Claimant won £7,675 awarded Employment Tribunal · 20 September 2022

Night concierge dismissed for acting as employee representative wins automatically unfair dismissal claim

A night concierge was automatically unfairly dismissed by Urbanbubble Liverpool Limited after being elected as an employee representative under TUPE regulations. The tribunal awarded £7,674.80 in compensation.

1 min read · Last updated 18 May 2026

Case details

Key facts

  • Mr Sinnott was employed as a night concierge by Urbanbubble Liverpool Limited.
  • He was elected as an employee representative in relation to TUPE regulations.
  • The respondent entered creditors' voluntary liquidation and its response was struck out.
  • The tribunal found the reason for dismissal was Mr Sinnott's role as employee representative.
  • Mr Sinnott was awarded £7,674.80 in total compensation.

Timeline

  1. Bubble notifies staff of replacement

    Urbanbubble Liverpool Limited emailed staff that Evolution was replacing it for all Elliot Group properties, stating TUPE would apply.

  2. Nationwide takes physical control

    Nationwide Facilities Management Limited took over physical control of the properties, and Bubble staff were refused entry.

  3. Email regarding employee representative

    Claire Howard of the respondent sent an email referencing Mr Sinnott's role as employee representative.

  4. Employment ended

    Mr Sinnott's employment with Urbanbubble Liverpool Limited ceased.

  5. Preliminary hearing day 1

    Employment Tribunal hearing on TUPE transfer issues; claimants gave evidence.

  6. Preliminary hearing day 2

    Further evidence and submissions on TUPE transfer.

  7. Preliminary hearing day 3

    Resumed hearing for additional evidence and cross-examination.

  8. Reserved judgment on TUPE

    Employment Judge McDonald issued judgment that no TUPE transfer occurred; claims against second and third respondents dismissed.

  9. Rule 21 judgment

    Judgment in favour of Mr Sinnott for automatically unfair dismissal, breach of contract, and holiday pay; total award £7,674.80.

The outcome

The tribunal ruled in favour of the night concierge, finding that his dismissal was automatically unfair due to his role as an employee representative. The respondent had entered liquidation and its response was struck out, leading to a default judgment.

Compensation breakdown:

  • Basic award: £6,408.00
  • Compensatory award: £500.00
  • Total: £7,674.80

Lessons & takeaways

  • Employees elected as representatives under TUPE regulations are protected from dismissal for carrying out those duties.
  • If an employer enters liquidation, the tribunal can still proceed and issue a default judgment if the employer fails to respond.
  • Automatically unfair dismissal claims do not require a minimum length of service to bring a claim.
  • Representatives should keep evidence of their election and any communications about their role.

What this case shows

This case illustrates the protection afforded to employee representatives under TUPE regulations. The night concierge was elected to represent colleagues during a potential transfer of employment, a role that carries legal safeguards. When the employer, Urbanbubble Liverpool Limited, dismissed him shortly after he took on that role, the tribunal found the dismissal was automatically unfair.

The employer had entered creditors' voluntary liquidation and did not defend the claim, leading to a default judgment. This highlights that even if an employer becomes insolvent, employees can still pursue claims and obtain compensation.

What the employer could have done differently

The employer could have avoided liability by respecting the claimant's role as a representative and not taking any adverse action against him for performing those duties. Had the employer continued to trade, it should have sought legal advice before dismissing an employee representative.

Why this matters

This case reinforces that the right to be an employee representative is a protected status. Employees who are elected should be aware that they cannot be dismissed or subjected to detriment for carrying out their representative functions. The compensation awarded, though modest, reflects the seriousness of the breach.

For employees in similar situations, it is important to document all communications about your representative role and any subsequent treatment by your employer. Even if your employer goes into liquidation, you may still be able to obtain a judgment and potentially recover compensation through the Insolvency Service.

Similar cases