Unfair Dismissal · reason
Conduct
869 cases
Former employee v Landmark Space Ltd
A former employee who withdrew her unfair dismissal claim against Landmark Space Ltd could not revive it, even after applying for reconsideration. The tribunal confirmed it has no power to set aside a withdrawal.
Dismissed · Jan 2025Dismissed—Jan 2025Former employee (2 years' service) v Nathan Gittings
A former employee with two years' service was unfairly dismissed after being suspended and then sacked without any disciplinary hearing. The Cambridge tribunal awarded £9,546.81 in compensation.
Won · £9,547 · Nov 2024Won£9,547Nov 2024Delivery driver (2.5 years' service) v NHK Enfield Ltd
A delivery driver was unfairly dismissed after his manager told him 'I don't need you any more' and used abusive language. The Watford tribunal awarded £4,656 in compensation.
Partial · £4,656 · Mar 2024Partial£4,656Mar 2024Former employee (5 years' service) v Fairview Grocers Limited
A former employee of Fairview Grocers Limited was unfairly dismissed without any meeting or right of appeal, but his own conduct led to a 60% cut in compensation. He was awarded £3,752.89 in total.
Partial · £3,753 · Mar 2024Partial£3,753Mar 2024Care home worker (4 years' service) v Mid-sized care home group
A care worker was sacked for gross misconduct after a Facebook comment about a colleague. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair — but reduced compensation by 25% for contributory conduct.
Won · £9,870 · Feb 2024Won£9,870Feb 2024Control Room Team Leader (11 years' service) v MTR Corporation (Crossrail) Limited t/a MTR Elizabeth Line
A tribunal found that MTR Elizabeth Line unfairly dismissed a control room team leader of 11 years over a hug and alleged anti-Semitic comments, but reduced compensation by 75% due to his own conduct.
Partial · £23,361 · Jan 2024Partial£23,361Jan 2024Former employee and one-third shareholder v Yellowcoat Holdings Limited
A former employee and shareholder sought extensive disclosure of communications between his employer and an external investigator. The tribunal refused, finding the request was not necessary for fair disposal.
Dismissed · Jan 2024Dismissed—Jan 2024Former employee v Marks and Spencer PLC
A former employee's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims against Marks and Spencer were struck out after she failed to comply with tribunal orders and did not actively pursue her claim.
Dismissed · Jan 2024Dismissed—Jan 2024Warehouse operative (18 years' service) v ASDA Stores Limited
An employment tribunal found ASDA unfairly dismissed a warehouse operative with 18 years' service after failing to investigate his mitigation evidence, awarding £14,817 in compensation.
Won · £14,817 · Jan 2024Won£14,817Jan 2024Bus driver (13 years' service) v London Central Bus Company Ltd
A bus driver with 13 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after driving onto a pavement to overtake another bus. The tribunal rejected claims of race and religious discrimination.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Depot Infrastructure Technician (12 years' service) v Govia Thameslink Railway Limited
A depot technician with 12 years' service was dismissed after reversing a work van into a tree and attempting to repair the damage himself. The tribunal upheld the dismissal, finding it was for misconduct, not because of his protected disclosures.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee v Giuseppe Of Belgravia Limited
A former employee was unfairly dismissed but received only limited compensation because the tribunal found he would have been fairly dismissed a month later when the workplace closed. Total award: £12,419.29.
Partial · £12,419 · Dec 2023Partial£12,419Dec 2023Janitor (6 years' service) v Gentoo Group Ltd
A janitor with six years' service was fairly dismissed after CCTV and fob data showed he spent extended periods away from his post. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023General administrative and sales assistant (3 years' service) v Mr John Kittelsen t/a Speedwell Cars
A father who told his daughter 'I don't have a job for you, in fact I hope I never see u again' in a WhatsApp message was found to have unfairly dismissed her. The tribunal awarded £13,977.58.
Won · £13,978 · Dec 2023Won£13,978Dec 2023Former employee v South Coast Skips Limited (in Creditor’s Voluntary Liquidation)
A former employee was unfairly dismissed, wrongfully dismissed without notice, and discriminated against on grounds of sex. The tribunal awarded £16,208.68, including an uplift for the employer's failure to follow the ACAS code.
Won · £16,209 · Dec 2023Won£16,209Dec 2023Primary school teacher (2 years 6 months' service) v Diocese of Southwell and Nottingham Multi Academy Trust
A primary school teacher who exchanged personal messages with a vulnerable pupil via Class Dojo over the summer holidays was fairly dismissed. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Part-time takeaway worker (2 years' service) v Crispy Cod Ketley Ltd
A part-time takeaway worker was unfairly dismissed by text message after complaining about undercooked chicken. The tribunal awarded £14,628.50 in compensation.
Won · £14,629 · Dec 2023Won£14,629Dec 2023Area manager (3+ years' service) v Hamble Foods Limited
An area manager was unfairly dismissed after editing a timesheet, but the tribunal found the investigation was flawed and the disciplinary process lacked proper notice. He was awarded £8,026 after reductions for contributory conduct and a Polkey finding.
Partial · £8,026 · Dec 2023Partial£8,026Dec 2023Machine Room Manager (8 years' service) v UHV Design Limited
An Employment Tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a Machine Room Manager with 8 years' service who admitted physically blocking a subordinate during a workplace argument. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Packing and Logistics Operator (11 years' service) v Mexichem UK Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a packing operator with 11 years' service who left work early without authorisation and was found to have been dishonest about his start time. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee v Mitie Ltd
A Watford tribunal found Mitie Ltd unfairly dismissed a former employee but reduced his basic award by 70% for his own conduct and made no compensatory award due to a 100% Polkey reduction. He received £1,298.10.
Partial · £1,298 · Dec 2023Partial£1,298Dec 2023Deputy Customer Services and Housing Options Manager (16 years' service) v London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth
A deputy manager with 16 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct over visitor parking permits. The tribunal found the process unfair and awarded £35,318.56, but rejected her whistleblowing claim.
Partial · £35,319 · Dec 2023Partial£35,319Dec 2023Medical secretary (5 years' service) v Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a medical secretary who made racist comments about a colleague's appointment, finding the NHS trust acted reasonably.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee v Amey Services Limited
A former employee who sent threatening emails to colleagues and called a witness a liar outside the tribunal room had his unfair dismissal claim struck out. The tribunal said a fair trial was no longer possible.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Former employee (housing officer) v Equans Regeneration Limited
A former housing officer's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims were struck out after she repeatedly failed to serve a witness statement, despite extensions and warnings. She was also ordered to pay £3,870 in costs.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023PCV driver (5 years' service) v National Express Limited
A PCV driver who failed three breath alcohol tests was unfairly dismissed due to a flawed appeal, but the tribunal found she would have been dismissed anyway and reduced compensation by 75% for contributory conduct.
Partial · £3,682 · Dec 2023Partial£3,682Dec 2023Kitchen Porter (22 years' service) v Marriot Hotels Ltd
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a kitchen porter with 22 years' service after he whispered 'I wish I could impregnate you' to a colleague, following a previous warning about inappropriate comments.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Branch Care Manager (18 months' service) v MIDSHIRES CARE LTD T/A HELPING HANDS HOME CARE
A Branch Care Manager's claim for direct race discrimination and victimisation was dismissed because she presented it 28 days late. The tribunal refused to extend time, finding no just and equitable reason.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Managing Director (5 years' service) v Panache Leasing Ltd
A managing director who was dismissed for alleged threats and misappropriation of funds without any investigation has been awarded £53,212.50 after the tribunal found the dismissal unfair. The High Court had previously found no evidence of fraud or dishonesty.
Won · £53,213 · Dec 2023Won£53,213Dec 2023Former employee v CSH Surrey
A former employee's disability discrimination claim against the CEO of CSH Surrey was struck out after she failed to particularise any specific allegations against him. The tribunal found the claim had no reasonable prospects of success.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Front of house worker (11 years' service) v L&M Coventry Limited
A front of house worker at a pub/restaurant was unfairly dismissed after 11 years' service. The tribunal awarded £10,800 in compensation, including basic award and notice pay.
Won · £10,800 · Dec 2023Won£10,800Dec 2023Tutor (3 years' service) v The Trustees of Al Madaar (a charity)
A tutor with three years' service was unfairly dismissed when her employer wrongly believed she had resigned. The tribunal awarded £1,499.54 for breach of contract and unlawful deduction of wages.
Partial · £1,500 · Dec 2023Partial£1,500Dec 2023Bus driver (6 years' service) v London United Busways Ltd
A bus driver with 6 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after refusing a breath alcohol test following an at-fault collision. The tribunal also dismissed his discrimination and victimisation claims.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former HGV driver v George Walker Transport Manchester Limited
A former HGV driver's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claim was dismissed after he continued using abusive language, breaching an unless order. His application to set aside the order was refused.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Catering manager (16 years' service) v Serco Ltd
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a catering manager who was found guilty of gross misconduct for stealing tea bags and bullying a colleague, ruling that Serco Ltd's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Car valet (6 years' service) v Southern Car Sales Limited
A car valet with six years' service was unfairly dismissed after using foul language towards a colleague, but the tribunal awarded no compensation because his conduct wholly caused his dismissal.
Partial · £0 · Dec 2023Partial£0Dec 2023Restaurant server (9 months' service) v London XXI Limited t/a ME London
A restaurant server with less than two years' service had his unfair dismissal claim struck out after he failed to attend hearings or comply with tribunal orders. The tribunal also dismissed his race discrimination claim due to unreasonable conduct.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Legal secretary (trainee) v AD (deceased)
A trainee legal secretary who was assaulted by her employer and made protected disclosures has won claims of unfair dismissal, sex discrimination, harassment and victimisation. She was awarded £28,986.85.
Partial · £28,987 · Dec 2023Partial£28,987Dec 2023Former employee (11 years' service) v Motus Commercials Limited
A tribunal dismissed all claims from a former employee with 11 years' service and a clean disciplinary record, finding his misconduct dismissal fair and not discriminatory.
Lost · Dec 2023Lost—Dec 2023Former employee v London & Quadrant Housing Trust
The tribunal struck out all remaining claims brought by a former employee against London & Quadrant Housing Trust after she failed to provide required details, despite having dyslexia.
Dismissed · Dec 2023Dismissed—Dec 2023Teaching Assistant (2 years 7 months' service) v Calcot Services for Children Limited
A teaching assistant who pulled a young person's hood and took them to the floor in a ground hold was fairly dismissed for misconduct, the tribunal has ruled. The claim for race discrimination also failed.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Shift Leader (17 years' service) v Tesco Stores PLC
A shift leader with 17 years' service had his unfair dismissal claim struck out after he failed to provide a witness statement, disclosure, or a schedule of loss, and did not engage with the respondent or the tribunal.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023PCV bus driver (18 years' service) v Abellio London Limited
An 18-year bus driver was sacked for gross misconduct after CCTV showed him using a mobile phone while driving. The tribunal upheld the dismissal but awarded £1,019 for unpaid wages and holiday pay.
Partial · £1,019 · Nov 2023Partial£1,019Nov 2023Warehouse operative (32 years' service) v Bapp Industrial Supplies (Huddersfield) Limited
A warehouse operative with 32 years' service was fairly dismissed after failing to contact his employer for nearly a month. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Media Sales Operator (10 years' service) v Discovery Communications Europe Limited
A Media Sales Operator with 10 years' service had his unfair dismissal and discrimination claims struck out after repeatedly failing to comply with tribunal directions. The tribunal awarded costs against him.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Branch Manager (8 years' service) v VP Plc (1) and Brandon Hire Station Limited (2)
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a branch manager who used 'dump codes' to circumvent the company's asset tracking system, rejecting his claims of unfair dismissal and whistleblowing.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v Navaratna South Indian Restaurant Ltd.
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Navaratna South Indian Restaurant Ltd. was struck out after she failed to attend a hearing and did not comply with case management orders. No compensation was awarded.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee v RR Swami Ltd
A former employee has been awarded £12,503 after an employment tribunal found she was unfairly dismissed, not given notice, and had wages unlawfully deducted by RR Swami Ltd.
Partial · £12,503 · Nov 2023Partial£12,503Nov 2023Customer Care Assistant / Lead Customer Host (10 years' service) v First Greater Western Limited
A Customer Care Assistant with 10 years' service was unfairly dismissed after being accused of breaching a COT3 settlement agreement. The tribunal awarded £9,074, but applied a 50% Polkey reduction.
Won · £9,074 · Nov 2023Won£9,074Nov 2023Skilled mechanical maintenance fitter (22 years' service) v Vauxhall Motors Ltd
Three skilled maintenance fitters with up to 25 years' service were unfairly dismissed by Vauxhall Motors after a flawed investigation into an anonymous letter about overtime. The tribunal rejected claims of whistleblowing or union-related automatic unfair dismissal.
Partial · Nov 2023Partial—Nov 2023Project Engineer (1 year 9 months' service) v Armour Home Electronics Limited
A tribunal struck out a project engineer's unfair dismissal, sexual orientation discrimination, and wrongful dismissal claims after he was sacked for sending a confidential email to colleagues. His sex discrimination claim survived but required a £200 deposit.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Support worker (16 years' service) v Craegmoor Healthcare Company Limited
A support worker with a clean record was fairly dismissed for failing to document a resident's coffee burn, the Leeds Employment Tribunal has ruled. The tribunal rejected claims of race discrimination and victimisation linked to a 2015 claim.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023HGV Class 1 Night Driver (10 years' service) v Maritime Transport Limited
An HGV driver with 10 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after a member of the public complained he was watching videos on his phone while driving. The tribunal struck out his unfair dismissal claim as having no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Night Care Assistant (5 years' service) v Adara Healthcare Limited
A night care assistant with five years' service was unfairly dismissed after being seen asleep on duty, because her employer did not hold a disciplinary hearing before sacking her. The tribunal awarded £962.79, reduced by 75% for her contributory conduct.
Won · £963 · Nov 2023Won£963Nov 2023Former employee v Paragon Network Services Limited (Previously Core Network Services Limited)
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim faced a setback when the tribunal granted the employer extra time to respond, due to an incorrect address on the claim form.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former employee v North East Autism Society
Two former employees of North East Autism Society who refused the Covid-19 vaccine had their unfair dismissal and discrimination claims struck out after failing to attend a preliminary hearing and comply with tribunal orders.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Enquiry unit advisor (2 years' service) v Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy
An enquiry unit advisor who sent threatening WhatsApp messages and emails to his line manager was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected claims of disability discrimination.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Mailman/driver (32 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A mailman with 32 years of unblemished service was unfairly dismissed by Royal Mail after a customer complaint about a duplicate barcode. The tribunal found the investigation and disciplinary process flawed, and reduced compensation by 20% for his own conduct.
Won · Nov 2023Won—Nov 2023Headteacher (17 years' service) v Arbor Academy Trust
A headteacher with 17 years' service was unfairly dismissed after tapping her 3-year-old son's hand to get his attention. The tribunal awarded £102,328.80, reduced by 20% for contributory fault.
Won · £102,329 · Nov 2023Won£102,329Nov 2023Delivery and Collection Manager (2 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A black Caribbean delivery manager was unfairly dismissed and racially stereotyped after a returned iPhone went missing. The tribunal found Royal Mail's investigation was flawed and the claimant was treated less favourably than a hypothetical white comparator.
Won · Nov 2023Won—Nov 2023Former employee v Sainsbury’s Supermarkets Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Sainsbury’s was struck out after she failed to attend the final hearing and did not provide a witness statement as ordered. The tribunal refused her application for reconsideration.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Clerical Officer (5 years' service) v Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust
A clerical officer with five years' service was fairly dismissed after repeatedly refusing to attend investigation and disciplinary meetings. The tribunal rejected her unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Trainee solicitor (1 year 3 months' service) v Sterling Lawyers Limited
A trainee solicitor who sent 106 confidential client emails to her personal address was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal ruled. Her claims of whistleblowing and pregnancy discrimination were rejected.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v Cardiff & Vale University Local Health Board
An employee with a mental health disability lost all claims of unfair dismissal and discrimination after the tribunal found the health board's absence management process was reasonable.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v A&A Enterprises London Ltd
A former employee who signed a settlement agreement and later brought new claims had her case struck out as an abuse of process. The tribunal found she had mental capacity when signing.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Healthcare Consultant (6 years' service) v BUPA Insurance Services Ltd
A healthcare consultant with 6 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct following four customer complaints about his attitude. The tribunal also rejected his claims of race discrimination and victimisation.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Emergency Medical Technician 1 (15 years' service) v North West Ambulance Service NHS Trust
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of an EMT with 15 years' service who used the n-word about a black colleague on two occasions, finding the employer's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Taxi driver (2 years 9 months' service) v Uber Britannia Limited
A taxi driver who waited over six months to bring his claim after Uber deactivated his account has had his case thrown out by the Nottingham tribunal for being well outside the three-month time limit.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Security Officer (17 years' service) v Bouygues E&S Solutions Limited
A security officer who refused to carry out hand sanitiser checks was unfairly dismissed due to a flawed investigation, but his 75% contribution and a 90% Polkey reduction meant he received only £5,281.
Partial · £5,281 · Nov 2023Partial£5,281Nov 2023Housing Officer (agency worker, 1 month service) v Central Bedfordshire Council
A housing officer who worked for Central Bedfordshire Council for just one month via an agency had her claims of whistleblowing detriment and harassment related to disability and transgender status dismissed by the Watford Employment Tribunal.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v Serco Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims were struck out after they failed to attend hearings, comply with case management orders, or contact the tribunal for over six months.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Hairdresser (2 years 5 months' service) v Layla's Lengths Limited
A hairdresser with over two years' service was dismissed by text message after a dispute over taking a half day. The tribunal awarded £4,778 for unfair dismissal and unpaid wages.
Won · £4,778 · Nov 2023Won£4,778Nov 2023Manager (6 years' service) v Stapletons (Tyre Services) Limited
A manager with six years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed investigation into password sharing and order deletion. The tribunal awarded £5,552 but reduced compensation because he contributed to his own dismissal.
Won · £5,552 · Nov 2023Won£5,552Nov 2023Customer service assistant (3 years 8 months' service) v Trenitalia C2C Limited
A customer service assistant who tried to strike a teenage customer with an open hand was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal ruled. His race discrimination claims against third-party security guards were also dismissed.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Assistant headteacher (12 years' service) v YY
An assistant headteacher with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after sending a sexual message to a child under duress from a coercive partner. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Former employee v The A&S Leisure Group Ltd (t/a Napoleon’s Casino Bradford)
A tribunal struck out a former employee's claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination after she admitted inappropriate touching, failed to attend hearings, and ignored tribunal communications.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Healthcare assistant (3 months' service) v Gain Healthcare Limited
A healthcare assistant who was dismissed without notice after just three months has been awarded £480 in notice pay. The tribunal rejected his other claims for automatic unfair dismissal, sex discrimination, and breach of contract.
Partial · £480 · Nov 2023Partial£480Nov 2023Night care assistant (3 years' service) v Runwood Homes Ltd
A night care assistant who was found asleep on three occasions was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal also rejected his claims of discrimination and whistleblowing detriment.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Senior Lecturer v Teesside University
A tribunal struck out a Senior Lecturer's unfair dismissal and race discrimination claim after he failed to attend a preliminary hearing and did not comply with orders to explain his absence. His application to reconsider was refused.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Service host (22 years' service) v Asda Stores Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld Asda's dismissal of a service host with 22 years' service after CCTV showed her taking coins and bags for life without paying. The tribunal found the decision was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Senior Customer Advisor (16 years' service) v EE Limited
A senior customer advisor with 16 years' unblemished service was dismissed for gross misconduct after creating two accounts for one customer. The tribunal upheld the decision, finding the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Nov 2023Lost—Nov 2023Bureau operator (19 years' service) v Thales DIS UK Limited
A bureau operator with 19 years' service had his claims for breach of contract and discrimination thrown out because they were lodged over four years after his dismissal.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Former store manager v Co-operative Group Limited
A former store manager's unfair dismissal claim against Co-operative Group Limited was struck out after he failed to provide a witness statement or attend the final hearing.
Dismissed · Nov 2023Dismissed—Nov 2023Cleaner (evening, 6 hours/week, 3 years' service) v Razors and Blades Limited
A part-time cleaner who was dismissed after asking to be furloughed has won her unfair dismissal claim after her employer failed to submit a response to the tribunal.
Partial · £2,720 · Oct 2023Partial£2,720Oct 2023Former employee v Samuel Smith (Southern)
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Samuel Smith (Southern) has been struck out for failing to comply with tribunal orders and not actively pursuing the case.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Regional Manager (10 years' service) v POhWER
A regional manager with 10 years' service was fairly dismissed after admitting she had not been following the employer's safeguarding policy for external reporting in secure settings.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee v LHR Airports Limited
A former employee who threatened to reveal damaging information unless his claim was settled has been ordered to pay £750 costs after withdrawing his claim minutes before a hearing.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Operations Manager (24 years' service) v DPD Group UK Ltd
An operations manager with 24 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after making unauthorised manual carded entries and giving incorrect explanations. The tribunal rejected both his unfair and wrongful dismissal claims.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Senior Bookseller (13 years' service) v Waterstones Booksellers Limited
A senior bookseller with 13 years' service was unfairly dismissed after being summarily dismissed during an investigation meeting. The tribunal awarded £11,471.80, including a 12.5% uplift for failing to follow the ACAS Code.
Partial · £11,472 · Oct 2023Partial£11,472Oct 2023Course Leader for Sport (23 years' service) v New City College Limited
A tribunal found that New City College unfairly dismissed a course leader with 23 years' service after a flawed investigation into misconduct during the pandemic. The claimant was awarded £53,256.95 including a 20% ACAS uplift.
Partial · £53,257 · Oct 2023Partial£53,257Oct 2023General Assistant (4 months' service) v Durham Indoor Bowling Club Community Association Limited
A general assistant who walked out of his shift twice and claimed he was dismissed for whistleblowing has lost his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the real reason was his conduct, not any protected disclosure.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Shunter (HGV driver, 2 years' service) v Moran Logistics Ltd
A shunter with two years' service was unfairly dismissed after an accident while 'buddying up' — a practice that was custom and practice at the site. The tribunal found procedural flaws and pressure from senior management made the dismissal unreasonable.
Won · Oct 2023Won—Oct 2023Care home manager (9 years' service) v Prime Care (UK) Ltd t/a Sylvan Home Care Service
A Liverpool tribunal ruled that a care home manager with nine years' service was unfairly dismissed for smoking in the office, finding the real reason was antagonism after she raised a grievance. She was awarded £3,854.25, reduced by 50% for contributory fault.
Partial · £3,854 · Oct 2023Partial£3,854Oct 2023Swimming teachers v Achieve Lifestyle Ltd
A tribunal found that Achieve Lifestyle Ltd unfairly dismissed two swimming teachers after a dispute over furlough pay, and failed to make reasonable adjustments for one teacher with breast cancer.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023General Manager (17 years' service) v Bestway Wholesale Limited
A General Manager with 17 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after his IT account was used to raise fraudulent credit notes worth £32,000. The tribunal found the dismissal fair and rejected all other claims.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee (22 years' service) v Optim Management Ltd
A former employee with 22 years' service was unfairly dismissed after being given just one week's notice. The employer failed to attend the hearing or provide a reason, resulting in a £25,055 award.
Won · £25,056 · Oct 2023Won£25,056Oct 2023Civil Enforcement Officer (parking warden) (12 years' service) v NSL Limited
A civil enforcement officer with severe dyslexia was unfairly dismissed after GPS data appeared to contradict his patrol records. The tribunal found procedural failings and indirect disability discrimination, awarding £17,126.
Partial · £17,127 · Oct 2023Partial£17,127Oct 2023Operational Postal Grade employee (19 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
An employment tribunal has ruled that Royal Mail fairly dismissed a 19-year employee after magic mushrooms were found with his locker key fob, despite his later retraction of an admission.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Science Director (7 years' service) v O3Biotech Limited
A science director who was dismissed after a colleague reported smelling cannabis in his company car has lost his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023On Train Technician (health and safety critical role, 8 years' service) v Network Rail Infrastructure Limited
An On Train Technician was unfairly dismissed after testing positive for cocaine metabolite from coca tea, but the tribunal reduced his compensation to nil because he was wholly to blame for failing to research the product.
Partial · £0 · Oct 2023Partial£0Oct 2023Production Manager (23 years' service) v Northern Joinery Limited
A production manager with 23 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after an investigation into missing scrap wood sale proceeds, the tribunal ruled, despite errors in the employer's spreadsheet evidence.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Shift Manager (5.5 years' service) v Lidl Great Britain Ltd
A Lidl shift manager who admitted lone working and asking colleagues to remain in store after clocking out was fairly dismissed, the tribunal ruled.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Night shelf stacker (12 years' service) v Tesco Stores Limited
A Tesco employee with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to scan and pay for items on multiple occasions while using the Scan as You Shop service. The tribunal found Tesco's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Senior management team (CEO, Finance Director, Commercial Director, Operations Director, Acting Managing Director) v Futurama Limited (in administration)
Five senior managers were summarily dismissed for gross misconduct without any investigation or appeal. The tribunal found the dismissals unfair and wrongful, and awarded unpaid wages, holiday pay, and notice pay.
Won · Oct 2023Won—Oct 2023Driver v Conexim Solutions Ltd
An employment tribunal struck out a driver's unfair dismissal and age discrimination claims after he failed to attend a case management hearing and did not comply with orders to provide details of his case.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Driving examiner (14 years' service) v Driving & Vehicle Standards Agency
A driving examiner with 14 years' service was dismissed for taking photos of a colleague's personal data. The tribunal found the dismissal fair and rejected all claims of discrimination and whistleblowing detriment.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee v Strong Maker Limited
Two former employees of Strong Maker Limited were awarded over £20,000 in total after the tribunal found they were unfairly and automatically unfairly dismissed, with a 25% uplift for the employer's failure to follow the ACAS Code of Practice.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023Security guard (short service) v Lionhart Security Services Limited
A security guard with only weeks of service was dismissed after being accused of taking items without permission. The tribunal rejected his claims of protected disclosure detriment and notice pay, but awarded £627 for missing written particulars.
Lost · £627 · Oct 2023Lost£627Oct 2023Barber's assistant (2 years 6 months' service) v Mr Panayiotis Andreou Chimonides t/a Cutthroat Kings Barbers
A barber's assistant who was dismissed by text message while on sick leave has won £16,840 in compensation for unfair dismissal, unpaid wages, holiday pay and sick pay.
Won · £16,840 · Oct 2023Won£16,840Oct 2023Family Support Worker (14 years' service) v Leeds City Council
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a family support worker with 14 years' service who began a personal and later romantic relationship with a service user, finding the council's decision was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Dog walker/day care worker (5 years' service) v Look Who’s Walking Limited
A dog walker who worked set hours for five years was found to be an employee, not a self-employed contractor, and awarded over £11,700 for unfair dismissal and age discrimination.
Won · £11,707 · Oct 2023Won£11,707Oct 2023Production operative (10 months' service) v GI Recruitment Limited
A production operative who reported sexual harassment but was later dismissed for gross misconduct after leaving work early without clocking out has lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Director (solicitor, 2 years' service) v Duncan Lewis Solicitors Limited
A director with extreme fatigue was dismissed for unauthorised absence without any medical evidence or occupational health referral. The tribunal found unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Partial · Oct 2023Partial—Oct 2023CEO (6 years' service) v Penny Post Credit Union Limited
A CEO with six years' service was unfairly dismissed after his employer abandoned a redundancy process and pursued gross misconduct allegations to avoid paying his 12-month contractual notice. The tribunal awarded £73,816.91.
Won · £73,817 · Oct 2023Won£73,817Oct 2023Delivery driver v Euro Car Parts Limited
A delivery driver with ADHD was dismissed for persistent lateness while on a final warning. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination, finding the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Former employee v First Greater Western Ltd
A tribunal found that a former employee had conducted litigation unreasonably but refused to strike out her claim, allowing it to proceed to a final hearing despite delays and disputes over the list of issues.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Technical Services Manager (5 years' service) v Incentive Facilities Management Limited
A Technical Services Manager was fairly dismissed after bypassing an overheat stat on an air handling unit and swearing at a colleague. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Paramedic (27 years' service) v London Ambulance Service NHS Trust
A London Ambulance Service paramedic who was dismissed for bullying colleagues after failing a mask fit test has lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer's investigation was thorough and the decision reasonable.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Project manager (21 years' service) v Greenhey Industrial and Marine Engineering Limited
A project manager with 21 years' service was fairly dismissed after a listening device was found in his boss's office, with wires leading to his desk. The Liverpool tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Nurse (3 years 3 months' service) v Quality Care Management Ltd
A nurse who was dismissed for gross misconduct in 2021 waited over two years to bring her claim. The tribunal refused to extend time, striking out both her unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims.
Dismissed · Oct 2023Dismissed—Oct 2023Process Controller / Vessel Controller (25 years' service) v The Felixstowe Dock and Railway Company
A process controller with 25 years' service had his harassment claim struck out as too old, and his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims dismissed after a full hearing. The tribunal found the dismissal was fair and any discrimination was justified.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Maths teacher (3 years' service) v Summit Learning Trust
A maths teacher with three years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after sharing his personal mobile number and a test paper with a student, and sending over 50 emails to students outside school hours. The Employment Tribunal upheld the dismissal.
Lost · Oct 2023Lost—Oct 2023Job applicant (employment status disputed) v General Mills UK Limited
An employment tribunal struck out a claim after the claimant accused the respondent of orchestrating her eviction, finding the allegations scandalous and vexatious.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee v Fyfe Mcdade Ltd
A former employee was unfairly dismissed after Fyfe Mcdade Ltd applied an unreasonable disciplinary procedure. The tribunal awarded £2,373.20, reduced by 50% for the employee's own conduct.
Partial · £2,373 · Sept 2023Partial£2,373Sept 2023Pastry chef (zero-hours contract) v Damask Catering Limited
A pastry chef on a zero-hours contract claimed she was verbally dismissed during a 10-minute meeting, but the tribunal found no dismissal took place and struck out her claims.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee v Beechwood Property Services Ltd
A former employee who was sacked for alleged dishonesty over a positive Covid-19 test in Cameroon lost his unfair dismissal claim but won £1,536.60 for wrongful dismissal. The tribunal found the dismissal was procedurally fair but the employer failed to give proper notice.
Partial · £1,537 · Sept 2023Partial£1,537Sept 2023Former employee v London Borough of Newham
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was thrown out because he contacted ACAS two days after the three-month deadline, even though he read his dismissal email the day after it was sent.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Senior Legal Counsel (2.5 years' service) v R&F Properties QS (UK) Co Ltd
A senior legal counsel who contacted CMS directly about an alleged conflict of interest was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal awarded £1,871.46 for unpaid notice and holiday pay.
Partial · £1,871 · Sept 2023Partial£1,871Sept 2023Restoration technician (5 years' service) v Restoration Force Limited
A restoration technician who left work early and then behaved aggressively during an investigation meeting was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Account Manager (19 years' service) v 52 Street Events Supplies Ltd
An account manager with 19 years' unblemished service was summarily dismissed by email while on maternity leave, with no investigation or disciplinary hearing. The tribunal awarded £37,310.
Won · £37,310 · Sept 2023Won£37,310Sept 2023IT and Comms Manager (1 year 2 months' service) v The Charles Kalms, Henry Ronson Immanuel College
An IT manager with 14 months' service was fairly dismissed for gross negligence after a sophisticated cyber-attack. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim, finding the school's decision within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Deputy Manager (3 years' service) v Really Flexible Care Ltd
A deputy manager with three years' service was unfairly dismissed after her employer relied solely on a council safeguarding report without conducting its own investigation or disciplinary hearing. The Watford tribunal awarded £26,926.
Won · £26,926 · Sept 2023Won£26,926Sept 2023Support worker (3 years' service) v Acorn Care Home
A support worker who missed the three-month deadline to bring an unfair dismissal claim because her legal representative failed to act in time has had her case dismissed. The tribunal ruled it was reasonably practicable for her to have filed on time.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Firefighter (18 years' service) v Royal Berkshire Fire Authority (also known as Royal Berkshire Fire and Rescue Service)
An employment tribunal has ruled that Royal Berkshire Fire Authority fairly dismissed a firefighter who pleaded guilty to 12 firearms offences, rejecting claims of race and disability discrimination.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Security guard v Seal Security UK Ltd
A security guard who was dismissed after being found asleep during his shift at Bloomberg LLP has lost his claims for unfair dismissal and discrimination. The tribunal found the employer acted reasonably and the discrimination claims had no merit.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023HGV driver (11 years' service) v Lomas Distribution Limited
An HGV driver with 11 years' service resigned after a heated exchange about a recurring vehicle fault. The tribunal ruled he was not dismissed, rejecting his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee (shop worker) v Ms M. Harvey T/A The Pickle Barrel
A former shop worker's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after the tribunal struck out the employer's response for failing to comply with case management directions for over two years.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Team Leader (16+ years' service) v ISS Facilities Services Ltd
A team leader with 16+ years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after three colleagues saw an indecent video of child abuse on her phone. The employment tribunal upheld the dismissal as fair.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v Works Manager Guarantee Laundries Ltd
A former employee who sent abusive emails to the tribunal and swore at the employment judge has had his discrimination claims struck out for unreasonable conduct.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Trailer loader (4 years' service) v Fleet Express and Logistics Ltd
A trailer loader was unfairly dismissed after threatening to knock out his supervisor, but the tribunal found the process flawed because the employer failed to preserve CCTV evidence and delayed the appeal until the footage was lost. He was awarded £2,743 after a 75% reduction for his own conduct.
Won · £2,743 · Sept 2023Won£2,743Sept 2023Security Patrol Officer v Pace Security Services Limited
A tribunal dismissed claims that a security officer was left out of furlough and overlooked because of his race, but awarded £984 for unpaid holiday accrued during sickness.
Partial · £984 · Sept 2023Partial£984Sept 2023EMEA Regulatory Exam Management and Oversight – Senior Analyst (7 years' service) v Citibank N.A.
A senior analyst with 7 years' service was fairly dismissed after submitting an expense claim that included his partner's meals and then denying it during investigation. The tribunal upheld Citibank's decision.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Senior Lecturer (14 years' service) v University of the Arts London
A senior lecturer with 14 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after developing a romantic relationship with a student. The tribunal rejected his claims of unfair dismissal and race discrimination.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee (5 years' service) v Open GI Ltd
A tribunal found that Open GI Ltd unfairly dismissed a disabled employee after he attended his manager's home with white spirit, but awarded no compensation due to his conduct. The employee received £2,805 for injury to feelings on a related discrimination claim.
Partial · £2,805 · Sept 2023Partial£2,805Sept 2023Motor mechanic (3 years' service) v JDH Motor Repairs Limited
A motor mechanic with three years' service was unfairly dismissed after being told 'I think it's time you went' and 'There's no time like the present'. The tribunal found the employer's Facebook advert for a replacement on the same day confirmed the dismissal.
Won · Sept 2023Won—Sept 2023Property Maintenance Manager (2 years' service) v Melin Homes Ltd
A property maintenance manager who was dismissed after less than two years' service following bullying complaints has lost his claims of unfair dismissal, age discrimination and trade union detriment. The tribunal found the dismissal was fair and not motivated by age.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Road sweeper (19 years' service) v Veolia ES (UK) Limited
A tribunal struck out a road sweeper's unfair dismissal claim because his lay representative deleted a WhatsApp message and failed to disclose other relevant documents, making a fair trial impossible.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Access Resources Integrated Services Support Officer v London Borough of Enfield
A tribunal struck out a former support officer's unfair dismissal claim against London Borough of Enfield after he failed to confirm whether he wished to pursue it and did not attend hearings.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee v HFD Limited
A former employee who submitted an unfair dismissal claim and then cut all contact has had his case struck out and been ordered to pay £723.80 in costs.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Installation engineer (5 years' service) v ABS Installations Limited
An installation engineer who used his employer's credit card to fuel his personal car on three occasions was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Commercial Service Manager (22 years' service) v Denbighshire County Council
A 22-year council employee who set up a private company without telling his employer was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal ruled.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v Hydegate Pet Resort Ltd
A former employee was unfairly dismissed after the employer failed to follow a fair procedure. The tribunal awarded a 20% uplift for breaching the ACAS Code and confirmed one month's notice pay.
Won · Sept 2023Won—Sept 2023Personal Assistant (6 months' service) v Club19 Limited
A tribunal rejected a wrongful dismissal claim from a PA with six months' service who was summarily dismissed after blocking her manager on WhatsApp and returning the business phone unattended. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Sales consultant / casual worker v ABM Aviation UK Limited
A sales consultant who refused to participate in the final hearing and repeatedly failed to comply with case management orders had his unfair dismissal and discrimination claims struck out. Costs orders totalling £5,548 were made against him.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Support Worker (3 years 6 months' service) v Just One Health & Social Care Ltd
A support worker who raised her voice at a vulnerable adult was unfairly dismissed after her employer relied on undisclosed witness statements. The tribunal awarded £12,108, reduced by a third for her own conduct.
Won · £12,108 · Sept 2023Won£12,108Sept 2023Client care associate (6 years' service) v Shred-it Ltd
A client care associate with six years' service was dismissed for aggressive behaviour and unauthorised absences while on a final written warning. The tribunal upheld the dismissal, finding the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023HGV driver (3 years' service) v Sepco International Limited
An HGV driver who refused a route in anger and left work was unfairly dismissed when his employer treated it as resignation without a disciplinary hearing. The tribunal found the dismissal procedurally unfair, but will apply significant reductions for his conduct.
Won · Sept 2023Won—Sept 2023Bus driver (7 weeks' service) v Abellio London Limited
A bus driver with only 7 weeks' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after using his mobile phone while driving. The tribunal struck out his unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Postal worker (19 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A postal worker with 19 years' service was fairly dismissed for sending unsolicited items including scissors and a Hi Vis jacket to colleagues. The tribunal upheld Royal Mail's decision, finding the employer acted within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Shift manager (4 years 9 months' service) v One Stop Stores Limited
A shift manager who gave ice cream to a school and charity without approval was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected his claims of unfair dismissal and race discrimination.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Food Technology Teacher (4 months' service) v Cavendish Learning Limited
A tribunal struck out Cavendish Learning Limited's response after repeated failures to comply with case management orders, leaving the claimant's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims undefended.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Former employee v John Lewis plc
A former employee of John Lewis plc who was dismissed for unauthorised absence and failure to follow reporting procedures has lost her unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims. The tribunal also ordered her to pay £13,250 in costs.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Production Team Member (2 years' service) v Bighams Ltd
A production worker with a final written warning for threatening behaviour was fairly dismissed after shouting at a colleague. The tribunal also ordered Bighams Ltd to pay £648.96 for unpaid holiday.
Partial · £649 · Sept 2023Partial£649Sept 2023Security Operations Manager (14 years' service) v Mitie Limited
A Security Operations Manager with 14 years' service was fairly dismissed after taking two bicycles from lost property without permission. The tribunal rejected his claims of unfair dismissal and race discrimination.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v Italia2U Limited
A former employee of Italia2U Limited won over £11,700 after the company failed to respond to their tribunal claim, resulting in a default judgment and a remedy hearing.
Won · £11,759 · Sept 2023Won£11,759Sept 2023Process Technician (32 years' service) v Massmould Limited
A process technician with 32 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after kicking and throwing his bump cap towards a colleague. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Assistant team manager and duty manager (8 years' service) v John Lewis Plc
An assistant team manager with eight years' service was fairly dismissed after CCTV showed him pushing, grabbing and kicking members of the public. The tribunal rejected his claims of disability discrimination and unfair dismissal.
Lost · Sept 2023Lost—Sept 2023Former employee v Kelvedon Auto Spares 87 Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was thrown out after he failed to attend the final hearing and had already asked to cancel it. The tribunal also found the claim was presented out of time.
Dismissed · Sept 2023Dismissed—Sept 2023Trader (7 years' service) v EDF Trading Limited
A trader with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed by EDF Trading Limited after a flawed investigation into an alleged leak of confidential information. The tribunal found the dismissal procedurally unfair but rejected his whistleblowing claim.
Partial · Sept 2023Partial—Sept 2023Shop Assistant (9 years' service) v Tarsaim and Mandeep Sandhu t/a Station Stores
A shop assistant with nine years' service was unfairly dismissed after using the Post Office till for a personal transaction. The tribunal found the investigation was insufficient and the dismissal procedurally unfair.
Won · Sept 2023Won—Sept 2023Senior delivery, operations and support engineer (8 years' service) v BT PLC
An employment tribunal has rejected claims of unfair dismissal, race discrimination and victimisation brought by a BT engineer dismissed for breaching IT policies, but upheld claims for unpaid overtime and holiday pay totalling £4,666.81.
Partial · £4,667 · Sept 2023Partial£4,667Sept 2023Long-Term Delivery Postperson (17 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Limited
A postman with 17 years' service was fairly dismissed after a member of the public reported him drinking alcohol from a can and driving away. The tribunal found Royal Mail's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Porter (9 years' service) v Mitie Limited
A hospital porter with nine years' service was fairly dismissed for pushing a security guard who challenged him for not wearing a face mask. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision, finding the dismissal within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee (patient transport/administrative role) v Medicare EMS Group UK Limited
A former employee who brought claims for unfair dismissal and pregnancy discrimination had her case struck out after failing to comply with orders and not attending the hearing.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Former employee v CFE Lighting
A former employee who missed a telephone hearing due to connection problems has had her unfair dismissal claim reinstated after the tribunal granted reconsideration.
Remitted · Aug 2023Remitted—Aug 2023Store Manager (3 years' service) v EE Limited
A store manager who took unauthorised holiday during an iPhone launch embargo was fairly dismissed, the tribunal ruled, rejecting his claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination based on dyslexia.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Manual Handling Equipment Trainer (9 years' service) v DHL Services Ltd
A manual handling equipment trainer with 9 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to carry out practical assessments for two returning employees. The tribunal upheld DHL's decision.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Senior Construction Project Manager (3 years' service) v Ocado Central Services Limited
A senior project manager was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to disclose personal relationships with contractors and allowing a friend to use his work laptop. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Band 5 community nurse (6 years' service) v Guys & St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust
A Band 5 community nurse with six years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after inappropriate contact with a vulnerable patient, the tribunal ruled.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Studio sales administrator (3 years 10 months' service) v Fresh Transformations Ltd trading as Fresh Doors
A studio sales administrator was unfairly dismissed when her employer asked for her keys after she refused to attend work during lockdown. The tribunal awarded £723, reduced by 50% for her own conduct.
Won · £723 · Aug 2023Won£723Aug 2023Train cleaner (21 years' service) v Atalian Servest Limited
A train cleaner with 21 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed investigation into alleged theft of soap, but the tribunal found he actually committed theft, reducing compensation to zero.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Former employee (rehabilitation sector) v KTB Rehabilitation Ltd
A tribunal extended time for an unfair dismissal claim filed 11 days late, but struck it out for lack of merit. The claimant succeeded only on a breach of contract claim for notice pay, receiving £948.78.
Partial · £949 · Aug 2023Partial£949Aug 2023Bar staff (18 years' service) v Meanwood Conservative Club
An employment tribunal found that Meanwood Conservative Club acted fairly when it dismissed a bar worker with 18 years' service for failing to improve her attitude towards the club secretary, following a final written warning.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Commercial Development Executive (8 years' service) v DPD Group UK Ltd
A commercial development executive with 8 years' service was fairly dismissed after he failed to report three commission overpayments totalling £6,049.83 that he knew he was not entitled to. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee v Skins Laser Clinic Ltd
A former employee of Skins Laser Clinic Ltd was awarded over £21,000 after the tribunal found she was not paid for 142 hours of work and suffered race discrimination. The award was increased by 25% because the employer failed to address her grievance.
Won · £21,124 · Aug 2023Won£21,124Aug 2023Export clerk (4 years 8 months' service) v UPS SCS UK Limited
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of an export clerk who repeatedly failed to work his contractual hours, finding the employer's decision was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Former employee v Greene King Retail Services Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims were struck out after she repeatedly failed to comply with tribunal orders and did not attend the preliminary hearing. She was also ordered to pay £1,000 in costs.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Postal worker (25 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A postal worker with 25 years' service was fairly dismissed after a Facebook post implying managers bully and harass employees. The tribunal found Royal Mail's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Warehouse manager (26 years' service) v Tesco Stores Limited
A warehouse manager with 26 years' service was unfairly dismissed by Tesco for alleged favouritism, but his race discrimination claim failed. The tribunal awarded £2,848.74 in compensation.
Partial · £2,849 · Aug 2023Partial£2,849Aug 2023Bid Manager (12 years' service) v Mears Group plc
A tribunal found that Mears Group plc unfairly dismissed a Bid Manager with spinal injuries and victimised her for raising concerns about reasonable adjustments. She was awarded £964,465.37.
Won · £964,465 · Aug 2023Won£964,465Aug 2023Depot manager (18 years' service) v Concord Lifting Equipment Limited
A depot manager with 18 years' service was unfairly dismissed after his employer relied on a stale theft allegation and denied him the chance to respond. The tribunal awarded £22,000.
Partial · £22,001 · Aug 2023Partial£22,001Aug 2023Maths teacher and KS5 coordinator (2 years' service) v Middlesex Learning Partnership
A maths teacher with less than two years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct. The employment tribunal dismissed his unfair dismissal claim for lack of jurisdiction and found no race discrimination.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Security Officer (6 years' service) v Alpha Response 2004 Ltd t/a Red Support Services
A security officer with six years' service was fairly dismissed after CCTV footage showed he left his post without authorisation on multiple occasions. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Customer assistant (7 years' service) v Marks and Spencer PLC
A customer assistant with autism was unfairly dismissed by Marks and Spencer after leaning on a colleague, as the tribunal found the employer failed to consider his condition or obtain updated medical reports.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Former employees (family-run supermarket) v Medsun Food Ltd
Three employees were fairly dismissed for a roof confrontation and assault, but a fourth was unfairly dismissed for taking goods without payment. The tribunal reduced her compensation to zero due to her conduct.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Former employee v Change Grow Live
A former employee's unfair dismissal, whistleblowing and discrimination claims have been struck out after being brought too late, with the tribunal also citing unreasonable conduct. The respondent was awarded £5,000 in costs.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Former employee v St John's Nursing Home Limited
A former employee's race and sex discrimination claims were struck out after she and her representative failed to attend a preliminary hearing without explanation. A later bid to reinstate the case was refused.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Security Officer (13 years' service) v Secure Frontline Services Limited
A tribunal found that a security officer with 13 years' service was unfairly dismissed after being sacked by email without any disciplinary hearing, but reduced her compensation to zero because her own conduct contributed entirely to the dismissal.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Chief Executive Officer (13 years' service) v Integration Support Services
A tribunal has rejected an unfair dismissal claim brought by a CEO with 13 years' service, finding that the employer acted reasonably in dismissing for gross misconduct following an independent investigation into bullying allegations.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Gymnastics coach (3 years' service) v Doncaster Gymnastics Academy Ltd
A gymnastics coach who encouraged gymnasts to leave for a rival club was unfairly dismissed by text message, but her compensation was cut by 75% for her own misconduct. She was awarded £167.08.
Won · £167 · Aug 2023Won£167Aug 2023Shop assistant / supervisor (2 years' service) v Beauty Base Ltd
A shop assistant who took a long holiday after an informal arrangement with his manager was unfairly dismissed for alleged mobile phone use. The tribunal awarded £18,441 after finding the real reason was unknown and the procedure was a sham.
Partial · £18,441 · Aug 2023Partial£18,441Aug 2023Former employee v Department for Education
A former employee who filed eight separate claims against the Department for Education and others has had all claims struck out after the tribunal found his conduct scandalous, unreasonable and vexatious.
Dismissed · Aug 2023Dismissed—Aug 2023Finance and accounting consultant v Ruby Labs Ltd
A finance and accounting consultant who threatened to report his client for tax irregularities unless paid £600,000 has had all his employment tribunal claims dismissed. He was ordered to pay €86,200 in costs.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Manager (18 years' service) v Lloyds Banking Group PLC
A manager with 18 years' service was unfairly dismissed and discriminated against for using the full N-word during a race education session. The tribunal found his dyslexia contributed to the error and ordered Lloyds Banking Group to pay over £454,000.
Partial · £454,715 · Aug 2023Partial£454,715Aug 2023Former employee v Kitrinos Healthcare (charity No. 1172586)
A former employee settled her claims for £11,210.89 after the employer conceded unfair dismissal at the final hearing. The tribunal later ordered the employer to pay £6,485.88 in preparation time costs for unreasonable conduct.
Settled · £11,211 · Aug 2023Settled£11,211Aug 2023Former employee (30 years' service) v Dunwood Specialties Limited
A tribunal found that Dunwood Specialties Limited unfairly dismissed a long-serving employee after failing to follow any disciplinary process, but reduced compensation by 80% because the employee would likely have been dismissed anyway.
Partial · £27,075 · Aug 2023Partial£27,075Aug 2023Midwife (22 years' service) v Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust
A Reading tribunal struck out a midwife's discrimination claims against Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust after finding they could not be fairly heard, but allowed her unfair and wrongful dismissal claims to proceed.
Partial · Aug 2023Partial—Aug 2023Human Resources Business Partner v Romac Logistics Limited
A tribunal has refused an employer's attempt to strike out claims of disability discrimination and victimisation brought by an autistic HR Business Partner who was dismissed after raising concerns about missing right-to-work documents.
Lost · Aug 2023Lost—Aug 2023Lead nurse specialist (4 years 8 months' service) v Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust
A lead nurse specialist was unfairly dismissed by Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust after the trust failed to properly handle her grievance. The tribunal found she had committed gross misconduct but the dismissal was procedurally unfair.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Former retail worker v Primark Stores Ltd
A former Primark employee who refused to attend her own unfair dismissal hearing had her claim dismissed under Rule 47. The tribunal also ordered her to pay £400 in costs for unreasonable conduct.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Registered nurse (band 5, 6 years' service) v Tees Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust
A band 5 nurse with six years' unblemished service was fairly dismissed after CCTV showed her dragging a vulnerable patient with learning disabilities along the floor. The employment tribunal rejected her unfair and wrongful dismissal claims.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Bus driver (5 years' service) v Abellio London Ltd
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a bus driver with five years' service who drove through a red light, finding the employer's decision was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023General Operative (5 years' service) v Amalga Ltd
A general operative who flew to Slovakia while on furlough was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Personal assistant (1 year's service) v Miss S Powell
A personal assistant with less than two years' service was summarily dismissed via WhatsApp after she could not get to work due to heavy snowfall. The tribunal rejected her claim that the dismissal was automatically unfair for health and safety reasons.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Stock Technician (6 years' service) v Stanmore Implants Worldwide Limited
A stock technician with six years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after an unauthorised absence. The tribunal rejected claims of unfair dismissal, age discrimination, and harassment.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Train operator (11 years' service) v London Underground Limited
A tribunal found London Underground unfairly dismissed a train operator with 11 years' service for opening doors on the wrong side, but awarded no compensation because a fair process would have reached the same outcome.
Partial · £0 · Jul 2023Partial£0Jul 2023Carer (4 years 8 months' service) v Miss Gurshital Gill
A carer with nearly five years' service was dismissed by email after reporting a back injury at work. The tribunal found the dismissal procedurally unfair but limited compensation because a fair dismissal would have occurred anyway.
Partial · £1,536 · Jul 2023Partial£1,536Jul 2023Assistant Restaurant General Manager (12 years' service) v Splendid Restaurants (Colonel) Ltd
A 12-year employee who waited until after his internal appeal to bring an unfair dismissal claim was out of time. The tribunal rejected arguments that his wife's stillbirth and his own ignorance of procedure made it not reasonably practicable to claim earlier.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Ward manager (12 years' service) v Cheshire and Wirral Partnership NHS Foundation Trust
A ward manager with 12 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after the trust used CCTV and fob records to investigate her hours. The tribunal found the dismissal fair but awarded £10,269.96 for breach of contract — she should have received notice pay.
Partial · £10,270 · Jul 2023Partial£10,270Jul 2023Former employee v Warburtons Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims were struck out after he failed to particularize them despite multiple hearings and warnings. The tribunal found no reasonable prospect of success and unreasonable conduct.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Train driver (10 years' service) v Arriva Rail London Limited
An employment tribunal has ruled that Arriva Rail London fairly dismissed a train driver of 10 years who tested positive for cannabis metabolites in a random drug test, rejecting his defence that the result was caused by CBD oil.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Senior Sales Consultant (2 years' service) v Ninety Watches and Jewellery Limited
A tribunal dismissed a former sales consultant's race and religion discrimination claims because they were presented more than six months after her dismissal, and it was not just and equitable to extend time.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Yard Controller (30 years' service) v Abellio East Anglia Limited T/A Greater Anglia
A yard controller with 30 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a 16-second delay in stopping a train due to a radio failure. The tribunal found the employer's investigation was inadequate and the procedure fell outside the range of reasonable responses.
Won · Jul 2023Won—Jul 2023Swimming teacher (8 years' service) v Doncaster Culture & Leisure Trust
A swimming teacher with 8 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after telling a 10-year-old pupil 'it looks like you work out'. The Leeds tribunal upheld the employer's decision, citing safeguarding concerns.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Welder (20 years' service) v Silo Services Limited
A welder who resigned after his employer failed to make reasonable adjustments for his heart condition has won his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims. The tribunal awarded £42,334 but reduced compensation because he turned down a job offer the day after leaving.
Won · £42,334 · Jul 2023Won£42,334Jul 2023Cleaner (2 years' service) v M & I t/a Jetmaid Cleaning Services Ltd
A cleaner with two years' service was dismissed by text message after calling in sick. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair and awarded £8,192.72.
Won · £8,193 · Jul 2023Won£8,193Jul 2023Online delivery driver v Sainsbury’s Supermarkets Ltd
A Sainsbury's delivery driver who claimed he was unfairly dismissed for discount card misuse had his case dismissed because he presented his claim two months after the deadline.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Firefighter (3 years' service) v London Fire Commissioner
A firefighter who waited over a year to bring unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims after his misconduct dismissal had his case struck out by the tribunal as out of time.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Former employee (IT professional, £55k salary) v JP Morgan Chase Bank N.A London Branch
A tribunal struck out a former JP Morgan employee's discrimination claim after he inserted a poem into disclosed documents and sent the tampered version to the tribunal. Most allegations were also dismissed as out of time.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Former employee v The CS Group Limited
A former employee with less than two years' service was awarded £3,876 after the tribunal found unauthorised wage deductions and a breach of contract over notice pay. The employer also failed to provide written particulars.
Partial · £3,876 · Jul 2023Partial£3,876Jul 2023Former employee v Financial Ombudsman Service Limited
A former complainant who claimed to be an employee of the Financial Ombudsman Service had all his claims struck out after failing to attend a preliminary hearing and providing no evidence of an employment relationship.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Former employee v The Beehive (Penrith) Ltd (in voluntary liquidation)
A former employee with less than two years' service had their unfair dismissal claim struck out, but recovered £1,263 in unpaid wages after the employer failed to respond.
Partial · £1,263 · Jul 2023Partial£1,263Jul 2023Head of Sales (2 years' service) v Pendragon Plc t/a Stratstone BMW
A tribunal found the dismissal of a Head of Sales was procedurally unfair due to a flawed appeal and inconsistent treatment, but awarded no compensation because of the employee's contributory conduct.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Associate Specialist Cardio-Thoracic surgeon (12 years' service) v Cardiff and Vale University Local Health Board
A Cardiff tribunal dismissed claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination by a surgeon who accessed his ex-wife's medical records without consent over 13 years. The tribunal found he resigned voluntarily and the employer's disciplinary process was fair.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Head of PE Faculty (7 years' service) v Kings Monkton School Limited
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a Head of PE who authorised the use of another pupil's inhaler for a child with severe allergies during an off-site lesson. All disability discrimination claims also failed.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Assistant Store Manager (4 years' service) v Poundland Limited
An assistant store manager who allowed a colleague to work without clocking in and later falsified time records was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected her claim that lack of training excused the manipulation of the Kronos system.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee (Project Manager, Surrey Fire and Rescue Service Pensions) v Surrey County Council
A tribunal has struck out a former employee's unfair dismissal claim after he deliberately misled the tribunal about a medical appointment and failed to comply with case management orders.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Factory manager (3 years' service) v Laporte Industries UK Limited
A tribunal ruled that a meeting between a factory manager and Laporte Industries UK Limited was a genuine without-prejudice negotiation, making it inadmissible in his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee (5 years' service) v Entain Marketing (UK) Limited trading as Entain Group
A former employee with five years' service was awarded £4,505 after his employer failed to defend the claim. His discrimination claim was dismissed for lack of evidence.
Partial · £4,505 · Jul 2023Partial£4,505Jul 2023Health Care Support Worker (4 years' service) v Avon and Wiltshire Mental Health Partnership NHS Trust
A Health Care Support Worker with four years' service was fairly dismissed for failing to treat a service user with dignity, the tribunal ruled, rejecting claims of whistleblowing detriment and race discrimination.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee (11 years' service) v Catwalk Dogs St Helens Ltd
A former employee with 11 years' service was unfairly dismissed and underpaid the national minimum wage. The tribunal awarded £4,694.53, including an ACAS uplift.
Won · £4,695 · Jul 2023Won£4,695Jul 2023Trainee route setter (2 years' service) v Ascendant Leisure Properties Limited
A trainee route setter who emailed about changing her role was unfairly dismissed when her employer treated it as a resignation. The tribunal awarded £5,597, including an 18% uplift for failing to follow the ACAS Code.
Won · £5,597 · Jul 2023Won£5,597Jul 2023Former employee v Tesco Stores Limited
A former employee was unfairly dismissed by Tesco, but the tribunal reduced his compensation by 10% because his own conduct contributed to the dismissal. Discrimination claims were dismissed.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Care home worker (5 years' service) v SSL Healthcare Ltd t/a Brookfields Care Home
A care home worker was unfairly dismissed after procedural flaws, but the tribunal found her guilty of the alleged misconduct and reduced compensation to zero.
Partial · £1,482 · Jul 2023Partial£1,482Jul 2023Postal worker (21 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Limited
A postal worker with 21 years' service was fairly dismissed for not wearing a seatbelt while sharing a vehicle during the pandemic, the tribunal ruled, rejecting his claim of unfair dismissal.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee v Cerberus Security and Monitoring Services Ltd
A former employee of Cerberus Security and Monitoring Services Ltd has succeeded in unfair dismissal and victimisation claims after being dismissed for conduct failings. Remedy is yet to be determined.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Early years practitioner (8 years' service) v Hertsmonceux Pre-School Limited
An early years practitioner with 8 years' service was automatically unfairly dismissed after raising concerns about underpayment of SSP and holiday pay. The tribunal found the real reason for her dismissal was her assertion of statutory rights.
Won · Jul 2023Won—Jul 2023Regional Sales Manager (3 years' service) v Central Extrusions Limited
A Regional Sales Manager with three years' service was unfairly dismissed after using the word 'spastic' in a conversation about historical language. The tribunal awarded £7,710.31 for procedural failures including a pre-signed dismissal letter.
Won · £7,710 · Jul 2023Won£7,710Jul 2023Former employee v Marks and Spencer plc
A former Marks and Spencer employee had several claims struck out due to lack of reasonable prospect of success, but race and religion discrimination claims survive subject to small deposits.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023HGV driver (4 years' service) v Lindab Limited
An HGV driver who used a company fuel card for his personal vehicle and falsified time sheets was fairly dismissed. The tribunal rejected his claims of race discrimination and unfair dismissal.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Road marking linesmen v WJ Roadmarkings North Ltd
Two road marking linesmen were fairly dismissed after GPS tracking showed they used a company vehicle to do private work during paid hours. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Site manager (26 years' service) v Tithe Barn Club (Aldwick) Limited
A site manager with 26 years' service was unfairly dismissed for alleged gross misconduct after a breakdown in the relationship between the owner and his son. The tribunal awarded £51,785, including a 25% uplift for failing to follow the ACAS Code.
Won · £51,785 · Jul 2023Won£51,785Jul 2023Production operative v Jaguar Land Rover Limited
A production operative dismissed for gross misconduct after an NHS COVID-19 app self-isolation alert was found to be fairly dismissed. The tribunal ruled the employer's investigation and belief in fraud were reasonable.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Former employee v Surrey and Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust
Two former employees of Surrey and Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust had their unfair dismissal and discrimination claims struck out after repeatedly failing to provide details of their case, despite multiple extensions and a warning.
Dismissed · Jul 2023Dismissed—Jul 2023Highways Maintenance Operative (5 years' service) v Amey Services Ltd
A Highways Maintenance Operative was unfairly dismissed after admitting to stealing diesel, but the tribunal found the investigation and disciplinary process were procedurally flawed.
Partial · Jul 2023Partial—Jul 2023Finance director (38 years' service) v Implex Consultants Ltd
A finance director with 38 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after taking confidential documents from a locked cupboard to help a family member in a legal dispute with his employer. The tribunal rejected his whistleblowing claims.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Purge and relight engineer (5 years' service) v Network Plus Services Limited
A purge and relight engineer with five years' service was unfairly dismissed after a dispute over whether he was told to return to a work site. The tribunal found the employer failed to consider the possibility of miscommunication and did not interview a key witness.
Won · Jul 2023Won—Jul 2023Immigration Enforcement Officer (31 years' service) v Home Office
An Immigration Enforcement Officer with 31 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after carrying out unauthorised lookups on a Home Office database, including after a zero-tolerance policy was introduced. The tribunal found the employer's belief in misconduct was genuine and reasonable, despite procedural shortcomings.
Lost · Jul 2023Lost—Jul 2023Dog Handler (2 years' service) v Global Support Services (UK) Ltd
A dog handler who secretly recorded managers and sent a threatening email was dismissed. The tribunal upheld some claims but found no sex discrimination or whistleblowing victimisation.
Partial · £7,857 · Jun 2023Partial£7,857Jun 2023Senior health care assistant (3 years' service) v Signature Senior Lifestyle Operations Limited
A senior care assistant who shouted at a resident and called her 'stupid', inadvertently recorded on a voicemail, was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected her unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Store manager (21 years' service) v Holland and Barratt Retail Limited
A tribunal has dismissed an unfair dismissal claim by a store manager with 21 years' service who was sacked for overbooking holidays and falsifying time records.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023IT support technician (3 years 6 months' service) v Birmingham City University
An employment tribunal struck out the entire claim of an IT support technician who called counsel 'a retard' and discussed evidence on Twitter during the hearing, ruling his conduct made a fair trial impossible.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Former employee v Holland and Barrett Retail Ltd
A former employee won her unfair and wrongful dismissal claims against Holland and Barrett, but an 80% reduction for contributory conduct cut her compensation to £3,407.
Partial · £3,407 · Jun 2023Partial£3,407Jun 2023Senior manager (6 years' service) v 221B Limited
A senior manager who was summarily dismissed after her solicitor demanded a £500,000 bonus has won her unfair dismissal claim, but the tribunal said she would have been fairly dismissed after a proper process.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Area sales manager (7 years' service) v Core Communications Retail Limited
An area sales manager with 7 years' service was fairly dismissed after admitting to logging visits that never happened and making cash sales. The tribunal found the employer's decision was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Bus operations manager (4 years' service) v Rowgate Group Ltd and CE Jeatt & Sons Ltd
A bus operations manager was unfairly dismissed after recording a colleague dancing to 'The Stripper'. The employer conceded liability and was ordered to pay £52,190.47.
Won · £52,190 · Jun 2023Won£52,190Jun 2023Former employee v Aspinalls Club Limited t/a Crown London Aspinalls
A former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims against Aspinalls Club were struck out after repeated failures to provide required documents and respond to tribunal orders.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Former employee (cleaner) v Tame Cleaning & Maintenance Ltd
A former cleaner was unfairly dismissed by Tame Cleaning & Maintenance Ltd. The tribunal allowed her late claims because severe depression made it not reasonably practicable to file on time.
Partial · £7,621 · Jun 2023Partial£7,621Jun 2023Deputy Managing Director (15 years' service) v Phase II International Ltd
A deputy managing director with 15 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed misconduct process. The tribunal found the decision-maker had prejudged the outcome, but applied a 50% Polkey reduction.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Former employee v Gatwick Construction Limited
A former employee of Gatwick Construction Limited had their unfair dismissal claim thrown out because they had not worked there for two years. Their other claims for wrongful dismissal and unauthorised deductions also failed.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Office Manager (3 years 7 months' service) v Main Group Services Ltd
An office manager with 3 years 7 months' service was unfairly dismissed after calling her managers 'dickheads' in jest during a heated meeting. The tribunal found the employer's subsequent disciplinary process was contrived and awarded £15,042.81.
Won · £15,043 · Jun 2023Won£15,043Jun 2023Accuracy Checking Pharmacy Technician (12 years' service) v Boots Management Services Ltd
A tribunal allowed a Boots pharmacy technician with 12 years' service to amend her claim to include unfair dismissal, finding the new claim was a relabelling of existing facts.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Personal Relationship Manager (9 years' service) v Lloyds Bank plc
A Personal Relationship Manager with nine years' service was fairly dismissed for deliberately coughing towards a colleague during the pandemic, breaching lone-working rules and lying to his manager. The tribunal rejected all claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Former employee v Sharps Bedrooms Limited
A former employee was unfairly dismissed by Sharps Bedrooms Limited, but received only £1,502.32 after the tribunal found he would have been dismissed anyway if a fair procedure had been followed.
Partial · £1,502 · Jun 2023Partial£1,502Jun 2023Care worker (4 years' service) v GGN Limited t/a Golders Green Nursing
A care worker who arranged for a friend to help her look after a vulnerable client during lockdown was unfairly dismissed, but the tribunal reduced her compensation by 70% for the chance she would have been fairly dismissed anyway and by 60% for her own misconduct.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Former employee v Skins Laser Clinic Ltd
A former employee of Skins Laser Clinic Ltd won nearly £19,000 in compensation after the company failed to respond to her tribunal claim, leading to a default judgment for unfair dismissal and race discrimination.
Won · £18,769 · Jun 2023Won£18,769Jun 2023Deputy Chief Executive (12 years' service) v Alice (Relief of Poverty Advancement of Community)
A deputy chief executive with 12 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after claiming nursery fees from the charity she helped establish. The tribunal upheld the unfair dismissal claim but awarded £4,296 for wrongful dismissal and a defective written statement.
Partial · £4,296 · Jun 2023Partial£4,296Jun 2023UNISON branch secretary (full-time release since 1998) v Kirklees Council
A UNISON branch secretary with 49 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after two complaints of bullying and threatening behaviour. The tribunal rejected his claim that he was targeted for trade union activities.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Beauty Consultant (2 weeks' service) v Elle Beauty Limited t/a Elevatione Time Stops London
A beauty consultant who was dismissed by WhatsApp after just 10 days lost her race discrimination claim but won £382 for unpaid training days and underpayment.
Partial · £382 · Jun 2023Partial£382Jun 2023Civil servant (Higher Officer, Commercial Directorate, HMRC) v HM Revenue and Customs
A long-serving HMRC civil servant who covertly recorded meetings with his manager had his unfair dismissal and whistleblowing claims dismissed after the tribunal found a fair trial was impossible.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Maths teacher (15 years' service) v Ernest Bevin College and London Borough of Wandsworth
A tribunal struck out a maths teacher's unfair dismissal and age discrimination claims after he filed 18 days late and failed to pay a £500 deposit for the weak discrimination claim.
Dismissed · Jun 2023Dismissed—Jun 2023Cabin crew and purser (35 years' service) v British Airways plc
An employment tribunal has upheld British Airways' decision to dismiss a cabin crew member with 35 years' service for gross misconduct after she made racist comments about a doctor and left hospital while self-isolating with suspected COVID-19.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Reablement Support Assistant (13 years' service) v Bristol City Council
A Reablement Support Assistant with 13 years' service was dismissed for conduct after a disciplinary hearing she could not attend because the Teams link was sent to the wrong email address. The tribunal found the dismissal substantively fair but procedurally unfair, though no compensation was awarded.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Former employee v Xiamen Ason Products Limited
A former employee who was dismissed without notice by Xiamen Ason Products Limited has been awarded £15,495.72 for breach of contract and failure to provide a written statement of particulars.
Partial · £15,496 · Jun 2023Partial£15,496Jun 2023Retail Store Manager (16 years' service) v EE Limited
A retail store manager with 16 years' service was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct after the employer failed to obtain medical advice about her depression and anxiety. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair and wrongful, with compensation reduced by 20% for Polkey and 50% for contributory conduct.
Won · Jun 2023Won—Jun 2023Warehouse operative and union convener (5 years' service) v DHL Services Ltd
A warehouse operative and union convener was fairly dismissed after falsely claiming to be a union member's representative when calling the employer's solicitors. The tribunal rejected his claims of automatic and ordinary unfair dismissal.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Online Editor (6 years' service) v Al Quds Al-Arabi Publishing & Advertising
An online editor who was paid a monthly retainer and subject to editorial control has been found to be an employee and unfairly dismissed. The tribunal awarded £32,020.80 in compensation.
Won · £32,021 · Jun 2023Won£32,021Jun 2023Night Senior Carer (2 years 8 months' service) v Barchester Healthcare Ltd
A night senior carer with over 40 years' experience was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after moving an unresponsive resident before calling 999, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Cleaner v Bidvest Noonan (UK) Limited
A cleaner who received a final written warning but was not dismissed brought an unfair dismissal claim 65 days out of time. The tribunal found no dismissal occurred and refused to extend the deadline.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Payroll clerk/Bookkeeper (10 years' service) v Philips Accountants (Southgate) Ltd
A payroll clerk with a decade of service was dismissed on the same day an incident occurred, without any investigation or prior warnings. The tribunal awarded £10,384.50 for unfair and wrongful dismissal.
Won · £10,385 · Jun 2023Won£10,385Jun 2023Trainee Nursing Associate (2 years' service) v North West Anglia NHS Foundation Trust
A trainee nursing associate was unfairly dismissed after a disciplinary hearing went ahead while she was signed off sick following her mother's death. The tribunal found the process unfair but awarded no compensation, ruling she would have been dismissed anyway.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Team Supervisor (17 years' service) v Wilko Ltd
A tribunal found that Wilko Ltd unfairly dismissed a long-serving team supervisor for smoking on company property, but reduced compensation by 50% due to her admitting the misconduct.
Partial · Jun 2023Partial—Jun 2023Apprentice gas fitter (18 years old, 14 months' service) v DW Gas Services Limited
An 18-year-old apprentice gas fitter has been awarded £5,613 after his employer failed to pay his contractual wages, dismissed him without notice, and never provided written terms or pay statements.
Won · £5,613 · Jun 2023Won£5,613Jun 2023Operations and Control Manager (11 years' service) v Santander UK PLC
An operations manager with 11 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed investigation into financial irregularities, but the tribunal awarded no compensation because a fair dismissal would have occurred anyway.
Won · £0 · Jun 2023Won£0Jun 2023Project Coordinator (12 years' service) v London Borough of Southwark
A project coordinator with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed for failing to declare property ownership on a housing application and providing false information about his brother. The tribunal also dismissed his whistleblowing claim and ordered him to pay £5,000 in costs.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Customer service advisor (7 years' service) v Dermalogica UK Limited
A customer service advisor with 7 years' service was fairly dismissed for posting critical comments about her employer on Facebook during the first COVID-19 lockdown. The tribunal found the employer's decision fell within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Warehouse picker / Distribution Depot Operative (9 years' service) v Muller UK & Ireland Group T/A Muller Milk and Ingredients
A warehouse picker with nine years' service was fairly dismissed for lifting an empty trolley to chest height as an act of horseplay. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision, finding it within the band of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Customer delivery driver (18 years' service) v Tesco Stores Limited
A Tesco delivery driver with 18 years' service was dismissed for failing to attend meetings while on sick leave. The tribunal upheld the dismissal as fair but ordered Tesco to pay £1,398.60 in unpaid notice pay.
Partial · £1,399 · Jun 2023Partial£1,399Jun 2023Senior Quantity Surveyor (6 years' service) v NGE Contracting Limited
A senior quantity surveyor with six years' service was unfairly dismissed after his employer called it redundancy but the tribunal found the real reason was conduct or capability. He was awarded £38,225.
Partial · £38,225 · Jun 2023Partial£38,225Jun 2023Sales and Reservations Agent (4 years' service) v Turkish Airlines
A sales agent who photographed a colleague's email and sent it to her husband was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the Reading Employment Tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023General Manager (6 years' service) v Mitchells & Butlers Retail Ltd
A tribunal upheld the dismissal of a general manager who stayed drinking after the 10pm COVID curfew and misused staff discounts, but awarded £2,311.72 for unlawful deductions from wages.
Partial · £2,312 · Jun 2023Partial£2,312Jun 2023Postal worker (2 years' service) v Angard Staffing Solutions Ltd and Royal Mail Group Ltd
A postal worker with multiple sclerosis who swore at a colleague after being asked about his blue badge was fairly dismissed for abusive conduct, the tribunal ruled.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Border Force Officer (3 years' service) v Home Office (Border Force (UK))
A Border Force officer with three years' service was fairly dismissed after shouting at managers while under a live final written warning. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal and discrimination.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Rebuild Repair Engineer (3 years' service) v Finning (UK) Limited
A Rebuild Repair Engineer was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after improvising a complex lift without proper equipment or training, breaching the company's Lifesaving Rules. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Jun 2023Lost—Jun 2023Former employee (34 years' service) v Ministry of Defence
A former Ministry of Defence employee with 34 years' service had his second unfair dismissal claim struck out for being substantially the same as a 2015 claim he withdrew, and for paying a deposit late.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Commercial Bodywork Engineer (3 years' service) v Solomon Commercials Ltd
A commercial bodywork engineer who removed a piece of GRP without checking his surroundings, causing a colleague to suffer a fractured orbital bone, was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal found the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023HGV Driver (17 years' service) v Hopkinson Waste Management Limited
A default judgment for unfair dismissal was revoked after the employer argued it had informally requested an extension. The case will now proceed to a full hearing.
Remitted · May 2023Remitted—May 2023Postal worker (Operational Postal Grade) v Royal Mail Group Limited
A postal worker who relied on his trade union's incorrect advice about the time limit for bringing an unfair dismissal claim had his case struck out as out of time. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for him to have presented the claim within the three-month window.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Marex Financial
A former employee was fairly dismissed after entering his workplace out of hours despite a final written warning. A Teams chat showing he planned to evade security was key evidence. The tribunal dismissed his unfair dismissal claim and refused the employer's costs application.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Transport Manager (8 years' service) v Polish Village Bread Limited
A transport manager who was summarily dismissed for sending a cancellation email using his boss's name has won his unfair dismissal claim after the tribunal found the employer fabricated the reason. The case settled for £15,000.
Settled · £15,000 · May 2023Settled£15,000May 2023Service colleague (15 years' service) v Asda Stores Ltd
A service colleague with 15 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after making unsubstantiated race discrimination allegations. The tribunal rejected claims of automatic unfair dismissal and victimisation.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee (fixed-term contract worker) v University of the West of England
A former fixed-term contract worker lost his whistleblowing detriment claim after presenting it nearly a year late. The tribunal also dismissed all other claims of unfair dismissal and discrimination.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Nursery Nurse (3 years 10 months' service) v R Ltd
A nursery nurse who was dismissed for breaching confidentiality after discussing a colleague's disciplinary hearing has lost her unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal also rejected her sexual harassment and victimisation claims.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee v Dr French Memorial Home Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Dr French Memorial Home Limited was struck out after she failed to attend a hearing and ignored tribunal orders, even after being given a second chance.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee (Border Force officer) v Secretary of State for The Home Department (Border Force)
A former Border Force officer who failed to disclose a previous gross misconduct dismissal on his application was fairly dismissed. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were within the band of reasonable responses.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Force Control Room Operator (4 years' service) v Surrey Police
A Force Control Room Operator was fairly dismissed after failing to provide proof of a charity donation from a cake sale, the tribunal has ruled. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Night Shift Postman (34 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A night shift postman with 34 years of service was fairly dismissed for intimidating a colleague, the tribunal ruled, rejecting claims that the process was flawed.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Car mechanic v NK MOT Limited
A car mechanic who was summarily dismissed after a missing tool was found in his toolbox had his unfair dismissal claim rejected because he presented it 17 days after the legal deadline.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Store Manager (32 years' service) v Tesco Stores Limited
A Tesco store manager with 32 years' service was fairly dismissed for misconduct after repeatedly opening the store alone and leaving it unsupervised, despite a live final written warning. The tribunal upheld the dismissal, finding it within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Supervisor of Special Services (4 years' service) v Stagecoach South East
A supervisor with depression was unfairly dismissed after posting an offensive tweet while on furlough. The tribunal found Stagecoach failed to consider his mental health before deciding to dismiss.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Senior technician (12 years' service) v Teva UK Limited
A senior technician with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed after failing to lock out a damaged charger, leading to a colleague's electric shock. The tribunal rejected his claims of unfair dismissal and homophobic harassment.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Professor (University of Oxford) v The Chancellor, Masters and Scholars of the University of Oxford
A University of Oxford professor won his unfair dismissal and age discrimination claims, but was ordered to pay £7,500 in costs after failing to provide remedy disclosure for his £3 million compensation claim.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023Head of Sales (3 years' service) v Sequin Art Ltd
A Head of Sales with 3 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a series of conduct allegations, including a joke about a 'drive-by shooting'. The tribunal awarded £27,777.76, reduced by 25% for contributory fault.
Won · £27,778 · May 2023Won£27,778May 2023Mobile Heavy Goods Vehicle Technician (13 years' service) v Enterprise Rent a Car UK Ltd
A mobile technician with 13 years' service was unfairly dismissed after describing a colleague as a 'female Eastern European woman' who 'always makes mistakes'. The tribunal found the employer's investigation was inadequate.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023Fleet Operative-Drayman (7 years' service) v GXO Logistics Drinks Limited (formerly XPO Logistics Drinks Limited)
A fleet operative who was dismissed for using his mobile phone while driving has won his race discrimination and unfair dismissal claims. The tribunal found the dismissal was tainted by race and reduced compensation by 50% for contributory fault.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023HGV driver (1 year 1 month service) v A R Wholesale Ltd
An HGV driver with just over a year's service was dismissed for misconduct. The tribunal struck out his unfair dismissal claim because he lacked the required two years' continuous service and could not identify any statutory exception.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Al-Khair Foundation
A former employee brought claims for unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and more against Al-Khair Foundation, but all were dismissed as presented too late.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Studio Manager (9 years' service) v Consol Tanning Limited t/a Consol
A tribunal has dismissed an unfair dismissal claim from a studio manager with nine years' service who was sacked for gross misconduct after repeatedly giving free sunbed sessions without authorisation. The employer's investigation and decision were found to be within the range of reasonable responses.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v The Commissioners for HM Revenue and Customs
A former HMRC employee who did not attend his final hearing after three postponement requests were refused has had all his claims dismissed by the Newcastle Employment Tribunal.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Wellbeing Worker (21 years' service) v The African Caribbean Care Group
A wellbeing worker with 21 years' service was fairly dismissed after he continued a free meals project with his son, despite a final written warning. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Emergency Medical Technician (6 years' service) v North West Ambulance Service NHS Trust
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of an Emergency Medical Technician who made crude sexual remarks about children and showed colleagues photographs of children in a swimming pool. The employer's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Restaurant employee (9 years' service) v Red Fortuna Limited, trading as Ciao Baby Restaurant
A 9-year restaurant employee was unfairly dismissed after raising concerns about furlough fraud, but his claim for automatic unfair dismissal due to protected disclosure failed. The tribunal awarded £6,300 in compensation.
Partial · £6,300 · May 2023Partial£6,300May 2023Site coordinator (13 years' service) v East Riding of Yorkshire Council
A school site coordinator with 13 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after making sexually explicit comments to female colleagues. The tribunal also awarded £10,000 costs against him.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee v Riley Foods Limited
A former employee won nearly £15,000 after being unfairly dismissed by Riley Foods Limited, with the tribunal adding a 25% uplift for the company's failure to follow the ACAS Code of Practice.
Won · £14,966 · May 2023Won£14,966May 2023HGV driver v Logikal Network Limited
An HGV driver who refused to drive to Stafford because he needed an 11-hour rest break was summarily dismissed without any investigation. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair and awarded £2,179.42, reduced by 50% for the driver's contributory conduct.
Won · £2,179 · May 2023Won£2,179May 2023Former employee (3 years' service) v Altran UK Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claim survives a strike-out bid, with the tribunal ruling that a fair trial remains possible despite abusive correspondence and procedural delays.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Customer Service Assistant (later Train Operator) v London Underground Ltd
A London Underground train operator was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after refusing to provide a hair sample for drug testing, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Shunter (6 years' service) v DHL Services Ltd
A shunter with six years' service was fairly dismissed after driving while using a hand-held phone and breaching a red light. The tribunal rejected claims that the dismissal was linked to earlier health and safety concerns.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Former employee v West Midlands Ambulance Service University NHS Foundation Trust
A former employee who failed to attend his final hearing and repeatedly ignored tribunal orders has had all his claims dismissed. The tribunal found no realistic prospect of progressing the case.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Field Engineer (32 years' service) v Openreach Plc.
A field engineer with 32 years' service was fairly dismissed after falsely reporting his gas detection unit stolen and failing to use it on four jobs. The tribunal upheld Openreach's decision.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Bar staff (3 years' service) v Mitchells & Butlers Retail Ltd
A tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claim from a bar worker with three years' service because she brought it too late, despite her depression and alcohol misuse.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Occupational Therapy Technical Instructor (2.5 years' service) v South West London and St George’s Mental Health NHS Trust
An occupational therapy instructor who was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct saw his claim dismissed because he presented it too late. The tribunal found he could have brought it in time.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Specialty anaesthetist doctor v Cwm Taf Morgannwg University Local Health Board
A specialty anaesthetist doctor had his race discrimination and victimisation claims dismissed after the tribunal found he missed the time limits and it was not just and equitable to extend time.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Postman (5 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A postman with five years' service was unfairly dismissed after Royal Mail's covert monitoring operation was found to have significant deficiencies, including misidentification and procedural unfairness. The tribunal upheld his unfair dismissal claim but rejected an automatic unfair dismissal claim on health and safety grounds.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Former employee v Barts Health NHS Trust
A former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claim was struck out after he failed to comply with orders, respond to correspondence, or attend the hearing. The tribunal found his delay was intentional and disrespectful.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Total Support Services Limited
A former employee's claims for unfair dismissal and disability discrimination were struck out for failing to pursue them, but the tribunal allowed her claims for notice pay and holiday pay to proceed as they were undisputed.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Former apprentice electrician v Power Up Manchester Limited
A former apprentice electrician had his unfair dismissal and discrimination claims dismissed after he failed to attend a preliminary hearing and ignored tribunal orders. The employer was awarded £760 in preparation costs.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Customer advisor (5 years' service) v B&Q Ltd
A customer advisor with depression was dismissed for gross misconduct after a series of incidents with colleagues. The tribunal ruled the dismissal was fair and not discriminatory.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Electrician's mate (4 days' service) v Clearfield Recruitment Ltd
A tribunal dismissed claims of race and disability discrimination brought by an electrician's mate who worked for only four days, after the claimant withdrew most allegations.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former employee v Atalian Servest Security Ltd
A former employee's claims for race discrimination and unlawful deduction of wages were dismissed because they were brought too late. The tribunal also refused a reconsideration application.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Former crew member (6 years' service) v McDonalds
A former McDonald's crew member lost his unfair dismissal claim because he contacted Acas more than three months after the deadline, despite visiting the tribunal earlier. The claim was struck out as out of time.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Postal worker (34 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Limited
A Watford tribunal found Royal Mail unfairly dismissed a postal worker with 34 years' service after a manager used PDA tracking data to investigate him, contrary to a union agreement. The tribunal reduced any compensation by 60% for the employee's contributory conduct.
Won · May 2023Won—May 2023Former employee v T4 Trust
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after he presented his claim 15 days after the three-month time limit expired. The tribunal rejected his argument that he relied on advice from his union representative.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Distribution centre HGV driver (2 years' service) v Tesco Stores Limited
An HGV driver who was dismissed for aggressive behaviour after managers contacted him on his personal smartphone without permission has won his unfair dismissal claim, but lost his whistleblowing case. The tribunal found the dismissal was procedurally unfair.
Partial · May 2023Partial—May 2023Executive General Manager (2 years' service) v Eastman Staples Ltd
An executive general manager with two years' service was unfairly dismissed for alleged gross misconduct. The company entered liquidation and did not defend the claim, resulting in a £13,716 award.
Won · £13,716 · May 2023Won£13,716May 2023Doctor (NHS trainee) v Health Education England
An NHS trainee doctor who flew to India for his mother's surgery after a tribunal refused to postpone a 35-day hearing had his unfair dismissal claim struck out for unreasonable conduct.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Senior Paramedic (18 years' service) v East of England Ambulance Service NHS Trust
An NHS Trust unfairly dismissed a Senior Paramedic with 18 years' service after he reacted to being struck by a patient. The tribunal found the investigation failed to properly assess witness credibility and withheld key evidence, awarding £49,314.66.
Won · £49,315 · May 2023Won£49,315May 2023Fleet and Security Manager (4 years' service) v Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office
A Fleet and Security Manager who worked for the British High Commission in Fiji lost his unfair dismissal claim after the tribunal ruled it had no territorial jurisdiction to hear the case.
Dismissed · May 2023Dismissed—May 2023Teacher of maths and computing (5 years' service) v Devonport High School for Girls
A teacher with five years' service was unfairly dismissed after the school failed to properly investigate allegations made by pupils. The tribunal awarded £44,868.
Won · £44,868 · May 2023Won£44,868May 2023Warehouse operative (12 years' service) v Stanley Black & Decker Limited
A warehouse operative with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed for grabbing colleagues' private areas. The tribunal found the employer had reasonable grounds for its belief despite the operative's conspiracy claims.
Lost · May 2023Lost—May 2023Maintenance technician (3 years' service) v APM Nationwide Ltd
A maintenance technician was unfairly dismissed after being accused of defaming his employer. The tribunal found the investigation was minimal, the outcome predetermined, and the appeal conducted by the managing director's brother-in-law. He was awarded £10,896.94.
Won · £10,897 · May 2023Won£10,897May 2023Patient Administrator (6 years' service) v Chelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
A tribunal struck out an unfair dismissal claim from a Patient Administrator who was dismissed for allegedly stealing a colleague's bag, after finding CCTV footage left no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee (4 years' service) v Department for Work and Pensions
A Department for Work and Pensions employee who was sacked for secretly recording colleagues has won his unfair dismissal claim after the tribunal found serious flaws in the disciplinary process. He was awarded £25,788 after reductions for his own contribution.
Partial · £25,788 · Apr 2023Partial£25,788Apr 2023Tanker driver (5 years' service) v Hoyer Gas & Petroleum Logistics Limited
A tanker driver was unfairly dismissed after failing to report dropping a hose on her foot, but the tribunal found she would have been dismissed anyway, awarding only £807.
Partial · £807 · Apr 2023Partial£807Apr 2023Warehouse operative (5 months' service) v Lidl Great Britain Limited
A warehouse operative with five months' service who stopped attending work after a child maintenance deduction from his wages was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected all claims of unauthorised deductions and wrongful dismissal.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee v Slough Borough Council
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Slough Borough Council was dismissed after she and her representative failed to attend the final hearing, despite multiple attempts by the tribunal to contact them.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee v Mrs Patricia Bowey
A tribunal granted an extension for a late response from an employer with no legal experience who was ill, accepting the ET3 one working day late due to a communication error by her daughter.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Teacher (Course Leader for Ethics and Philosophy, 8 years' service) v Better Futures Multi-Academy Trust
A tribunal found that a teacher's dismissal for gross misconduct after visiting a student's home was fair, but the school breached his contract by dismissing without notice.
Partial · Apr 2023Partial—Apr 2023Taxi insurance renewals specialist (12 years' service) v Grayson Insurance (Consultants) Ltd
A taxi insurance renewals specialist with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed after his employer found he had fraudulently claimed overtime. The tribunal upheld the dismissal but awarded £1,032 for unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £1,032 · Apr 2023Partial£1,032Apr 2023Healthcare assistant (6 years' service) v Guy's and St Thomas's NHS Foundation Trust
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a healthcare assistant with six years' service who slapped a colleague on the cheek during handover, finding the NHS trust acted reasonably.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee (school staff) v Al Iman Community Educational Services Ltd.
A school staff member who claimed she was unfairly dismissed after an investigation meeting was found by the tribunal to have resigned voluntarily. Her claim was dismissed and she was ordered to pay £300 in costs.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Consultant haematologist (33 years' service) v Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust
A consultant haematologist with 33 years' service lost his unfair dismissal claim after the tribunal ruled he filed it 89 days late. The claim was struck out because it was reasonably practicable for him to have submitted it on time.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Community Hub Director (11 years' service) v Santander UK PLC
A Community Hub Director with 11 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after allegedly faking a stolen card. The tribunal struck out his unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims as having no reasonable prospects of success.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Head Housekeeper (3 years' service) v Griffin Catering Services Ltd
A head housekeeper was unfairly dismissed after failing to return from Bulgaria on 48 hours' notice. The tribunal found the appeal was not conducted with an open mind, but reduced compensation by 80% for her contribution.
Partial · £3,202 · Apr 2023Partial£3,202Apr 2023Former employee (driver) v Travis Perkins Trading Co Ltd
A former driver's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims were struck out after the tribunal found they had no reasonable prospects of success and were submitted late.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee v Sullivan Bus and Coach Limited
A former employee's claims of sex, sexual orientation and victimisation discrimination against Sullivan Bus and Coach Limited were dismissed by the Watford Employment Tribunal. The unfair dismissal complaint had already been struck out.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Factory Manager (13 years' service) v SIPS (UK) Ltd
A factory manager with 13 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after a wall saw fell during unloading, causing damage and minor injuries. The tribunal upheld the decision, citing a reasonable investigation and a breakdown in trust.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Senior Nursery Practitioner (3 years' service) v Swans Day Nurseries Ltd
A senior nursery practitioner was unfairly dismissed after her employer fabricated an allegation that she was under the influence of alcohol at work. The Watford tribunal awarded £5,325.75, including a 25% Acas uplift for ignoring the code of practice.
Won · £5,326 · Apr 2023Won£5,326Apr 2023Reablement Support Worker (19 months' service) v North East London NHS Foundation Trust
The tribunal dismissed all claims by a former NHS support worker who alleged he was unfairly dismissed for raising concerns about PPE, finding that his disclosures were not protected and his dismissal was due to gross misconduct involving homophobic harassment.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Quality Improvement Manager (probationary employee) v BPP University Ltd
A Quality Improvement Manager dismissed while on probation after her miscarriage lost her unfair dismissal and discrimination claims. The tribunal found the decision was based on genuine performance concerns and a breakdown in working relationships, not pregnancy.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former director/manager of seasonal decorations business (16 years' service) v Chic Flower Design Limited (in liquidation)
A director with 16 years' service was dismissed days after being told he was 'too expensive' and 'no longer needed'. The tribunal found the real reason was not misconduct but cost-cutting, and awarded £61,298.
Won · £61,298 · Apr 2023Won£61,298Apr 2023Night reception team member v Whitbread Plc
A Premier Inn night receptionist was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after a guest complained someone entered their room. CCTV and key access logs showed the claimant on the floor and using his key twice that night.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Drainage surveying manager (2 years' service) v Jet Maintenance Limited
A drainage surveying manager was unfairly dismissed after a verbal altercation with a director. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and appeal were predetermined, awarding £3,345 in compensation.
Won · £3,345 · Apr 2023Won£3,345Apr 2023Former employee v First Transpennine Express Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after he presented it one week late and failed to explain the delay or attend the hearing.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Driver (6 years' service) v Eastbrook Logistics Ltd
A driver with six years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after urinating on a loading dock in full view of CCTV. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision, finding the dismissal was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Head priest (4 years' service) v Singh Sabha London East
A head priest who was paid £390 per month without tax or NI deductions saw his unfair dismissal claim thrown out after the tribunal found the employment contract was illegally performed.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Former employee v South Wales Campers Limited
An employment tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal claim after the former employee failed to attend the final hearing and did not respond to any tribunal communications. The respondent believed the claim had been settled directly.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Priest (Purohit) at a Hindu Mandir v Trustees of Vishwa Hindu Parishad - a registered charity
A Hindu priest who was summarily dismissed after a dispute over Covid-19 safety measures has won his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal awarded £15,924, reduced by 40% for his own conduct.
Won · £15,924 · Apr 2023Won£15,924Apr 2023Kitchen porter (3 years' service) v Mildreds Ltd
A kitchen porter who was dismissed after managers smelled marijuana from his bike bag had his unfair dismissal claim rejected, but won £3,618 after a tribunal found a manager's assumption he was intoxicated was based on a racial stereotype.
Partial · £3,618 · Apr 2023Partial£3,618Apr 2023Security Officer (3 years 9 months' service) v Corps Security (UK) Limited
A security officer who feinted a punch at a cadet after being sworn at was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected his claim that a colleague was treated more leniently for a similar incident.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Former employee v London Underground Limited
A former employee who brought claims of unfair dismissal and discrimination against London Underground Limited has had all his claims struck out after failing to attend two preliminary hearings and not responding to tribunal orders.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023House Manager (4 years' service) v Jewish Blind and Physically Disabled Society
A house manager with four years' service was unfairly dismissed after giving a vulnerable tenant two paracetamol tablets and a hot water bottle. The tribunal awarded £17,266.74, finding the employer had no reasonable grounds to believe the actions were dangerous.
Won · £17,267 · Apr 2023Won£17,267Apr 2023Barmaid (3 years' service) v Real Bars Ltd
A barmaid with three years' service was unfairly dismissed when her employer sacked her by text message without notice. The tribunal awarded her £8,619.38 in compensation for unpaid wages, holiday pay, notice pay, and unfair dismissal.
Won · £8,619 · Apr 2023Won£8,619Apr 2023Trade Counter Sales Manager (2 years 11 months' service) v Charles Watts Engineering Limited
A Trade Counter Sales Manager who raised COVID-19 safety concerns was unfairly dismissed after his employer gathered customer complaints against him. The tribunal found the investigation and disciplinary process were flawed.
Partial · Apr 2023Partial—Apr 2023Optical assistant (10 years' service) v Fairford Opticians Limited
An optical assistant with 10 years' service was dismissed after making a harassing phone call from her employer's line. Her unfair dismissal claim was struck out for having no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Marketing associate (1 year 4 months' service) v Arapina Bakery Ltd
A marketing associate who shouted at his boss and threatened to force entry into the bakery was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected his claim for notice pay.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Domestic Assistant (4 years' service) v Sussex Health Care Limited
A domestic assistant with 4 years' service was fairly dismissed after entering a care home without following infection control measures. The tribunal found the employer's belief in gross misconduct was reasonable and the process was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Head Chef/Kitchen Manager (3 months' service) v United Kitchen Concepts Ltd
A head chef who stopped attending work after a dispute over hours and overtime was dismissed for unauthorised absence. The tribunal struck out his unfair dismissal claim due to insufficient service and rejected his remaining pay claims.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Employee, shareholder and director v Arcstream Ltd (In Liquidation)
A director and shareholder was summarily dismissed without any disciplinary process or notice. The tribunal awarded £16,916.86 for unfair dismissal and breach of contract.
Won · £16,917 · Apr 2023Won£16,917Apr 2023Former employee (certification suspended after dismissal) v Isle of Wight NHS Trust
The tribunal dismissed unfair and wrongful dismissal claims after the claimant failed to attend the final hearing, and ordered her to pay £1,400 in costs for repeated delays and non-compliance.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Warehouse/Transport Supervisor (12 years' service) v City Plumbing Supplies Holdings Limited
A warehouse supervisor with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed after falsifying stock counts while already on a final written warning for driving an overloaded vehicle. The tribunal found the employer followed a reasonable process.
Lost · Apr 2023Lost—Apr 2023Prison officer (14 years' service) v Secretary of State for Justice
A prison officer with 14 years' service had his unfair dismissal claim rejected as out of time after a union email was lost in a junk folder, leaving him 10 days late in filing.
Dismissed · Apr 2023Dismissed—Apr 2023Headteacher (5 years 6 months' service) v Governing Body of Northwood Community Primary School and Knowsley Metropolitan Borough Council
A headteacher with over five years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed investigation into his decision to engage a former teacher subject to a Prohibition Order. The tribunal found the employer failed to consider alternatives to dismissal.
Won · Mar 2023Won—Mar 2023Postman (16 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A postman with 16 years' service who took undelivered mail home on Christmas Eve had his unfair dismissal claim struck out after the tribunal found his conduct during proceedings was scandalous, unreasonable, and vexatious.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee (6 years' service) v Tesco Store Limited
A Tesco employee with six years' service was unfairly dismissed after being accused of smoking cannabis on the premises. The tribunal awarded £4,395.25 in compensation.
Partial · £4,395 · Mar 2023Partial£4,395Mar 2023Care Assistant (2 years' service) v WT UK OPCO Ltd (formerly Gracewell Healthcare 3 Ltd)
A care assistant with two years' service was unfairly dismissed for alleged gross misconduct after a flawed investigation. The tribunal awarded £27,316, including a 25% ACAS uplift for the employer's failure to follow the ACAS Code.
Won · £27,316 · Mar 2023Won£27,316Mar 2023Practice manager (6 years' service) v Firvale Clinic Limited
A practice manager who was dismissed via a WhatsApp message after a Christmas party incident has been awarded £12,431 after an employment tribunal found the dismissal procedurally unfair and outside the range of reasonable responses.
Won · £12,431 · Mar 2023Won£12,431Mar 2023Support worker (7 years' service) v Creative Support Ltd
A support worker with 7 years' service was fairly dismissed after refusing to wear a face mask or a visor in the office. The tribunal found the employer acted within the band of reasonable responses.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Registered Manager (7 years' service) v Trentside Manor Care Limited
A registered manager with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed and discriminated against after her employer used a minor incident as a pretext to dismiss her for requesting flexible working due to disability.
Won · £100,840 · Mar 2023Won£100,840Mar 2023General assistant (12 years' service) v Sainsbury’s Supermarkets Limited
A Sainsbury's general assistant with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed after posting accusations of racist mindsets on Yammer and breaching suspension conditions. The tribunal rejected claims of automatic unfair dismissal and victimisation.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Beauty therapist (3 years' service) v Monas Beauty Lounge
A beauty therapist with three years' service was unfairly dismissed after her employer refused a last-minute leave request and told her not to come back. The tribunal awarded £22,073.20, including a 20% uplift for failing to follow the ACAS Code.
Won · £22,073 · Mar 2023Won£22,073Mar 2023Head chef and manager (4 years' service) v Affinity18 Limited
A head chef and manager who was effectively dismissed after being asked to drop off keys, and who never received a written contract, has been awarded £7,861.30 for unfair dismissal, breach of contract, and unauthorised deductions from wages.
Partial · £7,861 · Mar 2023Partial£7,861Mar 2023Teaching and Learning Assistant (18 years' service) v Southend East Community Academy Trust
A teaching assistant dismissed for a Facebook post about her school was too late to bring an unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal ruled it was reasonably practicable for her to have filed in time, despite her stress and anxiety.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Teaching Assistant v Three Milestone Education Ltd
A teaching assistant was unfairly dismissed over a cocaine incident at a special needs school, but received no compensation because she would have been sacked anyway. A second assistant won a disability discrimination claim after her mother was refused as a companion at her disciplinary hearing.
Partial · Mar 2023Partial—Mar 2023Blind installer (7 years' service) v Brian English T/A Insignia Shade & Shutter Company
A blind installer who accepted an offer to leave with 7 weeks' pay was found to have been dismissed, not to have resigned. The tribunal rejected the employer's claim for damages over alleged poor work.
Partial · Mar 2023Partial—Mar 2023Nursery worker (2 years' service) v Bright Eyes Day Care Nursery Ltd.
A nursery worker with two years' service was unfairly dismissed for refusing to work her contractual hours, but her whistleblowing claims failed. She was awarded £959 in compensation.
Partial · £959 · Mar 2023Partial£959Mar 2023Postman (27 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Limited
A postman who collected mail 11 minutes early and scanned the barcode away from the box was unfairly dismissed. The tribunal found Royal Mail ignored his mental health and failed to follow proper procedures.
Won · Mar 2023Won—Mar 2023Former employee (construction labourer) v St Edward Homes Limited
An employment tribunal struck out a series of claims brought by a former construction labourer against multiple respondents, finding them to be res judicata, an abuse of process, and totally without merit. The claimant was ordered to pay £20,000 in costs and £1,786 in preparation time.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023First Line Leader (5 years' service) v Unilever UK Limited
A First Line Leader with 5 years' service was unfairly dismissed by Unilever after unclear instructions on social distancing measures and a 6-week investigation delay. The tribunal reduced compensation by 30% for his own contribution.
Partial · Mar 2023Partial—Mar 2023Neighbourhood Services Assistant (4 years' service) v Leicester City Council
A Neighbourhood Services Assistant was fairly dismissed after copying council-owned CCTV footage without permission and dishonestly denying it when questioned. The tribunal upheld the dismissal.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Nakanojo UK Ltd
A former employee's claims for unpaid wages and race discrimination were struck out after she presented them eight months late, believing the time limit was two years as in Italy.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Bus driver (4 years' service) v Abellio London Limited
A bus driver with 4 years' service was fairly dismissed after CCTV showed him speeding and running a red light, leading to a customer complaint. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023IT Project Manager (fixed-term contract) v Warwickshire County Council
An IT project manager on a fixed-term contract brought multiple claims of race discrimination, victimisation and whistleblowing detriment against Warwickshire County Council. The tribunal dismissed every claim, finding he had invented allegations and created false documents.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee (personal assistant/chauffeur assistant) v HCL Chauffeurs UK Ltd
A former personal assistant was dismissed for gross misconduct over fuel card use, but the tribunal found the process unfair. However, due to a break in service she lacked two years' continuous employment, so her unfair dismissal claim failed.
Partial · £1,225 · Mar 2023Partial£1,225Mar 2023Chef (7 years' service) v Bright Horizons Family Solutions Limited
A chef with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed investigation that showed gender bias. The tribunal found the employer treated him less favourably than a female colleague in similar circumstances. He was awarded £33,666.99.
Won · £33,667 · Mar 2023Won£33,667Mar 2023Customer Service Adviser (11 years' service) v Student Loans Company Limited
A Customer Service Adviser with 11 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a single rude call. The tribunal found procedural failings but reduced compensation by 40% for her conduct.
Partial · £22,122 · Mar 2023Partial£22,122Mar 2023Accounts employee (6 years' service) v Defries Associates Ltd
An accounts employee who emailed 298 tenant contact details to an unsecured address was unfairly dismissed because no disciplinary procedure was followed, but a 100% contributory fault finding reduced his compensation to just £1,361.54.
Partial · £1,362 · Mar 2023Partial£1,362Mar 2023Part-time waitress (3 years' service) v Ocho Steak House Limited
A part-time waitress with 3 years' service was unfairly dismissed when her employer fired her by text message after she said she could not return to work immediately due to depression and anxiety. The tribunal awarded £1,724.84 in compensation.
Partial · £1,725 · Mar 2023Partial£1,725Mar 2023Regional Desk Manager – Programmes Manager - Middle East (3 years' service) v Ummah Welfare Trust (trading as Amanat Charity Trust)
A regional desk manager who refused to travel to Iraq without sufficient Covid-19 assurances was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Deputy Manager (5 years' service) v Paramount Care (Easington) Limited
A deputy manager with five years' service was unfairly dismissed after a CQC report highlighted failures at her care home. The tribunal found the investigation unreasonable but reduced her award by 20% for her own poor record-keeping.
Partial · £6,914 · Mar 2023Partial£6,914Mar 2023Former employee v LJE Management Limited
A former employee won £13,617 after a tribunal found she was racially discriminated against, harassed, and unfairly dismissed by LJE Management Limited, which did not attend the hearing.
Won · £13,617 · Mar 2023Won£13,617Mar 2023Former employee v Richard Frost
A former employee who withdrew an earlier claim and then brought the same complaints again has had her case struck out. The tribunal ruled it had no jurisdiction to hear the identical allegations.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Field engineer v Openreach Limited
A field engineer who was tricked by a fraudulent adviser into believing his claim had been submitted in time has been granted an extension by the tribunal, allowing his unfair dismissal case to go ahead.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee v Amazon UK Services Limited
A former Amazon employee who wrongly assumed the three-month time limit for an unfair dismissal claim ran from his appeal outcome has had his claim thrown out by a tribunal.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee v Sainsburys Supermarkets Ltd
An employment tribunal struck out a former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims after they failed to comply with a deposit order and an order for further particulars. The decision was upheld on reconsideration.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Customer Assistant (10 years' service) v Tesco Stores Ltd
A Tesco customer assistant with 10 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after making racist comments, the tribunal ruled, rejecting claims of race discrimination and victimisation.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Whittington Health NHS Trust
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Whittington Health NHS Trust was dismissed as out of time after he contacted ACAS two days late and presented his claim nine days after the deadline.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Warehouse Partner (4 weeks' service) v John Lewis plc
A warehouse partner who was sacked after just four weeks for using a false name and lying about previous employment had his unfair dismissal and whistleblowing claims struck out by the Reading Employment Tribunal.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Customer Services Supervisor (safety critical role) v London Underground Ltd
A Customer Services Supervisor for London Underground was fairly dismissed after being discharged from residential drug rehabilitation for threatening behaviour. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Shunter (6 years' service) v Cordant Cleaning Limited
A shunter with six years' service was fairly dismissed for using his mobile phone in a safety-critical area, a tribunal has ruled. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Breakers Yard Manager (17 years' service) v Inglemere Metals (Blackpool) Limited
A Breakers Yard Manager who had worked for the company for 17 years without any prior warnings was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after he ignored express instructions about a customer, sold tyres without authorisation and granted extended credit. The tribunal rejected all three claims.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Teen Support Services Ltd
A former employee of Teen Support Services Ltd has won a claim for unauthorised deductions from wages, receiving £1,704.12 for unpaid sleep-in payments and annual leave. Her unfair dismissal claim was rejected.
Partial · £1,704 · Mar 2023Partial£1,704Mar 2023Commis chef (zero hours contract) v Eclipse Hotels (Bristol) Ltd
A commis chef on a zero-hours contract was fairly dismissed for failing to attend assigned shifts, but the tribunal awarded him £1,687.38 for unpaid notice pay because the employer did not follow the correct notice procedure.
Partial · £1,687 · Mar 2023Partial£1,687Mar 2023Funeral director (30 years' service) v Dignity Funerals Ltd
A funeral director with 30 years' service was unfairly dismissed after removing a deceased person's jewellery. The tribunal found procedural unfairness and awarded £43,350.60 after a 40% reduction for contributory fault.
Won · £43,351 · Mar 2023Won£43,351Mar 2023Minibus driver (4 years' service) v Blackburn and Darwen Community Transport Limited
A minibus driver who was dismissed shortly after complaining about unpaid holiday pay has been found unfairly dismissed. The tribunal awarded £12,489.86 in compensation.
Won · £12,490 · Mar 2023Won£12,490Mar 2023Civil enforcement officer (CEO) v NSL Ltd
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a civil enforcement officer who assaulted a member of the public by knocking a phone from their hand. All race discrimination and harassment claims were also rejected.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Surveyor (probationary period) v Mersey Eco Grants Ltd
A surveyor who was dismissed by phone just before his probation ended had his unfair dismissal and discrimination claims dismissed because he presented his claim six days late and failed to comply with tribunal orders.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Former employee v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A former Royal Mail employee won £308.66 in unpaid sick pay, but his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims were dismissed by the tribunal.
Partial · £309 · Mar 2023Partial£309Mar 2023Chef (part-time) v Rimad Ltd
A part-time chef who was summarily dismissed for threatening a manager with a knife withdrew his unfair dismissal claim at the final hearing. The tribunal also refused his late application to add a harassment claim.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Machine Tool Services Engineer (9 years' service) v Design & Technical Services (UK) Ltd
A machine tool services engineer was unfairly dismissed after using a company fuel card during furlough, but the tribunal awarded no compensation because he would have been dismissed anyway.
Partial · £0 · Mar 2023Partial£0Mar 2023Mobile patrol officer (5 years' service) v G4S Secure Solutions (UK) Ltd
A mobile patrol officer who gave a dishonest account of a collision while using his mobile phone and not wearing a seatbelt has lost his unfair dismissal claim against G4S Secure Solutions (UK) Ltd.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Shaw Trust Ltd
A former employee of Shaw Trust had his unfair dismissal and redundancy claims struck out because he had less than two years' service. His race and sex discrimination claims were partially struck out and partially subject to a £5 deposit order.
Dismissed · Mar 2023Dismissed—Mar 2023Chief Technology Officer / Chairman and Chief Innovation Officer (9 years' service) v MYPINPAD Ltd
A tribunal found that a founder and chief technology officer was summarily dismissed during a Teams call, despite the company later claiming otherwise. The preliminary ruling on the effective date of termination has implications for similar disputes.
Won · Mar 2023Won—Mar 2023Sports bar employee (17 years' service) v Rileys Sports Bar (In Administration)
A sports bar employee with 17 years' service was unfairly dismissed after being accused of drinking on duty. The tribunal found the real reason was the bar's poor business performance.
Won · £7,875 · Mar 2023Won£7,875Mar 2023Sales assistant (2 years' service) v Mr Muhammad Azeeem Khan t/a Yorkshire Retail Services
A sales assistant caught on CCTV playing scratch cards and lottery tickets during shifts without paying was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal upheld the dismissal but ordered the employer to pay £608.55 for unauthorised wage deductions and unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £609 · Mar 2023Partial£609Mar 2023Former employee v Verifone UK Ltd
A former employee of Verifone UK Ltd has been awarded £88,519 after an employment tribunal upheld her claims of unfair dismissal and victimisation, while dismissing her race discrimination complaints.
Partial · £88,519 · Mar 2023Partial£88,519Mar 2023Recycling contractor (26 years' service) v Magpie Recycling Co-operative Limited
A recycling contractor with 26 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after repeatedly ignoring health and safety restrictions following a heart condition. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Cashier (3 years' service) v AY & Y Patel Ltd
A cashier claimed she was unfairly dismissed after a manager told her she was 'sacked' during a heated argument. The tribunal found she was not dismissed because the manager had no authority to dismiss and the employer never accepted the termination.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Registered Nurse (3 years 8 months' service) v East Suffolk and North Essex NHS Foundation Trust
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a Band 5 registered nurse who refused to return to work after being removed from clinical duties over patient safety concerns. All claims, including unfair dismissal and disability discrimination, were dismissed.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Oak Furnitureland Group Limited
A former employee who was dismissed for gross misconduct after an investigation into a theft of £14,500 from a store safe has lost his claims for unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal, and unpaid commission.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Former employee v Heatrod Elements Ltd
A former employee won his unfair dismissal claim but received no compensation after the tribunal found his own conduct wholly caused the dismissal. He was awarded £439.25 for unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £439 · Mar 2023Partial£439Mar 2023Administrator (9 years' service) v Parkcare Homes (No2) Limited
An experienced administrator was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after repeated errors in financial processing and payroll, despite having 9 years' service. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Mar 2023Lost—Mar 2023Customer service advisor (3 years' service) v Alliance Healthcare Management Services Ltd
A customer service advisor with Ménière's disease was unfairly dismissed after refusing to work from home when her face shield was banned. The tribunal reduced her compensation by 75% for her own conduct.
Partial · Feb 2023Partial—Feb 2023Forklift truck driver (18 years' service) v R&R Ice Cream Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a forklift truck driver with 18 years' service who was found to have been under the influence of alcohol at work, ruling that the employer's belief was reasonable based on witness reports and CCTV evidence.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Headteacher (10 years' service) v The Governing Body of St Charles RC Primary School
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a headteacher with 10 years' service who was found to have smelled of alcohol and left children unsupervised. The school's investigation, though lengthy, was deemed reasonable.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Production Manager (34 years' service) and Factory Manager (42 years' service) v Snowbird Foods Limited
Two production managers with 34 and 42 years' service were fairly dismissed after refusing to manage a trial of Cumberland sausage rings. The tribunal rejected their claims of health and safety detriment and unfair dismissal.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Bus driver (5 years' service) v Arriva London (North) Ltd
A bus driver who was caught on CCTV reading a disciplinary letter while driving and running a red light was fairly dismissed. The tribunal rejected claims for unfair dismissal and breach of contract.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Security Officer (11 years' service) v G4S Secure Solutions (UK) Limited
A security officer with 11 years' service was fairly dismissed after video evidence showed her apparently sleeping on duty. The tribunal upheld G4S's decision, finding the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Emergency Medical Technician, Grade 1 (12 years' service) v Yorkshire Ambulance Service NHS Trust
An emergency medical technician with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed after accessing a patient's records and forming a relationship with her. The tribunal found the trust's decision was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v ACE Scaffolding (M/CR) Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was thrown out after he failed to attend three preliminary hearings, despite repeated warnings that his case could be struck out.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Former employee v B Barton and D Ford T/a Exquisite Catering with Class
A former catering worker was awarded £1,671.15 after her employer failed to pay the National Minimum Wage and provide a written contract. Her claims for unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal, and harassment related to sex were dismissed.
Partial · £1,671 · Feb 2023Partial£1,671Feb 2023Former employee v Dimensions UK Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Dimensions UK Ltd was struck out after he failed to comply with tribunal orders and did not attend the hearing. The tribunal found his non-compliance was intentional and disrespectful.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Ward manager (40 years' experience as a nurse) v Priory Healthcare Limited
A 40-year nursing veteran was unfairly dismissed by Priory Healthcare after the employer mistakenly believed a urine test showed she was under the influence of cannabis at work. The tribunal found the dismissal was outside the range of reasonable responses.
Won · Feb 2023Won—Feb 2023Piano and singing teacher (24 years' service) v The Mount School Limited
A piano and singing teacher with 24 years' service was unfairly dismissed after she refused to attend a mandatory staff meeting at short notice because of a pre-arranged family gathering to discuss her mother's cancer care. The Leeds tribunal awarded £16,802.31.
Won · £16,802 · Feb 2023Won£16,802Feb 2023HGV driver (3 years' service) v R.F. Bellis Haulage Limited
HGV driver fairly dismissed after refusing to return to work; race discrimination claims rejected
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Nurse (15 years' service) v Mission Care Management Limited
A nurse with 15 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after taking annual leave that was only partially approved. The tribunal upheld her wrongful dismissal claim, awarding £5,275.36.
Partial · £5,275 · Feb 2023Partial£5,275Feb 2023Barman and cocktail mixologist (9 months' service) v H &AB-Side Limited
A barman who claimed he was dismissed for raising health and safety concerns during the pandemic lost his unfair dismissal case, but won over £3,200 for unpaid wages, notice pay and holiday pay.
Partial · £3,276 · Feb 2023Partial£3,276Feb 2023Bursar and Clerk to the Governors (7 years' service) v Alpha Schools (Holdings) Ltd and Wellesley House School Ltd
A bursar and clerk to the governors was summarily dismissed without notice or pay. The tribunal awarded £97,220.70 for unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal, and unpaid holiday pay, plus a penalty for failing to provide written particulars.
Won · £97,221 · Feb 2023Won£97,221Feb 2023Ground operations lead (5 years' service) v British Airways PLC
A ground operations lead's claims for unfair dismissal and race discrimination against British Airways were struck out after he repeatedly failed to comply with case management orders and did not attend the preliminary hearing.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Community Healthcare Assistant/Support Worker (20 years' service) v Cornwall Partnership NHS Trust
An NHS trust fairly dismissed a community healthcare assistant with 20 years' service for gross misconduct after she introduced a vulnerable patient to a convicted fraudster and shared confidential information. The employment tribunal upheld the dismissal.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Area Manager (11 years' service) v Crystal Services plc
An area manager who was moved to a new division and had his working pattern changed was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct and subjected to direct race discrimination. The tribunal found the dismissal both procedurally and substantively unfair.
Partial · Feb 2023Partial—Feb 2023Branch manager (care services) v Helping Hands Midshires Care Ltd
A branch manager who was dismissed just three weeks into her role failed to prove she was sacked because of her race or for raising safety concerns. The tribunal dismissed all claims after she did not attend the hearing.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Night Worker (4 months' service) v St Mungo Community Housing Association
A night worker with four months' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to carry out mandatory building patrols. The tribunal rejected his claims of automatic unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and victimisation.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Subcontractor manager (4 years' service) v Q
A subcontractor manager with four years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to pass on penalty costs to subcontractors. Her claims for unfair dismissal, disability discrimination and failure to make reasonable adjustments were all rejected.
Partial · Feb 2023Partial—Feb 2023Former employee v Skolak Healthcare Limited T/A Beechill Nursing Home
A former employee of Beechill Nursing Home was unfairly dismissed and had wages deducted for three shifts. The tribunal awarded £578.40 including an ACAS uplift.
Won · £578 · Feb 2023Won£578Feb 2023Warehouse operative (3 years' service) v Greggs Plc
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a warehouse operative with three years' service who washed her hands for less than five seconds, ruling that Greggs' decision was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Finance manager (13 years' service) v CI Accountancy Limited
A finance manager with 13 years' service was dismissed after taking leave to care for her husband with heart failure. The tribunal found disability discrimination and automatic unfair dismissal, awarding £114,421.
Partial · £114,421 · Feb 2023Partial£114,421Feb 2023Former employee v Chris Hayter Haulage Limited
A tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claim after the former employee admitted he knew the time limits but delayed because he hoped for a settlement. The claim was presented 32 days late.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Assistant Director, Border Force (9 years' service) v The Home Office
A 9-year Border Force Assistant Director was unfairly and wrongfully dismissed after refusing a redeployment instruction. The Leeds tribunal awarded £51,891.73, including a 10% ACAS uplift.
Won · £51,892 · Feb 2023Won£51,892Feb 2023Former employee v James Mclaughlin
A former employee's claims for unfair dismissal and unauthorised deduction from wages were struck out or dismissed after he failed to attend the final hearing and had less than two years' service.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Quality Inspector (6 years' service) v I Holland Limited
A quality inspector with six years' service was fairly dismissed after using a micrometer to measure dies, despite a final warning for non-compliance. The tribunal found the employer acted within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Maintenance craftsperson (Barnet Hospital) v Bouygues Energies and Services
A maintenance worker at Barnet Hospital was unfairly dismissed after refusing a COVID-19 test. The tribunal found the procedure was rushed and the testing policy was never properly communicated.
Won · Feb 2023Won—Feb 2023Former fuel depot operator (2 years' service) v The Oil and Pipelines Agency
A former fuel depot operator who repeatedly accessed his employer's IT system after being told not to has lost his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the dismissal for gross misconduct was fair.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Mechanical Engineer (37 years' service) v Ministry of Defence
A mechanical engineer with 37 years' service was unfairly dismissed for unauthorised absence after the Ministry of Defence failed to consider his mental health. He was awarded £19,710.
Won · £19,710 · Feb 2023Won£19,710Feb 2023Accounts manager (22 years' service) v Real Estates (Cornwall) Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of an accounts manager with 22 years' service who failed to open nearly 2,000 work emails and set up two-step verification blocking her boss's access. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Progression Manager (21 years' service) v Countryside Properties (UK) Limited
A Progression Manager with 21 years' service was unfairly dismissed after an investigation that relied on hearsay and leading questions. The employment tribunal found the process fell outside the band of reasonable responses.
Won · Feb 2023Won—Feb 2023Process Improvement Leader (3 years' service) v Unilever UK Limited
A Process Improvement Leader who refused to wear face masks and glasses during the pandemic and behaved aggressively towards managers was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal ruled.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Sales agent (7 months' service) v Hansbiomed Europé Ltd
A sales agent with seven months' service was fairly dismissed after refusing to accept a PR manager role that required some sales tasks. Her claims of unfair dismissal, discrimination, and whistleblowing were all rejected.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v Kapetil (High Peak) Ltd T/A Toni & Guy Macclesfield
A former employee's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims have been struck out after he repeatedly failed to comply with case management orders and did not attend the strike-out hearing.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Warehouse operative (2 years' service) v Bunzl UK Limited
A warehouse operative who knocked a colleague unconscious with a roll of pallet wrap during a fight was fairly dismissed. The tribunal upheld Bunzl UK Limited's decision, finding the investigation and process reasonable.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Former employee v Greenwich Leisure Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed after she did not attend the final hearing. The tribunal refused a last-minute postponement because the medical evidence did not show she was unfit to attend the hearing.
Dismissed · Feb 2023Dismissed—Feb 2023Shop assistant (part-time, 4 years' service) v Neil Adams and David Asplin T/a G David Bookseller
A part-time shop assistant who told a partner to 'fuck off' and left work early was not dismissed but resigned, the Cambridge Employment Tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Feb 2023Lost—Feb 2023Transport coordinator (2 years 5 months' service) v Speedy Asset Services Limited
A transport coordinator with two years' service was unfairly dismissed after being sacked for driving without a tachograph card. The tribunal found the employer failed to consider her mitigation and awarded £5,991.
Won · £5,991 · Feb 2023Won£5,991Feb 2023Maintenance manager (6 years' service) v Cosgrove Leisure Parks UK Ltd
A maintenance manager with 6 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed disciplinary process. The tribunal awarded £8,455, applying a 20% ACAS uplift, a 25% Polkey reduction, and a 20% contributory fault reduction.
Won · £8,455 · Jan 2023Won£8,455Jan 2023Chef (2 years' service) v Bills Restaurants Limited
A chef who was dismissed for gross misconduct after an allergen incident saw his unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal and unlawful deduction claims dismissed because they were presented to the tribunal one day after the statutory deadline.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee v RT Decorators and Builders Ltd
A former employee who brought an unfair dismissal claim without the required two years' service, and a notice pay claim nearly eleven months late, has had both claims dismissed by the London Central Employment Tribunal.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Loading Dock Operative and Pit Driver (5 years' service) v Amazon UK Services Ltd
An Amazon loading dock operative was fairly dismissed after driving a PIT truck within touching distance of pedestrians crossing a walkway, despite denying wrongdoing. The tribunal upheld the decision, citing the employer's genuine belief in misconduct and the claimant's lack of remorse.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v Manor Restaurants (UK) Limited
A former employee's claim for unpaid wages and discrimination was struck out after he presented it late and failed to attend the preliminary hearing. No damages were awarded.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee v Norton Industrial Fasteners Ltd
A former employee who was unfairly dismissed and subjected to a sexist comment by a director has been awarded £5,665.07 by the Cambridge Employment Tribunal.
Partial · £5,665 · Jan 2023Partial£5,665Jan 2023Administrative assistant and library assistant (7 months' service) v John Colet School
An employment tribunal struck out an administrative assistant's unfair dismissal claim after she behaved disruptively, made unfounded allegations, and repeatedly failed to provide further particulars despite multiple orders.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions
The tribunal struck out race and disability discrimination claims because they were presented late, and the claimant failed to attend the hearing or provide reasons for the delay.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Barber (3 years' service) v Mr Christian Donnelly t/a Acute Barbers
A barber with three years' service was unfairly dismissed via WhatsApp after calling in sick. The tribunal also found the employer made unauthorised deductions from wages and failed to provide a written contract, awarding £3,435.59.
Partial · £3,436 · Jan 2023Partial£3,436Jan 2023Support worker (4 years' service) v Salutem LD Bidco IV Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a support worker who refused to comply with a mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy, finding the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v Nottingham City Council
A default judgment against Nottingham City Council was revoked after the tribunal found it had lost the employer's response. The case will now proceed to a full hearing.
Remitted · Jan 2023Remitted—Jan 2023Group Facilities Manager (4 years' service) v AI-Mubarakia Limited
A Group Facilities Manager was dismissed in a sham redundancy after a director made racist comments. The tribunal upheld claims of unfair dismissal, direct race discrimination, and harassment.
Won · Jan 2023Won—Jan 2023Facilities service support assistant (41 years' service) v University Hospitals of North Midlands NHS Trust
A facilities service support assistant with 41 years' service was fairly dismissed after failing to return from the Gambia when flights were available, the tribunal ruled.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Fork Lift Truck Driver (13 years' service) v Unipart Group
A forklift driver with 13 years' service was fairly dismissed after dropping a pallet, failing to report it, and attempting to cover up the incident while still under a live warning.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee v Creations Hairdressers & Barbering Studio Ltd.
A former employee who did not attend hearings or respond to a strike-out warning had his unfair dismissal and discrimination claim struck out. The tribunal also ordered him to pay £3,488.40 in costs.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Supermarket Assistant (3 years' service) v John Lewis PLC
A Waitrose employee who refused to carry out reasonable tasks and used foul language about managers was fairly dismissed for misconduct. The tribunal awarded £536.94 for unpaid holiday and overtime.
Partial · £537 · Jan 2023Partial£537Jan 2023Former employee (6 years' service) v Ibco Limited
A tribunal upheld claims of unfair dismissal, indirect race discrimination, and victimisation for one former employee, and unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and failure to make reasonable adjustments for another. Damages of £31,752 were awarded to the first claimant.
Partial · £31,752 · Jan 2023Partial£31,752Jan 2023Stress Testing Controls Analysis Manager v National Westminster Bank PLC
A tribunal has allowed a former Stress Testing Controls Analysis Manager to amend her claim to include public interest disclosure detriment and an additional equal pay comparator, but refused most of her sex and race discrimination allegations.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Former employee (Spare Passenger Vehicle Driver) v Pertemps Recruitment Partnership Limited
A former passenger vehicle driver lost his unfair dismissal, race discrimination, and unlawful deduction claims after the tribunal found they were brought too late and he failed to attend the preliminary hearing.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee v Vision on Services GB Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after he failed to attend a preliminary hearing, despite being warned that non-attendance could lead to strike-out. No compensation was awarded.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Former employee v Kalchal Limited
A former employee was awarded over £1,100 after her employer failed to pay her final week's wages and holiday pay, and unfairly dismissed her. The employer did not file a response to the claim.
Won · £1,102 · Jan 2023Won£1,102Jan 2023Store manager (7 years' service) v Cruise Clothing Limited
A store manager with seven years' service was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to report and dispose of cannabis found in the store, but the tribunal found the allegations of offering drugs to staff were not proven.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Band 5 Staff Nurse (30 years' experience) v University Hospitals Bristol and Weston NHS Trust
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a nurse who failed to demonstrate basic nursing skills during a supernumerary training period, despite 30 years of experience. The trust's decision was found to be within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Postman (35 years' service) v Royal Mail Group
A postman with 35 years' unblemished service was fairly dismissed after walking through a prohibited area without a high-vis jacket, the tribunal ruled. He refused to engage in the disciplinary process.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Former employee (short service) v Phew Limited
A former employee who missed the three-month deadline to bring unfair dismissal and discrimination claims by four months had her case struck out, despite severe depression and an overdose.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Driver (4 years' service) v Acrelane Timber Limited
Two drivers were fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after they misled their employer about their whereabouts when recalled from furlough. The tribunal upheld the dismissals but found the employer breached contract by failing to give notice.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Prison officer v Secretary of State for Justice
Two prison officers at HMP Belmarsh were dismissed for gross misconduct after a physical altercation with a prisoner. The tribunal upheld the dismissals, finding the employer's investigation and disciplinary process were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Hygiene Operative (train cleaning contract) v Atalian Servest Limited
A hygiene operative who waited over five months to bring an unfair dismissal claim had his case thrown out as the tribunal found it was reasonably practicable to have filed on time.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Manager (32 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A manager with 32 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after selling Royal Mail PPE worth £20 on a local website. The tribunal upheld the dismissal, finding the employer's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Practice Manager (former employee and director) v Khan Solicitors Limited
A tribunal revoked a 2014 judgment finding a practice manager guilty of financial impropriety, after new documents emerged and the parties reached a settlement. The claim was then dismissed on withdrawal.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Business Development Director (5 years' service) v Travelliance Inc
A Business Development Director who was summarily dismissed on a Zoom call and told he was a contractor has won nearly £293,000 after a tribunal ruled he was an employee and unfairly dismissed.
Partial · £292,790 · Jan 2023Partial£292,790Jan 2023Bus driver (2 years 5 months' service) v M Limited
A bus driver who performed oral sex on a woman while driving and used his mobile phone was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal also ordered him to pay £7,500 costs for pursuing hopeless discrimination claims.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Delivery driver (over 20 years' service) v M G Seven Ltd (t/a Gainsborough Flower)
A delivery driver with over 20 years' service was unfairly dismissed when his employer sent a P45 via WhatsApp without any disciplinary process. The tribunal awarded £5,786.78 after deductions for contributory conduct and a Polkey reduction.
Partial · £5,787 · Jan 2023Partial£5,787Jan 2023Retail assistant (15 years' service) v Sainsbury’s Supermarkets Ltd
A 15-year retail assistant had her entire claim struck out after failing to respond to a strike-out warning and not complying with case management orders. The tribunal had already dismissed her race discrimination claims and refused to add a whistleblowing complaint.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Administrator/Receptionist (2.5 years' service) v Opus Care Limited
An administrator with 2.5 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after an audit revealed failures in pre-employment checks and confidential documents were found at her desk. The tribunal upheld the dismissal as fair.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Delivery driver (7 years' service) v The Harlestone Group Limited
A delivery driver on a zero-hours contract was unfairly dismissed when his employer summarily ended his work without following any disciplinary process. The tribunal awarded £6,675.
Won · £6,675 · Jan 2023Won£6,675Jan 2023Waitress (5 years' service) v Burger & Lobster Restaurant Group Ltd
A waitress with five years' service who was dismissed after taking unauthorised time off to care for her father following a stroke has lost her unfair dismissal and associative disability discrimination claims. The tribunal found the employer acted within the band of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Optical assistant (10 years' service) v Fairford Opticians Ltd
An optical assistant who was convicted of harassment for a phone call made from her employer's phone had her unfair dismissal claim struck out as having no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Cash and valuables in transit driver (18 years' service) v G4S Cash Solutions (UK) Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a cash-in-transit driver with 18 years' service who was sacked for breaching the 'golden rule' twice while under a final written warning, despite a 130-day delay in the disciplinary process.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Sales agent (11 years' service) v Sky Retail Stores Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a sales agent with 11 years' service who wrote a customer's name and email address on an unauthorised document, finding that Sky Retail Stores Limited acted within the band of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Apprentice carpenter (2 years' service) v Perrin & Son Construction Limited
An apprentice carpenter was unfairly dismissed after taking a week's holiday despite his employer's refusal. The tribunal found the dismissal procedurally unfair and awarded £918.13, including unlawful deduction claims.
Partial · £918 · Jan 2023Partial£918Jan 2023Registered Care Home Manager (4 years' service) v Hastings & Rother Voluntary Association for the Blind
A registered care home manager with four years' service has won her unfair dismissal claim after a tribunal found her employer failed to establish a fair reason for dismissal. The tribunal awarded £24,697.76, including a 15% uplift for breaching the ACAS Code.
Won · £24,698 · Jan 2023Won£24,698Jan 2023Care home worker v Burlington Care (Yorkshire) Limited
An employment tribunal struck out unfair dismissal and discrimination claims brought by 127 care home workers against the government and the Care Quality Commission over the mandatory Covid-19 vaccination policy.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Tax Manager (6 months' service) v Optivo
A Tax Manager with six months' service who made multiple false allegations of harassment and discrimination was fairly dismissed during probation. The tribunal struck out his unfair dismissal claim and ordered him to pay £10,000 in costs.
Lost · Jan 2023Lost—Jan 2023Accountant (7 years' service) v Finanspol Group Ltd
An accountant with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed after refusing to accept self-employment and reduced pay. The tribunal awarded £9,063.83.
Won · £9,064 · Jan 2023Won£9,064Jan 2023Branch manager (3 years 9 months' service) v Marquis Motorhomes Ltd.
A tribunal upheld the dismissal of a branch manager who made inappropriate sexual comments to female colleagues, but ordered his former employer to pay £19,402 in unpaid bonuses he earned before being sacked.
Partial · £19,402 · Jan 2023Partial£19,402Jan 2023Former employee (less than 2 years' service) v Tesco Stores Limited
A former Tesco employee with less than two years' service has been allowed to pursue a disability discrimination claim even though it was brought six weeks late. The tribunal said it was 'just and equitable' to extend time.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Former employee (disputed status) v Thomas Roofing (NW) Ltd
A former employee who forged a contract of employment and swapped a blank SD card for evidence has had her unfair dismissal claim struck out for abuse of process.
Dismissed · Jan 2023Dismissed—Jan 2023Compounder (2 years' service) v Dugdale Limited
A compounder was unfairly dismissed after being accused of new allegations at his disciplinary hearing, but the tribunal found he contributed 100% to his dismissal and awarded no compensation.
Partial · Jan 2023Partial—Jan 2023Former employee v Stephen M S Lai & Co Business Consulting Ltd
A former employee was awarded £34,204 after being unfairly dismissed and harassed due to his age. The employer did not attend the hearing or file a response.
Partial · £34,204 · Jan 2023Partial£34,204Jan 2023School delivery driver and taxi driver v Mr Steven Barnes trading as Bernie Taxi Services
A tribunal found that a school delivery driver was an employee for that role but only a worker for taxi work. The case settled before the final hearing, with no compensation awarded.
Settled · Jan 2023Settled—Jan 2023Factory/supervisor cutter (4 years' service) v Razzle Dazzle Costumes Limited
A factory supervisor with a colostomy who said 'I'm done' and handed in her keys during an anxiety attack was unfairly dismissed when her employer treated it as a resignation without checking. Tribunal awards £7,449.
Partial · £7,449 · Dec 2022Partial£7,449Dec 2022Senior Control Centre Officer (13 years' service) v Waltham Forests Services Ltd
A long-serving control centre officer was unfairly dismissed after he did not report a man drinking on a town hall complex. The tribunal found the employer failed to genuinely believe misconduct had occurred and relied on an unwritten procedure.
Won · Dec 2022Won—Dec 2022Branch Manager (12 years' service) v Jayar Components Ltd
A branch manager with 12 years' service who was clinically extremely vulnerable to COVID-19 was unfairly dismissed and discriminated against after his employer demanded he return to an office he considered unsafe. The tribunal found the disciplinary process was a sham.
Won · Dec 2022Won—Dec 2022Fitness club manager (4 months' service) v Inrenos 2 Ltd
A fitness club manager who swore at his boss during a heated phone call about his resignation was wrongfully dismissed. The tribunal awarded £1,273.52 in damages and repayment of unauthorised deductions.
Won · £1,274 · Dec 2022Won£1,274Dec 2022Lubrication team leader (17 years' service) v Network Rail Infrastructure Limited
A lubrication team leader with 17 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a 16-month investigation into a near-miss incident. The tribunal found the delay and failure to consider alternatives made the dismissal unreasonable.
Won · £15,383 · Dec 2022Won£15,383Dec 2022Country director (29 years' service) v The British Council
A country director with 29 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed investigation into a sexual harassment allegation. The tribunal ordered his re-engagement.
Won · Dec 2022Won—Dec 2022Airline employee (32 years' service) v British Airways plc
British Airways unfairly dismissed a 32-year employee for alleged misuse of sickness and dependency leave. The tribunal found the employer presumed absences were not genuine, awarding over £49,000.
Won · £49,121 · Dec 2022Won£49,121Dec 2022Driving Examiner (4 years' service) v The Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency
A driving examiner with four years' service was fairly dismissed after driving recklessly on DVSA property and failing to check a candidate's licence. The tribunal rejected his claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Part-time sales advisor (dairy farming equipment) v LC Longtown Limited
A part-time sales advisor who admitted submitting false time sheets was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal also awarded him £250 in unpaid commission and £1,412 for the employer's failure to provide written particulars.
Partial · £1,662 · Dec 2022Partial£1,662Dec 2022Postal worker (21 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Limited
A postal worker with 21 years' service was fairly dismissed for pushing a colleague during a dispute over equipment, the tribunal has ruled. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Hygiene operative (16 years' service) v Anglo Beef Processors UK
A hygiene operative with 16 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a disciplinary hearing that had already decided his guilt. The tribunal awarded £23,091 in compensation.
Won · £23,091 · Dec 2022Won£23,091Dec 2022Sales Manager (24 years' service) v The Estate of Glenn Hamish Manuel T/A Baytree Car Sales
A sales manager with 24 years' service was dismissed by text message without any disciplinary process. The tribunal awarded him £38,229.54 for unfair dismissal, unpaid wages, and breach of contract.
Won · £38,230 · Dec 2022Won£38,230Dec 2022Complaints Resolution Manager (6 years' service) v E.ON UK PLC
A Complaints Resolution Manager was fairly dismissed after closing 81 complaints but making only 15 outbound calls. The tribunal upheld E.ON's decision, finding the investigation and dismissal were reasonable.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Machine operator (3 years' service) v Delphi Technologies Ltd
A machine operator who returned late from unpaid leave to visit his ill mother in Mali was fairly dismissed for misconduct. The tribunal also struck out his race discrimination claim for failing to provide a witness statement despite an Unless Order.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Residential Support Worker (3 years' service) v Hertfordshire County Council
A residential support worker was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after attending work while possibly having COVID-19 symptoms. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal, race discrimination and victimisation.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Head of Welding (Mr Fuller, 5 years' service) and Welder/MOT tester (Mr Jackson, 4 years' service) v Kingsley Cars Limited
Two employees were unfairly dismissed after being sacked for gross misconduct without a disciplinary hearing. The tribunal found the process was procedurally flawed.
Partial · Dec 2022Partial—Dec 2022Group Leader (8 years' service) v Jaguar Land Rover Limited
A Jaguar Land Rover group leader who simulated sex acts on a colleague and called it 'banter' was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022HR Manager (8 years' service) v North Northamptonshire Council
An HR Manager with 8 years' service was summarily dismissed for breaching confidentiality. The tribunal found the council's investigation and disciplinary process were fair and the dismissal was within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Nurse (Band 5 Staff Nurse, 15 years' service) v Dorset Healthcare University NHS Foundation Trust
A Band 5 staff nurse with 15 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after allegedly sleeping on duty. The tribunal found the dismissal fair for unfair dismissal purposes but ruled the trust failed to prove gross misconduct, awarding £7,045.65 in notice pay.
Partial · £7,046 · Dec 2022Partial£7,046Dec 2022Postman (15 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Limited
A postman with 15 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after refusing to work, posting abusive comments about colleagues on Facebook, and behaving aggressively. The tribunal rejected his claims of unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and whistleblowing detriment.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Trainee Assistant Psychological Wellbeing Practitioner v Pennine Care NHS Foundation Trust
A former trainee assistant psychological wellbeing practitioner had her unfair dismissal and discrimination claims struck out after repeatedly failing to comply with case management orders and not responding to a strike-out warning.
Dismissed · Dec 2022Dismissed—Dec 2022Assistive technology support role (21 years' service) v Thirteen Housing Group Ltd
A tribunal dismissed all claims brought by an assistive technology support worker with 21 years' service against Thirteen Housing Group Ltd, including allegations of direct age discrimination and unfair dismissal.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Former employee (17 years' service) v Drive Software Solutions Limited
A former employee with 17 years' service was awarded over £100,000 after his employer failed to engage with the tribunal process, leading to a default judgment and strike-out of their response.
Won · £100,332 · Dec 2022Won£100,332Dec 2022Former employee (long service, dismissed for gross misconduct) v Care UK Community Partnerships Ltd
A tribunal struck out claims of unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal, and detriment for protected disclosures after the claimant failed to pay a £300 deposit order. The unlawful deductions claim was also struck out as having no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Dec 2022Dismissed—Dec 2022Warehouse operative (8 years' service) v Alliance Healthcare Management Services Limited
A warehouse operative with 8 years' service was unfairly dismissed, victimised, and discriminated against after reporting safety issues and then being absent due to work-related stress. The tribunal awarded over £16,000 in compensation.
Partial · £16,295 · Dec 2022Partial£16,295Dec 2022Sales Advisor (9 years' service) v Sky Retail Stores Limited
A sales advisor with 9 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after an Insight Report flagged suspicious customer signatures. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision to dismiss were within the band of reasonable responses.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Lead manager (18 years' service) v Tesco Stores Ltd
A lead manager with 18 years' service and a clean record was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after recruiting two relatives without following Tesco's recruitment procedures. The tribunal rejected her unfair and wrongful dismissal claims.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Area Service Manager (3 years' service) v Acis Group Limited
An Area Service Manager was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after driving his personal vehicle for business without a valid MOT certificate for nearly a year. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Beauty course teacher (3 months' service) v The Vogue Clinic Limited
A teacher who resigned after just three months' service failed to prove she was dismissed. The tribunal found she quit voluntarily, and her disability discrimination claims did not succeed.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Butcher (12 years' service) v Bicks Chicks Ltd
A butcher with 12 years' service was summarily dismissed for coming to work after testing positive for COVID-19. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair but reduced compensation by 75% for contributory fault.
Partial · £2,202 · Dec 2022Partial£2,202Dec 2022Cleaner (4 years' service) v Direct Cleaning Services SW Ltd
Two cleaners were unfairly dismissed after their employer accused them of gross misconduct but failed to hold a disciplinary hearing or give details of the allegations. The tribunal awarded over £9,600 in compensation.
Won · £9,658 · Dec 2022Won£9,658Dec 2022PR and Community Manager v Arjuna Seth Shoes Limited
An employment tribunal struck out a former PR and community manager's claims of sexual harassment and victimisation after she failed to pursue them for over two and a half years, following the respondent's liquidation.
Dismissed · Dec 2022Dismissed—Dec 2022HGV driver (12 years' service) v Kier Integrated Services Ltd
An HGV driver with 12 years' service was reinstated after a successful appeal against dismissal for gross misconduct. The tribunal allowed his victimisation claims to proceed but dismissed direct race discrimination claims as out of time.
Partial · Dec 2022Partial—Dec 2022Former employee v Park & Birch Ltd
A former employee won £10,748.88 after their employer made an unauthorised deduction from wages and unfairly dismissed them. The tribunal added a 25% uplift because the employer breached the ACAS Code of Practice.
Partial · £10,749 · Dec 2022Partial£10,749Dec 2022Former employee v Boilertech (NW) Limited
A former employee has won a default judgment against Boilertech (NW) Limited after the company failed to respond to claims of unauthorised wage deductions and unfair dismissal. The tribunal awarded £2,758.46 in total.
Won · £2,758 · Dec 2022Won£2,758Dec 2022Former employees (3 years' service) v Costal and Country Devonshire Arms Ltd (trading as Coastal and Country Devonshire Arms Ltd)
Two former employees were unfairly dismissed and awarded over £42,000 for unpaid notice, unauthorised deductions, holiday pay, and pension contributions, plus a 25% uplift for the employer's failure to comply with ACAS rules.
Won · £42,071 · Dec 2022Won£42,071Dec 2022Former employee v Govia Thameslink Railway Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims against Govia Thameslink Railway were struck out after he repeatedly refused to proceed without a prior criminal investigation by MI5 or the Serious Fraud Office.
Dismissed · Dec 2022Dismissed—Dec 2022Train manager (32 years' service) v London Underground Limited
A train manager with 32 years' service was unfairly dismissed for posting racially divisive social media messages about George Floyd, but the tribunal found she would have been dismissed anyway and cut her award by 75% for her own conduct.
Partial · £7,285 · Dec 2022Partial£7,285Dec 2022Former employee v Hayre Builders Company Limited
A Reading tribunal awarded a former employee £178,199.82 after finding he was unfairly dismissed, with the employer failing to provide a written statement of particulars and unreasonably ignoring the Acas Code.
Won · £178,200 · Dec 2022Won£178,200Dec 2022HGV driver (6 years' service) v DHL Services Limited
An HGV driver with six years' service was unfairly dismissed by DHL after a physical altercation with a colleague, but his compensation was reduced by 85% for the likelihood he would have been dismissed anyway and by 50% for his own conduct.
Partial · £4,593 · Dec 2022Partial£4,593Dec 2022Team leader (6 years' service) v Stateside Foods Limited
A team leader with 6 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a flawed investigation into a safety breach. The tribunal found the employer's process was inadequate and reduced compensation by 20% for the chance she would have been dismissed anyway.
Partial · £5,643 · Dec 2022Partial£5,643Dec 2022Electrical Operations Manager / Projects Manager (4 years' service) v Sodexo Limited
An electrical operations manager dismissed after systemic failings in hospital emergency lighting lost his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims. The tribunal found Sodexo acted reasonably.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Security Officer (7 months' service) v Mitie Security (First) Ltd
A security officer with only seven months' service was fairly dismissed for aggressive behaviour and misuse of the grievance policy after repeatedly challenging his employer's face mask rules during the pandemic. The tribunal rejected all claims of automatic unfair dismissal and discrimination.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Senior Control Systems Engineer (20+ years' service) v Sellafield Ltd
A Senior Control Systems Engineer with over 20 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after leaving an unencrypted USB stick containing official sensitive data in a car park. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Assistant Principal (7 years' service) v The Thinking Schools Academy Trust
An assistant principal with seven years' service was unfairly dismissed after physically restraining a disruptive student. The school had not provided positive handling training and failed to preserve full CCTV evidence.
Won · Dec 2022Won—Dec 2022Care assistant (3 years 4 months' service) v R G Care Ltd
A care assistant was unfairly dismissed after a 10-minute disciplinary hearing where the decision-maker had already decided she was guilty. The tribunal awarded £11,300.97.
Won · £11,301 · Dec 2022Won£11,301Dec 2022Product Coach (7+ years' service) v Jaguar Land Rover Ltd
A Jaguar Land Rover product coach who was reinstated after a conduct dismissal but then resigned and sued for constructive dismissal and race discrimination has lost his claim. The tribunal found his allegations lacked credibility and criticised his late disclosure of covert recordings.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Customer assistant (13 years' service) v Tesco Stores Limited
A customer assistant with 13 years' service was fairly dismissed after showing a sexually explicit video to a colleague. The tribunal upheld Tesco's decision, finding the investigation and dismissal were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Operational Postal Grade / Delivery Office Manager Support (22 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Limited
An employee with 22 years' service was fairly dismissed for fraudulently claiming 706 hours of unauthorised overtime, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Head of Estates (13 years' service) v Muntham House Ltd
A head of estates with 13 years' service was unfairly dismissed for selling a disused oil tank for £230. The tribunal found the investigation and appeal process were biased and procedurally flawed.
Won · Dec 2022Won—Dec 2022Prison officer (2 years 10 months' service) v Ministry of Justice
A prison officer who systematically inflated mileage claims and claimed travel time as expenses to avoid tax was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal also ordered him to repay £863.25.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Former employee v Openreach Limited
A former Openreach employee won his unfair dismissal claim but saw his compensation cut by 30% because his own conduct contributed to his sacking. The tribunal awarded £42,845.56.
Partial · £42,846 · Dec 2022Partial£42,846Dec 2022Agency driver v DHU Healthcare CIC
An agency driver who was dismissed after his mask exemption led to a dispute with a healthcare provider has won his unfair dismissal claim, but the tribunal found he was not an employee of the company that refused his services.
Partial · £27,275 · Dec 2022Partial£27,275Dec 2022Engineering Manager (1 year 2 months' service) v UPW Industrial Applications Ltd
An Engineering Manager who refused to return to work citing childcare commitments was not automatically unfairly dismissed for raising health and safety concerns. The tribunal found his principal reason for refusing was childcare, not Covid-19 fears.
Partial · Dec 2022Partial—Dec 2022Cleaner v MITIE Limited
A cleaner who was dismissed for allegedly making a sexist remark to a member of the public has lost his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer acted reasonably based on the evidence available.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Former employee v Store Retail Group Limited (in creditors voluntary liquidation)
A former employee was unfairly and wrongfully dismissed after a disciplinary hearing. The tribunal awarded £3,210 but reduced compensation due to the employee's conduct and failure to appeal.
Won · £3,210 · Dec 2022Won£3,210Dec 2022Train driver (12 years' service) v First MTR South Western Trains Limited
A train driver with 12 years' service was unfairly dismissed for posting offensive tweets, but the tribunal awarded no compensation due to his blameworthy conduct.
Won · Dec 2022Won—Dec 2022Former employee (6 years' service) v WFM Food London Ltd
A former employee with six years' service was unfairly dismissed by WFM Food London Ltd and awarded £27,863 after the company failed to follow the ACAS code and made unauthorised deductions from wages.
Partial · £27,863 · Dec 2022Partial£27,863Dec 2022Development Engineer (4 years' service) v Rheon Labs Limited
A development engineer with 4 years' service was fairly dismissed after a final written warning and further complaints about his behaviour. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Customer assistant (9 years' service) v Lidl Great Britain Limited
A Lidl customer assistant was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct over a chicken discount code and a dwarf plant purchase, but the tribunal awarded only £633.60 after finding she was 90% to blame.
Partial · £634 · Dec 2022Partial£634Dec 2022Integrated Pest Management Specialist (6 years' service) v Fargro Ltd
An employee dismissed for refusing to remove a screensaver and discussing politics at work has won his unfair dismissal claim after the tribunal found the appeal process was fatally flawed. No compensation was awarded at this stage.
Won · Dec 2022Won—Dec 2022Senior Underwriter (17 years' service) v Ark Syndicate Management Ltd
A senior underwriter with 17 years' service was unfairly dismissed after raising concerns about a potentially fraudulent claim. The tribunal found the employer failed to investigate whether the performance targets were reasonable.
Partial · Dec 2022Partial—Dec 2022Former employee (warehouse operative) v Tesco Stores Limited
A former Tesco warehouse operative who was dismissed for making a racist remark and sending threatening messages has lost his claims for unfair dismissal, race discrimination, victimisation, whistleblowing detriment, and holiday pay.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Housing and Support Officer (13 years' service) v Transform Housing and Support
A housing officer with 13 years' service was fairly dismissed after sending an unauthorised email to a local council criticising her employer's eviction of a client. The tribunal rejected her whistleblowing claims.
Lost · Dec 2022Lost—Dec 2022Former employee v London Underground Limited
A former London Underground employee who was dismissed for having a second full-time job without consent had all his claims struck out. The tribunal found his unfair dismissal claim could not proceed due to lack of service, and his discrimination claim was brought too late.
Dismissed · Nov 2022Dismissed—Nov 2022Cardio-thoracic surgeon (20 years' service) v Liverpool Heart and Chest Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
A cardio-thoracic surgeon with 20 years' service was fairly dismissed after admitting he completed 98 site verification forms before patients were admitted, inappropriately cancelled surgery, and failed to document care. The tribunal upheld the NHS Trust's decision.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Headteacher (18 years' service) v Urbis Academy Trust
A headteacher who accepted vouchers without declaring them and breached suspension terms was fairly dismissed. The tribunal rejected her claims of unfair dismissal, race discrimination and victimisation.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Office manager (14 years' service) v Deltec industries Limited
An office manager who stopped placing stock orders due to cash flow concerns was unfairly dismissed. The tribunal found the employer had already decided to dismiss before the hearing.
Won · Nov 2022Won—Nov 2022Band 4 Caterer (14 years' service) v Secretary of State for Justice
A Band 4 caterer with 14 years' service was fairly dismissed for pinching a colleague's bottom. The tribunal rejected his claim that his Asperger's syndrome caused the behaviour.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022PO3 Examiner (1 year 8 months' service) v The Home Office
An employment tribunal has held that the Home Office fairly dismissed a PO3 examiner who sent unsolicited sexual messages to female colleagues and made inappropriate comments about a colleague's teenage daughter.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Key worker (2 years' service) v Phase II Care Limited
A care worker with two years' service was unfairly dismissed after a misconduct investigation and disciplinary hearing were both conducted by the same biased manager. The tribunal awarded £11,538.75 in compensation.
Partial · £11,539 · Nov 2022Partial£11,539Nov 2022Assistant Service Engineer (15 years' service) v Govia Thameslink Railway Ltd
An assistant service engineer with 15 years' service was fairly dismissed for bullying a vulnerable colleague, the tribunal ruled, upholding the employer's investigation and decision.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Teacher of Modern Foreign Languages v New College Leicester
A teacher who brought claims for unfair dismissal, disability and race discrimination, and failure to deal with a flexible working request had all her claims dismissed because they were presented to the tribunal too late.
Dismissed · Nov 2022Dismissed—Nov 2022Hotel manager (3 years' service) v N & C Leisure Limited
A hotel manager was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct after being drunk on the premises, but the tribunal found she was 100% to blame, awarding only £1,076 for the employer's failure to provide written particulars.
Won · £1,076 · Nov 2022Won£1,076Nov 2022Director and employee (family-run auto centre) v Wessex Auto Centres Ltd
A director and employee of a family-run auto centre was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after twice hitting his father in the head and transferring £10,000 from the company account without authorisation.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Security Valet Officer (9 months' service) v Ballymore (Millharbour) Ltd
A security valet officer with nine months' service lost his claims of unfair dismissal, race discrimination, harassment, victimisation, and whistleblowing detriment after a tribunal found the employer's conduct concerns were genuine.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Sales manager (15 years' service) v Grange Motors (Brentwood) Limited
A sales manager with 15 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross negligence after failing to escalate a pricing error on two Land Rovers. The tribunal rejected his claims for unfair dismissal and unpaid wages.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Former employee (telephony service worker) v Capita Customer Management Ltd
A former Capita employee had her unfair dismissal claim struck out after she refused to engage with documents during cross-examination, making a fair hearing impossible.
Dismissed · Nov 2022Dismissed—Nov 2022Customer Service Assistant (4 years' service) v Sainsbury’s Supermarkets Limited
A Customer Service Assistant who pushed a roll cage at a manager was fairly dismissed, the tribunal ruled, finding Sainsbury's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Former employee v University College of Osteopathy
A former employee was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal applied a 20% ACAS code uplift but also reduced compensation by 20% for contributory conduct and 20% for the chance she would have been dismissed anyway.
Won · £6,931 · Nov 2022Won£6,931Nov 2022Crematorium Technician (2 years' service) v North East Lincolnshire Council
A crematorium technician with two years' service was fairly dismissed after failing to clean pet remains from a cremator, falsifying timesheets, and creating a fire hazard. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Driver of 7.5 tonne vehicles (7 years' service) v Halls Distribution Ltd
A driver with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a road traffic accident when his employer failed to contest his claims. The tribunal awarded £5,586.99.
Won · £5,587 · Nov 2022Won£5,587Nov 2022Carer (2 years' service) v Mr Paul Orkin
A carer with two years' service was unfairly dismissed after being fired via WhatsApp message with no disciplinary process. The tribunal awarded £2,639 in compensation, including an ACAS code uplift.
Won · £2,639 · Nov 2022Won£2,639Nov 2022Warehouse operative (2 years' service) v DHL Services Limited
A warehouse operative with two years' service was fairly dismissed after repeatedly refusing a reasonable instruction to clean up debris. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Team Manager (18.5 years' service in a law firm) v Minster Law Limited
An employment tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal claim from a team manager with 18.5 years' service because it was presented just four days after the deadline. The key issue was the effective date of termination.
Dismissed · Nov 2022Dismissed—Nov 2022Retained crew manager and firefighter (12 years' service) v Staffordshire Fire & Rescue Service
A retained crew manager with 12 years' service was fairly dismissed for failing to challenge a homophobic comment in a WhatsApp group and for coordinating grievances to delay a crewing policy. The tribunal rejected his claims of unfair dismissal and part-time worker discrimination.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Practice Business Manager (16 years' service) v The Partners t/a Shelley Manor and Holdenhurst Medical Centre
A Practice Business Manager with 16 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after claiming overtime from the COVID-19 Support Fund without partner approval. The tribunal rejected her claims of whistleblowing and unfair dismissal.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Rehabilitation support worker (6 years' service) v The Disabilities Trust
A rehabilitation support worker with a live final written warning was fairly dismissed after leaving her CCTV post to answer buzzers, allowing a vulnerable service user to abscond. The tribunal dismissed her claims for unfair dismissal and race discrimination.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Electrician (5 years' service at Broadgate Campus) v ABM Technical Solutions Limited
An electrician who switched on a water-damaged electrical board, creating a serious safety risk, was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal also rejected his claim that the dismissal was due to his trade union membership.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Course Director and Lecturer (7 years' service) v The College of West Anglia
A college lecturer with seven years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after using a compressed air hose to extinguish a workshop fire, breaching health and safety rules. The tribunal upheld the dismissal.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Customer service assistant (15 years' service) v Wilko Limited
A customer service assistant with 15 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after selling a knife to a 16-year-old police test purchaser without checking ID. The tribunal upheld Wilko's decision, finding the dismissal within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Production operative (9 years' service) v Jaguar Land Rover Limited
A production operative with 9 years' service was fairly dismissed after refusing to wear a face covering during the pandemic, despite claiming an exemption. The tribunal upheld Jaguar Land Rover's decision.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Production Team Manager (5 years' service) v Edible Oils Ltd
A production manager who was called a 'gangster' by a colleague in a canteen row had his racial harassment claim upheld, but his unfair dismissal claim failed because a later investigation was thorough.
Partial · Nov 2022Partial—Nov 2022Lecturer and programme coordinator (10 months' service) v London School of Science and Technology Ltd
A tribunal dismissed claims of race discrimination and automatically unfair dismissal by a lecturer with 10 months' service, finding the real reason was poor performance.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Practice Manager (4.5 years' service) v Dr A Milner t/a Anlaby Surgery
A practice manager with 4.5 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a dispute over pay for work at an Improving Access Hub. The tribunal found the real reason was a breakdown in the relationship, not misconduct. She was awarded £24,440.
Won · £24,440 · Nov 2022Won£24,440Nov 2022Van driver (2 years 8 months' service) v Complex Logistics Ltd
A van driver lost his unfair dismissal claim after breaching a final written warning, but was awarded £3,507 for unpaid notice, wages, and holiday pay.
Partial · £3,508 · Nov 2022Partial£3,508Nov 2022Office administrator v Emax Trading Limited
A tribunal awarded over £10,000 to two office administrators after finding that one was discriminated against due to pregnancy and the other unfairly dismissed. The employer failed to conduct a pregnancy risk assessment and did not provide written employment particulars.
Partial · £10,114 · Nov 2022Partial£10,114Nov 2022IT consultant (3 years' service) v Primary Technologies (S.E.) Limited
An IT consultant who took unpaid leave after her furlough request was refused, then failed to return to work, was fairly dismissed for misconduct. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022HGV driver (12 years' service) v MAM Transport Services Limited
A tribunal found that an HGV driver with 12 years' service was unfairly dismissed after his employer lost trust in him over a back injury suffered in Poland. He was awarded £13,335.
Partial · £13,335 · Nov 2022Partial£13,335Nov 2022Managing Director (25 years' service) v Eville & Jones (GB) Ltd
A managing director with 25 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, including a sham payment, despite his bipolar disorder. The tribunal rejected claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022NHS employee v Guys and St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust
An NHS employee was unfairly dismissed but had her compensation cut by 50% for contributory conduct. Her race discrimination claims were dismissed.
Partial · £32,057 · Nov 2022Partial£32,057Nov 2022Bus driver (8 years' service) v London United Busways Limited
An employment tribunal found that London United Busways unfairly dismissed a bus driver who refused to work in March 2020 due to Covid-19 safety concerns. The driver was awarded £13,410 in compensation.
Partial · £13,410 · Nov 2022Partial£13,410Nov 2022Former employee v Halsey Masonic Hall, Watford, Limited
An employment tribunal dismissed all remaining claims of a former employee who did not attend the final hearing and failed to comply with court orders, ending a case that had already lost several claims due to non-compliance.
Dismissed · Nov 2022Dismissed—Nov 2022Security guard (placed by recruitment agency) v CDX Security Ltd
A security guard who alleged race and sex discrimination by a senior officer had her entire claim dismissed after repeatedly failing to provide a list of documents as ordered by the tribunal.
Dismissed · Nov 2022Dismissed—Nov 2022Driver and machine operator (6 years' service) v Viam Infrastructure Asset Management (VIAM) Ltd (in administration)
A driver and machine operator was unfairly dismissed after using a company vehicle with permission, a common practice, while a colleague was not disciplined. The tribunal awarded a basic award and notice pay but no compensatory award due to the employer's subsequent administration.
Partial · £8,776 · Nov 2022Partial£8,776Nov 2022Social worker v Cumbria County Council
A social worker who waited over a year to bring an unfair dismissal claim after being summarily dismissed for gross misconduct had her case struck out as out of time. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for her to have claimed within the three-month limit.
Dismissed · Nov 2022Dismissed—Nov 2022Former employee (Principal Stylist) v Ms M Bratton and Evanlils Ltd
A tribunal dismissed all claims of unfair dismissal and homophobic abuse brought by a former Principal Stylist after he failed to attend the preliminary hearing or comply with case management orders.
Dismissed · Nov 2022Dismissed—Nov 2022Online delivery driver (2.5 years' service) v Sainsbury's Supermarkets Ltd
An online delivery driver with a live final written warning was fairly dismissed after speeding 30% over the limit. The tribunal upheld Sainsbury's decision, finding it fell within the band of reasonable responses.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Waitress (2 years' service) v Cribben Southampton Limited
A waitress unfairly dismissed after being accused of stealing from the till has been awarded £4,168. The tribunal found the investigation was unreasonable and the employer's belief in guilt was not based on reasonable grounds.
Won · £4,168 · Nov 2022Won£4,168Nov 2022Cleaner and Catering Assistant (5 years' service) v Hartlepool Borough Council
A cleaner and catering assistant who refused a transfer after raising Covid safety concerns was unfairly dismissed from one role but fairly dismissed from another. She was awarded £551.53.
Partial · £552 · Nov 2022Partial£552Nov 2022Club secretary (20 years' service) v Peterborough Milton Golf Club Ltd
A club secretary with 20 years' service was fairly dismissed for misconduct after two female employees alleged sexual touching. The tribunal found the golf club's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022HGV driver (15 years' service) v DHL Services Limited
An HGV driver who alleged he was dismissed for whistleblowing about an unreported accident has lost his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found his aggressive behaviour towards managers was the real reason for dismissal.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Unit Manager (18 years' service) v John Lewis Plc
A Waitrose unit manager with 18 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after leaving a petrol filling station without a duty manager or keyholder present. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Installation Engineer (2 years' service) v Lasyl Audio and Visual Ltd
An installation engineer who refused to attend work over Covid-19 safety fears was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal also rejected his disability discrimination claim as out of time.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Former employee v Kirkby Blinds Direct Limited (In Voluntary Liquidation)
A former employee won claims for unfair dismissal, notice pay, and unlawful deduction of wages (holiday pay and underpayment of salary) against Kirkby Blinds Direct Limited, which was in voluntary liquidation. The tribunal awarded £1,497.36.
Won · £1,497 · Nov 2022Won£1,497Nov 2022PCV Bus Driver (2 years' service) v Metroline Travel Ltd
A bus driver with two years' service was unfairly dismissed after a physical altercation at a bus station. The tribunal found the investigation was flawed, but reduced compensation by 20% for his own conduct.
Partial · £10,242 · Nov 2022Partial£10,242Nov 2022Senior child care practitioner (3 years' service) v The Midcounties Co-operative Limited
A senior child care practitioner was fairly dismissed after CCTV showed her placing her hand over a three-year-old's face. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision, finding the investigation and dismissal were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Warehouse operative / fork lift driver (4 years' service) v DHL Services Limited
A warehouse operative who refused to wear a face covering during the pandemic was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal ruled.
Lost · Nov 2022Lost—Nov 2022Driver (2 years 7 months' service) v Uber London Limited
A driver who was dismissed by Uber and relied on his union for advice missed the three-month deadline by over three months. The tribunal dismissed his claim as out of time, finding it was reasonably practicable for him to have presented it earlier.
Dismissed · Nov 2022Dismissed—Nov 2022Travel consultant (2 years' service) v Rankin Travel Ltd
A travel consultant was unfairly dismissed for working a second job without permission while on furlough, but the tribunal awarded nothing due to Polkey and contributory fault reductions.
Won · £0 · Nov 2022Won£0Nov 2022MDU engineer (5 years' service) v Sky In-Home Services Limited
An engineer with 5 years' service had his unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims struck out after relying on incorrect ACAS advice that caused an 8-month delay in presenting his claim.
Dismissed · Nov 2022Dismissed—Nov 2022Former employee v Morrison Data Services Limited
A former employee with a final written warning was unfairly dismissed after a misconduct incident. The tribunal found the employer failed to follow a fair process and awarded £4,081.99.
Partial · £4,082 · Nov 2022Partial£4,082Nov 2022Multi-Skilled Operative (2.5 years' service) v Cemex UK Operations Limited
A multi-skilled operative was unfairly dismissed after a collision with a customer lorry that had entered the yard without permission. The tribunal found the appeal process was procedurally unfair and closed-minded.
Won · Nov 2022Won—Nov 2022Mental Health Care Assistant (nearly 4 years' service) v Healthcare and Transport Services
An employment tribunal entered default judgment against Healthcare and Transport Services after it failed to submit a response to an unfair dismissal claim within the time limit, and refused the employer's late application for an extension.
Partial · Oct 2022Partial—Oct 2022Former employee v GeoAmey PECS Limited
A former employee who withdrew her claim the day before the hearing and failed to attend had her case dismissed and was ordered to pay £246 in preparation time costs.
Dismissed · Oct 2022Dismissed—Oct 2022Ductwork manufacturer (11 years' service) v H & V 2000 Limited
A ductwork manufacturer with 11 years' service had his unfair dismissal claim struck out after he missed the three-month time limit by nearly two months, despite his father's death.
Dismissed · Oct 2022Dismissed—Oct 2022Cleaner (2 years' service) v CAD Services Ltd t/a Facilities by ADF
A cleaner with two years' service who was dismissed for poor performance and attendance lost her claims of unfair dismissal, whistleblowing, disability and sex discrimination. The tribunal found the employer acted reasonably.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Porter (3 years' service with respondent, transferred from trust in 2017) v Serco Limited
A porter who refused blood tests and vaccinations required by the hospital trust was fairly dismissed, the tribunal ruled, finding Serco acted reasonably.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Support Worker (3 years' service) v Protea Care Homes Kent Limited
A support worker was unfairly dismissed after a disciplinary hearing described as an 'ambush' with vague allegations. The tribunal awarded £9,111.12 in compensation.
Partial · £9,111 · Oct 2022Partial£9,111Oct 2022Process Operator (16 years' service) v ATAG Cables & Tapes Limited (in liquidation)
Two process operators with 16 years' service who signed a mutual termination agreement after being caught stealing copper were not entitled to redundancy payments, the tribunal ruled.
Dismissed · Oct 2022Dismissed—Oct 2022Curriculum Leader and Lead Internal Verifier (6 years' service) v Capital City College Group
A curriculum leader was unfairly dismissed after submitting predicted grades as final grades without internal verification, but the tribunal found she would have been dismissed anyway and awarded no compensation.
Partial · Oct 2022Partial—Oct 2022Sales Executive – New Cars (8 months' service) v Mercedes Benz Retail Group Ltd
A sales executive dismissed during probation for poor performance had his unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims thrown out because he lacked two years' service and filed his claim 17 days late.
Dismissed · Oct 2022Dismissed—Oct 2022Warehouse operative (4 years' service) v Samworth Brothers Limited Trading as Samworth Brothers Supply Chain
A warehouse operative with 4 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a powered pallet truck collision with his supervisor. The tribunal found the employer failed to consider the supervisor's own fault, but reduced compensation by 70% for the employee's contributory negligence.
Partial · Oct 2022Partial—Oct 2022Sales advisor (3 years' service) v Sky Retail Stores Limited
A sales advisor was unfairly dismissed by Sky Retail Stores Limited for a data protection breach after an 11-month investigation and disciplinary process. The tribunal awarded £807, reduced by 50% for contributory conduct.
Won · £807 · Oct 2022Won£807Oct 2022LGV driver (10 years' service) v A&F Haulage Limited
An LGV driver with 10 years' service was fairly dismissed for removing his tachograph card near the depot, the Manchester Employment Tribunal ruled, despite procedural shortcomings in the disciplinary process.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Neighbourhood caretaker (13 years' service) v London Borough of Croydon
A 13-year neighbourhood caretaker was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after a disabled service user complained he was verbally abusive and made a kicking motion. The tribunal rejected claims that the real reason was trade union activities.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Band 6 midwife (9 years' service) v Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust
A band 6 midwife with nine years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after an alleged physical assault on a colleague. The tribunal found the dismissal fair and rejected claims of race discrimination and victimisation.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Detention Custody Officer (11 years' service) v Mitie Care and Custody Limited
An Employment Tribunal has ruled that Mitie Care and Custody Limited fairly dismissed a Detention Custody Officer with 11 years' service who failed to carry out three hourly patrols and the morning roll count. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Mobile Electrical Craftsperson (7 months' service) v Bouygues E & S Solutions Ltd
A mobile electrical craftsperson with seven months' service lost his race discrimination claim after the tribunal found his evidence lacked credibility and he failed to raise the most serious allegations at the time.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Relief Manager (20 hours/week) v RSPCA North Somerset Branch
A relief manager who was dismissed after sending an inflammatory email and failing to comply with instructions lost his unfair dismissal, whistleblowing, and disability discrimination claims. The tribunal found no protected disclosures and no discrimination.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Chauffeur (seasonal, 17 years' service) v UK Mission Enterprise Limited
A chauffeur who worked for the Dubai Royal Family for 17 years under fixed-term contracts was unable to claim unfair dismissal because gaps between seasons broke his continuous service. The tribunal found the 2019 gap was due to resignation, not a temporary cessation of work.
Dismissed · Oct 2022Dismissed—Oct 2022Train driver (18 years' service) v Govia Thameslink Railway Limited
A train driver who pulled an emergency lever to board a moving train was unfairly dismissed, but his compensation was cut by 75% for contributory fault.
Won · Oct 2022Won—Oct 2022Operational Postal Grade (21 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
An employment tribunal has dismissed claims of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination brought by a postal worker with 21 years' service who was sacked for shouting and swearing at managers.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Administrative officer (18 years' service) v Department for Work and Pensions
An administrative officer with 18 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after searching her own and her neighbour's addresses on a DWP database. The tribunal upheld the dismissal and found her menopausal symptoms did not amount to a disability.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Former employee v Irubber Ltd
A former employee who withdrew his unfair dismissal claim the day before a preliminary hearing has been ordered to pay £1,200 in costs after failing to comply with tribunal orders.
Dismissed · Oct 2022Dismissed—Oct 2022Security officer (4 years 7 months' service) v Atalian Servest Security Ltd
A security officer with nearly five years' service was unfairly dismissed after leaving his post for a break and prayers. The tribunal found the employer's investigation was inadequate, failing to obtain CCTV or witness statements.
Partial · Oct 2022Partial—Oct 2022Former employee v GXO Logistics UK Limited (formerly XPO Supply Chain Services UK Ltd)
An employment tribunal has struck out a former employee's unfair dismissal, disability discrimination and whistleblowing claims as vexatious and having no reasonable prospects of success, after she had already lost a substantially similar claim against the same employer.
Dismissed · Oct 2022Dismissed—Oct 2022Sales Assistant (5 years' service) v Currys Group Ltd
A sales assistant with five years' service was fairly dismissed after CCTV footage showed her taking an item from a locked cabinet where Apple AirPods were later found missing. The tribunal upheld the decision despite a six-week delay in the appeal process.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Senior sales person (9 years' service) v The Flannels Group Limited
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a senior salesperson with 9 years' service after he made a 'race card' comment to street wardens and acted intimidatorily towards two schoolboys in the store.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Complex Dependency Key Worker (12 years' service) v Wigan Borough Council
A 12-year employee of Wigan Borough Council was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after repeatedly accessing a service user's confidential records without authorisation. The tribunal upheld the dismissal, finding the council's investigation and procedure were reasonable.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Bus driver (14 years' service) v Metroline Travel Ltd.
A bus driver with 14 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after covert footage showed her driving and shopping while on sick leave for back pain. The tribunal rejected her unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Shop worker (5 years' service) v Mohammed Saleem Arif (trading as The Suntrap)
A shop worker was unfairly dismissed after her employer sent a text message sacking her over alleged car damage by her ex-partner, without any investigation. The tribunal awarded £1,949.29.
Won · £1,949 · Oct 2022Won£1,949Oct 2022Service Delivery Manager (2 years' service) v Vohkus Limited
A Service Delivery Manager was unfairly dismissed for alleged misconduct and awarded £20,927 after his employer failed to respond to the tribunal claim. The award covered lost earnings and future loss.
Won · £20,927 · Oct 2022Won£20,927Oct 2022Super Operator / Coin Processor (10 years' service) v Vaultex UK Ltd
A coin processor with 10 years' unblemished service was unfairly dismissed for posting a racist joke on the company intranet. The tribunal found a final written warning would have been appropriate and awarded £6,139.92.
Won · £6,140 · Oct 2022Won£6,140Oct 2022Security systems engineer (9 years' service) v London Security Automation Limited
A security systems engineer with 9 years' service was unfairly dismissed after his employer discovered he had done private work for a client, but failed to hold a disciplinary hearing. The tribunal awarded £25,664 in compensation.
Partial · £25,664 · Oct 2022Partial£25,664Oct 2022Senior teaching assistant (attendance officer, inclusion and wellbeing team) v The Governing Body of Cathays High School and Cardiff Council
A 72-year-old senior teaching assistant was fairly dismissed after sending an all-staff email with confidential information, posting derogatory Facebook comments, and writing a book critical of the school. The tribunal rejected claims of age discrimination, whistleblowing, and trade union victimisation.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Former employee v 1st Civils Ltd and Hudson Reign Developments Ltd
A former employee who was dismissed on the same day she transferred to a new employer under TUPE has been awarded over £64,000 for unfair dismissal, unauthorised wage deductions, and breach of contract.
Won · £64,473 · Oct 2022Won£64,473Oct 2022Assistant Manager (8 years' service) v Poundland Limited
An assistant manager with eight years' service was fairly dismissed for amending his Kronos time records after CCTV showed discrepancies. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Salaried employee (3 years' service) v Hazel Grove DIY Centre Limited
An employee with three years' service was dismissed on his second day under new ownership, with no warning or consultation. The tribunal awarded £3,767 for unfair dismissal, unpaid holiday pay, notice pay, and failure to provide written particulars.
Won · £3,767 · Oct 2022Won£3,767Oct 2022Factory operative (2 years' service) v Cranswick Convenience Foods Plc
A factory operative was fairly dismissed for refusing to sanitise her hands during COVID-19, but the tribunal found the conduct did not amount to gross misconduct, entitling her to notice pay.
Partial · Oct 2022Partial—Oct 2022HR Advisor (3 years' service) v London Borough of Haringey
An HR advisor who emailed confidential employee information to her personal Hotmail account was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal has ruled. Her claims of unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and breach of contract were all dismissed.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Assistant Site Manager (2 years 3 months' service) v Frencon Construction Ltd
An assistant site manager was unfairly dismissed by Frencon Construction Ltd. The tribunal found the dismissal procedurally flawed and applied a 20% ACAS uplift because the employer contacted his GP without consent.
Won · Oct 2022Won—Oct 2022Senior contracts manager (6 years' service) v Fire Integrity Limited
A senior contracts manager who resigned after being instructed to carry out a repair job for Kier failed to prove he was dismissed or that he made protected disclosures. The tribunal found he resigned voluntarily and his race discrimination claims were out of time or unsubstantiated.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Former employee v Pfizer Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Pfizer was struck out after she repeatedly failed to comply with tribunal orders and requested a postponement 11 minutes before a 9-day hearing. She was also ordered to pay £1,200 in costs.
Dismissed · Oct 2022Dismissed—Oct 2022Former employee v Skylane Hotel Limited
A former employee who did not attend her final hearing and failed to comply with directions had her claim dismissed by the tribunal.
Dismissed · Oct 2022Dismissed—Oct 2022Former employee v Hirst Family Trading Company Limited
A former employee was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct, but the tribunal reduced compensation to zero because her own conduct caused the dismissal. However, the employer was ordered to pay £576 for failing to provide written reasons and a statement of terms.
Partial · £576 · Oct 2022Partial£576Oct 2022Former employee v Verisure Services (UK) Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was thrown out after she failed to join a preliminary hearing, despite multiple warnings from the tribunal clerk.
Dismissed · Oct 2022Dismissed—Oct 2022Maintenance manager (8.5 years' service) v Equinox Kensington Ltd
A maintenance manager who secretly recorded a gym member and shared the audio on WhatsApp was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal also rejected his race discrimination claim.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Senior Technical Officer (7 years' service) v Network Rail Limited
A Senior Technical Officer with Type 1 diabetes was dismissed for speeding while experiencing low blood sugar. The tribunal found the dismissal fair for conduct but discriminatory under the Equality Act, awarding £66,790.
Partial · £66,790 · Oct 2022Partial£66,790Oct 2022Part-time centre manager (6 years' service) v Millstream Day Centre
A part-time centre manager with 40 years of voluntary service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to follow management instructions and breaching confidentiality. The tribunal upheld the dismissal.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022IT customer service worker (18 years' service) v Openreach Ltd
An IT customer service worker with 18 years' service was fairly dismissed after failing to follow safety procedures while already under a final written warning for a similar breach. The tribunal rejected his unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Former employee v Royal Mail Group Limited
A former employee's attempt to strike out Royal Mail's defence for alleged disclosure failures was refused, with the tribunal finding no material breach. The underlying unfair dismissal claim will proceed to a full hearing.
Dismissed · Oct 2022Dismissed—Oct 2022Former employee v Children Assisted in a Real Environment Ltd.
A former employee failed to have her employer's response struck out despite very late disclosure of documents. The tribunal said a fair trial remained possible.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Home Delivery Relief (milk and food delivery driver) v Muller UK & Ireland Group LLP t/a Milk & More
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a milk delivery driver who was caught on CCTV removing milk from customers' doorsteps. The respondent's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Operational Postal Grade (18 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
An employment tribunal struck out an unfair dismissal claim after the claimant harassed and intimidated a proposed witness on social media and in person.
Dismissed · Oct 2022Dismissed—Oct 2022Non-executive Director of Sales (15 years' service) v Globalgrange Ltd
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a non-executive director of sales who was sacked for soliciting a fellow employee to join a competitor. His claims of whistleblowing and unfair dismissal were rejected.
Lost · Oct 2022Lost—Oct 2022Cleaner (1 year 1 month service) v Sentrex Services UK Ltd
A cleaner with less than two years' service had her unfair dismissal claim struck out, and her race discrimination claims were later struck out for failing to comply with tribunal orders and not actively pursuing the case.
Dismissed · Oct 2022Dismissed—Oct 2022Former employee v The London Onyx Limited t/a Dubai Lounge
A former employee's unfair dismissal and unpaid wages claim was thrown out after she failed to attend the video hearing and had less than two years' continuous employment.
Dismissed · Oct 2022Dismissed—Oct 2022Former employee (11 months' service) v Mr Jonathan Bailey
A former employee with only 11 months' service had his unfair dismissal claim struck out due to insufficient service, but the tribunal awarded him £2,265.13 for an unlawful wage deduction and breach of contract after his employer dismissed him without notice.
Partial · £2,265 · Sept 2022Partial£2,265Sept 2022Senior practitioner in regional safeguarding unit v Staffordshire County Council
Staffordshire County Council had its defence struck out for persistent failure to comply with tribunal orders, leading to a finding of unfair dismissal and disability discrimination against a senior practitioner with osteoarthritis.
Won · Sept 2022Won—Sept 2022Support worker (5 months' service) v Learning Disability Network London Limited
A support worker who presented her tribunal claim one day before obtaining an ACAS early conciliation certificate had her case dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, despite later rectifying the error.
Dismissed · Sept 2022Dismissed—Sept 2022General assistant (Emirates porterage) / OOG operative v Teamwork UK Limited
A general assistant who admitted he did not check a passenger's boarding pass before processing oversize baggage was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal found the employer acted reasonably throughout.
Lost · Sept 2022Lost—Sept 2022Former employee v Premier Cars Bangor Ltd
A former driver with COPD and back pain was unfairly dismissed and discriminated against by Premier Cars Bangor Ltd. The tribunal awarded £3,230.76 for unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and unpaid holiday pay.
Won · £3,231 · Sept 2022Won£3,231Sept 2022Business Manager and PA (17 years' service) v Lactodorum Contracts Limited
A business manager and PA with 17 years' service was summarily dismissed for alleged gross misconduct without any investigation or hearing. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair and awarded £33,813.
Partial · £33,813 · Sept 2022Partial£33,813Sept 2022Pharmacy assistant (qualified dispenser) v Health Hut Professionals Ltd
A pharmacy assistant was told to hand in her keys and leave after a heated meeting over an anonymous complaint. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair and awarded £9,867 including a 25% ACAS uplift.
Won · £9,868 · Sept 2022Won£9,868Sept 2022Senior Account Manager v Infor (United Kingdom) Limited
A Senior Account Manager who took an unauthorised holiday to Bali was summarily dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected her claims of sex discrimination, victimisation, and whistleblowing.
Lost · Sept 2022Lost—Sept 2022Courier (9 years' service) v ABG Couriers Ltd (in administration)
A courier who was summarily dismissed without notice after 9 years' service has won his unfair dismissal claim, securing over £15,000 in compensation for unpaid wages, notice pay, and holiday pay.
Won · £15,378 · Sept 2022Won£15,378Sept 2022Forklift truck operator (2 years' service) v Plastic Omnium Ltd
A forklift truck operator was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after CCTV footage showed his account of a workplace accident was implausible. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Sept 2022Lost—Sept 2022Bus driver (5 months' service) v Abellio London Ltd
A bus driver with 5 months' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after refusing to return to work during the pandemic. The tribunal rejected his claim of automatic unfair dismissal, ruling he could have reasonably averted the danger by following government guidelines.
Lost · Sept 2022Lost—Sept 2022Former employee v Northfields Liversedge Ltd
A former nursery employee's unfair dismissal and breach of contract claims were dismissed after the tribunal found the correct respondent under TUPE was the successor company, but the claims themselves were not well-founded.
Lost · Sept 2022Lost—Sept 2022Security and maintenance worker (22 years' service) v Seighford Hall Nursing Home Ltd
A security and maintenance worker with 22 years' service was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct, but the tribunal awarded no compensation because he would have been dismissed anyway and contributed to his own dismissal.
Partial · £4,066 · Sept 2022Partial£4,066Sept 2022Healthcare assistant v Orwell Housing Association
A healthcare assistant withdrew her unfair dismissal claim at a tribunal hearing. The tribunal allowed her to change her discrimination claim from race to religion or belief, but refused to add a disability claim.
Dismissed · Sept 2022Dismissed—Sept 2022Former employee v St Vincent de Paul Society (England and Wales)
A former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims have been struck out after she repeatedly failed to comply with tribunal orders to provide further information, despite having legal representation throughout.
Dismissed · Sept 2022Dismissed—Sept 2022Carer (8 years' service) v Natalie Farrar
A carer with eight years' service was awarded over £2,500 after her employer failed to file a response to her tribunal claim, leading to a default judgment.
Won · £2,540 · Sept 2022Won£2,540Sept 2022Headteacher (6 years' service) v Kent Catholic Schools’ Partnership
A headteacher was unfairly dismissed after sharing sensitive pupil data with her husband, but the tribunal found she would have been dismissed anyway with a fair process. No compensation was awarded due to contributory conduct.
Partial · Sept 2022Partial—Sept 2022Former employee v Virgin Media
A former Virgin Media employee had his latest tribunal claims struck out after bringing complaints that had already been decided in previous cases. The tribunal found the claims had no reasonable prospect of success.
Dismissed · Sept 2022Dismissed—Sept 2022Chef (20 hours/week, 3.5 years' service) v The Westerfield Railway Ltd
A chef who asked to be treated as a relief chef and then claimed unfair dismissal when his employment ended has lost his case. The tribunal found the contract ended by mutual agreement.
Lost · Sept 2022Lost—Sept 2022Senior engineer (12 years' service) v Fisk Fire Group Ltd
A senior engineer with 12 years' service was summarily dismissed in a lay-by after falsifying fire alarm test records. The tribunal found the dismissal procedurally unfair but awarded nothing because the engineer was 100% to blame.
Won · £0 · Sept 2022Won£0Sept 2022Territory Sales Specialist (South East of England) v Trudell Medical UK Ltd
A Territory Sales Specialist who claimed he was dismissed for reporting an alleged bribe saw his whistleblowing and unfair dismissal claims rejected after the tribunal found he had not made a protected disclosure.
Lost · Sept 2022Lost—Sept 2022HGV driver (4 years' service) v Port Traction Limited
A tribunal found that Port Traction Limited unfairly dismissed an HGV driver for exceeding driving hours, but reduced compensation to zero because the driver would have been dismissed anyway and contributed to his own dismissal.
Won · Sept 2022Won—Sept 2022Prison officer (2 years' service) v Secretary of State for Justice
A prison officer with two years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after signing off a Category A prisoner's cell without checking it. The tribunal upheld the dismissal as fair but found the prison failed to make reasonable adjustments by not providing a mentor.
Partial · Sept 2022Partial—Sept 2022Postman and Health and Safety/Union Representative (18 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A postman with 18 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to apply the HIT procedure, causing a vehicle to roll into a parked car. The tribunal upheld the dismissal as within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Sept 2022Lost—Sept 2022Homeless Social Practitioner (social worker, 18 years' service) v Oxford Health NHS Foundation Trust
A homeless social practitioner with 18 years' service was fairly dismissed after he falsely represented himself as a substance user at a police station, while still under a final written warning for a previous boundary breach.
Lost · Sept 2022Lost—Sept 2022IT consultant (web development) v Puma Solutions IT Consultancy Limited
A tribunal struck out the employer's response and awarded £7,119.71 for unfair dismissal after the company failed to comply with directions and did not attend the hearing.
Won · £7,120 · Sept 2022Won£7,120Sept 2022Production operator (also known as production planner) v 4BG Group
A production operator who asked a colleague to clock her in early was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected her unfair dismissal claim, finding the employer's investigation and decision were reasonable.
Lost · Sept 2022Lost—Sept 2022Former employee v Kisiel Limited
A default judgment of £23,238.49 was set aside because the employer had actually submitted its response by the extended deadline, even though the tribunal had not processed it before issuing judgment.
Remitted · Sept 2022Remitted—Sept 2022Assistant store manager (15 years' service) v Next Retail Ltd
A Next assistant store manager with 15 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after repeatedly bypassing cash-handling procedures to process refunds. The tribunal rejected her unfair dismissal claim.
Lost · Sept 2022Lost—Sept 2022Former employee v Decorative Panels Furniture Limited
A former employee who refused to return to work due to a belief in serious and imminent danger was dismissed for conduct. The tribunal rejected claims of automatic unfair dismissal and detriment.
Lost · Sept 2022Lost—Sept 2022Security officer (14 years' service) v Profile Security Services Limited
A security officer with 14 years' service was unfairly dismissed after attending work while awaiting a Covid-19 test result. The tribunal found the investigation was flawed and the outcome predetermined.
Won · Sept 2022Won—Sept 2022Former employee v JCB Cabs System
A former employee who was dismissed for gross misconduct after two colleagues alleged inappropriate touching has lost his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal found the employer's decision was within the range of reasonable responses, and the claimant's late disclosure of his autism did not make the dismissal unfair.
Lost · Aug 2022Lost—Aug 2022Apprentice barber (later stylist) v Mr Mark Brown t/a Strongman Moustache
An apprentice barber who was summarily dismissed for soliciting clients and setting up a rival business failed to prove his dismissal was due to whistleblowing. The tribunal awarded £1,431 for unauthorised wage deductions.
Partial · £1,431 · Aug 2022Partial£1,431Aug 2022Electrical Repairs and Maintenance Manager (acting) v Gentoo Group Limited
A manager with 19 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct over an electrical safety classification. The tribunal found the dismissal substantively fair but procedurally unfair because the appeal was heard by one manager instead of the required two-person panel.
Partial · £14,823 · Aug 2022Partial£14,823Aug 2022Cleaning operative (15 hours/week) v TC Facilities Management Ltd
A cleaning operative was unfairly dismissed after refusing to attend mediation with a co-worker who had called him a 'golliwog' and 'cheeky monkey'. The tribunal awarded £29,251 in compensation.
Partial · £29,251 · Aug 2022Partial£29,251Aug 2022Community healthcare professional (HCPC-registered) v Northern Care Alliance NHS Foundation Trust
A community healthcare professional was unfairly dismissed by Northern Care Alliance NHS Foundation Trust after a biased investigation into an allegation he tried to film a colleague in the ladies' toilets. The tribunal awarded £21,469.59.
Won · £21,470 · Aug 2022Won£21,470Aug 2022Former employee v Shoosmiths LLP
A former employee had his unfair dismissal claim struck out after telling the tribunal he could not play cricket due to disability, when in fact he played cricket in 2021. The tribunal found he deliberately misled the court.
Dismissed · Aug 2022Dismissed—Aug 2022Caretaker (16 hours per week, 5 years' service) v Fordbridge Town Council
A part-time caretaker was unfairly dismissed by Fordbridge Town Council after a disciplinary panel included the wife of a complainant and an appeal panel included the husband of a witness. The tribunal awarded £1,060.41.
Won · £1,060 · Aug 2022Won£1,060Aug 2022Customer Assistant – Self Service (part-time, one day a week) v Tesco Stores Ltd
A part-time customer assistant with 27 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after Tesco mistakenly believed she was absent without leave when she was actually on approved annual leave. The tribunal awarded £4,934.18 in compensation.
Won · £4,934 · Aug 2022Won£4,934Aug 2022Plaster technician/orthopaedic practitioner (11 years' service) v James Paget University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
A plaster technician with 11 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a disciplinary panel imposed a final written warning and redeployment, but an appeal panel restricted redeployment to non-clinical roles without consulting him. Tribunal awarded £22,335.09.
Won · £22,335 · Aug 2022Won£22,335Aug 2022Team Leader (Covid testing station) v Commisceo Primary Care Solutions Limited
A team leader who alleged he was dismissed because of his race had his claim struck out after missing two preliminary hearings and failing to respond to tribunal correspondence.
Dismissed · Aug 2022Dismissed—Aug 2022Health Care Assistant (HCA) (night shifts) v Brooklands Care Home Limited
A care home assistant was unfairly dismissed after an inadequate investigation into allegations of misconduct. The tribunal dismissed her race discrimination claims but upheld a complaint about missing written employment particulars.
Partial · Aug 2022Partial—Aug 2022Senior advisor to MP (17 years' service) v Mr Khalid Mahmood MP
A senior advisor with 17 years' service was unfairly dismissed by her MP boss after making protected disclosures about misuse of parliamentary stationery and alleged criminal activity. The tribunal awarded £11,729.99 in compensation, reduced by 75% for contributory fault and a Polkey deduction.
Partial · £11,730 · Aug 2022Partial£11,730Aug 2022Contracts manager (less than 2 years' service) v Building Product Solutions Limited
A contracts manager who resigned after a grievance outcome had his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims thrown out because he did not attend the preliminary hearing.
Dismissed · Aug 2022Dismissed—Aug 2022Security officer (17 years' service) v LHR Airports Limited
A security officer with Asperger's Syndrome was unfairly dismissed after raising a grievance about a manager, who then counter-claimed that the complaint was false and vexatious. The tribunal found the investigation biased and the dismissal procedurally unfair.
Won · Jul 2022Won—Jul 2022Hair salon employee v Mrs L Trill t/a Thairapy Hair Design
A hair salon employee was fairly dismissed after her husband sent 41 threatening texts to the owner. The tribunal dismissed her unfair dismissal and holiday pay claims, and considered a costs application.
Dismissed · Jul 2022Dismissed—Jul 2022Former employee v Teleperformance Limited
A former employee's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims have been struck out after they failed to comply with an unless order and did not attend a case management hearing. No compensation was awarded.
Dismissed · Jul 2022Dismissed—Jul 2022Night manager (reception) v Heathrow Hotel Limited
A night manager who left the reception desk for three hours, allowing a minibus to be stolen, was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected claims of unfair dismissal, race discrimination, and unlawful deduction of wages.
Lost · Jul 2022Lost—Jul 2022Customer Service Security Officer (7 years 9 months' service) v Wilson James Limited
A security officer who stopped attending work to care for his vulnerable mother was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal found the employer acted reasonably in dismissing for unauthorised absence, but awarded £195.72 for unpaid holiday pay.
Partial · £196 · Jul 2022Partial£196Jul 2022Personal Adviser (8 years' service) v Department for Work & Pensions
A Personal Adviser with 8 years' service was unfairly dismissed after the DWP investigated her LinkedIn profile and found she had been working without permission during carers leave. The tribunal awarded £2,263.52.
Partial · £2,264 · Jul 2022Partial£2,264Jul 2022Employee (20 years' service) v London Borough of Newham
An employee with 20 years' service was fairly dismissed for unauthorised absence after failing to maintain contact while overseas. The tribunal rejected claims of unfair and wrongful dismissal.
Lost · Jul 2022Lost—Jul 2022Running Shift Service Engineer (16 years' service) v Metroline Travel Limited
A tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a bus engineer with 16 years' service who told a driver to continue driving despite a brake shudder. The decision confirms that safety-critical roles require strict compliance.
Lost · Jul 2022Lost—Jul 2022Sales director (self-employed services provider) v Bayleaf Janitorial Supplies Limited
A sales director who provided services as a self-employed worker was dismissed by telephone in July 2020. The tribunal ruled his unfair dismissal claim was presented too late and he was not an employee.
Dismissed · Jul 2022Dismissed—Jul 2022Former employee (4 years' service) v Shuropody Retail Ltd
A former employee of Shuropody Retail Ltd has been awarded £17,355.27 after the tribunal found the company made unauthorised wage deductions, failed to pay holiday pay, and unfairly dismissed her.
Won · £17,355 · Jul 2022Won£17,355Jul 2022Security Guard (3 years' service) v Sentinel Group Security Ltd
A security guard who was dismissed for gross misconduct after leaving his site early had his unfair dismissal claim rejected because he presented it 11 days after the three-month time limit. The tribunal said ignorance of the deadline was not a reasonable excuse.
Dismissed · Jul 2022Dismissed—Jul 2022Director and shareholder (19 years' service) v Lowther Decorators Limited
A director with 19 years' service was summarily dismissed for gross misconduct after withdrawing company funds, but the employer carried out no investigation or disciplinary hearing. The tribunal awarded £68,048.
Won · £68,048 · Jul 2022Won£68,048Jul 2022Former employee v Wilkinson Retail Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claim was struck out after he repeatedly failed to comply with tribunal orders over two years. The tribunal found a fair hearing was no longer possible.
Dismissed · Jul 2022Dismissed—Jul 2022Former employee v Tees Valley Community Asset Preservation Trust
A tribunal found that Tees Valley Community Asset Preservation Trust underpaid a former employee for weekend shifts, failed to pay Sunday premiums, notice pay, and holiday pay. The unfair dismissal claim was dismissed.
Partial · Jul 2022Partial—Jul 2022Decorator (3 years' service) v Bell Decorating Group
A decorator with three years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after an anonymous HSE complaint alleged he urinated behind a customer's shed. The tribunal upheld the dismissal, finding the employer's investigation and belief were reasonable.
Lost · Jul 2022Lost—Jul 2022Bus driver (Stagecoach Manchester) v Greater Manchester Buses South LTD t/a Stagecoach Manchester
A bus driver was unfairly dismissed by Stagecoach Manchester, but the tribunal reduced his compensation by 75% because his own conduct contributed to the dismissal. He received a total of £4,306.62 including damages for wrongful dismissal.
Won · £4,307 · Jul 2022Won£4,307Jul 2022Carer v Alliance Point Limited
A carer with 10 years' service was unfairly dismissed without any disciplinary procedure. The tribunal awarded £16,064.63, including an uplift for failing to follow the ACAS Code.
Won · £16,065 · Jul 2022Won£16,065Jul 2022Locum consultant psychiatrist v Medecho Ltd and Gloucestershire Health and Care NHS Foundation Trust (formerly 2Gether NHS Foundation Trust)
A locum consultant psychiatrist who was summarily dismissed after three days when the NHS Trust discovered he was subject to GMC proceedings had his claim against the Trust dismissed as out of time.
Dismissed · Jul 2022Dismissed—Jul 2022Secretary/administrator (job-share, 4 days a week) v Building Services (Kent) Ltd
A secretary/administrator was dismissed via text message without notice or reason. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair and awarded over £6,000 in compensation and holiday pay.
Won · £6,044 · Jul 2022Won£6,044Jul 2022Groundworker v Tallington Lakes Activities Limited; Tallington Lakes Site Limited; Tallington Lakes Land Limited; Neil Morgan
A groundworker who was unfairly dismissed has been awarded over £5,000 in costs after the employer's abusive and disruptive behaviour during proceedings. The tribunal found the conduct was unreasonable and warranted a costs order.
Won · £5,055 · Jul 2022Won£5,055Jul 2022Greggs Franchise Manager (6 months' service) v Euro Garages Ltd
A Greggs franchise manager with six months' service was wrongfully dismissed when his employer failed to pay one week's notice. He was awarded £346 but his other claims – including race discrimination – were dismissed.
Partial · £346 · Jul 2022Partial£346Jul 2022Apprentice bricklayer v Fosters Building Contractors Limited
An apprentice bricklayer was unfairly dismissed after using his mobile phone on scaffolding. The tribunal found the employer failed to carry out any investigation or disciplinary hearing.
Won · £1,939 · Jun 2022Won£1,939Jun 2022Postwoman (20 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
A postwoman with 20 years' service was dismissed for breaking COVID self-isolation rules, but her unfair dismissal claim was rejected because she filed it too late. The tribunal also refused to add a disability discrimination claim.
Dismissed · Jun 2022Dismissed—Jun 2022Campus support officers v Kirklees College
Two campus support officers claimed unfair dismissal and discrimination after a restructure introduced Saturday working. The tribunal struck out most claims, allowing only one ordinary unfair dismissal claim to proceed.
Dismissed · Jun 2022Dismissed—Jun 2022Field sales retail development executive (7 years' service) v CPM UK Ltd
A field sales executive with 7 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after deliberately misrecording stock availability to generate bonus payments. The tribunal rejected his claims of unfair dismissal and age discrimination.
Lost · Jun 2022Lost—Jun 2022Customer Service Assistant (14 years' service) v Tesco Stores Limited
A 14-year Tesco employee who withdrew his unfair dismissal claim and repeatedly abused tribunal staff had his remaining discrimination claims struck out. No compensation was awarded.
Dismissed · Jun 2022Dismissed—Jun 2022Bus driver (2 years' service) v Metroline West Limited
A bus driver with two years' service was fairly dismissed for making an aggressive phone call to a controller while on a final written warning. The tribunal rejected his claims of race discrimination and victimisation.
Lost · Jun 2022Lost—Jun 2022Legal executive (CILEX) specialising in residential conveyancing v ODT Professional Services Limited
A legal executive was unfairly dismissed by ODT Professional Services Limited after a disciplinary process that the tribunal found fundamentally unfair. She was awarded £2,621.57 after reductions for contributory fault and the chance she would have been dismissed anyway.
Partial · Jun 2022Partial—Jun 2022Branch Sales Co-ordinator (8 years' service) v CCF Ltd
A branch sales co-ordinator with 8 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after sending a series of inappropriate emails to senior staff, the Watford Employment Tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Jun 2022Lost—Jun 2022Former employee v Old Macmillan Company Ltd
A former employee who resigned with immediate effect and later declined to attend the final hearing had all claims for notice pay, wages, and holiday pay dismissed by the tribunal.
Lost · Jun 2022Lost—Jun 2022Development project co-ordinator (26 years' service) v South Yorkshire Housing Association
A development project co-ordinator with 26 years' service was fairly dismissed for sending 11 confidential documents to his personal email and forwarding them to a former colleague at a competitor. The Sheffield tribunal upheld the employer's decision.
Lost · Jun 2022Lost—Jun 2022Consultant Colorectal Surgeon v Hywel Dda University Health Board
An employment tribunal dismissed all claims of unfair dismissal, race discrimination and victimisation brought by a consultant colorectal surgeon against Hywel Dda University Health Board following a lengthy disciplinary process.
Lost · Jun 2022Lost—Jun 2022Supermarket assistant (17 years' service) v John Lewis PLC
A supermarket assistant with 17 years' service was unfairly dismissed after sending bizarre text messages to his manager. The tribunal awarded £33,232.48, finding the employer's investigation was inadequate.
Won · £33,232 · May 2022Won£33,232May 2022Grade 5 Analyst on Operation Stovewood v National Crime Agency
A Grade 5 analyst at the National Crime Agency was unfairly dismissed after making allegedly racist comments during a training event. The tribunal found the process was flawed by an initial promise of informal resolution and a 16-month delay, but reduced compensation due to her own conduct.
Won · £7,321 · May 2022Won£7,321May 2022Former employee v Digital Grading Studio Limited
A former employee of Digital Grading Studio Limited has won her claim for sex discrimination after a remark made during a stressful meeting. She was also awarded holiday pay, notice pay, and compensation for unfair dismissal, totalling £2,989.36.
Partial · £2,989 · May 2022Partial£2,989May 2022Driving examiner (10 years' service) v Department of Transport
A driving examiner with 10 years' service was unfairly dismissed for taking a photo of his manager's notebook. The tribunal ordered reinstatement with a £113,585 payment, but reduced the award by 33% for his own fault.
Partial · May 2022Partial—May 2022Senior Lecturer and Course Director, MA Planning, Policy and Practice (27 years' service) v London South Bank University
A senior lecturer and course director with 27 years' service was fairly dismissed for bullying and harassment after a lengthy internal process. The tribunal rejected all claims of race discrimination, victimisation, and whistleblowing detriment.
Lost · May 2022Lost—May 2022HGV driver (6 months' service) v The Haulage (Holdings) Organisation Limited
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of an HGV driver with six months' service who failed to report two spillages and was found to have damaged a tachograph and deleted dashcam footage after a third incident.
Lost · May 2022Lost—May 2022Night Support Worker v Parkcare Homes (No. 2) Limited
A care home worker who pushed a resident with autism was unfairly dismissed because the employer failed to hold a disciplinary hearing or consider an appeal. The tribunal awarded £2,436.73, reduced by 75% for his misconduct.
Partial · £2,437 · Apr 2022Partial£2,437Apr 2022Deputy Store Manager (10 years' service) v Asda Stores Ltd
An Asda deputy store manager with 10 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after asking a 15-year-old customer for her phone number, the Watford Employment Tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Apr 2022Lost—Apr 2022Concierge (15 years' service); Security officer/Contractor liaison coordinator (7 years); Assistant security manager (10 years); Security officer (3 years) v Knightsbridge Residents Management Company Limited
Four employees dismissed for posting a thumbs up emoji in a WhatsApp group were unfairly dismissed, the tribunal has ruled. The employer had no reasonable grounds to believe its policies were breached.
Won · Apr 2022Won—Apr 2022Former employee v Tesco Stores Limited
A former employee who did not attend his final hearing due to work commitments had his unfair dismissal and discrimination claims dismissed by the tribunal. The respondent's application for costs was later refused.
Dismissed · Mar 2022Dismissed—Mar 2022Production Operative/Assembly Worker (5 years' service) v GI Group Recruitment Limited
A production operative with five years' service was unfairly dismissed for briefly visiting his car during a break. The tribunal found the employer failed to investigate his claim that leaving site was common practice, and the dismissing officer lacked impartiality.
Partial · £16,917 · Mar 2022Partial£16,917Mar 2022Senior Pastor (33 years' service) v The Church of God Prophecy (Trust)
A senior pastor who held a personal belief that women should not preach to men was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after creating an environment where women were denied the opportunity to preach. The tribunal upheld the church's decision.
Lost · Mar 2022Lost—Mar 2022Fitter/mechanic (5 months' service) v Star Multifuels
A fitter/mechanic with only five months' service was summarily dismissed for declaring a fuel trailer roadworthy when it was not. The tribunal upheld the dismissal, finding his actions amounted to gross misconduct.
Lost · Mar 2022Lost—Mar 2022Operational Postal Grade (OPG) v Royal Mail Group Ltd
An OPG was fairly dismissed after twice being caught smoking in a Royal Mail van. The tribunal upheld the decision because he had admitted the conduct and been warned before.
Lost · Mar 2022Lost—Mar 2022Chief Revenue Officer and 50% shareholder v Cryoaction Limited
A director and 50% shareholder was wrongfully and unfairly dismissed after temporarily bypassing a safety system during commissioning. The tribunal awarded £15,028 but reduced compensation because his employment would have ended fairly within six months.
Partial · £15,028 · Mar 2022Partial£15,028Mar 2022Fashion graphic designer (2 years' service) v UBI Limited
A fashion graphic designer with less than two years' service was dismissed for performance and conduct issues, not for raising health and safety concerns about returning to work during the pandemic. The tribunal rejected her claims of automatic unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.
Lost · Feb 2022Lost—Feb 2022Consultant Radiologist (breast imaging) v University Hospitals Bristol and Weston NHS Foundation Trust
A consultant radiologist who raised patient safety concerns was unfairly dismissed by University Hospitals Bristol and Weston NHS Foundation Trust. The tribunal found the process was flawed because he was not warned that a breakdown in relationships could lead to dismissal.
Partial · Feb 2022Partial—Feb 2022Former employee v Priory Group
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Priory Group was back on track after the tribunal revoked a strike-out, finding the employer had not received correspondence due to an email address error.
Remitted · Feb 2022Remitted—Feb 2022Customer Adviser (4.5 years' service) v HBOS Plc
A customer adviser with 4.5 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after two elderly customers reported cash shortfalls following transactions he processed. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision.
Lost · Jan 2022Lost—Jan 2022Customer service advisor (10 years' service) v London Borough of Havering Council
A customer service advisor with 10 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after obtaining a resident's parking permit for an address where he did not live. The tribunal found the council's investigation and decision were within the range of reasonable responses.
Lost · Jan 2022Lost—Jan 2022Registered nurse (night shifts, neuro-disability ward) v The Royal Hospital for Neuro-Disability
A registered nurse with limited English was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct after the Royal Hospital for Neuro-Disability failed to provide an interpreter at his disciplinary hearing. The tribunal also found indirect race discrimination.
Partial · Jan 2022Partial—Jan 2022Practice nurse (46 years' nursing experience, 10 as practice nurse) v Mr Mark Moss, as personal representative of the estate of Dr Paul Moss, formerly t/a North Shoebury Surgery
A practice nurse with 46 years' experience was unfairly dismissed due to a flawed disciplinary process, but the tribunal found she would have been dismissed anyway and reduced her compensation by 60% for her own conduct. She was awarded £1,610.66.
Partial · £1,611 · Jan 2022Partial£1,611Jan 2022Security officer (10 years' service) v Securitas Security Services (UK) Ltd
A security officer with 10 years' service was fairly dismissed after attending work with a cough and later testing positive for Covid-19. The tribunal upheld the employer's decision, finding the investigation and disciplinary process were reasonable.
Lost · Jan 2022Lost—Jan 2022Medical secretary v Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust
A medical secretary who refused a management instruction to move offices and was verbally aggressive was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal rejected her claims of race discrimination and victimisation.
Lost · Jan 2022Lost—Jan 2022Senior lecturer in physics (30 years' service) v University of Exeter
A senior physics lecturer at the University of Exeter has been awarded £100,969.78 after an employment tribunal found her dismissal for gross misconduct was unfair and that she was harassed for raising unconscious bias concerns.
Partial · £100,970 · Dec 2021Partial£100,970Dec 2021Customer Assistant (9 years' service) v Marks and Spencer Plc
A Marks and Spencer customer assistant with nine years' service was unfairly dismissed for alleged theft after a seriously flawed investigation. The tribunal awarded £10,309.86.
Won · £10,310 · Dec 2021Won£10,310Dec 2021Compliance Manager (7 years' service) v Lean Education and Development Limited
A compliance manager with 7 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after being demoted and raising a grievance. The tribunal found the real reason was a mix of poor performance and the grievance, not misconduct, and awarded £11,885.
Won · £11,886 · Dec 2021Won£11,886Dec 2021Team Leader (Hot End) (36 years' service) v Pilkington UK Limited
A team leader with 36 years' service was unfairly dismissed after covert surveillance showed him helping at a farm while on sick leave. The tribunal found the employer's procedure was flawed and the decision unreasonable.
Won · Dec 2021Won—Dec 2021Border Readiness Operative (less than 2 years' service) v MITIE Ltd
A Border Readiness Operative with less than two years' service was dismissed for being absent without leave after his authorised childcare leave ended. The tribunal upheld the dismissal, finding it was not automatically unfair.
Lost · Nov 2021Lost—Nov 2021Team Leader Track Inspections (safety critical role, managing 12 colleagues) v Network Rail Infrastructure Ltd
A team leader at Network Rail was unfairly dismissed after a flawed drug and alcohol test failed to account for his undiagnosed medical condition. The tribunal ordered reinstatement, which the employer refused, leading to a compensation award of £89,861.86.
Won · £89,862 · Nov 2021Won£89,862Nov 2021Regional Organiser (5 years' service) v UNISON
A regional organiser who was arrested in Tenerife for breaching Spain's COVID lockdown and then gave media interviews against instructions was fairly dismissed by UNISON, the tribunal has ruled.
Lost · Nov 2021Lost—Nov 2021Business development manager (senior, 4 years' service) v Ground Control Limited
A business development manager was unfairly dismissed after an anonymous allegation that he tried to poach colleagues. The tribunal found the investigation was inadequate and the real reason was his report on team morale.
Won · £24,025 · Nov 2021Won£24,025Nov 2021Rigger (2 years' service) v Cape Environmental Services Limited t/a Altrad Services
A rigger with two years' service was unfairly dismissed after an investigation relied on an anonymous witness who refused to provide a statement. The tribunal awarded £39,330.
Won · £39,330 · Sept 2021Won£39,330Sept 2021Assistant solicitor v Spring And Co Solicitors Ltd
An assistant solicitor was unfairly dismissed after being refused a postponement despite a fit note, but his award was cut by 50% for his own conduct. He received £1,177.51.
Won · £1,178 · Sept 2021Won£1,178Sept 2021Team Leader (care sector) v Lifeway Community Care Ltd
A care sector Team Leader who took a career break and then refused to return to work has lost his unfair dismissal and discrimination claims. The tribunal found he fabricated grievance documents to bolster his case.
Lost · Sept 2021Lost—Sept 2021General business administration role with some HR functions (14 years' service) v Hafod Care Organisation Limited
A tribunal found that a care organisation unfairly dismissed a long-serving employee for gross misconduct after a flawed investigation into a reference she provided. The employee was awarded £13,578.56.
Won · £13,579 · Sept 2021Won£13,579Sept 2021Administrative Officer (AO) National, Child Support Agency v Department for Work and Pensions
An administrative officer was unfairly dismissed after attending a trade union conference while on sick leave and sending an email about a colleague. The tribunal found the process flawed and ordered re-engagement with a 30% reduction for contributory fault.
Partial · Aug 2021Partial—Aug 2021CEO and co-founder v Peoples Coffee Ltd
A co-founder and CEO who was summarily dismissed for gross misconduct after a disciplinary meeting he did not attend has won his unfair dismissal claim. The tribunal awarded him over £41,000 in compensation.
Won · £41,728 · Jul 2021Won£41,728Jul 2021Full-time union official (firefighter on release) v Fire Brigades Union
A full-time union official was unfairly dismissed by the Fire Brigades Union after speaking at a Leave Means Leave rally. The tribunal awarded £8,308.45 in compensation.
Partial · £8,308 · Jul 2021Partial£8,308Jul 2021Store manager (4 months' service) v H2C Gelati Ltd t/a Amorino
A store manager with four months' service was summarily dismissed for gross misconduct after a freezer temperature issue. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair and ordered the employer to pay over £1,500 for unpaid suspension and holiday pay.
Partial · £1,540 · Jun 2021Partial£1,540Jun 2021Service desk consultant (IT help desk, 12-hour shifts) v Intergence Systems Limited
An IT help desk consultant was unfairly dismissed after her employer caved to client pressure following a missed handover email. The tribunal awarded £10,787.47, reduced by a third for her own fault.
Partial · £10,787 · May 2021Partial£10,787May 2021Former employee v ISS Facility Services Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after they repeatedly failed to comply with case management orders and missed a deadline to respond to a strike-out application. The tribunal also refused a later request to reconsider the decision.
Dismissed · Apr 2021Dismissed—Apr 2021Carer for brother with mental health conditions (5 years' service) v Mrs. Naima El-Alaoui
A tribunal found that a carer for his brother was unfairly dismissed after he raised concerns about how family finances were being managed, awarding over £7,000 in compensation.
Won · £7,026 · Mar 2021Won£7,026Mar 2021Consultant obstetrician and gynaecologists v Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust
Two long-serving consultant gynaecologists were unfairly dismissed by Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust, but the tribunal awarded no compensation because they would have been dismissed anyway and were wholly at fault.
Partial · Feb 2021Partial—Feb 2021Former employee v Dar Corporation Ltd
A former employee was unfairly dismissed by Dar Corporation Ltd and awarded £6,320.60, including unpaid holiday pay and notice pay.
Won · £6,321 · Feb 2021Won£6,321Feb 2021Employee (sales and administrative duties, 8 years' service) v Mr X Zheng
An employee with 8 years' service was constructively dismissed after his employer withheld sales commission and gave him an ultimatum to pay money or be treated as resigned. The tribunal awarded £55,267.37.
Won · £55,267 · Feb 2021Won£55,267Feb 2021Night receptionist (6 years' service) v Care Property Management Ltd
A night receptionist with six years' service was suspended without pay and later dismissed without any disciplinary hearing. The tribunal awarded £19,276 in compensation and applied a 25% uplift for breaching the ACAS Code.
Won · £19,276 · Jan 2021Won£19,276Jan 2021Buyer (6.5 months' service) v Johnson Matthey plc
A buyer who was dismissed after just six and a half months for performance and attendance issues lost her claims of automatic unfair dismissal, race and sex discrimination, harassment and victimisation.
Lost · Dec 2020Lost—Dec 2020Group Finance Director and Company Secretary v The Character Group plc
The tribunal dismissed claims of automatic unfair dismissal and detriment from a Group Finance Director who alleged he was sacked for whistleblowing. The disclosures were not in the public interest, and the dismissal was fair.
Lost · Nov 2020Lost—Nov 2020Consultant Paediatric Neurologist v University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust
A consultant paediatric neurologist who made multiple whistleblowing allegations was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. His repeated attempts to reopen the case using a Serious Untoward Incident Report failed, and he was ordered to pay over £83,000 in costs.
Lost · Mar 2020Lost—Mar 2020General Manager, building services and industry, UK and Ireland (RS); Managing Director of sales and marketing (DL) v Xylem Water Solutions UK Limited
Two long-serving managers were unfairly dismissed for offensive WhatsApp messages, but a tribunal awarded no compensation because they would have been sacked anyway and their conduct contributed fully.
Partial · Mar 2020Partial—Mar 2020Former employee v Priory Education Services Ltd
A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out because her legal representative failed to provide medical evidence as ordered. The tribunal refused to reconsider and ordered the representative to pay £11,906.17 in wasted costs.
Dismissed · Mar 2020Dismissed—Mar 2020Head of Financial Audit (8 years' service) v Gulf International Bank (UK) Limited
An employment tribunal found that Gulf International Bank (UK) Limited unfairly dismissed its Head of Financial Audit after a conflict with the Head of Legal, awarding £87,693.83 including a 25% ACAS uplift.
Partial · £87,694 · Mar 2020Partial£87,694Mar 2020Newly Qualified Social Worker (ASYE programme) v London Borough of Croydon
A newly qualified social worker was awarded £1,500 for injury to feelings after a without prejudice meeting was used to victimise her, but her unfair dismissal claim over tenancy and DBS fraud allegations was rejected.
Partial · £1,500 · Feb 2020Partial£1,500Feb 2020Catering staff (patient catering) v Oxford University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
Two catering staff were dismissed for an alleged assault that CCTV footage did not capture. The tribunal found the investigation flawed and ruled the dismissals unfair — one was also wrongfully dismissed.
Partial · Dec 2019Partial—Dec 2019Head teacher (primary school) v The Governing Body of Tywyn Primary School
A primary school head teacher was constructively unfairly dismissed and directly discriminated against because of his sexual orientation after consensual contact with two 17-year-olds via Grindr. The tribunal awarded £696,255.65.
Won · £696,256 · Nov 2019Won£696,256Nov 2019Support Worker v Dimensions (UK) Ltd
A support worker who claimed he was unfairly dismissed after allegedly threatening a colleague with a gun has lost his case. The tribunal found the employer's investigation and dismissal were reasonable.
Lost · Jun 2019Lost—Jun 2019Bus driver v Abellio London Ltd
A bus driver who twice failed to service the first stop on his route was fairly dismissed, the Watford Employment Tribunal has ruled. No compensation was awarded.
Lost · May 2018Lost—May 2018Business Line Leader/Global Sales Director (23 years' service) v Matcon Limited
A long-serving sales director was unfairly dismissed after instructing a customer to backdate a contract under pressure from his managing director. The tribunal found the investigation and appeal process were flawed.
Won · Mar 2018Won—Mar 2018Domestic cleaner (11 years' service) v Leicester City Council
A Leicester City Council cleaner with 11 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after a colleague secretly recorded her using racist language. The tribunal found the dismissal procedurally unfair but awarded no compensation because she would have been dismissed anyway.
Partial · Feb 2018Partial—Feb 2018Consultant emergency surgeon v The Ipswich Hospitals NHS Trust
An employment tribunal has upheld the dismissal of a consultant emergency surgeon by The Ipswich Hospitals NHS Trust for gross misconduct, finding the trust's disciplinary process fair and rejecting claims of whistleblowing detriment and discrimination.
Lost · Aug 2017Lost—Aug 2017
