2021

Former employee v Bath Cricket Club

A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Bath Cricket Club was allowed to proceed after the tribunal ruled that a second early conciliation certificate obtained against a differently named entity was valid, rejecting the club's attempt to strike out the claim.

Finance Director v ABP (London) Investment Limited

A finance director who made protected disclosures about his employer's finances was automatically unfairly dismissed. The tribunal awarded £754,380.97 after the employer provided false evidence and failed to attend the final hearing.

Compliance Manager (7 years' service) v Lean Education and Development Limited

A compliance manager with 7 years' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after being demoted and raising a grievance. The tribunal found the real reason was a mix of poor performance and the grievance, not misconduct, and awarded £11,885.

Nurse v Indigo Care Services Ltd t/a Orchard Care Homes

A nurse who resigned and later tried to add whistleblowing claims had her case dismissed because the tribunal found she presented her claim too late.

Former employee v Co-operative Group Limited

A former employee's claim that he was dismissed for making a protected disclosure about a colleague's alleged corruption has been struck out by the Manchester Employment Tribunal because the disclosure was based on rumours and the claims were out of time.

Journalist (20 years' service) v Bloomberg L.P.

An employment tribunal has ruled that Bloomberg L.P. fairly dismissed a journalist with 20 years' service after he failed to meet performance targets under a second improvement plan. The claim for automatic unfair dismissal based on whistleblowing was rejected.

Quality control auditor (3 months' service) v Cranswick Country Foods Plc

A quality control auditor with three months' service was dismissed for gross misconduct after admitting he falsified temperature probe records. The tribunal rejected his claim that the real reason was whistleblowing.

Director of Public Services Reform (PSR) v London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham

A director was dismissed while on sick leave, with the council backdating the dismissal letter to appear to predate her grievance. The tribunal awarded £3.78 million for disability discrimination.

Head of Finance for Grenfell (agency worker, CIPFA qualified accountant) v Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea

Two finance agency workers were sexually harassed by a colleague who said they were sleeping together and made crude remarks. The tribunal awarded £4,000 and £7,000 for injury to feelings.

Contract worker (complex complaints handler) v MBNA Ltd and Paymaster (1836) t/a Equiniti Hazell Carr

A contract worker who raised health and safety concerns was subjected to detriments and dismissed. The tribunal found he was a worker, not an employee, but still protected under whistleblowing law.

Customer care specialist (8 years' service) v Coloplast Limited

A customer care specialist with depression and anxiety was found to be disabled under the Equality Act, overturning an earlier tribunal decision that her condition was not long-term.

Live-in nanny (7 months' service) v A Limited

A live-in nanny who reported her employers to the NSPCC had her whistleblowing and discrimination claims struck out after waiting over a year to bring them to tribunal.

Finance Officer (bookkeeper/accountant) v Stratford Advice Arcade (A company limited by guarantee)

A tribunal ruled that a finance officer who worked for eight years on a freelance basis was a 'worker' but not an 'employee', meaning he can pursue claims for holiday pay and unlawful deductions but not unfair dismissal.

Former employee v ISS Facility Services Ltd

A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after they repeatedly failed to comply with case management orders and missed a deadline to respond to a strike-out application. The tribunal also refused a later request to reconsider the decision.

Consultant obstetrician and gynaecologists v Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust

Two long-serving consultant gynaecologists were unfairly dismissed by Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust, but the tribunal awarded no compensation because they would have been dismissed anyway and were wholly at fault.

School Business Manager (18 years' service) v The Governors of St Mary's Roman Catholic Primary School

A school business manager who pursued a whistleblowing claim against an interim head teacher was ordered to pay £4,800 in costs after the tribunal found her conduct unreasonable. The school later settled the redundancy claim for £12,443.

Medical doctor (diet clinic) v The Fine Clinic Limited

A medical doctor at a diet clinic was found to be a worker rather than an employee, meaning her unfair dismissal claim failed. However, her whistleblowing claim was allowed to proceed, subject to a £50 deposit order.