v STA Travel Ltd (a company in creditors’ voluntary liquidation)
Five former employees of STA Travel Ltd have won a protective award after the company made them redundant without any collective consultation. The tribunal found that the company proposed to dismiss 20 or more employees at one establishment within 90 days.
Partial · Apr 2023Partial—Apr 2023Enablement Assistant (13 years' service) v City of Bradford Metropolitan District Council
A tribunal has dismissed claims of constructive unfair dismissal and disability discrimination brought by an enablement assistant with 13 years' service after her employer refused her request for reduced weekend-only hours.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee v Ryecourt Limited
A former employee succeeded in claims for constructive unfair dismissal and unauthorised wage deductions against Ryecourt Limited, but his disability discrimination and whistleblowing claims were dismissed.
Partial · Apr 2023Partial—Apr 2023Consultant haematologist (33 years' service) v Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust
A consultant haematologist with 33 years' service lost his unfair dismissal claim after the tribunal ruled he filed it 89 days late. The claim was struck out because it was reasonably practicable for him to have submitted it on time.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee v Revere Riverside Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after her employer was dissolved and she could not afford the £585 fee to restore it to the register.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Community Hub Director (11 years' service) v Santander UK PLC
A Community Hub Director with 11 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after allegedly faking a stolen card. The tribunal struck out his unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims as having no reasonable prospects of success.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Head Housekeeper (3 years' service) v Griffin Catering Services Ltd
A head housekeeper was unfairly dismissed after failing to return from Bulgaria on 48 hours' notice. The tribunal found the appeal was not conducted with an open mind, but reduced compensation by 80% for her contribution.
Partial · £3,202 · Apr 2023Partial£3,202Apr 2023Former employee (driver) v Travis Perkins Trading Co Ltd
A former driver's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims were struck out after the tribunal found they had no reasonable prospects of success and were submitted late.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Personal Assistant (1 year 10 months' service) v Disability Initiative Services Limited
A personal assistant who was required to stay home after her son developed a cough was owed £110.79 in pay, but her whistleblowing unfair dismissal claim was rejected because the redundancy decision came before the protected disclosure.
Partial · £111 · Apr 2023Partial£111Apr 2023Former employee (bus driver) v Arriva The Shires Limited
A former bus driver's claims for constructive dismissal and race discrimination were struck out after he presented his claim five months late and failed to attend the final hearing.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Charity shop manager (9 months' service) v Parity for Disability
A charity shop manager who resigned after her probation was extended lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found no link between her protected disclosures and the employer's actions.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee v Sullivan Bus and Coach Limited
A former employee's claims of sex, sexual orientation and victimisation discrimination against Sullivan Bus and Coach Limited were dismissed by the Watford Employment Tribunal. The unfair dismissal complaint had already been struck out.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee (10 years' service) v Fonmigo Limited
Fonmigo Limited conceded it unfairly dismissed a long-serving employee. The tribunal awarded £85,709.92, including a basic award of £5,710 and a capped compensatory award of £79,999.92.
Won · £85,710 · Apr 2023Won£85,710Apr 2023Factory Manager (13 years' service) v SIPS (UK) Ltd
A factory manager with 13 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after a wall saw fell during unloading, causing damage and minor injuries. The tribunal upheld the decision, citing a reasonable investigation and a breakdown in trust.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Lecturer in forensic science (12 years' service) v Capital City College Group
A lecturer with 12 years' service resigned after her flexible working request was refused. The tribunal held that the employer's conduct did not amount to a fundamental breach of contract.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee v Welbeck House Limited (in liquidation)
A former employee's claim for a protective award after redundancy has been dismissed by the Nottingham tribunal because it was brought well after the three-month time limit and the claimant did not attend the hearing.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Trainee pharmacy adviser v Boots Management Services Limited
A trainee pharmacy adviser who alleged she was discriminated against because of her race and sex when she was not signed off her training programme has had her claims dismissed by the Reading Employment Tribunal.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee (Nigerian national) v University College London Hospital
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out because it was presented eight and a half months after the three-month time limit expired. The tribunal found that neither his depression nor the ongoing internal appeal made it 'not reasonably practicable' to file on time.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee v Plastic Omnium Auto Exteriors
A former employee lost their unfair dismissal claim against Plastic Omnium Auto Exteriors but secured £509.26 in a consent order for unauthorised deductions and unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £509 · Apr 2023Partial£509Apr 2023Senior Nursery Practitioner (3 years' service) v Swans Day Nurseries Ltd
A senior nursery practitioner was unfairly dismissed after her employer fabricated an allegation that she was under the influence of alcohol at work. The Watford tribunal awarded £5,325.75, including a 25% Acas uplift for ignoring the code of practice.
Won · £5,326 · Apr 2023Won£5,326Apr 2023Reablement Support Worker (19 months' service) v North East London NHS Foundation Trust
The tribunal dismissed all claims by a former NHS support worker who alleged he was unfairly dismissed for raising concerns about PPE, finding that his disclosures were not protected and his dismissal was due to gross misconduct involving homophobic harassment.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Quality Improvement Manager (probationary employee) v BPP University Ltd
A Quality Improvement Manager dismissed while on probation after her miscarriage lost her unfair dismissal and discrimination claims. The tribunal found the decision was based on genuine performance concerns and a breakdown in working relationships, not pregnancy.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former director/manager of seasonal decorations business (16 years' service) v Chic Flower Design Limited (in liquidation)
A director with 16 years' service was dismissed days after being told he was 'too expensive' and 'no longer needed'. The tribunal found the real reason was not misconduct but cost-cutting, and awarded £61,298.
Won · £61,298 · Apr 2023Won£61,298Apr 2023Finance Officer (23 years' service) v The Governing Body of Kingsbury High School
A tribunal struck out claims of unfair dismissal, disability discrimination and victimisation brought by a finance officer with 23 years' service who was dismissed after 32 months' sick leave following a cancer diagnosis.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Manufacturing operative (18 years' service) v Anglian Windows Limited
An 18-year employee who walked out after being asked to work on a different line and later resigned has lost his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found his evidence dishonest and that the employer had acted reasonably.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Skilled labourer (26 years' service) v Balfour Beatty Group Employment Limited
A severely dyslexic labourer who could not read or write was granted an extension to bring an unfair dismissal claim against Balfour Beatty, after the tribunal found it was not reasonably practicable for him to meet the deadline.
Won · Apr 2023Won—Apr 2023Head Baker (6 years' service) v Leakers Limited
A head baker with six years' service was dismissed for poor-quality bread without any formal warning or right to appeal. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair and awarded £15,703, reduced by 50% for his own conduct.
Partial · £15,703 · Apr 2023Partial£15,703Apr 2023Night reception team member v Whitbread Plc
A Premier Inn night receptionist was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after a guest complained someone entered their room. CCTV and key access logs showed the claimant on the floor and using his key twice that night.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Drainage surveying manager (2 years' service) v Jet Maintenance Limited
A drainage surveying manager was unfairly dismissed after a verbal altercation with a director. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and appeal were predetermined, awarding £3,345 in compensation.
Won · £3,345 · Apr 2023Won£3,345Apr 2023General maintenance worker (13 years' service) v A Mead & K Hawke Farming
A general maintenance worker with 13 years' service had his unfair dismissal claim thrown out after submitting it 35 days past the deadline. The tribunal ruled it was reasonably practicable for him to have claimed on time.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023General Manager (36 years' service) v Charles Wares Classic Car Sales and Hire Ltd
A tribunal has allowed age and sex discrimination claims to proceed against a car sales company, while striking out an unfair dismissal claim because the claimant was not employed by the respondent at the time of dismissal.
Partial · Apr 2023Partial—Apr 2023Former employee v Malvern Tyres (Wholesale) Limited
A former employee who brought an unfair dismissal claim with less than two years' service had the claim struck out after failing to comply with tribunal orders or respond to warnings.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee v Stabby Limited
A former employee with a disability was directly discriminated against when she was dismissed, and the tribunal also found the employer failed to pay the national minimum wage and made unauthorised deductions. Total compensation of £5,537.38 was awarded.
Partial · Apr 2023Partial—Apr 2023Former employee v Harrods Ltd
A former Harrods employee's application for interim relief was dismissed by the tribunal, but he was allowed to amend his claim to include ordinary unfair and wrongful dismissal.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee v First Transpennine Express Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after he presented it one week late and failed to explain the delay or attend the hearing.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Venue stylist/stationery assistant (5 months' service) v Flossie's Wedding Limited
A venue stylist dismissed during probation for poor performance failed to prove wrongful dismissal. The tribunal found no breach of contract even though the employer had no written disciplinary or grievance policies.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee (8 years' service) v Paperchase Products Ltd (in administration)
A former employee's second unfair dismissal claim against Paperchase Products Ltd was struck out as an abuse of process, and his bid to force the Secretary of State to pay a basic award without a tribunal decision failed.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Driver (6 years' service) v Eastbrook Logistics Ltd
A driver with six years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after urinating on a loading dock in full view of CCTV. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision, finding the dismissal was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Head priest (4 years' service) v Singh Sabha London East
A head priest who was paid £390 per month without tax or NI deductions saw his unfair dismissal claim thrown out after the tribunal found the employment contract was illegally performed.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee v South Wales Campers Limited
An employment tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal claim after the former employee failed to attend the final hearing and did not respond to any tribunal communications. The respondent believed the claim had been settled directly.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Priest (Purohit) at a Hindu Mandir v Trustees of Vishwa Hindu Parishad - a registered charity
A Hindu priest who was summarily dismissed after a dispute over Covid-19 safety measures has won his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal awarded £15,924, reduced by 40% for his own conduct.
Won · £15,924 · Apr 2023Won£15,924Apr 2023Kitchen porter (3 years' service) v Mildreds Ltd
A kitchen porter who was dismissed after managers smelled marijuana from his bike bag had his unfair dismissal claim rejected, but won £3,618 after a tribunal found a manager's assumption he was intoxicated was based on a racial stereotype.
Partial · £3,618 · Apr 2023Partial£3,618Apr 2023Former employee (65 years old at dismissal) v Tarmac Trading Ltd
A tribunal threw out unfair dismissal and age discrimination claims brought 83 days late, finding the claimant had no reasonable excuse for the delay despite having access to ACAS and online resources.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Security Officer (3 years 9 months' service) v Corps Security (UK) Limited
A security officer who feinted a punch at a cadet after being sworn at was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected his claim that a colleague was treated more leniently for a similar incident.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee v London Underground Limited
A former employee who brought claims of unfair dismissal and discrimination against London Underground Limited has had all his claims struck out after failing to attend two preliminary hearings and not responding to tribunal orders.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Contract manager (3 years' service) v Bridge Facilities Engineers Limited
A contract manager who asked to work from home temporarily because his son was clinically vulnerable was dismissed for purported redundancy. The tribunal found the real reason was his home-working request and awarded £38,758.
Won · £38,759 · Apr 2023Won£38,759Apr 2023Former employee (supplied via agency) v The Commissioners for His Majesty's Revenue and Customs
A former agency worker who waited over three years to bring an unfair dismissal and race discrimination claim had his case struck out as having no reasonable prospects of success. He was also ordered to pay £4,203 in costs.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023House Manager (4 years' service) v Jewish Blind and Physically Disabled Society
A house manager with four years' service was unfairly dismissed after giving a vulnerable tenant two paracetamol tablets and a hot water bottle. The tribunal awarded £17,266.74, finding the employer had no reasonable grounds to believe the actions were dangerous.
Won · £17,267 · Apr 2023Won£17,267Apr 2023Booking Coordinator (probationary employee) v London Fire Commissioner
A Booking Coordinator who was dismissed during her probation for attendance issues failed to prove disability discrimination. The tribunal found the London Fire Commissioner acted reasonably given her short service and multiple probation extensions.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee (8 years' service) v Lodge Security Limited
A former employee's widow secured £16,821 in compensation after Lodge Security Limited failed to attend hearings or comply with tribunal orders, leading to the response being struck out.
Won · £16,821 · Apr 2023Won£16,821Apr 2023Teaching assistant (3 years' service) v Emmaus Catholic Academy Trust
A teaching assistant who alleged five incidents of race discrimination and harassment by her head teacher has lost her claims, with the tribunal finding the school acted for genuine operational reasons.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Waitress (zero-hours contract) v The Aviator Hotel Ltd
A waitress on a zero-hours contract who was excluded from a redundancy process has had her unfair dismissal claim dismissed, after a tribunal ruled she was never an employee.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Barmaid (3 years' service) v Real Bars Ltd
A barmaid with three years' service was unfairly dismissed when her employer sacked her by text message without notice. The tribunal awarded her £8,619.38 in compensation for unpaid wages, holiday pay, notice pay, and unfair dismissal.
Won · £8,619 · Apr 2023Won£8,619Apr 2023Chief Human Resources Officer (CHRO) on Executive Committee v Co-operative Group Limited
A Chief Human Resources Officer was unfairly dismissed by Co-operative Group Limited after a sex-biased performance appraisal and a flawed reorganisation. The tribunal awarded £101,373 in compensation.
Partial · £101,373 · Apr 2023Partial£101,373Apr 2023Former employee v Marian Langford T/A Towyn Capel Residential Home
A former employee who failed to comply with tribunal orders and did not pursue her unfair dismissal claim had it struck out. She was later ordered to pay £1,374.80 in preparation time costs.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee v Stanhay Webb Ltd
A former employee's claim against Stanhay Webb Ltd was struck out because the claim form was incomprehensible and the claimant failed to clarify it, even after being given a chance.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Driver (lorry driver) v Metal Processing Limited
A lorry driver was dismissed with immediate effect when his employer decided to make him redundant, with no warning, consultation, or fair selection process. The tribunal awarded £6,278.38.
Won · £6,278 · Apr 2023Won£6,278Apr 2023Store Manager (7 years 9 months' service) v B & M Retail Limited
A tribunal has dismissed all claims of disability discrimination and unfair dismissal brought by a store manager with 7 years' service who was sacked for failing to enforce social distancing and misleading Test and Trace during the pandemic.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee v Lunar Automotive Limited
A former employee won a constructive unfair dismissal claim after his employer failed to pay wages, holiday pay and notice pay. The tribunal awarded over £14,000 after the employer's response was struck out for non-attendance.
Won · £14,017 · Apr 2023Won£14,017Apr 2023Trade Counter Sales Manager (2 years 11 months' service) v Charles Watts Engineering Limited
A Trade Counter Sales Manager who raised COVID-19 safety concerns was unfairly dismissed after his employer gathered customer complaints against him. The tribunal found the investigation and disciplinary process were flawed.
Partial · Apr 2023Partial—Apr 2023Former employee v SteamCardiff Limited
A former employee who was not paid her accrued holiday pay or notice pay has been awarded £3,060.72 by an employment tribunal. Her claims for unfair dismissal and age discrimination were dismissed.
Partial · £3,061 · Apr 2023Partial£3,061Apr 2023Finance Assistant (12 years' service) v Lexington Catering Ltd
A finance assistant with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed for long-term sickness after her employer provided extensive support and considered redeployment. The tribunal upheld the decision, finding it within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Chief Product Officer (3 years' service) v Tendable Limited
A Chief Product Officer who moved to part-time work was unfairly dismissed after being replaced and subjected to detriment. The tribunal awarded £41,735.70, including an ACAS uplift for failing to follow grievance procedures.
Won · £41,736 · Apr 2023Won£41,736Apr 2023Optical assistant (10 years' service) v Fairford Opticians Limited
An optical assistant with 10 years' service was dismissed after making a harassing phone call from her employer's line. Her unfair dismissal claim was struck out for having no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Marketing associate (1 year 4 months' service) v Arapina Bakery Ltd
A marketing associate who shouted at his boss and threatened to force entry into the bakery was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected his claim for notice pay.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Domestic Assistant (4 years' service) v Sussex Health Care Limited
A domestic assistant with 4 years' service was fairly dismissed after entering a care home without following infection control measures. The tribunal found the employer's belief in gross misconduct was reasonable and the process was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Head Chef/Kitchen Manager (3 months' service) v United Kitchen Concepts Ltd
A head chef who stopped attending work after a dispute over hours and overtime was dismissed for unauthorised absence. The tribunal struck out his unfair dismissal claim due to insufficient service and rejected his remaining pay claims.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former COO and director of a digital publishing company v Greencastle MM LLP
A former COO and director of a digital publishing company could not claim unfair dismissal or a redundancy payment because he did not have sufficient continuous employment. The tribunal ruled there was no TUPE transfer, associated employer relationship, or successor employer.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Apprentice roofer (10 months' service) v Mr Kevin Mason t/a Kevin Mason Roofing Services
An apprentice roofer with 10 months' service was wrongfully dismissed after raising health and safety concerns. The tribunal awarded £3,012.50 for breach of his common law apprenticeship contract.
Partial · £3,013 · Apr 2023Partial£3,013Apr 2023Care worker (9 months' service) v Heheals Pharmaceutical Services Ltd t/a Christchurch Care
A care worker with nine months' service was constructively dismissed after reporting a colleague's failure to wear PPE and other concerns. The tribunal found she was subjected to detriments and victimised for making protected disclosures.
Partial · Apr 2023Partial—Apr 2023Sales employee (commission-based) v Maple Green Fine Foods Limited
A sales employee who claimed she was underpaid commission by Maple Green Fine Foods has been awarded £2,653.06, but her allegations of sex and age discrimination and pregnancy-related dismissal were dismissed.
Partial · £2,653 · Apr 2023Partial£2,653Apr 2023Trainee manager (3 years' service) v Joyners Plants Limited
A trainee manager who resigned claiming constructive dismissal lost his case, but the tribunal awarded £140 for unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £140 · Apr 2023Partial£140Apr 2023Senior ER Adviser (4 years' service) v St George’s University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
A senior ER adviser who claimed unfair dismissal and a redundancy payment had her case struck out because she presented the claim while still employed. The tribunal said it had no reasonable prospects of success.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee v Capita Business Services Limited
A former employee who brought claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination against Capita Business Services Limited reached a settlement at the final hearing, avoiding a full trial.
Settled · Apr 2023Settled—Apr 2023Former employee v Seqirus UK Ltd
A tribunal struck out a former employee's unfair dismissal, age discrimination, and disability discrimination claims after he failed to respond to case management orders and a strike-out warning.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Employee, shareholder and director v Arcstream Ltd (In Liquidation)
A director and shareholder was summarily dismissed without any disciplinary process or notice. The tribunal awarded £16,916.86 for unfair dismissal and breach of contract.
Won · £16,917 · Apr 2023Won£16,917Apr 2023Labelling staff/warehouse team member (22 years' service) v PIE Pharma Limited
A labelling worker with 22 years' service was handed a dismissal letter without any prior consultation. The tribunal found the redundancy unfair and awarded £2,616.71.
Won · £2,617 · Apr 2023Won£2,617Apr 2023Former employee (certification suspended after dismissal) v Isle of Wight NHS Trust
The tribunal dismissed unfair and wrongful dismissal claims after the claimant failed to attend the final hearing, and ordered her to pay £1,400 in costs for repeated delays and non-compliance.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee v Kloo Ltd
A former employee won £895.99 after being dismissed without notice and having unauthorised deductions taken from his wages. The tribunal found Kloo Ltd in breach of contract.
Partial · £896 · Apr 2023Partial£896Apr 2023Lead Medical Practitioner (GP, 6 months' service) v BUPA Occupational Health Limited
A GP dismissed during her six-month probation for performance issues lost her whistleblowing claim after a majority tribunal found she had not made any protected disclosures. No compensation awarded.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee v The Collective (Living) Limited (in administration)
A tribunal dismissed a former employee's claim against her employer's insurer, finding the insurer was entitled to avoid the policy because the employer had dismissed her against legal advice. No damages were awarded.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Car mechanic v AJSHM Limited
A car mechanic who claimed unfair dismissal and redundancy pay had his case struck out after he failed to comply with a tribunal order and ignored a strike-out warning. The tribunal decided the claim should be dismissed due to non-compliance.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee v Rayburn Trading Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out because he did not have two years' continuous service and failed to attend a preliminary hearing or comply with tribunal orders.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Primary school teacher (2 years' service) v Orchard Prep Ltd
A tribunal ruled that a teacher who invoiced via her limited company was an employee from September 2019, enabling her to pursue claims for unfair dismissal and whistleblowing.
Won · Apr 2023Won—Apr 2023Bus driver (14 months' service) v D&G Bus Limited
A bus driver who resigned after a dispute about unpaid leave and alleged unfair treatment during the pandemic has lost all his claims at an employment tribunal.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Engagement and Involvement Manager (9 years' service) v NHS Cheshire and Merseyside Integrated Care Board
A manager with nine years' service failed to prove he was constructively dismissed or discriminated against after resigning from NHS Cheshire and Merseyside Integrated Care Board. The tribunal dismissed all claims including disability discrimination, harassment, and whistleblowing detriment.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Warehouse/Transport Supervisor (12 years' service) v City Plumbing Supplies Holdings Limited
A warehouse supervisor with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed after falsifying stock counts while already on a final written warning for driving an overloaded vehicle. The tribunal found the employer followed a reasonable process.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee v London EV Company Limited
An employment tribunal refused to strike out a former employee's disability discrimination claim despite years of missed deadlines, but imposed strict conditions to get the case to trial.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Commercial Director (19 months' service) v Peterborough Limited
A black African Commercial Director dismissed without notice or consultation after a TUPE transfer lost his race discrimination claim. The tribunal found no evidence that race played any part in the decision.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Casting associate (8 years' service) v BBC Studios Productions Ltd
A casting associate who asked for voluntary redundancy to care for his father lost his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal held the employment ended by mutual agreement, not dismissal.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Acting manager (32 years' service) v Hindle Gears Limited
A tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal claim from an acting manager with 32 years' service because he filed it too late, despite multiple ACAS contacts and an ongoing appeal.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Bar person and keyholder (4 years' service) v Ravensworth Golf Club
A bar person who believed the time limit for an unfair dismissal claim ran from her appeal outcome rather than her dismissal date had her claim dismissed as out of time. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for her to have presented the claim on time.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Care home worker (13 days' service) v Four Seasons (No 7) Limited
A care worker who was dismissed after just 13 days for reporting a colleague's abuse of a resident has won her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal awarded £4,217.68 in compensation.
Partial · £4,218 · Apr 2023Partial£4,218Apr 2023Prison officer (14 years' service) v Secretary of State for Justice
A prison officer with 14 years' service had his unfair dismissal claim rejected as out of time after a union email was lost in a junk folder, leaving him 10 days late in filing.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee (prisoner work placement) v Bernard Matthews Foods Limited
A former prisoner working at Bernard Matthews had his unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal and sex discrimination claims struck out because of short service, late presentation and lack of evidence.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employees v Orthios (Anglesey) Technologies Ltd (In Administration)
Former employees of Orthios (Anglesey) Technologies Ltd won a protective award after the company failed to consult them before making redundancies. The tribunal awarded 90 days' pay.
Won · Apr 2023Won—Apr 2023Senior Creative Designer (2 years 8 months' service) v Herbalife Europe Ltd
A senior creative designer's constructive unfair dismissal claim was struck out as out of time, but her direct sex discrimination claim was allowed to proceed on just and equitable grounds.
Partial · Apr 2023Partial—Apr 2023Warehouse operative (7 months' service) v DHL Services Ltd
A tribunal rejected disability discrimination claims from a warehouse operative with a shoulder deformity who was dismissed for breaching health and safety rules by not reporting an injury. The employer's actions were found to be proportionate and not discriminatory.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Payroll administrator and receptionist (20 years' service) v Johnsons Financial Management Ltd
A payroll administrator with 20 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed capability process that lacked warnings, investigation, and an appeal. The tribunal awarded £28,333, including a 25% uplift for failing to follow the ACAS Code.
Won · £28,333 · Mar 2023Won£28,333Mar 2023Chef (former employee) v Gold Panda Limited
A chef was unfairly dismissed after her employment transferred to a new company under TUPE. The tribunal awarded over £12,800 for unfair dismissal, plus compensation for failure to inform and consult, unpaid holiday pay, and lost pension contributions.
Partial · £12,882 · Mar 2023Partial£12,882Mar 2023Headteacher (5 years 6 months' service) v Governing Body of Northwood Community Primary School and Knowsley Metropolitan Borough Council
A headteacher with over five years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed investigation into his decision to engage a former teacher subject to a Prohibition Order. The tribunal found the employer failed to consider alternatives to dismissal.
Won · Mar 2023Won—Mar 2023Former employee v Yumilicious Ltd
A former employee of Yumilicious Ltd had their unfair dismissal claim struck out because they had worked there for less than two years. They were awarded £880 for unauthorised deductions from wages.
Dismissed · £880 · Mar 2023Dismissed£880Mar 2023Postman (16 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A postman with 16 years' service who took undelivered mail home on Christmas Eve had his unfair dismissal claim struck out after the tribunal found his conduct during proceedings was scandalous, unreasonable, and vexatious.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee v Sami Husseyin
A former employee was awarded £26,668 after being dismissed because of pregnancy and pregnancy-related illness. The tribunal found the employer, a sole trader, discriminated against her and unfairly dismissed her.
Won · £26,668 · Mar 2023Won£26,668Mar 2023Registered general nurses (RGNs) at a care home v Aspen Care Village Ltd
Three Romanian nurses claimed race discrimination after a care home reported them to police for removing a deceased resident's belongings. The tribunal dismissed all claims, finding the employer's actions were based on their professional duties, not race.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Shift manager (2 years' service) v XPO Logistics UK Limited
A shift manager who resigned after her line manager's sarcastic comment and a refused flexible working request lost her constructive dismissal claim. The tribunal found she had affirmed the contract by continuing to work.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Waking Night Support worker (16 months' service) v BS Project Services Limited t/a BS Social Care
A tribunal confirmed it had no power to hear a waking night support worker's claim for damages after a service user threw a fire extinguisher at him, because the claim was for personal injury – which falls outside the employment tribunal's jurisdiction.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Security guard (mental health officer) v Atalian Servest Security Services Limited
A security guard who claimed constructive dismissal after his manager posted a complaint about him in a staff WhatsApp group lost his case because he delayed resigning and continued to engage with his employer.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Temporary employee (agency worker) v Brook Street (UK) Ltd
An agency worker won her claim for unlawful deduction of wages after being paid late for a March 2020 shift, but received no compensation as the sum was paid in May 2020. Her claim that she should have been furloughed was dismissed.
Partial · Mar 2023Partial—Mar 2023Former employee (6 years' service) v Tesco Store Limited
A Tesco employee with six years' service was unfairly dismissed after being accused of smoking cannabis on the premises. The tribunal awarded £4,395.25 in compensation.
Partial · £4,395 · Mar 2023Partial£4,395Mar 2023Care Assistant (2 years' service) v WT UK OPCO Ltd (formerly Gracewell Healthcare 3 Ltd)
A care assistant with two years' service was unfairly dismissed for alleged gross misconduct after a flawed investigation. The tribunal awarded £27,316, including a 25% ACAS uplift for the employer's failure to follow the ACAS Code.
Won · £27,316 · Mar 2023Won£27,316Mar 2023Medical secretary (11 years' service) v Surrey and Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust
An NHS medical secretary who resigned over workload and grievance handling lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the Trust had not breached the implied term of trust and confidence.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Accounts and Payroll Assistant (8 years' service) v Allcap Limited
An accounts assistant who resigned after an unsatisfactory grievance outcome lost her constructive dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer's conduct did not destroy trust and confidence.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Fleet Sales Assistant (4 years' service) v Ssangyong Motor UK Limited
A fleet sales assistant who was made redundant after returning from maternity leave has lost her claims of unfair dismissal and discrimination. The tribunal found the redundancy was genuine and her discrimination claims were out of time.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Process Manager (5 years' service) v TFC Holdings London Limited
A Process Manager who had his entire fortnightly pay withheld was constructively dismissed. The Watford tribunal awarded him £54,819.16 for unfair dismissal, notice pay, and pay statement breaches.
Partial · £54,819 · Mar 2023Partial£54,819Mar 2023Former employee v Network Rail Infrastructure Limited
A former employee won an unfair dismissal claim against Network Rail Infrastructure Limited, but saw compensation slashed by 80% because they would have been dismissed anyway, plus a further deduction for failing to look for work.
Won · £22,771 · Mar 2023Won£22,771Mar 2023Practice manager (6 years' service) v Firvale Clinic Limited
A practice manager who was dismissed via a WhatsApp message after a Christmas party incident has been awarded £12,431 after an employment tribunal found the dismissal procedurally unfair and outside the range of reasonable responses.
Won · £12,431 · Mar 2023Won£12,431Mar 2023Support worker (7 years' service) v Creative Support Ltd
A support worker with 7 years' service was fairly dismissed after refusing to wear a face mask or a visor in the office. The tribunal found the employer acted within the band of reasonable responses.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Registered Manager (7 years' service) v Trentside Manor Care Limited
A registered manager with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed and discriminated against after her employer used a minor incident as a pretext to dismiss her for requesting flexible working due to disability.
Won · £100,840 · Mar 2023Won£100,840Mar 2023Former employee v HYPHA Restaurants Limited
A former employee of HYPHA Restaurants Limited has won £5,421.70 after the company dismissed her with only one week's notice instead of the contractual month, and failed to pay pension contributions and holiday pay.
Won · £5,422 · Mar 2023Won£5,422Mar 2023General assistant (12 years' service) v Sainsbury’s Supermarkets Limited
A Sainsbury's general assistant with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed after posting accusations of racist mindsets on Yammer and breaching suspension conditions. The tribunal rejected claims of automatic unfair dismissal and victimisation.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Operations Manager (6 months' service) v Demicon Limited
An operations manager with asthma was constructively dismissed after being placed on short-time work for raising health and safety concerns during the first COVID-19 lockdown. The tribunal awarded £27,871 in damages.
Partial · £27,871 · Mar 2023Partial£27,871Mar 2023Former employee v Greenbrook Healthcare (Hounslow) Limited
A preliminary hearing ruled that a former employee's asthma and hypertension were disabilities under the Equality Act, but arteriosclerosis and cardiomyopathy were not. No damages awarded as this was a preliminary issue.
Partial · Mar 2023Partial—Mar 2023Beauty therapist (3 years' service) v Monas Beauty Lounge
A beauty therapist with three years' service was unfairly dismissed after her employer refused a last-minute leave request and told her not to come back. The tribunal awarded £22,073.20, including a 20% uplift for failing to follow the ACAS Code.
Won · £22,073 · Mar 2023Won£22,073Mar 2023Head chef and manager (4 years' service) v Affinity18 Limited
A head chef and manager who was effectively dismissed after being asked to drop off keys, and who never received a written contract, has been awarded £7,861.30 for unfair dismissal, breach of contract, and unauthorised deductions from wages.
Partial · £7,861 · Mar 2023Partial£7,861Mar 2023Former employee v Alma Ironcraft Limited (Creditors Voluntary Liquidation)
A former employee who waited over a year to claim a redundancy payment lost his case because he missed the strict six-month time limit. The tribunal refused to extend time.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Senior Nurse (Ward Manager, 1 year 3 months' service) v Elysium Healthcare Limited
A Ward Manager with 15 months' service claimed four white colleagues made false statements due to her race. The tribunal found no racial motivation and dismissed the claim.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Teaching and Learning Assistant (18 years' service) v Southend East Community Academy Trust
A teaching assistant dismissed for a Facebook post about her school was too late to bring an unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal ruled it was reasonably practicable for her to have filed in time, despite her stress and anxiety.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Teaching Assistant v Three Milestone Education Ltd
A teaching assistant was unfairly dismissed over a cocaine incident at a special needs school, but received no compensation because she would have been sacked anyway. A second assistant won a disability discrimination claim after her mother was refused as a companion at her disciplinary hearing.
Partial · Mar 2023Partial—Mar 2023Former employee v Bryn Labour Club
A former employee of Bryn Labour Club was unfairly dismissed, but the tribunal reduced her compensation by 75% for contributory conduct and a further 50% for the chance she would have been dismissed anyway, leaving a total award of £1,995.79.
Won · £1,996 · Mar 2023Won£1,996Mar 2023Blind installer (7 years' service) v Brian English T/A Insignia Shade & Shutter Company
A blind installer who accepted an offer to leave with 7 weeks' pay was found to have been dismissed, not to have resigned. The tribunal rejected the employer's claim for damages over alleged poor work.
Partial · Mar 2023Partial—Mar 2023Senior policy adviser (Grade 6) v Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
A senior policy adviser who resigned after her bullying grievance was rejected has lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer's actions did not breach trust and confidence.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Micrologic Property Holdings Limited
A former employee who withdrew their claim shortly before a hearing was ordered to pay £1,200 in costs. The employer's bid to have the award reconsidered has been refused.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Nurse Practitioner (4 years 11 months' service) v Drs M P Clarke and M R Sarrington T/a Solent View Medical Practice
A nurse practitioner with anxiety who resigned after her request for a dongle was refused has lost her disability discrimination claims. The tribunal found the practice acted reasonably.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Motor technician (8 years' service) v Leinster Motor Engineering Ltd
A motor technician who was dismissed for unauthorised absence after a dispute over furlough pay won £2,860 for unpaid holiday and missing written particulars, but lost his unfair dismissal claim.
Partial · £2,861 · Mar 2023Partial£2,861Mar 2023Former employee v Callacab (UK) Ltd (in liquidation)
A former employee won over £41,000 in compensation for sex discrimination and unfair dismissal after her employer failed to defend the claim.
Won · £41,205 · Mar 2023Won£41,205Mar 2023Recruitment consultant (less than 2 years' service) v FDS Recruitment Ltd
A recruitment consultant with less than two years' service won £15,280 after their employer failed to pay wages, holiday pay, commission and notice pay. The company did not attend the hearing.
Won · £15,280 · Mar 2023Won£15,280Mar 2023Technical Manager (11 years' service) v James Finlay Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a technical manager with 11 years' service, finding that the employer's formal performance process was fair and that the dismissal was for capability, not race discrimination.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Alan Holmes t/a Art Services
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out because they had worked for the employer for less than two years. However, they won a small award for unpaid notice pay.
Partial · £566 · Mar 2023Partial£566Mar 2023Job applicant (cruise ship entertainment host) v Carnival plc t/a Carnival UK
A cruise ship entertainment host applicant with bipolar disorder lost his discrimination and victimisation claims after a tribunal found the rejection was based on interview performance, not his disability or previous tribunal claim.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Mr H Thompson t/a Thompson & Co
A former employee has won £36,000 in a constructive unfair dismissal and holiday pay claim after the employer conceded liability on the day of the hearing.
Won · £36,000 · Mar 2023Won£36,000Mar 2023Band 6 Deputy Team Leader/Clinical Charge Nurse (Mental Health Nurse) v South West London & St Georges Mental Health NHS Trust
A mental health nurse who resigned after her employer failed to support her return to work was actually dismissed during her notice period without a fair reason. The trust admitted unfair dismissal and wrongful dismissal.
Partial · Mar 2023Partial—Mar 2023Nursery worker (2 years' service) v Bright Eyes Day Care Nursery Ltd.
A nursery worker with two years' service was unfairly dismissed for refusing to work her contractual hours, but her whistleblowing claims failed. She was awarded £959 in compensation.
Partial · £959 · Mar 2023Partial£959Mar 2023Postman (27 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Limited
A postman who collected mail 11 minutes early and scanned the barcode away from the box was unfairly dismissed. The tribunal found Royal Mail ignored his mental health and failed to follow proper procedures.
Won · Mar 2023Won—Mar 2023Former employee (construction labourer) v St Edward Homes Limited
An employment tribunal struck out a series of claims brought by a former construction labourer against multiple respondents, finding them to be res judicata, an abuse of process, and totally without merit. The claimant was ordered to pay £20,000 in costs and £1,786 in preparation time.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v St Edward Homes Limited
A former employee's claim for protected disclosure detriment was struck out after the tribunal found the alleged acts were covered by judicial proceedings immunity and the claim was an abuse of process. A costs order of £20,000 was made.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023First Line Leader (5 years' service) v Unilever UK Limited
A First Line Leader with 5 years' service was unfairly dismissed by Unilever after unclear instructions on social distancing measures and a 6-week investigation delay. The tribunal reduced compensation by 30% for his own contribution.
Partial · Mar 2023Partial—Mar 2023Neighbourhood Services Assistant (4 years' service) v Leicester City Council
A Neighbourhood Services Assistant was fairly dismissed after copying council-owned CCTV footage without permission and dishonestly denying it when questioned. The tribunal upheld the dismissal.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Reach Active Limited
A former employee who remained employed could not pursue unfair dismissal, and his attempt to add a whistleblowing detriment claim was refused as a new cause of action outside the time limit. However, his race discrimination claim was allowed to proceed.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee v MPS Housing Ltd
A former employee of MPS Housing Ltd won his constructive unfair dismissal claim but lost all disability discrimination claims. The tribunal awarded £16,250.48.
Partial · £16,250 · Mar 2023Partial£16,250Mar 2023Assistant Manager (6 months' service) v Done Brothers (Cash Betting) Ltd t/a Betfred
A Betfred assistant manager who refused to return to work claiming he needed to shield his father was dismissed after 6 months. The tribunal rejected his automatic unfair dismissal claim, finding his refusal was motivated by a pay dispute, not a genuine belief in danger.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee (8 years' service) v Z
A former employee with 8 years' service has won claims for unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal, unpaid holiday pay and unauthorised deductions, receiving over £16,000. Her disability discrimination claims were dismissed.
Partial · £16,374 · Mar 2023Partial£16,374Mar 2023Hotel employee (17 years' service) v Park Hall Hotel Ltd (in creditors voluntary liquidation)
A hotel employee of 17 years was unfairly dismissed and awarded over £15,000 after her employer deducted pension contributions without paying them in and failed to follow redundancy procedures.
Partial · £15,138 · Mar 2023Partial£15,138Mar 2023Former employee v Nakanojo UK Ltd
A former employee's claims for unpaid wages and race discrimination were struck out after she presented them eight months late, believing the time limit was two years as in Italy.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Senior director (shareholder) v Tower Demolition (Holdings) Ltd
A senior director who made protected disclosures about a fellow director's breaches of duty was automatically unfairly dismissed. The tribunal awarded £121,601.88, including a 25% uplift for failing to follow the ACAS Code.
Won · £121,602 · Mar 2023Won£121,602Mar 2023Bus driver (4 years' service) v Abellio London Limited
A bus driver with 4 years' service was fairly dismissed after CCTV showed him speeding and running a red light, leading to a customer complaint. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Service Delivery Manager (3 years 10 months' service) v HP INC UK Limited
A Service Delivery Manager who resigned after receiving a final written warning for bullying and safety violations lost his constructive dismissal claim. The tribunal found no breach of contract and dismissed all discrimination claims.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023IT Project Manager (fixed-term contract) v Warwickshire County Council
An IT project manager on a fixed-term contract brought multiple claims of race discrimination, victimisation and whistleblowing detriment against Warwickshire County Council. The tribunal dismissed every claim, finding he had invented allegations and created false documents.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee (personal assistant/chauffeur assistant) v HCL Chauffeurs UK Ltd
A former personal assistant was dismissed for gross misconduct over fuel card use, but the tribunal found the process unfair. However, due to a break in service she lacked two years' continuous employment, so her unfair dismissal claim failed.
Partial · £1,225 · Mar 2023Partial£1,225Mar 2023Former employees v Seychell Engineering and Fabrication Limited (in voluntary liquidation)
Three former employees had their claims for unfair dismissal, redundancy pay and unpaid wages dismissed after they failed to attend the tribunal hearing and provided no evidence.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee (bus driver) v London General Transport Services Ltd (t/a Go Ahead London)
A tribunal dismissed all claims from a former bus driver because they were brought well after the legal time limits, with no explanation for the delay.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Family Law Executive, later Head of Family Law (4 years' service) v Lawcommercial Trading Ltd t/a Lawcomm Solicitors
A family law executive who resigned after her employer failed to pay a £7,000 bonus and refused to make her a director has won her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal awarded £12,878 in compensation.
Partial · £12,878 · Mar 2023Partial£12,878Mar 2023IT/computing lecturer (8 years' service) v Bath College
An IT lecturer with eight years' service claimed he was forced to resign after raising concerns about 'dumbed down' assessments. The tribunal rejected his claims of constructive dismissal and whistleblowing detriment.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Project Manager (15 months' service) v Keepout Limited (in liquidation)
A project manager who was dismissed after 15 months with Keepout Ltd successfully claimed unpaid wages, holiday pay and notice pay, but his unfair dismissal and redundancy claims were struck out due to insufficient service. The tribunal awarded £9,915.80.
Partial · £9,916 · Mar 2023Partial£9,916Mar 2023Former employee v Amber Pubs Limited
A former employee won over £5,000 after being made redundant without proper notice, holiday pay, or written particulars. The employer's failure to comply with tribunal orders led to its defence being struck out.
Won · £5,038 · Mar 2023Won£5,038Mar 2023Window fabricator and installer (4 years' service) v Keepout Limited (in liquidation)
A window fabricator with four years' service was dismissed by redundancy without any warning or consultation. The tribunal awarded £15,319 in unpaid wages, holiday pay, notice pay, redundancy pay and compensation.
Won · £15,319 · Mar 2023Won£15,319Mar 2023Warehouse operative (29 years' service) v Valves and Engineered Products Limited
A warehouse operative with 29 years' service was found to have been unfairly dismissed after her employer sold the business and mistakenly treated her as an agency worker. The tribunal awarded over £11,000 in compensation.
Won · £11,228 · Mar 2023Won£11,228Mar 2023Chef (7 years' service) v Bright Horizons Family Solutions Limited
A chef with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed investigation that showed gender bias. The tribunal found the employer treated him less favourably than a female colleague in similar circumstances. He was awarded £33,666.99.
Won · £33,667 · Mar 2023Won£33,667Mar 2023Cleaner (4 years' service) v Clearlake Cleaning Ltd
A cleaner with four years' service was unfairly dismissed after she raised concerns about unpaid wages. The tribunal awarded £11,226.61, including a 25% ACAS uplift for the employer's failure to follow procedures.
Won · £11,227 · Mar 2023Won£11,227Mar 2023Customer Service Adviser (11 years' service) v Student Loans Company Limited
A Customer Service Adviser with 11 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a single rude call. The tribunal found procedural failings but reduced compensation by 40% for her conduct.
Partial · £22,122 · Mar 2023Partial£22,122Mar 2023Accounts employee (6 years' service) v Defries Associates Ltd
An accounts employee who emailed 298 tenant contact details to an unsecured address was unfairly dismissed because no disciplinary procedure was followed, but a 100% contributory fault finding reduced his compensation to just £1,361.54.
Partial · £1,362 · Mar 2023Partial£1,362Mar 2023Part-time waitress (3 years' service) v Ocho Steak House Limited
A part-time waitress with 3 years' service was unfairly dismissed when her employer fired her by text message after she said she could not return to work immediately due to depression and anxiety. The tribunal awarded £1,724.84 in compensation.
Partial · £1,725 · Mar 2023Partial£1,725Mar 2023Laundry operative (29 days' service) v Elis UK Limited
A laundry operative who left work after 29 days and alleged racism had his claims dismissed by the Exeter tribunal after he failed to attend the hearing.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Paramedic (employed from 2 Feb 2015, paramedic from 1 Aug 2016) v South Central Ambulance Service NHS Foundation Trust
A paramedic who claimed he was constructively dismissed for blowing the whistle over reduced supernumerary training hours has lost his case. The tribunal found only one of his disclosures was protected and caused no detriment.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Restaurant employee (14 years' service) v Mr Andrew Hooper trading as Teesdale Restaurant and Coffee Shop
A restaurant employee with 14 years' service was awarded £6,728 in statutory redundancy pay after her employer closed the business, but her claims for unfair dismissal, notice pay and holiday pay were dismissed as too late.
Partial · £6,728 · Mar 2023Partial£6,728Mar 2023Regional Desk Manager – Programmes Manager - Middle East (3 years' service) v Ummah Welfare Trust (trading as Amanat Charity Trust)
A regional desk manager who refused to travel to Iraq without sufficient Covid-19 assurances was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Senior stylist (12 years' service) v The Dapper Clinic Limited
A senior stylist with 12 years' service was awarded £7,720 after his employer refused to pay him unless he submitted invoices, claiming he was a freelancer. The tribunal found his employment had transferred under TUPE.
Won · £7,720 · Mar 2023Won£7,720Mar 2023Deputy Manager (5 years' service) v Paramount Care (Easington) Limited
A deputy manager with five years' service was unfairly dismissed after a CQC report highlighted failures at her care home. The tribunal found the investigation unreasonable but reduced her award by 20% for her own poor record-keeping.
Partial · £6,914 · Mar 2023Partial£6,914Mar 2023Paralegal (3.5 years' service) v Swift Lawyers Ltd
A paralegal with 3.5 years' service was unfairly dismissed and discriminated against due to pregnancy when her employer made her redundant without proper consultation or considering alternative roles. The tribunal awarded £18,792.26.
Partial · £18,792 · Mar 2023Partial£18,792Mar 2023Former employee v LJE Management Limited
A former employee won £13,617 after a tribunal found she was racially discriminated against, harassed, and unfairly dismissed by LJE Management Limited, which did not attend the hearing.
Won · £13,617 · Mar 2023Won£13,617Mar 2023Former employee v Out and Out Original Limited
A former employee who attended a final hearing by phone, left twice, and refused to return had his unlawful deduction claim struck out for unreasonable conduct.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee v Altran UK Limited
A former employee's claim for breach of contract and unlawful deductions was struck out after he failed to comply with tribunal orders and did not attend the final hearing, citing health reasons without providing medical evidence.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee v Richard Frost
A former employee who withdrew an earlier claim and then brought the same complaints again has had her case struck out. The tribunal ruled it had no jurisdiction to hear the identical allegations.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Manager in Learning Disability Services (5 years' service) v Guideposts Trust Limited
A manager with 5 years' service had multiple discrimination and unfair dismissal claims struck out after failing to pay deposit orders totalling £125 per claim. The tribunal found some claims had little reasonable prospect of success.
Partial · Mar 2023Partial—Mar 2023Hire Controller (2 years' service) v Torrent Trackside Ltd
An employment tribunal has ruled that a hire controller with degenerative disc disease was unfairly dismissed and discriminated against because of her disability. The respondent, Torrent Trackside Ltd, dismissed her without warning after 10 months' absence.
Partial · Mar 2023Partial—Mar 2023Store Manager (6 years' service) v WM Morrison Supermarkets Limited
A store manager who resigned after three weeks without a grievance response lost his constructive dismissal claim. The tribunal found he left for a new job, not because of his employer's conduct.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Programme Executive (10 years' service) v Rolls Royce Plc
A Programme Executive with 10 years' service at Rolls Royce Plc failed to prove constructive unfair dismissal after resigning to take a significantly higher-paid job elsewhere. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Grade 10 Conciliator (9 years' service) v ACAS
A Grade 10 Conciliator with 9 years' service won her constructive unfair dismissal claim after ACAS repeatedly failed to clarify her holiday entitlement, leading to her resignation. The tribunal awarded £24,847.58.
Won · £24,848 · Mar 2023Won£24,848Mar 2023Chief Technical Officer (2 years' service) v Secarma Limited
A chief technical officer who resigned after being suspended, having his team made redundant without consultation, and being denied contractual sick pay has won his constructive unfair dismissal claim at the Bristol Employment Tribunal.
Won · Mar 2023Won—Mar 2023Finance Accountant (21 years' service) v The London Borough of Bexley
A finance accountant with 21 years' service was dismissed on capability grounds due to long-term sickness. Her unfair dismissal claim was rejected as out of time, and her discrimination claims were dismissed on the merits.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Greenfields Nursery Ltd
A former employee of Greenfields Nursery Ltd was unfairly dismissed after the nursery failed to carry out any redundancy consultation. The tribunal awarded £4,439.30.
Won · £4,439 · Mar 2023Won£4,439Mar 2023Human resources manager (2 years 10 months' service) v SM Sparkling Services Limited
A human resources manager was awarded £7,222 after her employer removed her from the payroll without notice, refused holiday leave, and underpaid her for months. The tribunal upheld her claim of constructive unfair dismissal.
Won · £7,222 · Mar 2023Won£7,222Mar 2023Showroom Manager/Designer (5 months' service) v GT Plumbing & Heating Ltd
A showroom manager with five months' service won £3,688 for unlawful deductions from wages, holiday pay and failure to provide written particulars, but her disability discrimination claim was dismissed because her employer did not know she had dyslexia.
Partial · £3,688 · Mar 2023Partial£3,688Mar 2023Field engineer v Openreach Limited
A field engineer who was tricked by a fraudulent adviser into believing his claim had been submitted in time has been granted an extension by the tribunal, allowing his unfair dismissal case to go ahead.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee v Amazon UK Services Limited
A former Amazon employee who wrongly assumed the three-month time limit for an unfair dismissal claim ran from his appeal outcome has had his claim thrown out by a tribunal.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Security Officer (4 years' service) v G4S Secure Solutions (UK) Ltd
A security officer with four years' service was unfairly dismissed after G4S mistakenly believed he could not legally work following his SIA licence revocation. The tribunal awarded £16,632.84.
Won · £16,633 · Mar 2023Won£16,633Mar 2023Former employee v LA Metalworks Limited (in Voluntary Liquidation)
A former employee of LA Metalworks Limited won a protective award of £9,562 after the company entered liquidation and failed to consult about redundancies. The tribunal found unfair dismissal but awarded no compensation because the employer was insolvent.
Partial · £9,563 · Mar 2023Partial£9,563Mar 2023Applications Engineer (7 years' service) v Sterling Thermal Technology Ltd
An applications engineer with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed after his redundancy scoring was manipulated and age played a material role. The tribunal awarded £65,747.54.
Partial · £65,748 · Mar 2023Partial£65,748Mar 2023Technician (4 months' service) v Heaton Park Garage Ltd
A technician who resigned after four months with only one week's notice has had his claim for an unpaid £1,000 signing-on bonus dismissed. The tribunal found that his contract allowed the employer to withhold the bonus if he did not work the required notice period.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Staff nurse (12 years' service) v Robert Jones and Agnes Hunt Orthopaedic Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
A staff nurse with 12 years' service who was dismissed after two years' sick leave and failed redeployment attempts has lost her unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Sainsburys Supermarkets Ltd
An employment tribunal struck out a former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims after they failed to comply with a deposit order and an order for further particulars. The decision was upheld on reconsideration.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Bar Manager (17 years' service) v United Services & Services Rendered Club (Tooting and Balham) Limited
An employment judge has refused to strike out disability discrimination claims brought by a bar manager with terminal lung cancer, ruling that factual disputes over reasonable adjustments during the pandemic must be heard at a full hearing.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Customer Assistant (10 years' service) v Tesco Stores Ltd
A Tesco customer assistant with 10 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after making racist comments, the tribunal ruled, rejecting claims of race discrimination and victimisation.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Whittington Health NHS Trust
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Whittington Health NHS Trust was dismissed as out of time after he contacted ACAS two days late and presented his claim nine days after the deadline.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Family Solicitor (less than 1 year post-qualification experience) v Optimal Claim Limited (t/a Optimal Solicitors)
A family solicitor who resigned after her employer forged her electronic signature on a probation appraisal form has won her constructive dismissal claim, with the tribunal ordering £2,543 in compensation.
Won · £2,543 · Mar 2023Won£2,543Mar 2023Neighbourhood Response Officer (13 years' service) v Clarion Housing Group Ltd
A neighbourhood response officer with bipolar disorder had his unfair dismissal claim struck out because he presented it five months late, despite the tribunal accepting his mental breakdown made it impossible to claim on time.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Café Manager (5 weeks' service) v Ms Jean Fox T/A Café 24
A café manager with fibromyalgia saw her disability discrimination claim struck out after her employer entered bankruptcy and she failed to get court permission to continue proceedings.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee v G4S Secure Solutions Limited
A former employee who brought discrimination and harassment claims with no basis in fact has been ordered to pay £15,165 in costs after the tribunal found her conduct vexatious and unreasonable.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Warehouse Partner (4 weeks' service) v John Lewis plc
A warehouse partner who was sacked after just four weeks for using a false name and lying about previous employment had his unfair dismissal and whistleblowing claims struck out by the Reading Employment Tribunal.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Contact Officer (6 years' service) v The Chief Constable of Devon and Cornwall Constabulary
A police contact officer who waited for his internal appeal to finish before bringing an unfair dismissal claim was out of time. The tribunal dismissed the claim, but allowed his discrimination complaints to proceed.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Customer service agent (12 years' service) v dnata Limited
A customer service agent with 12 years' service was awarded £2,213.32 after dnata Limited breached his contract by failing to pay sick pay correctly, but his unfair dismissal and all disability discrimination claims were rejected.
Partial · £2,213 · Mar 2023Partial£2,213Mar 2023Lettings Manager (3 years' service) v Phillip Ellis Properties Limited
A lettings manager who suffered a stroke was unfairly dismissed after his employer refused to allow him to work from home. The tribunal awarded £27,664.
Won · £27,665 · Mar 2023Won£27,665Mar 2023Agency worker (approximately 2 years' service) v Reckitt Benckiser Healthcare (UK) Ltd
An agency worker who took photographs of alleged health and safety breaches and had a job offer revoked over a mistaken firearms conviction has lost his whistleblowing claim. The tribunal found he did not make a protected disclosure.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Management Information Analyst (1 year's service) v Direct Commercial Limited
A management information analyst who resigned and was offered a conditional bonus during his notice period successfully claimed breach of contract when the employer refused to pay, winning £2,000.
Won · £2,000 · Mar 2023Won£2,000Mar 2023Plumber (3 years' service) v 24/7 Plumbing & Gas (UK) Limited
A plumber with three years' service was constructively dismissed after his employer refused to pay overtime for hours over 40 per week and mishandled his grievance. The tribunal awarded £26,953 in compensation.
Won · £26,953 · Mar 2023Won£26,953Mar 2023Customer Services Supervisor (safety critical role) v London Underground Ltd
A Customer Services Supervisor for London Underground was fairly dismissed after being discharged from residential drug rehabilitation for threatening behaviour. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Financial Accountant (5 months' service) v Saul D Harrison & Sons Plc (t/a Harrison Wipes)
An employment tribunal has dismissed claims of race discrimination and harassment brought by a financial accountant who was sacked after five months for her management style and refusal to accept suspension.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Production operative (semi-skilled, 7 years' service) v Jaguar Landrover Limited
A production operative with 7 years' service was fairly dismissed on capability grounds after an extensive search for alternative roles failed, the tribunal ruled.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Revenue Control Officer (10 months' service) v Govia Thameslink Railway Limited
A Revenue Control Officer with PTSD after four passenger assaults was not redeployed to a non-customer-facing role. The tribunal found the employer failed to make reasonable adjustments and discriminated against her.
Partial · Mar 2023Partial—Mar 2023Public House Manager (17 years' service) v Mr P Wiffin T/A Live and Let Live
A public house manager with 17 years' service was made redundant when the pub closed during COVID-19. The tribunal upheld the redundancy but awarded £17,936.55 for National Minimum Wage underpayments, notice pay, and holiday pay.
Partial · £17,937 · Mar 2023Partial£17,937Mar 2023Former employee v E Limited
A former employee who alleged that photographic evidence was fabricated has had her application for reconsideration refused. The tribunal found no reasonable prospect of the original decision being changed.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Shunter (6 years' service) v Cordant Cleaning Limited
A shunter with six years' service was fairly dismissed for using his mobile phone in a safety-critical area, a tribunal has ruled. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v DAU Draexlmaier Automotive UK Limited
A former employee has been found to be disabled under the Equality Act 2010 due to anxiety, after the tribunal accepted that her condition had a substantial and long-term adverse effect on daily activities.
Won · Mar 2023Won—Mar 2023Breakers Yard Manager (17 years' service) v Inglemere Metals (Blackpool) Limited
A Breakers Yard Manager who had worked for the company for 17 years without any prior warnings was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after he ignored express instructions about a customer, sold tyres without authorisation and granted extended credit. The tribunal rejected all three claims.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Agency nurse (Band 5, over 60, with HIV) v University Hospitals Bristol and Weston NHS Foundation Trust
An agency nurse over 60 with HIV lost her disability discrimination claims after refusing to work in ICU during COVID-19. The tribunal found the NHS Trust did not know about her HIV and acted reasonably in the pandemic context.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee (BT) v British Telecommunications plc (BT)
A former BT employee was unfairly dismissed in a redundancy process. The tribunal awarded £52,173.45 after applying a 75% Polkey reduction and compensating for lost share scheme benefits.
Won · £52,173 · Mar 2023Won£52,173Mar 2023Clinical Lead (7 months' service) v Rushcliffe Independent Hospitals (Kegworth) Limited
A Clinical Lead who alleged she was dismissed for raising patient safety concerns lost her automatic unfair dismissal claim after the tribunal found no protected disclosures were made and the real reason was poor performance.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Clinical Support Worker (6 years' service) v Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust
An NHS trust fairly dismissed a clinical support worker with rheumatoid arthritis and sickle cell anaemia after a 12-month absence, the tribunal ruled. The trust had explored redeployment and followed its procedures.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Night porter (14 years' service) v Mohammad Zishan Zaman
A night porter with 14 years' service and a maintenance man were awarded unpaid wages, holiday pay and redundancy after a tribunal found their employer deliberately used a complex corporate structure to avoid responsibility.
Partial · Mar 2023Partial—Mar 2023Electrician (5 years' service) v UK Power Networks (Services) Limited
An electrician with 5 years' service failed to prove direct age discrimination when his contract was not renewed after he mentioned retirement. The tribunal found no less favourable treatment on grounds of age.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v DMT Solutions UK Limited t/as Bluecrest
A tribunal has upheld a decision to grant an employer an extension of time to submit its response, after the claim form was delayed in internal mail for several weeks.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Utility Savings Group Ltd
A former employee's claims for unfair dismissal, holiday pay, and breach of contract were dismissed by the tribunal because they were brought outside the legal time limits and she failed to attend the final hearing.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Pharmacist (3 months' service) v L. Rowlands & Company (Retail) Limited
A tribunal struck out a pharmacist's claim of automatic unfair dismissal because it was presented more than three years after her dismissal, far beyond the three-month time limit.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Site Manager (3 years' service) v NB Construction (UK) Limited
A site manager was unfairly dismissed after a sham redundancy process and a subsequent gross misconduct dismissal that lacked proper investigation. The tribunal awarded £8,281.30, including a 20% ACAS uplift.
Won · £8,281 · Mar 2023Won£8,281Mar 2023Former employee v Teen Support Services Ltd
A former employee of Teen Support Services Ltd has won a claim for unauthorised deductions from wages, receiving £1,704.12 for unpaid sleep-in payments and annual leave. Her unfair dismissal claim was rejected.
Partial · £1,704 · Mar 2023Partial£1,704Mar 2023Former employee v EDF Energy Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims were struck out after he repeatedly failed to comply with tribunal orders to provide a disability impact statement, and did not attend any hearings.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Commis chef (zero hours contract) v Eclipse Hotels (Bristol) Ltd
A commis chef on a zero-hours contract was fairly dismissed for failing to attend assigned shifts, but the tribunal awarded him £1,687.38 for unpaid notice pay because the employer did not follow the correct notice procedure.
Partial · £1,687 · Mar 2023Partial£1,687Mar 2023Former employee v Active Assistance Limited; Staff Management Limited
A former employee who hung up on the tribunal clerk and ignored repeated attempts to contact her had her unfair dismissal claim thrown out for non-attendance.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Funeral director (30 years' service) v Dignity Funerals Ltd
A funeral director with 30 years' service was unfairly dismissed after removing a deceased person's jewellery. The tribunal found procedural unfairness and awarded £43,350.60 after a 40% reduction for contributory fault.
Won · £43,351 · Mar 2023Won£43,351Mar 2023Senior Staff Nurse (Band 6) – IVF and fertility services (12 years' service) v University Hospitals Plymouth NHS Trust
A senior staff nurse with 12 years' service was found to have transferred to the new IVF service provider under TUPE, despite the new provider's claim she was not assigned to the organised grouping.
Won · Mar 2023Won—Mar 2023Minibus driver (4 years' service) v Blackburn and Darwen Community Transport Limited
A minibus driver who was dismissed shortly after complaining about unpaid holiday pay has been found unfairly dismissed. The tribunal awarded £12,489.86 in compensation.
Won · £12,490 · Mar 2023Won£12,490Mar 2023Specialty doctor in emergency medicine (12 years' service) v Calderdale and Huddersfield NHS Foundation Trust
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a specialty doctor with 12 years' service for capability, finding the NHS trust's process was fair and that his disability was not the cause of his performance problems.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v ABM Facility Services UK Limited
A former employee withdrew claims of sex, race and religion or belief discrimination against ABM Facility Services UK Limited, and had her complaint about holiday pay, sick pay and unpaid wages struck out for failing to comply with a tribunal order.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Prison Custody Officer (2 years 10 months' service) v Serco Limited
A prison custody officer's unfair dismissal claim was struck out because she submitted her ET1 without an ACAS early conciliation certificate, and the defect could not be cured by later providing one.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Agency social worker (4.5 months' service) v South Gloucestershire Council
An agency social worker with endometriosis had her placement terminated five weeks early due to sickness absence. The tribunal found the council directly discriminated against her and awarded £12,570.
Partial · £12,570 · Mar 2023Partial£12,570Mar 2023Civil enforcement officer (CEO) v NSL Ltd
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a civil enforcement officer who assaulted a member of the public by knocking a phone from their hand. All race discrimination and harassment claims were also rejected.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Teaching Assistant and Midday Supervisor (10 years' service) v Derbyshire County Council
A teaching assistant who was dismissed on ill-health grounds had her unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims struck out after presenting them 415 days late. The tribunal found no explanation for the delay and no jurisdiction to hear the case.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Railway signaller (2 years' service) v Network Rail Infrastructure Limited
A railway signaller who resigned after his employer failed to discipline a bullying manager as promised by a grievance outcome has won his constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found a breach of trust and confidence.
Won · Mar 2023Won—Mar 2023Director (full-time working director) v The REC Horsham Limited
An employment tribunal dismissed a director's constructive dismissal claim after finding he was complicit in the company's failure to pay tax and National Insurance and abuse of the furlough scheme.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Production Manager (13 years' service) v Herongrange Manpower Direct Limited (previously Herongrange Security and Systems Limited)
A production manager with 13 years' service was dismissed without notice on the day his employment transferred to a new company. The tribunal found automatic unfair dismissal and direct age discrimination, awarding over £130,000.
Won · £130,257 · Mar 2023Won£130,257Mar 2023Former employee v Ansdell Institute and Social Club
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed because they had less than two years' service, but the employer agreed to pay £284.58 in notice pay.
Dismissed · £285 · Mar 2023Dismissed£285Mar 2023Organist (locum then permanent) v The Parochial Church Council of the Parish Church of St James and St Basil
A Newcastle tribunal has dismissed an organist's unfair dismissal claim because his continuous employment fell short of the two-year qualifying period by just two days.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Surveyor (probationary period) v Mersey Eco Grants Ltd
A surveyor who was dismissed by phone just before his probation ended had his unfair dismissal and discrimination claims dismissed because he presented his claim six days late and failed to comply with tribunal orders.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Room attendant (10 years' service) v Lainston House Limited
A room attendant with 10 years' service was unfairly dismissed for irretrievable breakdown of trust and confidence, but the tribunal found she would have been dismissed two weeks later anyway. She received a basic award of £1,665.
Partial · £1,665 · Mar 2023Partial£1,665Mar 2023Former employee v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A former Royal Mail employee won £308.66 in unpaid sick pay, but his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims were dismissed by the tribunal.
Partial · £309 · Mar 2023Partial£309Mar 2023Work coach (1 year's service) v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions
A work coach with one year's service was dismissed for accessing his own Universal Credit account from his work laptop. The tribunal rejected his claims of disability discrimination, finding he had committed the misconduct.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Machine Operator (57 years' service) v G & S Valves Limited
A machine operator with 57 years' service lost his unfair dismissal claim after telling his boss 'I'll retire now'. The tribunal ruled he had resigned, and the employer was not obliged to correct his misunderstanding.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Chef (part-time) v Rimad Ltd
A part-time chef who was summarily dismissed for threatening a manager with a knife withdrew his unfair dismissal claim at the final hearing. The tribunal also refused his late application to add a harassment claim.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Trainee Biomedical Scientist (12 years' service) v Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust
A trainee biomedical scientist with 12 years' service was unfairly dismissed after the NHS Trust failed to fix an appeal hearing, despite knowing she was seriously ill. The tribunal awarded £17,771.29.
Partial · £17,771 · Mar 2023Partial£17,771Mar 2023Machine Tool Services Engineer (9 years' service) v Design & Technical Services (UK) Ltd
A machine tool services engineer was unfairly dismissed after using a company fuel card during furlough, but the tribunal awarded no compensation because he would have been dismissed anyway.
Partial · £0 · Mar 2023Partial£0Mar 2023Mobile patrol officer (5 years' service) v G4S Secure Solutions (UK) Ltd
A mobile patrol officer who gave a dishonest account of a collision while using his mobile phone and not wearing a seatbelt has lost his unfair dismissal claim against G4S Secure Solutions (UK) Ltd.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Cabin crew (former employee) v Virgin Atlantic Airways Ltd
A former Virgin Atlantic cabin crew member who delayed her unfair dismissal claim by six months to preserve her chance of re-employment from a redundancy holding pool has had her claim dismissed as out of time.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee v Shaw Trust Ltd
A former employee of Shaw Trust had his unfair dismissal and redundancy claims struck out because he had less than two years' service. His race and sex discrimination claims were partially struck out and partially subject to a £5 deposit order.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee v London 01 Shop Ltd
A former employee was awarded £141.44 for unpaid annual leave, but his claims for breach of contract and other deductions were dismissed.
Partial · £141 · Mar 2023Partial£141Mar 2023Senior Asset Officer (4 years 9 months' service) v Evolve Facility Services Limited (A subsidiary of The Riverside Group)
A Senior Asset Officer who resigned after being placed at risk of redundancy has lost his claims of constructive dismissal, direct race discrimination and victimisation. The tribunal found the claims were either out of time or not well-founded.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Westminster City Council
A former employee’s attempt to add an equal pay complaint to her existing claim was refused by the tribunal, which found the new claim was out of time and would cause greater hardship to Westminster City Council than to her.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Chief Technology Officer / Chairman and Chief Innovation Officer (9 years' service) v MYPINPAD Ltd
A tribunal found that a founder and chief technology officer was summarily dismissed during a Teams call, despite the company later claiming otherwise. The preliminary ruling on the effective date of termination has implications for similar disputes.
Won · Mar 2023Won—Mar 2023Genetic Director (7 years' service) v Check4Cancer Ltd
A Genetic Director who resigned after feeling excluded from strategic decisions during her pregnancy has lost her constructive unfair dismissal and discrimination claims. The tribunal found the employer's actions were not because of her pregnancy.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee (long-term sickness absence) v Plusnet Plc
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a long-term sick employee by Plusnet Plc, finding the employer acted reasonably in concluding there was no prospect of a return to work.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v West London NHS Trust
A former employee of West London NHS Trust had his claims of unfair dismissal, unlawful deduction from wages, and race discrimination dismissed because he filed them too late.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Sports bar employee (17 years' service) v Rileys Sports Bar (In Administration)
A sports bar employee with 17 years' service was unfairly dismissed after being accused of drinking on duty. The tribunal found the real reason was the bar's poor business performance.
Won · £7,875 · Mar 2023Won£7,875Mar 2023Supply chain manager (1 year's service) v Fushi Wellbeing Ltd
A supply chain manager with one year's service lost her unfair dismissal claim due to insufficient service, but won £192.31 in unpaid holiday pay on termination.
Partial · £192 · Mar 2023Partial£192Mar 2023Sales assistant (2 years' service) v Mr Muhammad Azeeem Khan t/a Yorkshire Retail Services
A sales assistant caught on CCTV playing scratch cards and lottery tickets during shifts without paying was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal upheld the dismissal but ordered the employer to pay £608.55 for unauthorised wage deductions and unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £609 · Mar 2023Partial£609Mar 2023Former employee v Verifone UK Ltd
A former employee of Verifone UK Ltd has been awarded £88,519 after an employment tribunal upheld her claims of unfair dismissal and victimisation, while dismissing her race discrimination complaints.
Partial · £88,519 · Mar 2023Partial£88,519Mar 2023Recycling contractor (26 years' service) v Magpie Recycling Co-operative Limited
A recycling contractor with 26 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after repeatedly ignoring health and safety restrictions following a heart condition. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Operations Team Leader (2 years' service) v The Bennie Group Limited
A tribunal extended time for an employee who missed the claim deadline by one day after ACAS gave misleading advice about the deadline. The claims for unfair dismissal and disability discrimination were allowed to proceed.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Construction workers (self-employed subcontractors) v Capital Contractors Limited
Two construction workers who were not paid for short-term work on a day rate have had their claim for unauthorised deductions dismissed after the tribunal found they were independent contractors, not workers.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee (6 years' service) v Ibco Limited
A former employee with six years' service has been awarded £37,003.42 after an employment tribunal found Ibco Limited discriminated against him by failing to make reasonable adjustments, harassing and victimising him, and unfairly dismissing him.
Won · £37,003 · Mar 2023Won£37,003Mar 2023Cashier (3 years' service) v AY & Y Patel Ltd
A cashier claimed she was unfairly dismissed after a manager told her she was 'sacked' during a heated argument. The tribunal found she was not dismissed because the manager had no authority to dismiss and the employer never accepted the termination.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Meter reader (10 years' service) v Morrison Data Services Limited
A meter reader who refused to consent to an occupational health referral for months was fairly dismissed on capability grounds, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Registered Nurse (3 years 8 months' service) v East Suffolk and North Essex NHS Foundation Trust
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a Band 5 registered nurse who refused to return to work after being removed from clinical duties over patient safety concerns. All claims, including unfair dismissal and disability discrimination, were dismissed.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023HART Paramedic (7 years' service) v South Western Ambulance Service NHS Foundation Trust
A HART paramedic with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed and discriminated against after developing PTSD from a training incident. The tribunal awarded £26,087 in compensation.
Partial · £26,087 · Mar 2023Partial£26,087Mar 2023Former employee v Fiza Foods Ltd
A former employee was awarded £12,871 after being dismissed while pregnant. The tribunal found automatic unfair dismissal and pregnancy discrimination.
Won · £12,871 · Mar 2023Won£12,871Mar 2023Help to claim advisor (3 years' service) v Epping Forest District Citizens Advice Bureau
A help to claim advisor who was made redundant after a TUPE transfer had her unfair dismissal and discrimination claims thrown out because she contacted ACAS four months after her dismissal, well beyond the three-month time limit.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Paint technician (6 years' service) v Autotech Reading Limited
A paint technician with autism who was selected for redundancy after scoring lower on a 'team working' criterion has lost his claims for unfair dismissal, whistleblowing detriment and disability discrimination.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Teacher (former) v National Education Union
A former teacher's sex discrimination claim against the National Education Union was struck out after she filed it two and a half years after the alleged 'please be nice' email. The tribunal found no continuing act of discrimination.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee v Oak Furnitureland Group Limited
A former employee who was dismissed for gross misconduct after an investigation into a theft of £14,500 from a store safe has lost his claims for unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal, and unpaid commission.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Road operative (5 years' service) v Ringway Infrastructure Services Limited
A road operative's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed because his claim form omitted the full early conciliation certificate number and incorrectly claimed an exemption. The tribunal had no jurisdiction to hear the case.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee v IMT Transport Limited
A former employee was unfairly dismissed by IMT Transport Limited and awarded £4,357.90, but their claim of disability discrimination was rejected by the tribunal.
Partial · £4,358 · Mar 2023Partial£4,358Mar 2023Service controller (5 years' service) v Altegra Integrated Solutions Limited
A service controller's claims of constructive unfair dismissal and pregnancy/maternity discrimination were struck out after she failed to attend a preliminary hearing and did not comply with tribunal orders.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Dental nurses (job-sharing, 3-4 years' service) v 29 Fleet Street Limited, Dr R Dawood, Dr A Dawood, Dawood & Tanner (trading as Temple Dental), Darwood IP Limited
Two dental nurses were automatically unfairly dismissed when their employer claimed redundancy but the real reason was a planned transfer of the dental business to a new provider. The tribunal awarded £7,090 in compensation.
Partial · £7,090 · Mar 2023Partial£7,090Mar 2023Former employee v Oxleas NHS Foundation Trust
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Oxleas NHS Foundation Trust was struck out because she presented it too late. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable to have filed in time.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023General medical practitioner (2 years' service) v Japan Green Medical Centre Limited
A GP with two years' service was unfairly dismissed in a flawed redundancy process. The tribunal awarded £78,857 but rejected his whistleblowing claims, finding redundancy was the true reason.
Partial · £78,858 · Mar 2023Partial£78,858Mar 2023Locum occupational therapist/care coordinator (13 weeks' service) v South West London and St George's Mental Health NHS Trust
A locum occupational therapist with Type 1 diabetes succeeded in her disability discrimination claim after her NHS trust employer failed to carry out a proper risk assessment and required her to return to work during the pandemic. The tribunal found the trust's actions amounted to a failure to make reasonable adjustments and harassment.
Partial · Mar 2023Partial—Mar 2023Former employee v Heatrod Elements Ltd
A former employee won his unfair dismissal claim but received no compensation after the tribunal found his own conduct wholly caused the dismissal. He was awarded £439.25 for unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £439 · Mar 2023Partial£439Mar 2023Administrator (9 years' service) v Parkcare Homes (No2) Limited
An experienced administrator was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after repeated errors in financial processing and payroll, despite having 9 years' service. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee (Social Work Assistant/Early Help Worker, 2 years 7 months' service) v Kent County Council
A former employee who claimed constructive unfair dismissal lost her case when the tribunal ruled that a binding COT3 settlement had been reached, even though she tried to withdraw before the agreement was signed.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Electrical Biomedical Engineering technician (Band 6, 2 years' service) v IFM Bolton Limited
An electrical technician with two years' service was fairly dismissed after failing capability tests and refusing a downgraded post. The tribunal rejected claims of race and religion discrimination.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Head of HR (2 years' service) v Caritas Anchor House
A tribunal dismissed a constructive unfair dismissal claim by a Head of HR who resigned after feeling overwhelmed, finding no repudiatory breach by the employer.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023In-house employment solicitor (4 years' service) v National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers
An employment tribunal dismissed all 133 claims brought by an in-house solicitor against the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers, including allegations of assault, constructive dismissal, and disability discrimination.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Beauty therapist (2 years 5 months' service) v True Beauty Salon Limited
A beauty therapist who resigned claiming constructive unfair dismissal lost her case, but the tribunal ordered True Beauty Salon Limited to pay £639.60 for unpaid holiday pay and an unauthorised deduction.
Partial · £640 · Feb 2023Partial£640Feb 2023Former employee v Asda Stores Limited
A former employee who failed to comply with tribunal orders and did not attend a preliminary hearing has been ordered to pay £3,120 in costs after his claim was automatically struck out.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Customer service advisor (3 years' service) v Alliance Healthcare Management Services Ltd
A customer service advisor with Ménière's disease was unfairly dismissed after refusing to work from home when her face shield was banned. The tribunal reduced her compensation by 75% for her own conduct.
Partial · Feb 2023Partial—Feb 2023Forklift truck driver (18 years' service) v R&R Ice Cream Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a forklift truck driver with 18 years' service who was found to have been under the influence of alcohol at work, ruling that the employer's belief was reasonable based on witness reports and CCTV evidence.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Headteacher (10 years' service) v The Governing Body of St Charles RC Primary School
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a headteacher with 10 years' service who was found to have smelled of alcohol and left children unsupervised. The school's investigation, though lengthy, was deemed reasonable.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v Rujia Marketing Consultants Limited
A former employee with less than two years' service has been awarded £3,095.34 for unlawful deductions, wrongful dismissal, and failure to provide written particulars after her employer failed to attend the final hearing.
Won · £3,095 · Feb 2023Won£3,095Feb 2023Former employee v Gold Mount Markets Limited
Two former employees of Gold Mount Markets have won claims for unpaid wages, notice pay, and holiday pay after the company stopped paying them for over three months during the pandemic.
Partial · Feb 2023Partial—Feb 2023Community Care Assistant (5 years' service) v Heheals Pharmaceutical Ltd t/a Christ Church Care Agency
A community care assistant with severe asthma was summarily dismissed for not being able to wear a surgical mask. The tribunal found the employer failed to investigate alternatives or make reasonable adjustments.
Settled · Feb 2023Settled—Feb 2023Crime Scene Investigator (13 years' service) v Chief Constable of Wiltshire Police
A Crime Scene Investigator with 13 years' service resigned after his employer failed to act on a grievance report that backed his health and safety concerns. The tribunal found he was constructively unfairly dismissed.
Partial · Feb 2023Partial—Feb 2023Former employee v Central and North West London NHS Foundation Trust
An employment tribunal struck out discrimination and redundancy claims from a former NHS employee who failed to provide any details to support them, and dismissed her unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Secretary (2 years 5 months' service) v Contracting Synergy Limited
A secretary dismissed by text message after obtaining a non-molestation order against her boss has lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal held that the irretrievable breakdown in the working relationship was a genuine 'some other substantial reason' for dismissal.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Production Manager (34 years' service) and Factory Manager (42 years' service) v Snowbird Foods Limited
Two production managers with 34 and 42 years' service were fairly dismissed after refusing to manage a trial of Cumberland sausage rings. The tribunal rejected their claims of health and safety detriment and unfair dismissal.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Police Community Support Officer (PCSO) (14 years' service) v The Commissioner of Police for the Metropolis
A Police Community Support Officer with PTSD was dismissed for breaching a non-molestation order, but the tribunal found no link between his disability and the misconduct. He was later reinstated on appeal.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v Garmston Professional Ltd
A former employee won £35,163 after her employer failed to submit a response to her pregnancy discrimination claim in time, leading to a default judgment.
Won · £35,163 · Feb 2023Won£35,163Feb 2023Warehouse operative (6 years' service) v Alexir Co Packers Limited
A warehouse operative's sexual harassment claim was dismissed because she filed her claim too late, and her unfair dismissal claim was struck out as she never actually resigned.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Taproom manager (4 months' service) v Belleville Brewing Limited
A taproom manager with four months' service who raised concerns about reopening during Covid-19 regulations was dismissed, but the tribunal found he had not made a protected disclosure.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Beautician / salon manager (2 years' service) v Gorj Gillingham Ltd (in voluntary liquidation) and Rose Beauty Bar Ltd
A beautician and store manager was dismissed by her employer shortly after the salon was sold to a new company while she was on maternity leave. The tribunal found a TUPE transfer had occurred and the dismissal was automatically unfair, awarding £3,943.77.
Partial · £3,944 · Feb 2023Partial£3,944Feb 2023Former employee v Coventry University
A former employee of Coventry University was refused permission to add race and age discrimination claims to his unfair dismissal case, after applying to amend his claim over a year after the original deadline.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Bus driver (5 years' service) v Arriva London (North) Ltd
A bus driver who was caught on CCTV reading a disciplinary letter while driving and running a red light was fairly dismissed. The tribunal rejected claims for unfair dismissal and breach of contract.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Sales executive (4 years' service) v Ford Retail Ltd T/A Trustford
A sales executive with four years' service who resigned after a new commission structure was introduced has lost his constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found no fundamental breach of contract.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Security Officer (11 years' service) v G4S Secure Solutions (UK) Limited
A security officer with 11 years' service was fairly dismissed after video evidence showed her apparently sleeping on duty. The tribunal upheld G4S's decision, finding the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Support worker v Pathway for Care Ltd
A support worker who resigned after being suspended following a physical intervention incident lost his claim for constructive unfair dismissal and detriment because of a protected disclosure about a resident's safety.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Watch Manager (25 years' service) v Securitas Security (UK) Ltd
A Watch Manager with 25 years' service was fairly dismissed after Airbus withdrew his security badge, the tribunal ruled. He was awarded £2,245.67 for unpaid notice pay but his unfair dismissal and age discrimination claims failed.
Partial · £2,246 · Feb 2023Partial£2,246Feb 2023Former employee v Wellington for Langley Hall
A former employee's claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination were struck out after the tribunal found they were presented over a year after her employment ended, and she failed to attend the hearing.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Hairdresser (18 months' service) v Atelier Clifton Ltd
A hairdresser who was dismissed after self-isolating following contact with a COVID-positive client has won her claim for automatic unfair dismissal and pregnancy discrimination. The Bristol tribunal awarded £59,632.94.
Won · £59,633 · Feb 2023Won£59,633Feb 2023Building Supervisor (15 years' service) v Emcor Group (UK) Plc
A building supervisor was unfairly dismissed after a redundancy selection process that made a final decision before meaningful consultation. The tribunal awarded £4,130.86, reduced by 85% for the chance he would have been dismissed anyway.
Won · £4,131 · Feb 2023Won£4,131Feb 2023Part-time shed builder (7 years' service) v Hunt Sheds Limited
A part-time shed builder with bowel cancer was told he hadn't 'a fucking days' work' in him and dismissed. The tribunal awarded £10,610 after the employer failed to defend the claim.
Won · £10,610 · Feb 2023Won£10,610Feb 2023Former employee v Community Integrated Care
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after he failed to obtain an ACAS early conciliation number before presenting his claim, and the tribunal refused to extend time.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Senior Sector Analyst (2 years' service) v ING Bank N.V.
A Senior Sector Analyst who worked in Moscow for an ING subsidiary could not bring his constructive dismissal claim against the Dutch parent company in the UK. The tribunal ruled it had no territorial jurisdiction.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Emergency Medical Technician, Grade 1 (12 years' service) v Yorkshire Ambulance Service NHS Trust
An emergency medical technician with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed after accessing a patient's records and forming a relationship with her. The tribunal found the trust's decision was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Job applicant v Woven Solutions Ltd
A job applicant who had her offer withdrawn after providing a redacted, unrecognisable passport photocopy failed to prove race discrimination. The tribunal found the employer acted solely on right-to-work concerns.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v ACE Scaffolding (M/CR) Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was thrown out after he failed to attend three preliminary hearings, despite repeated warnings that his case could be struck out.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Nail/beauty technician (approx. 1 year's service) v Anna Health and Beauty Limited
A nail technician who resigned after a disagreement over furlough pay lost her pregnancy discrimination claim. The tribunal found she was not dismissed but resigned voluntarily.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v B Barton and D Ford T/a Exquisite Catering with Class
A former catering worker was awarded £1,671.15 after her employer failed to pay the National Minimum Wage and provide a written contract. Her claims for unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal, and harassment related to sex were dismissed.
Partial · £1,671 · Feb 2023Partial£1,671Feb 2023Cashier (nearly 3 years' service) v HSBC UK Bank Plc
A cashier with nearly 3 years' service was fairly dismissed for capability after failing to meet an attendance objective. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal, breach of contract, and unlawful deductions.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Head of finance (4 years' service) v North Central London Integrated Care Board
A head of finance who resigned after believing her manager had lied about instructing an external consultant to contact her has lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Therapeutic Community Support Worker (1 year 7 months' service) v Sea Sanctuary
A support worker with depression and anxiety was unfairly dismissed after her employer failed to consider concluding disciplinary proceedings in writing. The tribunal awarded £14,573.
Won · £14,573 · Feb 2023Won£14,573Feb 2023Head of Private Patients (band 8d, 4 years' service) v Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust
The employment tribunal dismissed claims of unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and whistleblowing detriment brought by a former head of private patients at Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust, finding the trust acted reasonably in dismissing her due to a breakdown in trust and confidence.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Social worker (23 years' service) v Doncaster Metropolitan Borough Council
A social worker with 23 years' service was constructively unfairly dismissed after her employer failed to implement Access to Work recommendations and refused a transfer. The tribunal found the council's conduct destroyed trust and confidence.
Won · Feb 2023Won—Feb 2023Former employee v National Utilities Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after he repeatedly failed to comply with tribunal orders, including providing a witness statement and further information.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Former employee v Tooth Fairies Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out because she lacked the required two years' continuous service. Her wrongful dismissal claim was also struck out for having no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Cabin crew (fixed-term contract) v Easyjet Airline Company Ltd
A fixed-term cabin crew member who raised health and safety concerns during the pandemic lost her whistleblowing detriment claim after the tribunal found no evidence that Easyjet's actions were motivated by her protected disclosure.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Bus driver v A & A Coach Travel Ltd
A bus driver with Asperger's Syndrome was constructively dismissed after repeated abusive comments on a WhatsApp group and threats to sack him if he pursued an insurance claim. The tribunal awarded £25,000 for injury to feelings.
Won · £25,000 · Feb 2023Won£25,000Feb 2023Shift manager/transport planner (2 years' service) v Chillaway Express Special Limited
A shift manager with chronic fatigue syndrome was fairly dismissed after 8 months' absence, the tribunal ruled, finding the small employer acted reasonably in the circumstances.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023MASH/Link Officer (7 years' service) v London Borough of Havering
A MASH/Link Officer with seven years' service was constructively dismissed after being removed from management duties and having her distress ignored. The tribunal awarded £39,168, reduced by 25% for her own conduct.
Won · £39,168 · Feb 2023Won£39,168Feb 2023Trainee Site Manager (5 years' service) v Buildakit (UK) Ltd
A trainee site manager with five years' service resigned after a dispute over sick pay and earlier workplace incidents, but the tribunal found no fundamental breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee (7 years' service) v Tidysite Building and Construction Service Limited
A former employee with seven years' service won £5,687.63 after his employer failed to file a response to his tribunal claims for unfair dismissal, unpaid sick pay, holiday pay and notice pay.
Won · £5,688 · Feb 2023Won£5,688Feb 2023Process Technician (15 years' service) v Thames Water Utilities Limited
A tribunal has ruled that a Thames Water process technician with 15 years' service was not disabled under the Equality Act, dismissing his disability discrimination claims. The decision turned on whether his stress, anxiety and depression had a long-term substantial effect.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Former employee v Dimensions UK Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Dimensions UK Ltd was struck out after he failed to comply with tribunal orders and did not attend the hearing. The tribunal found his non-compliance was intentional and disrespectful.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Former employee v Go Learn Education Limited
A former employee won £35,338.70 after Go Learn Education Limited made unauthorised wage deductions, failed to pay notice pay, and withheld holiday pay on termination.
Partial · £35,339 · Feb 2023Partial£35,339Feb 2023Scientist (agency worker) v UK Health Security Agency
A scientist who worked for the UK Health Security Agency via an umbrella company was not an employee, the tribunal ruled, striking out her claim for automatically unfair dismissal over protected disclosures.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Electrical apprentice (4 years) v CC Cousins Limited
An electrical apprentice was unfairly dismissed after a flawed redundancy selection process. The tribunal awarded £14,251 for loss of future prospects and the delay in qualifying.
Won · £14,251 · Feb 2023Won£14,251Feb 2023Ward manager (40 years' experience as a nurse) v Priory Healthcare Limited
A 40-year nursing veteran was unfairly dismissed by Priory Healthcare after the employer mistakenly believed a urine test showed she was under the influence of cannabis at work. The tribunal found the dismissal was outside the range of reasonable responses.
Won · Feb 2023Won—Feb 2023Piano and singing teacher (24 years' service) v The Mount School Limited
A piano and singing teacher with 24 years' service was unfairly dismissed after she refused to attend a mandatory staff meeting at short notice because of a pre-arranged family gathering to discuss her mother's cancer care. The Leeds tribunal awarded £16,802.31.
Won · £16,802 · Feb 2023Won£16,802Feb 2023HGV driver (3 years' service) v R.F. Bellis Haulage Limited
HGV driver fairly dismissed after refusing to return to work; race discrimination claims rejected
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Nurse (15 years' service) v Mission Care Management Limited
A nurse with 15 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after taking annual leave that was only partially approved. The tribunal upheld her wrongful dismissal claim, awarding £5,275.36.
Partial · £5,275 · Feb 2023Partial£5,275Feb 2023Driver/custodian (6 years' service) v Loomis UK Ltd
A driver/custodian with 6 years' service was made redundant after scoring 16 out of a breakpoint of 19. The tribunal found the redundancy process fair and dismissed claims of unfair dismissal and religious discrimination.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Accountant (7 months' service) v Tiffany & Co. (UK) Holdings Limited
An accountant who resigned during a redundancy process had his unfair dismissal and redundancy pay claims struck out because he lacked the required two years' continuous service.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Agency worker (assigned to Torque Retail Services Ltd) v Torque Retail Services Limited
An agency worker with a disability was discriminated against and victimised when his assignment was terminated. The tribunal awarded £5,005 in compensation.
Partial · £5,005 · Feb 2023Partial£5,005Feb 2023Quality Assurance Expert (approx. 2 years 8 months' service) v CMR Surgical Limited
A Quality Assurance Expert who resigned claiming constructive dismissal had her entire claim thrown out because she waited over three months to begin Early Conciliation. The tribunal found no excuse for the delay.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Skilled computer programmer (20 years' service) v Office for Students
A computer programmer with 20 years' service was constructively dismissed after her employer adopted a 'low code/no code' approach. The tribunal found the restructure amounted to a redundancy situation and the grievance process was mishandled.
Won · Feb 2023Won—Feb 2023Barman and cocktail mixologist (9 months' service) v H &AB-Side Limited
A barman who claimed he was dismissed for raising health and safety concerns during the pandemic lost his unfair dismissal case, but won over £3,200 for unpaid wages, notice pay and holiday pay.
Partial · £3,276 · Feb 2023Partial£3,276Feb 2023Former employee v Hydrosphere UK Ltd
A former employee's claims of age and race discrimination against Hydrosphere UK Ltd were dismissed as out of time, and his unfair dismissal claim was struck out for lack of service.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Former employee (pregnant at time of dismissal) v VPS PVT Limited
A tribunal found that VPS PVT Limited unfairly dismissed a pregnant employee and discriminated against her by failing to carry out a health and safety risk assessment. The claimant was awarded £23,823.50 in compensation.
Won · £23,824 · Feb 2023Won£23,824Feb 2023Anglican Prison Chaplain (3 years' service) v Secretary of State for Justice
A prison chaplain with 3 years' service was fairly dismissed for performance issues after extensive support, the Sheffield tribunal ruled, rejecting all discrimination and harassment claims.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Refuse Loader (10 years' service) v London Borough of Newham
A refuse loader with 10 years' service was dismissed for failing to wear his high-visibility vest and reporting late, while a white colleague who committed fraud received only a written warning. The tribunal found race discrimination.
Won · Feb 2023Won—Feb 2023Former employee v Lancashire County Council
A former employee was awarded £12,953.98 after Lancashire County Council's response was struck out for non-compliance, leading to a finding of unfair dismissal.
Won · £12,954 · Feb 2023Won£12,954Feb 2023Care worker (supporting service users) v iCare Living Limited
An employment tribunal dismissed a care worker's claims that he suffered detriments for making protected disclosures, and refused to allow him to add a religion/belief discrimination claim that was out of time.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Online teacher (7.5 hours per week) v Horizon Care and Education Group Limited
An online teacher who withdrew her disability discrimination claim on the second day of the hearing avoided a costs order, even though the tribunal found her conduct unreasonable.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Bursar and Clerk to the Governors (7 years' service) v Alpha Schools (Holdings) Ltd and Wellesley House School Ltd
A bursar and clerk to the governors was summarily dismissed without notice or pay. The tribunal awarded £97,220.70 for unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal, and unpaid holiday pay, plus a penalty for failing to provide written particulars.
Won · £97,221 · Feb 2023Won£97,221Feb 2023Dental practice employee v Park Cottage Dental Practice Limited
A dental practice employee's claims of constructive unfair dismissal, race discrimination, and harassment were dismissed by the tribunal after a full hearing. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v Lex Machinery Limited
A former employee won his unfair dismissal claim by default after Lex Machinery Limited failed to respond. He was awarded £5,989.65 in total, including redundancy pay, notice pay, holiday pay, and compensation for loss of earnings.
Partial · £5,990 · Feb 2023Partial£5,990Feb 2023Ground operations lead (5 years' service) v British Airways PLC
A ground operations lead's claims for unfair dismissal and race discrimination against British Airways were struck out after he repeatedly failed to comply with case management orders and did not attend the preliminary hearing.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Former employees v AAQUA LIMITED
Two former employees of AAQUA LIMITED were awarded over £24,000 after the company failed to respond to claims for unpaid wages, notice pay, and accrued holiday pay.
Won · £24,489 · Feb 2023Won£24,489Feb 2023Business adviser / hotel manager (4 years' service) v Masteron Group of Companies
A business adviser who was made redundant after his employer went into liquidation had his unfair dismissal claim rejected because he named the wrong company as respondent. The tribunal refused his late attempt to add the correct entity.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Former employee v Claim Time Limited t/a Claim Time Solicitors
A former employee who fabricated protected disclosures and pursued false allegations against his employer has had his unfair dismissal claim thrown out and been ordered to pay £17,650 in costs.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Customer service advisor (10 days' service) v ADP Call Centres Ltd
A customer service advisor who was dismissed after just 10 days had his unfair dismissal claim struck out for lack of qualifying service, and his discrimination claims dismissed as having no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Community Healthcare Assistant/Support Worker (20 years' service) v Cornwall Partnership NHS Trust
An NHS trust fairly dismissed a community healthcare assistant with 20 years' service for gross misconduct after she introduced a vulnerable patient to a convicted fraudster and shared confidential information. The employment tribunal upheld the dismissal.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Area Manager (11 years' service) v Crystal Services plc
An area manager who was moved to a new division and had his working pattern changed was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct and subjected to direct race discrimination. The tribunal found the dismissal both procedurally and substantively unfair.
Partial · Feb 2023Partial—Feb 2023Branch manager (care services) v Helping Hands Midshires Care Ltd
A branch manager who was dismissed just three weeks into her role failed to prove she was sacked because of her race or for raising safety concerns. The tribunal dismissed all claims after she did not attend the hearing.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Night Worker (4 months' service) v St Mungo Community Housing Association
A night worker with four months' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to carry out mandatory building patrols. The tribunal rejected his claims of automatic unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and victimisation.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Housing Options Advisor (21 years' service) v London Borough of Redbridge
A housing options advisor who was dismissed after failing a competitive interview was found to have been unfairly dismissed because the council failed to provide promised training and support. The tribunal awarded £2,698 in compensation.
Partial · £2,698 · Feb 2023Partial£2,698Feb 2023English & Maths Community Coordinator (9 years' service) v Birmingham Metropolitan College
An English & Maths Community Coordinator with 9 years' service was unfairly dismissed by Birmingham Metropolitan College during maternity leave, but the tribunal awarded no compensation due to a 100% Polkey reduction.
Partial · Feb 2023Partial—Feb 2023Fragrance Accounts Manager (11 years' service) v Mane Limited
A Fragrance Accounts Manager with 11 years' service was fairly dismissed for poor performance after a Performance Improvement Plan, and the tribunal rejected her claim that retirement discussions amounted to age discrimination.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v International Television Channel Limited
A tribunal refused to strike out an unfair dismissal claim despite the claimant's failure to comply with case management orders for months, because a fair hearing was still possible and less drastic measures could be used.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Bakery employee (7 years' service) v Dents Bakery Limited
A bakery employee with 7 years' service who believed he was suspended after a return-to-work meeting resigned two months later. The tribunal dismissed his constructive dismissal claim, finding no fundamental breach of contract.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Farm labourer (25 years' service) v Nodewell Farm Partners
A farm labourer with 25 years' service saw his unfair dismissal claim thrown out because he submitted it one day after the deadline, despite having previous tribunal experience.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Subcontractor manager (4 years' service) v Q
A subcontractor manager with four years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to pass on penalty costs to subcontractors. Her claims for unfair dismissal, disability discrimination and failure to make reasonable adjustments were all rejected.
Partial · Feb 2023Partial—Feb 2023Assistant manager (21 years' service) v Boots Management Services Limited
An assistant manager with 21 years' service was fairly dismissed for redundancy after scoring lower than a colleague on selection criteria. The tribunal upheld Boots' process.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Estate Caretaker (7 years' service) v Mainstay Facilities Management Limited
An estate caretaker who resigned claiming constructive unfair dismissal lost his case because he continued working for three years after the only proven breach of contract, amounting to affirmation.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Warehouse Department Manager (18 years' service) v Asda Stores Limited
An 18-year Asda manager resigned after being passed over for promotion and alleging verbal abuse, but the tribunal found he had affirmed the contract and the employer's conduct was not a repudiatory breach.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Direct Adviser (20 years' experience) v Gatehouse Bank Plc
A Direct Adviser with 20 years' experience was dismissed for performance after raising workload concerns. The tribunal found no causal link between the health and safety complaints and the dismissal, ruling it was a fair capability dismissal.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Teaching assistant (less than 2 years' service) v Meadowfield School
A teaching assistant with Type 1 diabetes, Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome and fibromyalgia had all her disability discrimination and victimisation claims against Meadowfield School dismissed by the tribunal.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v Skolak Healthcare Limited T/A Beechill Nursing Home
A former employee of Beechill Nursing Home was unfairly dismissed and had wages deducted for three shifts. The tribunal awarded £578.40 including an ACAS uplift.
Won · £578 · Feb 2023Won£578Feb 2023Warehouse operative (3 years' service) v Greggs Plc
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a warehouse operative with three years' service who washed her hands for less than five seconds, ruling that Greggs' decision was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Clinical night manager (clinical site practitioner) (35 years' service) v Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust
A clinical night manager with 35 years' service resigned over health and safety concerns during the pandemic. The tribunal found the trust did not breach her contract and dismissed her claim.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v First Rail Holdings Limited
A tribunal has refused a costs application by First Rail Holdings Limited against a former employee whose unfair dismissal claim was struck out, finding his genuine belief in the claim meant he did not act vexatiously.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Finance manager (13 years' service) v CI Accountancy Limited
A finance manager with 13 years' service was dismissed after taking leave to care for her husband with heart failure. The tribunal found disability discrimination and automatic unfair dismissal, awarding £114,421.
Partial · £114,421 · Feb 2023Partial£114,421Feb 2023Hair Assessor (4 years' service) v Skills to Group Limited
A tribunal has ruled that Skills to Group Limited fairly dismissed a hair assessor with 4 years' service who had been absent for 22 months due to complications from knee surgery. The employer's concerns about workplace safety justified the dismissal.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v Chris Hayter Haulage Limited
A tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claim after the former employee admitted he knew the time limits but delayed because he hoped for a settlement. The claim was presented 32 days late.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Personal Wellness Trainer (3 years 8 months' service) v The Wellness Zone Ltd t/a Klnik
A personal wellness trainer who resigned and claimed constructive unfair dismissal has had her claim thrown out, with the tribunal finding she made false allegations and was not forced to quit. She was ordered to pay £20,000 in costs.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Customer Care Adviser (6 years' service) v JD Sports Fashion Plc
A Customer Care Adviser who had worked from home for over two years was constructively dismissed when JD Sports forced him to relocate to a different office, increasing his commute to nearly three hours a day. The tribunal awarded £14,215.95.
Won · £14,216 · Feb 2023Won£14,216Feb 2023Former employee v Krispy Kreme U.K. Limited
A tribunal found that Krispy Kreme U.K. Limited constructively dismissed a former employee and discriminated against him because of his nationality. He was awarded £3,060 including £990 for injury to feelings.
Partial · £3,060 · Feb 2023Partial£3,060Feb 2023Sales Manager (3 years 8 months' service) v Jansen UK Ltd
A sales manager who was dismissed by phone after insisting on a contractual £3k bonus has been awarded over £39,000 for unfair dismissal. The tribunal found the real reason was the bonus dispute, not poor performance.
Won · £39,073 · Feb 2023Won£39,073Feb 2023General manager (3 years' service) v Sizer Engineering Limited
A general manager who resigned after a dispute over his bonus and holiday pay was not constructively dismissed, the tribunal ruled. All claims were dismissed.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v Craven Inns Limited
A former employee of Craven Inns Limited has won claims for unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal, and unlawful deduction from wages, receiving a total of £9,313.83 plus costs.
Won · £9,314 · Feb 2023Won£9,314Feb 2023Senior manager (1 year's service) v Nextsteps Development (1) and Nextsteps @ Barnstaple CIC (2)
A senior manager who was not paid for five months and then underpaid for six more has won her claim for unauthorised deductions. The tribunal found she was an employee from March 2021 and entitled to full pay.
Won · Feb 2023Won—Feb 2023Assistant Director, Border Force (9 years' service) v The Home Office
A 9-year Border Force Assistant Director was unfairly and wrongfully dismissed after refusing a redeployment instruction. The Leeds tribunal awarded £51,891.73, including a 10% ACAS uplift.
Won · £51,892 · Feb 2023Won£51,892Feb 2023Carpet fitter v Rema Tip Top Industry UK Ltd
A tribunal ordered a former carpet fitter to pay £12,950 in costs after he pursued disability discrimination and unfair dismissal claims that were out of time and based on untruthful evidence. His former solicitors were also ordered to pay £1,600 in wasted costs.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Former employee v James Mclaughlin
A former employee's claims for unfair dismissal and unauthorised deduction from wages were struck out or dismissed after he failed to attend the final hearing and had less than two years' service.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Home care worker (less than 6 weeks' service) v Joy2Care Ltd
A home care worker who sent abusive emails and refused to engage with her employer after less than six weeks' work was fairly dismissed for 'some other substantial reason'. The tribunal rejected all her claims.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Quality Inspector (6 years' service) v I Holland Limited
A quality inspector with six years' service was fairly dismissed after using a micrometer to measure dies, despite a final warning for non-compliance. The tribunal found the employer acted within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Vehicle Handling Operative (VHO) at Jaguar Land Rover Halewood v Resource Management Solutions (North East) Limited
A Vehicle Handling Operative was unfairly dismissed after his employer incorrectly scored his absence record and then removed two selection criteria on appeal, a tribunal has ruled. He was awarded £13,868.
Won · £13,868 · Feb 2023Won£13,868Feb 2023Senior vehicle engineer (16 years' service) v London General Transport Services Limited t/a Go-Ahead London
A senior vehicle engineer with 16 years' service was unfairly dismissed after his employer relied on a stale medical report. The tribunal awarded £12,473.64 but found he would have been fairly dismissed 7 weeks later.
Partial · £12,474 · Feb 2023Partial£12,474Feb 2023Former employee (service manager) v Enable Care Services (South Wales) Ltd
A former service manager's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after she failed to attend a case management hearing and did not comply with subsequent tribunal orders. Her application for reconsideration was refused.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Former employee v Busy Bees Nurseries Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was reinstated after the tribunal admitted it sent key correspondence to the wrong email address, causing the claim to be struck out for non-response.
Remitted · Feb 2023Remitted—Feb 2023Town Clerk (6 years' service) v Pembrey and Burry Port Town Council
A town clerk with six years' service resigned after her employer delayed a pay review and gave evasive responses to her grievance. The tribunal found she was constructively unfairly dismissed and awarded £40,299.
Partial · £40,299 · Feb 2023Partial£40,299Feb 2023Former employee v Bispham and Cleveleys Kitchens Limited
A former employee of Bispham and Cleveleys Kitchens Limited successfully claimed for an unlawful deduction of wages after the company failed to pay one week's statutory sick pay. Her automatic unfair dismissal claim was dismissed.
Partial · £99 · Feb 2023Partial£99Feb 2023Former employee v Gillian Saleem
A former employee who was not paid for 48 hours of work won her unauthorised deductions claim for £460.80, but her unfair dismissal claim was thrown out because she had less than two years' continuous employment.
Partial · £461 · Feb 2023Partial£461Feb 2023Teacher (2 years 8 months' service) v Orchard Hill College Academy Trust
A teacher at a special needs school succeeded in a whistleblowing detriment claim after the chair of governors sent an email suggesting counter-proceedings against him, which was accidentally disclosed. The tribunal awarded £2,500 for injury to feelings.
Partial · £2,500 · Feb 2023Partial£2,500Feb 2023Finance director (5 years' service) v Next Steps Independence Ltd
A finance director who raised concerns about safeguarding was suspended and forced to resign. The tribunal found he was constructively dismissed because of his public interest disclosures.
Won · Feb 2023Won—Feb 2023Business Administration Manager (21 years' service) v British Car Auctions Limited
A Business Administration Manager with 21 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed redundancy selection process that the tribunal found was tainted by age discrimination. The case highlights the risks of competency-based scoring lacking transparency.
Won · Feb 2023Won—Feb 2023Former employee v Bright Blue Foods Limited
A tribunal confirmed a costs order against a former employee even though the strike-out application was heard at a private hearing, which was a procedural error. The employee's reconsideration application was refused.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Maintenance craftsperson (Barnet Hospital) v Bouygues Energies and Services
A maintenance worker at Barnet Hospital was unfairly dismissed after refusing a COVID-19 test. The tribunal found the procedure was rushed and the testing policy was never properly communicated.
Won · Feb 2023Won—Feb 2023Former fuel depot operator (2 years' service) v The Oil and Pipelines Agency
A former fuel depot operator who repeatedly accessed his employer's IT system after being told not to has lost his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the dismissal for gross misconduct was fair.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Work area manager (11 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Limited
A manager with 11 years' service at Royal Mail had his unfair dismissal claim dismissed because he filed it after the three-month deadline. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for him to have filed in time.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Arrears and Investigations Manager (19 years' service) v Slough Borough Council
An Arrears and Investigations Manager with 19 years' service was unfairly dismissed when Slough Borough Council failed to consult properly and timed her redundancy 17 days before her 55th birthday, costing her pension access. Tribunal awarded £60,625.84.
Partial · £60,626 · Feb 2023Partial£60,626Feb 2023Former employee v Trackforce Recruitment Limited
A former employee won over £5,500 after her employer failed to respond to her tribunal claim for redundancy pay, unpaid holiday, notice pay and an unauthorised deduction from wages.
Won · £5,507 · Feb 2023Won£5,507Feb 2023Teaching assistant (8 years' service) v The Governing Body of Dalmain Primary School and the London Borough of Lewisham
An employment tribunal has dismissed an unfair dismissal claim by a teaching assistant who accepted voluntary redundancy during a school restructure, finding the process was fair.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v The Workshop Coffee House Ltd
A former employee was awarded over £18,500 after being automatically unfairly dismissed due to pregnancy. The employer did not defend the claim, leading to a default judgment.
Won · £18,523 · Feb 2023Won£18,523Feb 2023Mechanical Engineer (37 years' service) v Ministry of Defence
A mechanical engineer with 37 years' service was unfairly dismissed for unauthorised absence after the Ministry of Defence failed to consider his mental health. He was awarded £19,710.
Won · £19,710 · Feb 2023Won£19,710Feb 2023Accounts manager (22 years' service) v Real Estates (Cornwall) Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of an accounts manager with 22 years' service who failed to open nearly 2,000 work emails and set up two-step verification blocking her boss's access. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Finance Manager/Sales Executive (US-based) v Xexec Ltd
A finance manager who moved to New York for work was unable to pursue unfair dismissal claims in the UK because his employment had stronger ties to the US. The tribunal ruled it lacked territorial jurisdiction.
Partial · Feb 2023Partial—Feb 2023Progression Manager (21 years' service) v Countryside Properties (UK) Limited
A Progression Manager with 21 years' service was unfairly dismissed after an investigation that relied on hearsay and leading questions. The employment tribunal found the process fell outside the band of reasonable responses.
Won · Feb 2023Won—Feb 2023Former employee v Commissioners for Her Majesty's Revenue & Customs
An employee who worked for HMRC for under two years had their unfair dismissal claim automatically struck out, and their discrimination claims failed on the merits.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Live-in Governor (Tutor) (10 months' service) v Ms Y Shkop
A live-in governor who injured his wrist cutting lobsters and was dismissed days after raising health and safety concerns lost his automatic unfair dismissal claim because the employer was unaware of the complaint. The tribunal did, however, order the employer to provide an amended contract reflecting a promise to pay healthcare costs.
Partial · Feb 2023Partial—Feb 2023Senior Store Manager (11 years' service) v Credentia Foods Ltd
A senior store manager who resigned after his new employer withheld paternity pay and started disciplinary proceedings for unauthorised absence has won a constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal awarded £20,446.
Won · £20,446 · Feb 2023Won£20,446Feb 2023Process Improvement Leader (3 years' service) v Unilever UK Limited
A Process Improvement Leader who refused to wear face masks and glasses during the pandemic and behaved aggressively towards managers was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal ruled.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Yard Manager (2 years' service) v A.S.H Elite Equine Ltd
A yard manager was dismissed just weeks after telling her employer she was pregnant. The tribunal awarded over £54,000 for automatic unfair dismissal and pregnancy discrimination.
Won · £54,911 · Feb 2023Won£54,911Feb 2023Goods Receiving / Storekeeper (3 years 8 months' service) v Plaza Premium Lounge (UK) Limited
A tribunal has ruled that a storekeeper's redundancy dismissal was fair, finding that the employer followed a reasonable selection process and consulted properly during the pandemic.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Sales agent (7 months' service) v Hansbiomed Europé Ltd
A sales agent with seven months' service was fairly dismissed after refusing to accept a PR manager role that required some sales tasks. Her claims of unfair dismissal, discrimination, and whistleblowing were all rejected.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v Kapetil (High Peak) Ltd T/A Toni & Guy Macclesfield
A former employee's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims have been struck out after he repeatedly failed to comply with case management orders and did not attend the strike-out hearing.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Former employee (5 years' service) v Greenbrow Social Club Ltd (In Administration)
A former employee with 5 years' service was awarded £8,756 after her employer failed to defend her unfair dismissal claim and later entered administration.
Won · £8,756 · Feb 2023Won£8,756Feb 2023Sales assistant (12 years' service) v John Lewis Plc
A sales assistant with 12 years' service was dismissed for alleged dishonesty on his application form. The tribunal found the investigation was flawed but the dismissal was not because of his protected disclosure.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee (4 years' service) v Three Rivers District Council
A former employee of Three Rivers District Council was refused permission to add pregnancy discrimination claims to her existing race and constructive dismissal case, as the application came over two years after the time limit expired.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Bank recovery worker (healthcare assistant) v Elysium Healthcare Limited
An employment tribunal has dismissed claims of whistleblowing detriment and race discrimination brought by a former bank recovery worker against Elysium Healthcare Limited. The tribunal found that the claimant's removal from the bank staff list was due to a patient safety incident, not her protected disclosure or race.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee (white collar, salaried) v AC Precision Engineering Ltd
A former employee of AC Precision Engineering Ltd was awarded £4,101 after the tribunal found the company unlawfully deducted holiday pay and failed to provide a written contract.
Partial · £4,101 · Feb 2023Partial£4,101Feb 2023Relief Security Officer (2 weeks' service) v Sentry Consulting Limited
A relief security officer with only two weeks' service won his disability discrimination claim after his employer stopped offering him shifts when he disclosed his Asperger's and dyslexia and asked for flexibility on start times.
Partial · Feb 2023Partial—Feb 2023Former employee v Broadbent Assist Ltd
A former employee was unfairly dismissed by Broadbent Assist Ltd but her compensation was limited to just four weeks' pay. The tribunal also dismissed her discrimination and victimisation claims.
Partial · £2,070 · Feb 2023Partial£2,070Feb 2023Warehouse operative (2 years' service) v Bunzl UK Limited
A warehouse operative who knocked a colleague unconscious with a roll of pallet wrap during a fight was fairly dismissed. The tribunal upheld Bunzl UK Limited's decision, finding the investigation and process reasonable.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Employee Relations Advisor (6 weeks' service) v Care UK Community Partnerships Ltd
An employee with Asplenia and Ehlers Danlos Syndrome was automatically unfairly dismissed after asking to work from home on government shielding advice. The tribunal found the real reason was her disability.
Won · Feb 2023Won—Feb 2023Former employee v Greenwich Leisure Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after she did not attend the final hearing. The tribunal refused a last-minute postponement because the medical evidence did not show she was unfit to attend the hearing.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023IT business consultant / service designer (4 years' service) v Experian Limited
An IT consultant who resigned after being placed on performance improvement plans while experiencing menopausal symptoms lost her claims for constructive unfair dismissal and discrimination. The tribunal found Experian's actions were reasonable and not discriminatory.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Operations Director (6 years' service) v Opsec Security Limited
An Operations Director with six years' service resigned after his responsibilities were progressively stripped without consultation. The tribunal found constructive unfair dismissal.
Won · Feb 2023Won—Feb 2023Office Assistant (7 years' service) v UK Atlantis Ltd
An office assistant with seven years' service was unfairly dismissed after her husband fell out with the company director. The tribunal found the redundancy was a sham and awarded £17,235.
Won · £17,235 · Feb 2023Won£17,235Feb 2023Shop assistant (part-time, 4 years' service) v Neil Adams and David Asplin T/a G David Bookseller
A part-time shop assistant who told a partner to 'fuck off' and left work early was not dismissed but resigned, the Cambridge Employment Tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Transport coordinator (2 years 5 months' service) v Speedy Asset Services Limited
A transport coordinator with two years' service was unfairly dismissed after being sacked for driving without a tachograph card. The tribunal found the employer failed to consider her mitigation and awarded £5,991.
Won · £5,991 · Feb 2023Won£5,991Feb 2023Former employee (25 years' service) v MB Evans Limited
A Cardiff tribunal found that MB Evans Limited unfairly dismissed a 25-year employee without notice during a redundancy. The employee was awarded £21,936 in compensation.
Partial · £21,936 · Jan 2023Partial£21,936Jan 2023Maintenance manager (6 years' service) v Cosgrove Leisure Parks UK Ltd
A maintenance manager with 6 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed disciplinary process. The tribunal awarded £8,455, applying a 20% ACAS uplift, a 25% Polkey reduction, and a 20% contributory fault reduction.
Won · £8,455 · Jan 2023Won£8,455Jan 2023Kitchen/snack bar worker (21 years' service) v Ardeigh House Community Association
A kitchen worker with 21 years' service was found to have been discriminated against on grounds of age when her employer failed to contact her about a redundancy. The tribunal awarded £11,400 including injury to feelings.
Partial · £11,400 · Jan 2023Partial£11,400Jan 2023Chef (2 years' service) v Bills Restaurants Limited
A chef who was dismissed for gross misconduct after an allergen incident saw his unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal and unlawful deduction claims dismissed because they were presented to the tribunal one day after the statutory deadline.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Warehouse operative (7 years' service) v John Lewis plc
A warehouse operative with 7 years' service resigned after securing a new job, but his claim that a final incident forced him out was rejected by the tribunal. All claims of constructive dismissal, disability discrimination, and harassment were dismissed.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Executive Assistant (5 years' service) v University of London
An executive assistant who resigned after her request to reduce hours to 2.5 days per week was refused has lost her constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the university acted reasonably.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v RT Decorators and Builders Ltd
A former employee who brought an unfair dismissal claim without the required two years' service, and a notice pay claim nearly eleven months late, has had both claims dismissed by the London Central Employment Tribunal.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Loading Dock Operative and Pit Driver (5 years' service) v Amazon UK Services Ltd
An Amazon loading dock operative was fairly dismissed after driving a PIT truck within touching distance of pedestrians crossing a walkway, despite denying wrongdoing. The tribunal upheld the decision, citing the employer's genuine belief in misconduct and the claimant's lack of remorse.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Minibus driver and midday meals assistant (4 years' service) v Gatehouse Educational Trust Limited
A school minibus driver who claimed she was made redundant because of her sex has lost her case. The tribunal found no evidence of discrimination and noted she had not engaged with the consultation process.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Track technician (5 years' service) v Transport for London
A Transport for London track technician who resigned and then failed to comply with tribunal orders or attend hearings has had his unfair dismissal claim struck out.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Divisional Accountant (Family Care Division, 2007-2016) v East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust
A divisional accountant lost her equal pay claim after the tribunal accepted that the higher pay of male comparators was due to the greater size and complexity of their divisions, not sex discrimination.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Head of Digital, Wordpress Developer (1 year 8 months' service) v Alive Digital Limited
A head of digital who worked for less than two years had her unfair dismissal claim struck out for lack of jurisdiction, and her other claims dismissed after she failed to attend the hearing.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee v Manor Restaurants (UK) Limited
A former employee's claim for unpaid wages and discrimination was struck out after he presented it late and failed to attend the preliminary hearing. No damages were awarded.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee (concierge staff) v Urbanbubble Liverpool Limited (in Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation)
An employee who resigned with one month's notice was dismissed without notice by her employer, which later went into liquidation. The tribunal awarded £1,661.25 for unfair dismissal, statutory redundancy, and breach of contract.
Won · £1,661 · Jan 2023Won£1,661Jan 2023Former employee v Norton Industrial Fasteners Ltd
A former employee who was unfairly dismissed and subjected to a sexist comment by a director has been awarded £5,665.07 by the Cambridge Employment Tribunal.
Partial · £5,665 · Jan 2023Partial£5,665Jan 2023Project Controls Manager (5 years' service) v Ministry of Defence
A US national employed for five years by the Ministry of Defence was dismissed when the department realised her contract was void under Civil Service Nationality Rules. The tribunal struck out all claims as having no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Administrative assistant and library assistant (7 months' service) v John Colet School
An employment tribunal struck out an administrative assistant's unfair dismissal claim after she behaved disruptively, made unfounded allegations, and repeatedly failed to provide further particulars despite multiple orders.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee (34 years' service) v Mr N.D Brandon-King Trading as Kings Lettings
A former employee with 34 years' service won her constructive dismissal claim after her employer failed to follow proper grievance and disciplinary procedures. The tribunal awarded £62,416.88, including a 15% uplift for breaching the ACAS Code.
Won · £62,417 · Jan 2023Won£62,417Jan 2023Former employee v The Little School Day Nursery Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out because she had less than two years' service. Her wrongful dismissal claim was dismissed after she failed to attend the hearing.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee (HR department) v South East Coast Ambulance Service
A tribunal dismissed claims for unfair dismissal and discrimination after the former employee waited over eight months to bring her case, despite being told by her union that the deadline had passed.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions
The tribunal struck out race and disability discrimination claims because they were presented late, and the claimant failed to attend the hearing or provide reasons for the delay.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Senior Accountant (6 years' service) v Blackberry UK Limited
A senior accountant who was selected for redundancy shortly after returning from maternity leave has lost her unfair dismissal and discrimination claims. The tribunal found the redundancy was genuine and the scoring process was fair.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Social worker (Children's Services) v London Borough of Enfield
A children's services social worker with dyspraxia was discriminated against when her employer placed her on performance improvement plans. The tribunal awarded £5,382.90 but rejected her constructive dismissal claim.
Partial · £5,383 · Jan 2023Partial£5,383Jan 2023Design co-ordinator (sole director and shareholder of her own company) v Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy
A design co-ordinator who was the sole director and shareholder of her own company could not claim redundancy or other payments from the National Insurance Fund because she was not an employee. The tribunal dismissed her claims.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Stage crew member (long service) v Welsh National Opera
A long-serving stage crew member with dyslexia has won his unfair dismissal claim against Welsh National Opera after the tribunal found the employer failed to discuss reasonable adjustments during a redundancy process. All other claims, including age discrimination and protected disclosure complaints, were dismissed.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Barber (3 years' service) v Mr Christian Donnelly t/a Acute Barbers
A barber with three years' service was unfairly dismissed via WhatsApp after calling in sick. The tribunal also found the employer made unauthorised deductions from wages and failed to provide a written contract, awarding £3,435.59.
Partial · £3,436 · Jan 2023Partial£3,436Jan 2023Support worker (4 years' service) v Salutem LD Bidco IV Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a support worker who refused to comply with a mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy, finding the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Group Chief Technology Officer (CTO) v Telmar Europe Limited
A group chief technology officer who worked for a company via his own limited company before becoming an employee was unable to claim unfair dismissal because his continuous service fell short of two years.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee v Nottingham City Council
A default judgment against Nottingham City Council was revoked after the tribunal found it had lost the employer's response. The case will now proceed to a full hearing.
Remitted · Jan 2023Remitted—Jan 2023School Business Manager (17 years' service) v The Oak Trust
A school business manager with 17 years' service was unfairly dismissed and directly discriminated against on grounds of age when her redundancy was timed to avoid a pension strain payment. The tribunal found only a 10% chance she would have kept her job under a fair process.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Mechanical design engineer (2 years' service) v Federal-Mogul Controlled Power Limited
A mechanical design engineer with two years' service failed to prove his redundancy was a sham, with the tribunal rejecting claims of whistleblowing, age discrimination and health and safety detriments. Only a conceded holiday pay award of £2,249.99 was made.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Group Facilities Manager (4 years' service) v AI-Mubarakia Limited
A Group Facilities Manager was dismissed in a sham redundancy after a director made racist comments. The tribunal upheld claims of unfair dismissal, direct race discrimination, and harassment.
Won · Jan 2023Won—Jan 2023Former employee (just over 1 year's service) v Nubreed Hotels Ltd
A former employee of Nubreed Hotels Ltd who was made redundant after just over a year was unable to claim unfair dismissal due to insufficient service, but won £166 for a two-day shortfall in notice pay.
Partial · £166 · Jan 2023Partial£166Jan 2023Facilities service support assistant (41 years' service) v University Hospitals of North Midlands NHS Trust
A facilities service support assistant with 41 years' service was fairly dismissed after failing to return from the Gambia when flights were available, the tribunal ruled.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Personal assistant (carer) v G
Two personal assistants lost their unfair dismissal claims after a tribunal found a genuine redundancy situation when their employer's care needs changed. They were awarded notice pay of £156.
Partial · £628 · Jan 2023Partial£628Jan 2023Cleaner (1 year 9 months' service) v Anglia Cleaning Solutions Limited
A cleaner who was left waiting for a manager who never showed up, and later told the cleaning contract had ended, has been awarded £785.73 for unpaid wages, holiday pay, notice pay, expenses, and pension contributions.
Partial · £786 · Jan 2023Partial£786Jan 2023Social worker (14 years' service) v Cardiff County Council
A social worker with 14 years' service resigned after raising concerns about a colleague's return to work. Her claim was filed 7 days late, but the tribunal allowed it to proceed due to ongoing ACAS negotiations and her mental health.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Fork Lift Truck Driver (13 years' service) v Unipart Group
A forklift driver with 13 years' service was fairly dismissed after dropping a pallet, failing to report it, and attempting to cover up the incident while still under a live warning.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v People Solutions Resourcing Limited
A former employee who worked for less than two years had his unfair dismissal claim struck out for lack of jurisdiction. His separate claim for unpaid wages was dismissed as unfounded, and he was ordered to pay £1,000 in costs after leaving the hearing early.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee v The Department of Work and Pensions
A former employee who suffered PTSD after a violent attack at work was not considered disabled under the Equality Act until four months later, the tribunal ruled. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v Creations Hairdressers & Barbering Studio Ltd.
A former employee who did not attend hearings or respond to a strike-out warning had his unfair dismissal and discrimination claim struck out. The tribunal also ordered him to pay £3,488.40 in costs.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Supermarket Assistant (3 years' service) v John Lewis PLC
A Waitrose employee who refused to carry out reasonable tasks and used foul language about managers was fairly dismissed for misconduct. The tribunal awarded £536.94 for unpaid holiday and overtime.
Partial · £537 · Jan 2023Partial£537Jan 2023English to German translator (10 years' service) v STB Limited (trading as Surrey Translation Bureau)
An English to German translator with multiple sclerosis won her claim that her employer failed to make reasonable adjustments during redundancy consultation, but the tribunal upheld the redundancy dismissal as fair.
Partial · £1,350 · Jan 2023Partial£1,350Jan 2023YES youth worker (30 years' service) v Reading Borough Council
A Reading Borough Council youth worker with 30 years' service failed to prove her dismissal for poor performance was racially motivated. The tribunal found no less favourable treatment compared to a hypothetical comparator.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v West Suffolk Council
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against West Suffolk Council was settled via ACAS in June 2022, but a default judgment was mistakenly entered in December. The tribunal set it aside after a joint application.
Settled · Jan 2023Settled—Jan 2023Registered nurse / swabber (agency worker) v Hearts First Ambulance Ltd (1), Collinson Group (2)
A registered nurse working as a swabber at a COVID-19 testing site claimed she was removed after raising health and safety concerns, but the tribunal found she did not make any protected disclosures and was removed due to a dispute over a break rota.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Music tutor v Rhythmix (in Liquidation) Ltd
A tribunal found that music tutors for a charity were employees despite being treated as self-employed, entitling them to redundancy and holiday pay.
Won · Jan 2023Won—Jan 2023Prison Officer (13 years' service) v The Secretary of State for Justice
A prison officer with 13 years' service had her unfair dismissal claim thrown out because she presented it more than two years after being sacked. The tribunal accepted it was not reasonably practicable to claim in time due to mental health issues, but said she did not act quickly enough once able.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee (6 years' service) v Ibco Limited
A tribunal upheld claims of unfair dismissal, indirect race discrimination, and victimisation for one former employee, and unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and failure to make reasonable adjustments for another. Damages of £31,752 were awarded to the first claimant.
Partial · £31,752 · Jan 2023Partial£31,752Jan 2023Finance Business Partner (21 years' service) v Network Rail Infrastructure Ltd
A finance business partner with 21 years' service tried to withdraw from a voluntary severance scheme the day after signing. The tribunal upheld Network Rail's refusal, finding no dismissal and no age discrimination.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Stress Testing Controls Analysis Manager v National Westminster Bank PLC
A tribunal has allowed a former Stress Testing Controls Analysis Manager to amend her claim to include public interest disclosure detriment and an additional equal pay comparator, but refused most of her sex and race discrimination allegations.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Former employee v Ion Man Limited
A tribunal dismissed a former employee's claim for unpaid wages and holiday pay after he failed to attend the telephone hearing. His application for reconsideration was refused because the notice had been sent to his email address.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Spanish teacher (12 years' service) v Interhigh Education Ltd
A Spanish teacher with 12 years' service was unfairly dismissed for refusing a new contract after his employer misrepresented a pay rise as 10% when it was actually 1.2%. The tribunal found the dismissal outside the range of reasonable responses.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Former employee v CBRE Managed Services Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was rejected after she presented it 19 days late, citing an IT mistake and mental health issues. The tribunal found no exceptional circumstances to extend the time limit.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Transport Team Leader (16 years' service) v 3663 Transport Limited
A Transport Team Leader with 16 years' service was unfairly dismissed after his LGV licence was revoked due to depression. The tribunal found the employer failed to consider alternative roles or reasonable adjustments.
Won · Jan 2023Won—Jan 2023Former employee (Spare Passenger Vehicle Driver) v Pertemps Recruitment Partnership Limited
A former passenger vehicle driver lost his unfair dismissal, race discrimination, and unlawful deduction claims after the tribunal found they were brought too late and he failed to attend the preliminary hearing.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee v Vision on Services GB Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after he failed to attend a preliminary hearing, despite being warned that non-attendance could lead to strike-out. No compensation was awarded.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee v Kalchal Limited
A former employee was awarded over £1,100 after her employer failed to pay her final week's wages and holiday pay, and unfairly dismissed her. The employer did not file a response to the claim.
Won · £1,102 · Jan 2023Won£1,102Jan 2023Operations Manager (Structured Coaching) (5 years' service) v Crisis UK
An operations manager who previously brought a sex discrimination claim was victimised and constructively dismissed after a flawed disciplinary process. The tribunal found Crisis UK breached the implied term of trust and confidence.
Won · Jan 2023Won—Jan 2023Store manager (7 years' service) v Cruise Clothing Limited
A store manager with seven years' service was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to report and dispose of cannabis found in the store, but the tribunal found the allegations of offering drugs to staff were not proven.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Band 5 Staff Nurse (30 years' experience) v University Hospitals Bristol and Weston NHS Trust
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a nurse who failed to demonstrate basic nursing skills during a supernumerary training period, despite 30 years of experience. The trust's decision was found to be within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Bank worker (care home) v Cygnet Health Care Limited
A care home bank worker who was dismissed for not being vaccinated against COVID-19 failed to prove discrimination but succeeded in claiming unpaid wages and holiday pay for seven shifts, totalling £891.80.
Partial · £892 · Jan 2023Partial£892Jan 2023Gymnastics club employee (7 weeks' service) v AAW Holdings Limited (sued as Leeds Rebound Gymnastics Club Limited)
A tribunal found that a gymnastics club failed to make reasonable adjustments for a dyslexic employee and discriminated against her due to pregnancy, awarding £17,755.05.
Partial · £17,755 · Jan 2023Partial£17,755Jan 2023Postman (35 years' service) v Royal Mail Group
A postman with 35 years' unblemished service was fairly dismissed after walking through a prohibited area without a high-vis jacket, the tribunal ruled. He refused to engage in the disciplinary process.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v Ormskirk Metal Fabrications Ltd
A former employee won £10,405 after his employer failed to respond to his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found he was dismissed by reason of redundancy without proper notice or pay for accrued holiday.
Won · £10,405 · Jan 2023Won£10,405Jan 2023Quality assurance engineer (12 years' service) v Bridgehead Software Ltd
A quality assurance engineer with 12 years' service lost his unfair dismissal claim because he filed it one day late, and the tribunal refused to extend time despite his autism spectrum diagnosis.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Forklift truck driver (agency worker) v Extraman Limited
A tribunal has ruled that an agency forklift truck driver was not an employee of Extraman Limited, meaning he could not bring an unfair dismissal claim. The victimisation claim also failed.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Centre Manager (17 years' service) v West Northamptonshire Council
A centre manager with 17 years' service resigned after her employer delayed responding to her return-to-work plan and failed to follow occupational health advice. The tribunal found constructive unfair dismissal.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Sales Negotiator (4 years' service) v Bradleys Estate Agents Limited
A sales negotiator with cancer was constructively unfairly dismissed after her employer rejected her grievance about a manager's comment without holding a meeting. The tribunal found a fundamental breach of trust and confidence.
Won · Jan 2023Won—Jan 2023Former employee v Just One Body
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out because they had not worked for two years, but the tribunal awarded £2,580.16 for unauthorised deductions and breach of contract.
Dismissed · £2,580 · Jan 2023Dismissed£2,580Jan 2023Former employee v Arcadia Group Limited (in administration)
A former employee of Arcadia Group was automatically unfairly dismissed after being selected for redundancy during maternity leave. The tribunal awarded over £54,000 for injury to feelings and losses.
Won · £54,829 · Jan 2023Won£54,829Jan 2023Former employee (short service) v Phew Limited
A former employee who missed the three-month deadline to bring unfair dismissal and discrimination claims by four months had her case struck out, despite severe depression and an overdose.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Street cleaner (40+ years' service) v Continental Landscape Ltd
A street cleaner who was pressured to resign on his 66th birthday had his constructive dismissal claim dismissed because he filed it almost a year late. The tribunal said it had no jurisdiction to hear the case.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Tutor (8 months' service) v Middleton Murray Ltd (in liquidation)
A tribunal dismissed all claims of disability discrimination, harassment, victimisation, and wrongful dismissal brought by a tutor with depression against her employer and individual managers.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Warehouse operative (4.5 years' service) v Asda Stores Limited
A warehouse operative with 4.5 years' service was fairly dismissed after lengthy sickness absence. The tribunal rejected claims of discrimination and victimisation.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v Martin McColl Limited
A tribunal awarded wasted costs against a company's representative for failing to respond to correspondence and case management orders, causing the other side to incur unnecessary preparation costs.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v Change Hospitality Hub Ltd
A former employee's claim for holiday pay was dismissed after she failed to attend the final hearing and did not comply with case management orders. The tribunal found she had not actively pursued her claim.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Community Support Worker (30 years' service) v Bolton Cares (A) Limited
A community support worker with 30 years' service was constructively unfairly dismissed after her employer moved her to a location inaccessible by public transport without any consultation. The tribunal awarded £39,609.
Won · £39,609 · Jan 2023Won£39,609Jan 2023Education Safeguarding Officer (1 year 9 months' service) v City of Bradford Metropolitan District Council
An Education Safeguarding Officer who resigned and claimed constructive unfair dismissal, race discrimination, and whistleblowing detriment has lost all claims at tribunal. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v Linde Material Handling (UK) Ltd
An employment tribunal dismissed all claims after finding they were settled by a COT3 agreement, and refused reconsideration. The claimant was ordered to pay £1,750 + VAT in costs.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Driver (4 years' service) v Acrelane Timber Limited
Two drivers were fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after they misled their employer about their whereabouts when recalled from furlough. The tribunal upheld the dismissals but found the employer breached contract by failing to give notice.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Prison officer v Secretary of State for Justice
Two prison officers at HMP Belmarsh were dismissed for gross misconduct after a physical altercation with a prisoner. The tribunal upheld the dismissals, finding the employer's investigation and disciplinary process were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Operations Director (20 years' service) v Data Labs Global Ltd
Two operations directors with 20 years' service were awarded redundancy pay and notice pay after their employer went into winding-up, but their unfair dismissal claims were rejected.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023In-house Doctor (15 years' service) v Government of the State of Kuwait
An in-house doctor with 15 years' service was subjected to race discrimination and harassment by the Government of the State of Kuwait. The Central London Employment Tribunal awarded him £551,051 in damages for personal injury.
Partial · £551,051 · Jan 2023Partial£551,051Jan 2023Former employee v Rohit Vikal
A former employee's unfair dismissal and whistleblowing claims were dismissed after she failed to attend two hearings, including a telephone hearing where neither party showed up.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Health Care Assistant (bank staff, mental health) v Cornwall Partnership NHS Trust
A bank health care assistant at an NHS trust was de-registered after raising concerns about patients' neglected animals. The tribunal ruled she suffered a detriment for making protected disclosures.
Won · £20,713 · Jan 2023Won£20,713Jan 2023Clerk and receiver (29 years' service) v The Charity of Thomas Dawson
A charity's decision to delete a clerk and receiver role and replace it with a general manager post was fair, the tribunal ruled, rejecting claims of unfair dismissal and unpaid holiday pay.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Hygiene Operative (train cleaning contract) v Atalian Servest Limited
A hygiene operative who waited over five months to bring an unfair dismissal claim had his case thrown out as the tribunal found it was reasonably practicable to have filed on time.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Kitchen porter (2 years 10 months' service) v Nemaste Village Limited
A kitchen porter who refused to return to part-time work with furlough top-up during the pandemic was fairly dismissed for some other substantial reason. The tribunal awarded £218.04 in unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £218 · Jan 2023Partial£218Jan 2023Manager (32 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A manager with 32 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after selling Royal Mail PPE worth £20 on a local website. The tribunal upheld the dismissal, finding the employer's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Practice Manager (former employee and director) v Khan Solicitors Limited
A tribunal revoked a 2014 judgment finding a practice manager guilty of financial impropriety, after new documents emerged and the parties reached a settlement. The claim was then dismissed on withdrawal.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Business Development Director (5 years' service) v Travelliance Inc
A Business Development Director who was summarily dismissed on a Zoom call and told he was a contractor has won nearly £293,000 after a tribunal ruled he was an employee and unfairly dismissed.
Partial · £292,790 · Jan 2023Partial£292,790Jan 2023Bus driver (2 years 5 months' service) v M Limited
A bus driver who performed oral sex on a woman while driving and used his mobile phone was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal also ordered him to pay £7,500 costs for pursuing hopeless discrimination claims.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Leisure centre attendant v Active Northumberland
A leisure centre attendant who was dismissed after less than two years' continuous employment could not bring an unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal ruled his employment started only when he began his first paid shift, not when he did unpaid job shadowing.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Services Account Manager (4 years' service) v SAP (UK) Limited
A Services Account Manager with four years' service was constructively and unfairly dismissed after SAP placed her on a performance improvement plan and reallocated her largest accounts without proper process. The tribunal dismissed her discrimination claims.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Medical secretary (11.5 years' service) v East End Medical Centre
A medical secretary with 11.5 years' service resigned claiming bullying by her manager, but the tribunal found the employer's investigation was reasonable and there was no breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Delivery driver (over 20 years' service) v M G Seven Ltd (t/a Gainsborough Flower)
A delivery driver with over 20 years' service was unfairly dismissed when his employer sent a P45 via WhatsApp without any disciplinary process. The tribunal awarded £5,786.78 after deductions for contributory conduct and a Polkey reduction.
Partial · £5,787 · Jan 2023Partial£5,787Jan 2023Retail assistant (15 years' service) v Sainsbury’s Supermarkets Ltd
A 15-year retail assistant had her entire claim struck out after failing to respond to a strike-out warning and not complying with case management orders. The tribunal had already dismissed her race discrimination claims and refused to add a whistleblowing complaint.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Air conditioning unit service worker v Newage Environmental Technology Limited
A tribunal awarded £3,510 for unpaid wages but dismissed claims that the worker was dismissed for raising health and safety concerns about a staircase.
Partial · £3,510 · Jan 2023Partial£3,510Jan 2023Administrator/Receptionist (2.5 years' service) v Opus Care Limited
An administrator with 2.5 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after an audit revealed failures in pre-employment checks and confidential documents were found at her desk. The tribunal upheld the dismissal as fair.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Beauty therapist (7 years' service) v Brampton Manor Salon & Tea Rooms Ltd
A beauty therapist with seven years' service was dismissed by redundancy while on maternity leave without consultation. The tribunal awarded her a statutory redundancy payment, notice pay, and holiday pay, but found the dismissal fair due to the salon's closure.
Partial · £1,233 · Jan 2023Partial£1,233Jan 2023Caretaker (16 years' service) v Woodstock Town Council
A caretaker with 16 years' service resigned after a series of incidents with a new Town Clerk, but the tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence. The claim was dismissed.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Contract Manager (ground maintenance, physical role) v Oxfordshire GM Limited
An employment tribunal has dismissed a contract manager's unfair dismissal claim after his employer decided he was no longer capable of performing his physical role due to long-term knee pain.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Nursery manager (2 years' service) v Michael Sutton trading as St Margaret's Nursery
A nursery manager with two years' service was constructively dismissed after his employer sent a private message accusing him of dishonesty and lies, without any prior investigation. The tribunal awarded £5,298.
Won · £5,298 · Jan 2023Won£5,298Jan 2023Nightshift worker at Tesco Extra (4 years' service) v Tesco Stores Ltd
A tribunal dismissed a race discrimination claim by a Tesco nightshift worker after finding that, although the claim was brought out of time, it was not just and equitable to extend time for most allegations. The direct discrimination claim relating to dismissal was allowed to proceed but ultimately not upheld.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Aftercare Manager (4 years' service) v James Taylor Construction Ltd
An Aftercare Manager with 4 years' service was fairly dismissed for redundancy after refusing a suitable alternative role due to childcare commitments. The tribunal rejected claims of age discrimination and protected disclosure detriment.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Operations Manager (3 years' service) v AGTC Ltd
An operations manager who was dismissed for 'redundancy' that was actually a pretext for performance concerns has won his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal awarded £2,020 in compensation.
Partial · £2,020 · Jan 2023Partial£2,020Jan 2023Former employee (operations/business development administrator, 16 hours/week) v The Vital Element (UK) Limited
A former employee with PTSD was placed at risk of redundancy while on sick leave. The tribunal found it was discrimination arising from disability and awarded £12,183.
Won · £12,183 · Jan 2023Won£12,183Jan 2023Head of Property Management (4 years' service) v Stow Residential Ltd t/a Stow Brothers
A head of property management who refused to create false documents for an insurance claim was unfairly dismissed. The tribunal found the employer manufactured allegations and predetermined the outcome.
Partial · £33,584 · Jan 2023Partial£33,584Jan 2023Customer services assistant (18 years' service) v Wilko Limited
A customer services assistant with 18 years' service resigned after being rostered for Sundays despite opting out. The tribunal found Wilko's conduct was reasonable and dismissed all claims.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Teacher (science/maths) v Tameside College
A teacher who was dismissed for long-term sickness absence after 11 months has lost her claims for unfair dismissal, whistleblowing detriment and disability discrimination. The tribunal found the college acted reasonably.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Team Leader Clinical Records (11 months' service) v The Hillingdon Hospitals University NHS Trust
A team leader who relied on her union's advice to wait for an internal complaint outcome before bringing an unfair dismissal claim was out of time. The tribunal dismissed her case.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Clinical deputy manager (senior nurse) v Bagshot Rehab Centre Limited
A clinical deputy manager who raised concerns about training and patient safety was dismissed after just 18 days at work. The tribunal rejected his whistleblowing claim, finding his disclosures were not made with a reasonable belief of legal breaches.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Delivery driver (7 years' service) v The Harlestone Group Limited
A delivery driver on a zero-hours contract was unfairly dismissed when his employer summarily ended his work without following any disciplinary process. The tribunal awarded £6,675.
Won · £6,675 · Jan 2023Won£6,675Jan 2023Waitress (5 years' service) v Burger & Lobster Restaurant Group Ltd
A waitress with five years' service who was dismissed after taking unauthorised time off to care for her father following a stroke has lost her unfair dismissal and associative disability discrimination claims. The tribunal found the employer acted within the band of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Optical assistant (10 years' service) v Fairford Opticians Ltd
An optical assistant who was convicted of harassment for a phone call made from her employer's phone had her unfair dismissal claim struck out as having no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Driver, telephonist and controller (over 20 years' service) v Meadway Private Hire Ltd
A driver, telephonist and controller with over 20 years' service was constructively dismissed after his employer offered only limited holiday cover at reduced pay following furlough. The tribunal extended time for his unfair dismissal claim.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Former employee v Tesco Stores Ltd
A former employee's constructive dismissal and race discrimination claims against Tesco survive after the tribunal refused to strike them out for non-compliance with case management orders.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Support Worker (2 spells: Feb 2018-Apr 2020 and Jun-Nov 2020) v Caretech Community Services Limited
A support worker who used physical force to free himself from a service user who grabbed him was automatically unfairly dismissed. The tribunal found the principal reason was his health and safety actions, not misconduct.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Cash and valuables in transit driver (18 years' service) v G4S Cash Solutions (UK) Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a cash-in-transit driver with 18 years' service who was sacked for breaching the 'golden rule' twice while under a final written warning, despite a 130-day delay in the disciplinary process.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v The Furzedown Group Limited a.k.a The Furzedown Group
A former employee of The Furzedown Group has been awarded £10,358.50 after the company failed to pay full wages, holiday pay, and dismissed without notice.
Won · £10,359 · Jan 2023Won£10,359Jan 2023Former employee v Without Exceptions Ltd
A former employee won a partial victory for unpaid wages, holiday pay and notice pay, but her unfair dismissal claim was struck out due to insufficient service. The tribunal ordered £476.39 in compensation.
Partial · £476 · Jan 2023Partial£476Jan 2023Export Key Account Manager (2 years' service) v Stiltz Limited
An export manager who resigned after her employer insisted she continue selling lifts that were not certified for wheelchair use has won her whistleblowing unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal awarded £11,112.89.
Won · £11,113 · Jan 2023Won£11,113Jan 2023Front of House Supervisor (1 year 5 months' service) v TBB Leisure Limited
A front of house supervisor who named the wrong respondent on her claim form has had her unfair dismissal claim reinstated after the tribunal found the error was compounded by administrative delays.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Bus driver (13 years' service) v Metroline Travel Ltd
A bus driver with osteoarthritis was fairly dismissed for capability after 24 weeks' absence, but won £1,017 for unpaid sick pay. The tribunal rejected all discrimination claims.
Partial · £1,017 · Jan 2023Partial£1,017Jan 2023Communications Officer (9 years' service) v The Commissioner of the Police of the Metropolis
A tribunal struck out a communications officer's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims because she filed her claim one day after the three-month deadline, despite having previous tribunal experience.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee v Solus (London) Limited
A tribunal found that a former employee of Solus (London) Limited was not disabled under the Equality Act 2010, striking out most of his discrimination claims as out of time. His constructive unfair dismissal claim will proceed.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Sales agent (11 years' service) v Sky Retail Stores Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a sales agent with 11 years' service who wrote a customer's name and email address on an unauthorised document, finding that Sky Retail Stores Limited acted within the band of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v Work it Group Ltd
Tribunal rejects disability discrimination claim after finding former employee's stress was a reaction to life events, not a mental impairment with long-term effects.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v British Airways Plc
A former employee's claim against British Airways survives a strike-out bid after a 7-day delay in providing dates for events, with the tribunal ruling that striking out would be disproportionate.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Apprentice carpenter (2 years' service) v Perrin & Son Construction Limited
An apprentice carpenter was unfairly dismissed after taking a week's holiday despite his employer's refusal. The tribunal found the dismissal procedurally unfair and awarded £918.13, including unlawful deduction claims.
Partial · £918 · Jan 2023Partial£918Jan 2023Registered Care Home Manager (4 years' service) v Hastings & Rother Voluntary Association for the Blind
A registered care home manager with four years' service has won her unfair dismissal claim after a tribunal found her employer failed to establish a fair reason for dismissal. The tribunal awarded £24,697.76, including a 15% uplift for breaching the ACAS Code.
Won · £24,698 · Jan 2023Won£24,698Jan 2023Care home worker v Burlington Care (Yorkshire) Limited
An employment tribunal struck out unfair dismissal and discrimination claims brought by 127 care home workers against the government and the Care Quality Commission over the mandatory Covid-19 vaccination policy.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Chief Executive Officer (7 years' service) v Milton Keynes Development Partnership LLP
A CEO with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed when his employer rejected his proposed reduced-hours alternative without proper consideration. The tribunal found the redundancy process procedurally flawed but applied a 75% Polkey deduction.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Painter and decorator (employed from 29 Oct 2018) v East Sussex National Ltd
A painter and decorator who refused to return from furlough as a night porter, citing COVID-19 safety fears, has lost his constructive dismissal claim. The tribunal found no fundamental breach of contract.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Senior manager (1 year's service) v Nextsteps @ Barnstaple CIC
A senior manager who agreed to defer her salary until the company's cash flow improved was awarded £12,660.58 after the employer failed to pay her for five months and withheld holiday pay on dismissal.
Partial · £12,661 · Jan 2023Partial£12,661Jan 2023Tax Manager (6 months' service) v Optivo
A Tax Manager with six months' service who made multiple false allegations of harassment and discrimination was fairly dismissed during probation. The tribunal struck out his unfair dismissal claim and ordered him to pay £10,000 in costs.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Security officer (5 years' service) v ICTS (UK) Limited
A security officer with five years' service was fairly dismissed after Amazon requested his removal from all its sites and no alternative work was available. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v West Midlands Travel Ltd T/A National Express West Midlands
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against National Express West Midlands was dismissed because the corrected claim form was submitted 18 days after the rejection notice, putting it outside the time limit.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023UK Health, Safety and Environmental Manager (27 years' service) v Weetabix Limited
A health and safety manager with 27 years' service won his constructive unfair dismissal claim against Weetabix after the company mishandled his grievance, promoted his alleged bully, and delayed an occupational health referral.
Won · Jan 2023Won—Jan 2023Former employee v Ocado Central Service Limited
A tribunal has adjourned a preliminary hearing on time limits for a sexual harassment claim after the claimant's representative said she was too unwell to proceed. The judge found the risk of injustice to the claimant outweighed the delay to Ocado.
Remitted · Jan 2023Remitted—Jan 2023Gardener (part-time, 4.5 years' service) v Care UK Community Partnerships Limited
A part-time gardener with anxiety was unfairly dismissed after refusing to take COVID-19 tests. The tribunal awarded £27,605.13 in damages.
Won · £27,605 · Jan 2023Won£27,605Jan 2023Senior Healthcare Technical Officer (5 years' service) v R
An unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after the claimant failed to attend the final hearing and a preliminary hearing. The tribunal also ordered the claimant to pay £3,460.80 in costs for unreasonable conduct.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee (25 years' service) v S. J. Norman & Sons
A former employee with 25 years' service was awarded over £7,800 in redundancy pay and compensation, but his unfair dismissal and breach of contract claims were dismissed as out of time.
Partial · £7,869 · Jan 2023Partial£7,869Jan 2023Managing Director of Non-Recourse Lending (5 years' service) v DB Group Services (UK) Limited
A tribunal has dismissed claims of unfair dismissal and discrimination by a Managing Director made redundant when her role was eliminated in a cost-saving restructure.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v Ocean Design Storage Solutions Limited
A former employee won over £24,500 after being made redundant without consultation and suffering unauthorised deductions, unpaid holiday pay, and breach of contract.
Partial · £24,535 · Jan 2023Partial£24,535Jan 2023Service Engineer Level 1 (4.5 years' service) v Govia Thameslink Railway Limited
A service engineer with 4.5 years' service was fairly dismissed for poor attendance after progressing through a staged absence management process. The tribunal rejected his claims that the dismissal was linked to protected disclosures about a chemical.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023School employee (16 years' service) v London Borough of Brent
A school employee with 16 years' service who applied for voluntary redundancy had her unfair dismissal claim thrown out because she presented it over three months after the statutory time limit expired. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for her to have claimed in time.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee (12 hours/week, less than 2 years' service) v Khlaxon Ltd
A tribunal dismissed a former employee's indirect sex discrimination claim after she lost telephone connection during a preliminary hearing. Her unfair dismissal claim had already been struck out for lack of two years' service.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Sales Manager (22 years' service) v Whyte Bikes Limited
A sales manager with 22 years' service was automatically unfairly dismissed after making protected disclosures about Covid-19 travel restrictions. The tribunal found the redundancy was a sham and the real reason was whistleblowing.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Health and beauty manager (5 years' service) v Marston Health & Beauty Limited
A health and beauty manager who was made redundant after returning from maternity leave has lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the redundancy was genuine and the process fair.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Accountant (7 years' service) v Finanspol Group Ltd
An accountant with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed after refusing to accept self-employment and reduced pay. The tribunal awarded £9,063.83.
Won · £9,064 · Jan 2023Won£9,064Jan 2023Boiler installation engineer (2 months' service) v Glow Green Ltd
A tribunal found that a boiler installation engineer with only two months' service was not automatically unfairly dismissed for raising health and safety concerns, but was owed £40 in unpaid wages.
Partial · £40 · Jan 2023Partial£40Jan 2023Senior Account Executive (1 year's service) v AvePoint UK, Ltd
A Senior Account Executive's discrimination and whistleblowing claims were thrown out because he did not obtain an ACAS Early Conciliation certificate and the claimed exemption did not apply.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Junior accountant (apprentice) v Williams & Co (Corporate) Limited
A junior accountant resigned after her employer refused paid study leave and later deducted £1,472 from her wages for training costs. The tribunal upheld her unlawful deduction claim but dismissed her constructive unfair dismissal claim.
Partial · £1,472 · Jan 2023Partial£1,472Jan 2023Broadcast journalist (BBC World Service, Arabic Radio team) v British Broadcasting Corporation
A BBC World Service journalist who claimed disability discrimination and victimisation had her case dismissed after she failed to attend the final hearing. The tribunal refused her applications for postponement and later refused reconsideration.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023HR Business Partner (5 years' service) v The British Council
An HR Business Partner who worked for the British Council in Dubai has won the right to bring unfair dismissal and discrimination claims in the UK, after the tribunal ruled that diplomatic immunity in the UAE did not leave her without a remedy.
Won · Jan 2023Won—Jan 2023Branch manager (3 years 9 months' service) v Marquis Motorhomes Ltd.
A tribunal upheld the dismissal of a branch manager who made inappropriate sexual comments to female colleagues, but ordered his former employer to pay £19,402 in unpaid bonuses he earned before being sacked.
Partial · £19,402 · Jan 2023Partial£19,402Jan 2023Former employee v Blanc Aero Industries
A former employee who pursued an unfair dismissal claim that had no reasonable prospects of success has been ordered to pay £2,111.90 in costs after ignoring a without prejudice offer and failing to attend the costs hearing.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Worker (former employee) v GenderGP PTE Ltd
A former worker with fibromyalgia and other disabilities was awarded £84,599 after her employer failed to defend claims of disability discrimination. The tribunal entered default judgment when the company did not respond.
Won · £84,599 · Jan 2023Won£84,599Jan 2023Former employee v Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust
A former employee's claims of unfair dismissal and victimisation against Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust were struck out after she failed to attend a case management hearing and ignored orders to provide further particulars.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee (Transcare Nurse) v B. Braun Medical Ltd
A nurse who accepted re-engagement after being dismissed for gross misconduct could not later claim constructive unfair dismissal when she resigned. The tribunal struck out her claims.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Plumbing gas and heating engineer (1 year's service) v Hancox Gas and Plumbing Ltd
A plumbing engineer who was dismissed after raising concerns about his son's vulnerability to Covid-19 lost his automatic unfair dismissal claim but won £1,849 for breach of contract.
Partial · £1,849 · Jan 2023Partial£1,849Jan 2023Former employee (less than 2 years' service) v Tesco Stores Limited
A former Tesco employee with less than two years' service has been allowed to pursue a disability discrimination claim even though it was brought six weeks late. The tribunal said it was 'just and equitable' to extend time.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Former employee (disputed status) v Thomas Roofing (NW) Ltd
A former employee who forged a contract of employment and swapped a blank SD card for evidence has had her unfair dismissal claim struck out for abuse of process.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Design technician (3 years 9 months' service) v CCTV Monitoring Ltd
A design technician lost his constructive unfair dismissal claim after the tribunal found that being placed on furlough to prevent server access was a breach of trust, but not serious enough to justify resignation.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023IT Service Desk Manager (2 years' service) v Keltbray Ltd
An IT Service Desk Manager with two years' service was fairly dismissed for redundancy after being placed in a pool of one. His claims that the dismissal was due to protected disclosures about Covid-19 safety were rejected by the tribunal.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Compounder (2 years' service) v Dugdale Limited
A compounder was unfairly dismissed after being accused of new allegations at his disciplinary hearing, but the tribunal found he contributed 100% to his dismissal and awarded no compensation.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Former employee v Stephen M S Lai & Co Business Consulting Ltd
A former employee was awarded £34,204 after being unfairly dismissed and harassed due to his age. The employer did not attend the hearing or file a response.
Partial · £34,204 · Jan 2023Partial£34,204Jan 2023Sales executive (2 years' service) v Avalon Motor Co Limited
A sales executive who resigned after a flawed disciplinary process and proposed pay plan changes lost his constructive unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer's prompt retraction of the warning and fine prevented a breach of trust and confidence.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v Nano Fibre UK Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out because he had less than two years' service, and his remaining claims were dismissed after he failed to attend the hearing or comply with case management orders.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Care workers (dedicated carers for a quadriplegic individual) v Deborah Jude as Deputy for Property and Affairs for Stephen Martin; YS Services Limited t/a Embracing Care
Four care workers who lost their jobs when a quadriplegic man's care moved to a new provider won statutory redundancy pay, but their unfair dismissal and notice claims failed because they were brought too late.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Former employee (less than 3 months' service) v Chorley Borough Council and South Ribble Borough Council
A former employee who waited over two years to bring claims for constructive dismissal and discrimination saw his case thrown out by an employment tribunal for being out of time.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Café worker (12 years' service) v Camden Express Limited
A café worker with 12 years' service was automatically unfairly dismissed after repeatedly asking for his full wages, which were below the national minimum wage. The tribunal awarded £51,748.84.
Won · £51,749 · Jan 2023Won£51,749Jan 2023Former employees (redundancy) v Queensmead School Limited (in company voluntary arrangement)
Former employees of Queensmead School Limited have secured a 90-day protective award after the company failed to consult them properly before making them redundant.
Settled · Jan 2023Settled—Jan 2023Restaurant employee v Michael Shane Croner
A restaurant employee's unfair dismissal and redundancy pay claims were dismissed after the tribunal found the employer was unaware of the original proceedings. The original £8,721 wages award was revoked.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023School delivery driver and taxi driver v Mr Steven Barnes trading as Bernie Taxi Services
A tribunal found that a school delivery driver was an employee for that role but only a worker for taxi work. The case settled before the final hearing, with no compensation awarded.
Settled · Jan 2023Settled—Jan 2023
