2022

Complaints Resolution Manager (6 years' service) v E.ON UK PLC

A Complaints Resolution Manager was fairly dismissed after closing 81 complaints but making only 15 outbound calls. The tribunal upheld E.ON's decision, finding the investigation and dismissal were reasonable.

Medical Laboratory Assistant (22 years' service) v University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust

A Medical Laboratory Assistant with 22 years' service had his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims dismissed by an employment tribunal because they were presented about four months after the legal deadline, despite his serious health issues.

Former employee (12 years' service) v Owen Owen (Western) Ltd (in liquidation)

A former employee with 12 years' service was unfairly dismissed by reason of redundancy, but a 100% Polkey deduction meant no compensatory award. The tribunal awarded £4,362.20 for redundancy, unpaid wages, holiday pay, and other losses.

Out-of-hours call centre supervisor (4 months' service) v Healthbridge Direct

An out-of-hours call centre supervisor with four months' service was dismissed for redundancy during the pandemic. The tribunal found that, although she had made one protected disclosure, it was not the reason she lost her job.

Mystery shopper (worker) v My View Ltd

Four mystery shoppers who lost their jobs when Douglas Stafford Ltd collapsed failed to prove their contracts transferred to My View Ltd. The tribunal found no transfer of an undertaking, dismissing their claims for unpaid wages and holiday pay.

Butcher (12 years' service) v Bicks Chicks Ltd

A butcher with 12 years' service was summarily dismissed for coming to work after testing positive for COVID-19. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair but reduced compensation by 75% for contributory fault.

PR and Community Manager v Arjuna Seth Shoes Limited

An employment tribunal struck out a former PR and community manager's claims of sexual harassment and victimisation after she failed to pursue them for over two and a half years, following the respondent's liquidation.

Security officer v Amberstone Security Limited

A security officer was unfairly dismissed by Amberstone Security Limited in a flawed redundancy process, but his age discrimination claim was rejected. He was awarded £5,807.14, but also ordered to pay £1,796.26 in costs.

Office administrator (2 years' service) v Links Waste Management Ltd. t/a JM Waste Management

An office administrator with two years' service was unfairly dismissed after being told she was not an 'A player'. The tribunal awarded £3,809.67, including an ACAS uplift for failing to follow a fair procedure.

Train manager (32 years' service) v London Underground Limited

A train manager with 32 years' service was unfairly dismissed for posting racially divisive social media messages about George Floyd, but the tribunal found she would have been dismissed anyway and cut her award by 75% for her own conduct.

Former employee v Hayre Builders Company Limited

A Reading tribunal awarded a former employee £178,199.82 after finding he was unfairly dismissed, with the employer failing to provide a written statement of particulars and unreasonably ignoring the Acas Code.

Former employee (17 years' service) v Rayhome Limited

A former employee with 17 years' service was awarded over £20,000 after her employer failed to pay wages, notice pay, holiday pay, and pension contributions upon redundancy.

Petrol station employee (17 years' service) v AKS Forcort Limited

A petrol station employee with 17 years' service was automatically unfairly dismissed when the incoming operator refused to hire her. The tribunal awarded £29,242.10, with the transferee held solely liable.

Former employee v FPM Foods Ltd

An employment tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal claim after the former employee failed to attend the final hearing and made a last-minute adjournment request with no prior notice.

Former employee v New Platt Motors Ltd

A tribunal refused to reconsider a consent judgment after the employer alleged pressure, but provided no evidence. The former employee will receive £3,000.

Former employee (redundancy) v Nationwide Accident Repair Services Ltd (in administration)

A former employee of Nationwide Accident Repair Services has been awarded a protective award of 90 days' pay after the company failed to consult properly on mass redundancies. His unfair dismissal claim was later struck out because the company was in administration.

Clinical Programme Lead (7 years' service) v NHS Sussex Integrated Care Board

A Clinical Programme Lead who worked for the NHS for seven years under successive 'contract for services' agreements has been found to be an employee and unfairly dismissed in a redundancy restructure. She was awarded £25,000.

Former employee (7 years' service) v Constanter Limited

An employee with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed by reason of redundancy and awarded over £7,500 for breach of contract, redundancy payment, and unpaid holiday pay.

Business Development Manager (8 years' service) v FMG Repair Services Ltd

Three of seven employees found to have transferred under TUPE when part of their employer's business was sold out of administration. The tribunal examined assignment of roaming, multi-site workers.

Former employee v Kirwan and Sons Limited

A former employee was unfairly dismissed and awarded over £7,600 in compensation after her employer failed to pay redundancy, notice, holiday pay, and statutory sick pay.

Former employee v RSL Distribution Limited

Four former employees of RSL Distribution Limited have been awarded redundancy payments totalling over £26,000 after the company failed to defend the claim. Other claims were dismissed as out of time.

Driver of 7.5 tonne vehicles (7 years' service) v Halls Distribution Ltd

A driver with 7 years' service was unfairly dismissed after a road traffic accident when his employer failed to contest his claims. The tribunal awarded £5,586.99.

Kitchen Assistant/Relief Cook (16 years' service) v Thames Reach Charity

A kitchen assistant with 16 years' service had her disability discrimination claim struck out after failing to comply with a deposit order. The tribunal found no reasonable excuse for non-payment.

Cleaner (8 years' service) v Hallgarth Court Residents Limited

A cleaner who worked for eight years but was never paid for holidays won £162.71 in holiday pay after the tribunal ruled she was a worker, not an employee.

Sewing Machinist (7 years' service) v Sew On and Sew Forth Limited

A Norwich tribunal awarded £20,891.76 to a sewing machinist who was unfairly selected for redundancy when her employer closed the business but only dismissed her. The award included a 20% uplift for breaching the ACAS Code of Practice.

Course Director and Lecturer (7 years' service) v The College of West Anglia

A college lecturer with seven years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after using a compressed air hose to extinguish a workshop fire, breaching health and safety rules. The tribunal upheld the dismissal.

Self-employed quality management consultant v Shekinah Consultants Limited and Martec Limited

A self-employed consultant who worked for Shekinah Consultants Limited and Martec Limited was unable to establish he was an employee or worker, leading to the dismissal of his unfair dismissal and holiday pay claims.

Former employees v NV Projects Ltd

A Leeds tribunal ordered NV Projects Ltd to pay a group of former employees for unauthorised deductions from wages, holiday pay, and failure to provide written statements. One employee also won a breach of contract claim for notice pay.

Former employee v Fyre Group Limited

A former employee won over £41,000 for pregnancy discrimination after her employer failed to respond to the tribunal claim. The award includes loss of earnings, injury to feelings, and an ACAS uplift.

Technical Services Manager (11 years' service) v RGB HiFi & Video Limited

A Technical Services Manager who refused to attend welfare meetings or complete health questionnaires was fairly dismissed on capability grounds after 16 months' absence. The tribunal rejected his claims for unfair dismissal, redundancy pay, and arrears of pay.

NHS employee (fixed-term contract) v King's College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust

An NHS employee on a fixed-term contract had their unfair dismissal and redundancy claims thrown out because they lacked the required continuous service. The tribunal had no jurisdiction to hear the case.

Former employee (11 years' service) v Emma’s Beauty (Epsom) Limited

A former employee with 11 years' service was awarded over £4,600 after being made redundant without notice or redundancy pay by Emma’s Beauty (Epsom) Limited.

Former employee v St Cuthbert's House Limited

A former employee who took bereavement leave was awarded £540 in unpaid holiday pay and £1,560 for a wage deduction after her final pay slip wrongly deducted an overpayment she had already repaid.

Bakery operative (3.5 years' service) v Smart Dough Ltd

A bakery operative who resigned after being unable to take holiday for two years has been awarded £4,569.60 in unpaid wages, holiday pay and notice pay. The employer did not defend the claim.

Search Engine Optimisation (SEO) Lead (2 years' service) v Harrods Ltd

A tribunal rejected a constructive dismissal and disability discrimination claim by a Harrods SEO Lead, finding he was not disabled and that the employer's performance management was not a breach of contract.

MOT tester (8 years' service) v Uralmoto (UK) Ltd

An MOT tester with eight years' service was dismissed to facilitate a business transfer, making the dismissal automatically unfair. The tribunal awarded £6,837 in compensation, reduced by 10% for contributory conduct.

Social worker v Cumbria County Council

A social worker who waited over a year to bring an unfair dismissal claim after being summarily dismissed for gross misconduct had her case struck out as out of time. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for her to have claimed within the three-month limit.

Waitress (22 years' service) v Lornar Ltd

A waitress who worked for Lornar Ltd for 22 years had her unfair dismissal claim rejected because she missed the three-month time limit by several months.

Customer Sales Assistant (4 years' service) v The Co-operative Group

A customer sales assistant who resigned claiming bullying and race discrimination lost his constructive dismissal claim after tribunal found CCTV evidence contradicted his account. All claims were dismissed as unfounded and partly out of time.

Area Supervisor (10 months' service) v YBC Cleaning Services Limited

An area supervisor with 10 months' service was fairly dismissed for some other substantial reason after a restructure, despite procedural flaws, because further consultation would have been futile.

Warehouse operative / fork lift driver (4 years' service) v DHL Services Limited

A warehouse operative who refused to wear a face covering during the pandemic was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct, the tribunal ruled.

Former employees (redundant) v Blitz Communications Ltd (In Liquidation)

Blitz Communications failed to consult employees before making 20+ redundancies. The tribunal approved a protective award of 8 weeks' gross pay for each affected worker.

Cleaning supervisor (4 years' service) v Lewis & Graves Partnership Ltd

A cleaning supervisor with four years' service was unable to bring an unfair dismissal claim because her continuous service fell short of the two-year requirement after a TUPE transfer. The tribunal also dismissed her race discrimination and TUPE consultation claims as out of time.

AV Sales Manager (2 years' service) v Electec Electrical Ltd

A tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal claim by an AV Sales Manager who had less than two years' service because his employment started later than he claimed.

Process Operator (16 years' service) v ATAG Cables & Tapes Limited (in liquidation)

Two process operators with 16 years' service who signed a mutual termination agreement after being caught stealing copper were not entitled to redundancy payments, the tribunal ruled.

Former employee (alleged Accountant's Assistant) v Accountancy Business Centre Digital Limited

A tribunal has dismissed claims of unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal, and other employment rights after finding that a woman who received monthly payments from her husband's accounting firm was not an employee.

Driver specialist (12 years' service) v Babcock Land Defence Limited

A driver specialist with 12 years' service had his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims thrown out after submitting his claim form four months late, despite having been warned of the time limit.

Former employees v Mr J Miall t/a Ocean Fresh

A tribunal ordered a fish merchant to pay over £9,000 to two former employees for unpaid redundancy, notice pay, holiday pay and failure to provide written particulars.

Former employee v Total Physiotherapy Ltd (in voluntary liquidation)

A former employee was unfairly dismissed when Total Physiotherapy Ltd made him redundant without consultation, but a 100% Polkey reduction meant no compensation because the company had already gone into liquidation.

Human Resources Business Partner Lead (HR Vice President) v BSCL Realisation Ltd (in administration)

Five former Bathstore employees failed to prove their contracts transferred to Homebase after it bought 44 stores. The tribunal ruled each store was a separate economic entity and none of the claimants were assigned to a transferred store.

Salesperson (9 years' service) v Synergy (GB) Ltd

A salesperson who refused to return to work after furlough ended was found to have resigned, not been dismissed. The tribunal awarded £2,263.82 for unpaid holiday pay.

Statman and Induction Lead (NHS employee) v Barnet, Enfield and Haringey Mental Health NHS Trust

An NHS Statman and Induction Lead's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed because she started ACAS Early Conciliation after the three-month deadline, despite being wrongly told by Citizens Advice that pay in lieu of notice extended the time limit.

Former employee v Teresa Purdie

A former employee has won her claim for unfair dismissal, redundancy pay, unauthorised holiday pay deductions and breach of contract. The tribunal ordered Teresa Purdie to pay a total of £1,278.84.

Former employee (6 years' service) v Hilltop Hotel (Carlisle) Ltd

A former employee of Hilltop Hotel (Carlisle) Ltd has won claims for unfair dismissal, unpaid holiday pay and unpaid furlough pay after the employer failed to defend the case. The tribunal awarded £4,580 in total.

Head of Operations (16 years' service) v Vespertine Holidays Ltd

A tribunal found that Vespertine Holidays Ltd unfairly dismissed a Head of Operations with 16 years' service, who discovered her redundancy only when she received a P45. She was awarded £34,282.

Operations Manager (17 years' service) v Angel of Corbridge Ltd t/a The Angel Inn

A Newcastle tribunal found that Angel of Corbridge Ltd unfairly dismissed an operations manager with 17 years' service by failing to disclose the selection matrix and not considering a suitable alternative role. She was awarded £12,799.

Former employee v Arnold Sanderson Limited (in creditors' voluntary liquidation)

A former employee of Arnold Sanderson Limited has been awarded nearly £30,000 after the company dismissed him by reason of redundancy and failed to respond to his tribunal claim.

Branch manager (24 years' service) v Lancasters Property Services Limited

A branch manager who refused a suitable alternative role at a nearby office after 24 years' service has lost her claim for a redundancy payment. The tribunal found the offer was suitable and her refusal unreasonable.

Self-employed IT contractor (director of Consultco Ltd) v Investigo Ltd and Department for Education

A self-employed IT contractor who worked through his own limited company had his unfair dismissal claim struck out after the tribunal found he was neither an employee nor a worker of either respondent.

Team Leader (13 years' service) v XPO Logistics Limited

A tribunal awarded a team leader a statutory redundancy payment of £8,065 after she refused a relocation that would have increased her childcare costs, but rejected her sex discrimination claim.

Manager in Risk department v Financial Conduct Authority

A manager who developed a key financial model and made protected disclosures was dismissed for redundancy. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair because his appeal did not properly consider his whistleblowing concerns.

Former employee v Premier Cars Bangor Ltd

A former driver with COPD and back pain was unfairly dismissed and discriminated against by Premier Cars Bangor Ltd. The tribunal awarded £3,230.76 for unfair dismissal, disability discrimination, and unpaid holiday pay.

Support Practitioner v MacIntyre Care Limited

A tribunal found that a support practitioner with Mixed Connective Tissue Disease was not disabled under the Equality Act, striking out her discrimination claim for lack of medical evidence.

Former employee v Fivestars Limited

A former employee with less than two years' service won £1,316.22 for unpaid holiday pay, sick pay and wrongful dismissal after their employer failed to attend the final hearing.

Construction worker v Knights Bridge Contractors Limited

A construction worker was paid just £5 per hour and had £1,700 deducted for two allegedly missing boilers. The tribunal ordered Knights Bridge Contractors Limited to pay £13,717.47 in total.

Former employees (salon workers) v Group Momentum (Salons) Limited

Eleven salon workers were awarded over £240,000 after their employer laid them off without pay, leading to constructive unfair dismissal and breach of contract claims.

Former employee v University of Southampton NHS Foundation Trust

A former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims were dismissed after the tribunal found they were presented more than three months after dismissal, without ACAS early conciliation having been started in time.

Foster carer (from August 2012) v Blackpool Council

A foster carer who claimed unfair dismissal after being deregistered by Blackpool Council had his case struck out. The tribunal ruled that foster carers are not employees under established case law.

Security and maintenance worker (22 years' service) v Seighford Hall Nursing Home Ltd

A security and maintenance worker with 22 years' service was unfairly dismissed for gross misconduct, but the tribunal awarded no compensation because he would have been dismissed anyway and contributed to his own dismissal.

Structural fabricator v Standley Steel Stockholders

A structural fabricator who raised COVID-19 safety concerns was fairly selected for redundancy when his employer closed a business unit. The tribunal found no link between his disclosures and his dismissal.

Financial Advisor v Aspirations Financial Advice Limited

A financial advisor who sold his client bank to his employer was made redundant after scoring lowest on a matrix he never saw. The tribunal dismissed his unfair dismissal claim because he lacked the required two years' continuous service.

Concierge staff v Urbanbubble Liverpool Limited (in Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation)

A concierge staff member was awarded £3,664 after his employer entered liquidation and failed to pay redundancy, notice and holiday pay. The tribunal found the dismissal was unfair and ordered compensation.

Night concierge v Urbanbubble Liverpool Limited (in Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation)

A night concierge was automatically unfairly dismissed by Urbanbubble Liverpool Limited after being elected as an employee representative under TUPE regulations. The tribunal awarded £7,674.80 in compensation.

Head of Security Services Management (14+ years' service) v The Health and Social Care Information Centre t/a NHS Digital

A head of security services with 14 years' service had all his claims dismissed because he presented them too late. The tribunal had no power to hear them.

Sales Executive (5 years' service) v 40TUDE Ltd (Formerly J&M Insurances Services (UK) Ltd)

A sales executive with 5 years' service was unfairly dismissed after his employer decided to make him redundant before applying any selection criteria. The tribunal awarded £8,079.20, reduced by 20% for the chance he might have been dismissed fairly.

HGV driver (4 years' service) v Port Traction Limited

A tribunal found that Port Traction Limited unfairly dismissed an HGV driver for exceeding driving hours, but reduced compensation to zero because the driver would have been dismissed anyway and contributed to his own dismissal.

Employee (bus driver/transport worker) v HCT Group Operations Community Interest Company (Cic)

A transport worker was automatically unfairly dismissed when her employer failed to assign her to the correct transferring group under TUPE. The tribunal awarded £50,441.99 including a 20% ACAS uplift.

Postman and Health and Safety/Union Representative (18 years' service) v Royal Mail Group Ltd

A postman with 18 years' service was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct after failing to apply the HIT procedure, causing a vehicle to roll into a parked car. The tribunal upheld the dismissal as within the range of reasonable responses.

Former employees v Elliot House Limited

A tribunal found that Elliot House Limited unfairly dismissed most of its workforce in a redundancy process that failed to arrange employee representative elections, entitling them to a protective award, notice pay, and compensation for pension contribution breaches.

Dental practice employee (over 4 years' service) v Mrs A Abnoosian, as Personal Representative of the Estate of the late Dr V Toomassian

A dental practice employee who was not paid her final wages and was made redundant after her employer died unexpectedly has won £2,731.48 at an employment tribunal.

Former employee v Crest Communication Limited

A former employee of Crest Communication Limited was unfairly dismissed by reason of redundancy and awarded £8,097.31 for unpaid wages, holiday pay, and unfair dismissal compensation.

General manager and transport manager (28 years' service) v Flying Firkin Distribution Limited

A general manager with 28 years' service resigned after receiving emails from her boss suggesting she step down if she lacked confidence in the company. The tribunal found no breach of trust and confidence and dismissed her constructive unfair dismissal claim.

Joint pub managers (Brunton Arms, Nunthorpe) v Samuel Smith Old Brewery (Tadcaster)

Two pub managers who resigned after Samuel Smith Old Brewery deducted £4,361 from their wages for alleged stock losses have won their claims for unauthorised deductions and constructive unfair dismissal, receiving £35,791 in compensation.

Multi Skilled Operative/Hydraulic Hose Engineer v Westfield Shovels Limited

Five employees of Westfield Shovels Limited were unfairly dismissed when their jobs were lost to a service change. The tribunal found they should have been transferred to the new contractor, not made redundant.

Sales and Operator Manager (11 years' service) v Interactive Resorts Ltd

A sales and operator manager with 11 years' service was unfairly dismissed when her employer stopped paying her and later claimed gross misconduct. The tribunal found the real reason was redundancy and awarded over £30,000.

Plumber (fixed-term contract) v Shepherd’s Bush Housing Association Limited

A plumber on a fixed-term contract had his unfair dismissal and wages claims thrown out for being presented too late, and was ordered to pay £6,800 in costs for continuing to pursue a weak case after warnings.

Employee of a charity v World Shirdi Sai Baba Organisation UK (a charity)

An employee of a charity who complained about not receiving payslips and incorrect pay was dismissed soon after. The tribunal found the dismissal was not automatically unfair, but upheld claims for unlawful wage deductions and notice pay, awarding £6,309.

Bodyshop Manager (3 years' service) v Tokyo Customs Ltd

A bodyshop manager who was persuaded to keep working without pay after his employer was evicted from its premises has won £5,700 in unpaid wages and £10,382 for unfair dismissal and breach of contract.

Hair salon employee v Mrs L Trill t/a Thairapy Hair Design

A hair salon employee was fairly dismissed after her husband sent 41 threatening texts to the owner. The tribunal dismissed her unfair dismissal and holiday pay claims, and considered a costs application.

Customer Service Security Officer (7 years 9 months' service) v Wilson James Limited

A security officer who stopped attending work to care for his vulnerable mother was fairly dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal found the employer acted reasonably in dismissing for unauthorised absence, but awarded £195.72 for unpaid holiday pay.

Bar stewardess (17 years' service) v Halliwell Conservative Club

A bar stewardess with 17 years' service was unfairly dismissed when Halliwell Conservative Club closed without consulting her. The tribunal awarded £12,883.98 in redundancy and holiday pay but no compensation as closure was inevitable.

Director and shareholder (19 years' service) v Lowther Decorators Limited

A director with 19 years' service was summarily dismissed for gross misconduct after withdrawing company funds, but the employer carried out no investigation or disciplinary hearing. The tribunal awarded £68,048.

Secretary/administrator (job-share, 4 days a week) v Building Services (Kent) Ltd

A secretary/administrator was dismissed via text message without notice or reason. The tribunal found the dismissal unfair and awarded over £6,000 in compensation and holiday pay.

Operations Manager (wedding venue) v Thicket Priory Limited

A wedding venue operations manager lost her unfair dismissal claim but won £107.69 in unpaid holiday pay after being required to take holiday while on furlough.

Deputy Town Clerk (3 months' service) v Welshpool Town Council

A deputy town clerk with only three months' service was dismissed after repeatedly raising concerns about a failing fire alarm system. The tribunal found he suffered detriment for whistleblowing but dismissed his automatic unfair dismissal claim.

Chief Financial Officer/Chief Operations Officer v Leo Scheiner, Oscar Scheiner, 08344730 Limited (in voluntary liquidation), Fyrtorr Limited

A chief financial officer was dismissed by reason of redundancy when her employer entered liquidation. The tribunal awarded £9,015.92 for unpaid notice and holiday pay but dismissed claims for discrimination and unfair dismissal.

Housing Advice Worker / Housing Advisor (8 years' service) v Bermondsey Central Hall Methodist Church

A housing advisor with eight years' service was constructively dismissed after her employer instructed her to hand over work and equipment within two days, breaching the implied term of trust and confidence. The tribunal awarded £34,106.

Estimator (3 years' service) v Sowga Ltd

An estimator with 3 years' service was unfairly dismissed after his employer rushed through a redundancy consultation in just five working days. The tribunal found the process was too short and that alternative roles were not properly explored.

Director of Partnerships v JetEngage Limited

A director of partnerships was unfairly dismissed for redundancy due to a lack of consultation, but the tribunal reduced his compensation to nil because the redundancy was inevitable. He also won £1,211 for an unlawful deduction from wages.

Site supervisor/manager in window fitting v Flexwood Windows Ltd (In Voluntary Liquidation)

A tribunal ruled that a site supervisor who signed self-employed contracts with two agencies was in fact an employee of the end-user, Flexwood Windows Ltd, and awarded over £28,800 for unfair dismissal.

Solicitor (personal injury) v Charles Gregory Solicitors Ltd

A solicitor was constructively unfairly dismissed when his new employer failed to consult him about a TUPE transfer and imposed unilateral contract changes. The tribunal awarded £20,399.

Personal Assistant (11 years' service) v Gaynor Hartford

A personal assistant who was automatically unfairly dismissed after taking steps to protect herself from danger she reasonably believed to be serious and imminent has been awarded £7,394.82 by an employment tribunal.

Director – EMEA Operations (12 years' service) v Brocade Communications UK Ltd

A director with 12 years' service who had renal cancer was unfairly dismissed and denied reasonable adjustments during a redundancy alignment exercise. The tribunal awarded over £1.76 million.