Former employee recovers wrongful dismissal award from National Insurance Fund after employer insolvency
A former employee who won an unfair dismissal claim against a family business recovered £4,357.81 from the National Insurance Fund after the employer went into administration.
1 min read · Last updated 18 May 2026
Case details
- #rights-on-insolvency
- #unfair-dismissal
- #wrongful-dismissal
- #national-insurance-fund
- #mitigation
Key facts
- The claimant had previously succeeded in an unfair dismissal claim against Sheffield & Ford (Builders) Ltd.
- Sheffield & Ford (Builders) Ltd entered administration and the stay was lifted to obtain a remedy judgment.
- The claimant sought payment from the Secretary of State under Part XII of the Employment Rights Act 1996.
- The respondent argued for deductions from the outstanding award but the tribunal rejected this.
- The tribunal awarded the claimant £4,357.81, the balance of the wrongful dismissal award.
Timeline
-
Claimant succeeded in unfair dismissal claim
The claimant succeeded in his claim against Sheffield & Ford (Builders) Ltd.
-
Administration and stay lifted
Sheffield & Ford (Builders) Ltd entered administration and consent was obtained to lift the stay for remedy judgment.
-
Remedy judgment issued
Employment Judge Tynan awarded various sums including basic award, compensatory award, and damages for breach of contract.
-
Claim lodged with ACAS
The claimant lodged a claim against the Secretary of State for payment from the National Insurance Fund.
-
ACAS certificate issued
ACAS issued a certificate for the claim.
-
Respondent filed written submissions
The respondent filed an additional ET3 and written submissions arguing for deductions.
-
Hearing and judgment
Employment Judge Murdin heard the case and awarded the claimant £4,357.81.
The legal issue
Whether the Secretary of State must pay the outstanding balance of a wrongful dismissal award from the National Insurance Fund when the employer is insolvent, and whether deductions for mitigation should apply.
The outcome
The tribunal awarded the former employee £4,357.81, the balance of the wrongful dismissal award from the National Insurance Fund.
The key reason was that the employer was insolvent and the employee had already succeeded in his unfair dismissal claim. The Secretary of State argued for deductions but the tribunal rejected this, finding no basis to reduce the award.
Compensation:
- Total awarded: £4,357.81
Lessons & takeaways
- If your employer becomes insolvent after you win a tribunal award, you can claim unpaid sums from the National Insurance Fund under Part XII of the Employment Rights Act 1996.
- The Secretary of State may argue for deductions, but tribunals will only allow them if there is clear evidence of failure to mitigate or other statutory grounds.
- Keep records of all tribunal judgments and correspondence with administrators to support your claim against the National Insurance Fund.
- You do not need a solicitor to make this type of claim – a lay representative can assist.
When an employer goes bust after a tribunal win
This case shows what happens when an employee wins a tribunal claim but the employer becomes insolvent before paying. The former employee had already succeeded in an unfair dismissal claim against Sheffield & Ford (Builders) Ltd, a family business. The tribunal awarded him a basic award, compensatory award, and damages for breach of contract, including wrongful dismissal. But before he could be paid, the company entered administration.
Claiming from the National Insurance Fund
The employee then made a claim against the Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy under Part XII of the Employment Rights Act 1996. This part of the law allows employees to recover certain debts from the National Insurance Fund when their employer is insolvent. The employee sought payment of the outstanding wrongful dismissal award, arguing it was a debt under section 184(1)(b) of the Act.
The Secretary of State initially argued that deductions should be made, for example for failure to mitigate loss. But the tribunal rejected this, noting that the employer's insolvency had already been established and the employee was entitled to the full amount of the wrongful dismissal award. The tribunal ordered payment of £4,357.81.
Why this matters
This case is a reminder that even if your employer goes out of business, you may still be able to recover tribunal awards from the National Insurance Fund. The process involves making a claim to the Redundancy Payments Office, but it can be done without a solicitor. The key is to act promptly and provide the tribunal with evidence of the employer's insolvency and the original award.
Similar cases
Dismissed without notice and discriminated against: a double blow for a former employee
A former employee was unfairly dismissed, wrongfully dismissed without notice, and discriminated against on grounds of sex. The tribunal awarded £16,208.68, including an uplift for the employer's failure to follow the ACAS code.
Dismissed after raising health and safety concerns: a partial win for the employee
A former employee of Ian Henery Solicitors Ltd was initially found to be unfairly dismissed for raising health and safety concerns, but the unfair dismissal judgment was later revoked. The tribunal confirmed wrongful dismissal and awarded £3,336 in total.
Unfair dismissal and unpaid wages: former employee awarded £12,503
A former employee has been awarded £12,503 after an employment tribunal found she was unfairly dismissed, not given notice, and had wages unlawfully deducted by RR Swami Ltd.
Redundancy without process: food sales assistant awarded £12,651 after unfair dismissal
A food sales assistant dismissed by a butchers that went into liquidation has won £12,651 for unfair dismissal, redundancy and wrongful dismissal after the tribunal found the employer failed to follow proper procedures.
