Claim dismissed

Senior Financial Planning and Reporting Manager (8 years' service) v North West London Integrated Care Board

A senior manager's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after he failed to disclose documents about his new job. The tribunal ordered him to pay £6,853 in costs for unreasonable conduct.

Head of Trade and Data (over 5 years' service) and Head of Finance (over 7 years' service) v Hallett Retain Services Ltd (in voluntary liquidation)

Two former employees who brought claims for unfair dismissal, discrimination and redundancy had their cases thrown out after failing to attend the final hearing or provide any evidence.

Former employee v Velocity Delivery Services Limited

A former employee who had worked for Velocity Delivery Services Limited for less than two years had their unfair dismissal and redundancy claims struck out, but was awarded £1,985.61 for an unauthorised deduction from wages.

Former employee v Brian Colledge

A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after he and his son repeatedly failed to attend hearings and did not comply with tribunal directions.

Chartered Surveyor (self-employed consultant) v Clements Agency Limited

A chartered surveyor who worked for Clements Agency Limited for nearly 30 years on a self-employed basis had his claim for unfair dismissal and discrimination struck out. The tribunal found he had no reasonable prospect of proving he was an employee.

Senior nurse (3 years' service) v Barchester Healthcare Ltd

A tribunal struck out a senior nurse's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims because she filed them more than four years after the deadline, despite knowing the time limits.

Former employee v Cinzia Morris and Ian Morris

A former employee's race and religion discrimination claims were struck out after she failed to provide a properly constructed amendment despite a tribunal order. Her solicitor's last-minute postponement request was refused.

Driver v Conexim Solutions Ltd

An employment tribunal struck out a driver's unfair dismissal and age discrimination claims after he failed to attend a case management hearing and did not comply with orders to provide details of his case.

Playgroup employee v The Committee of Pevensey and Westham Playgroup

A playgroup employee's constructive dismissal claim was struck out after she failed to respond to a strike-out warning, ending a case that had already been delayed by a police investigation.

Former employee v London Borough of Newham

A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was thrown out because he contacted ACAS two days after the three-month deadline, even though he read his dismissal email the day after it was sent.

Former employee v Circle Wood Ltd

A tribunal struck out a former employee's claim that she was discriminated against because of her caring responsibilities for her disabled mother, ruling that section 15 of the Equality Act does not cover discrimination by association.

Former employee v Extreme Networks

A former employee of Extreme Networks had all claims struck out after failing to meet the two-year service requirement for unfair dismissal and not complying with tribunal orders.

Managing Director (21 years' service) v Robert Woodhead Ltd (in liquidation)

A preliminary hearing determined that a managing director who worked across four group companies was employed only by the first respondent. Claims against the other three were dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.

Former employee v Whitbread Group Plc

A tribunal has dismissed a former employee's claims of constructive unfair dismissal, unpaid wages and race discrimination against Whitbread Group Plc because they were brought too late.

Former employee v Worker Bee UK Ltd

A tribunal struck out a former employee's claims against Worker Bee UK Ltd after she failed to comply with multiple orders and did not actively pursue her case, making a fair hearing impossible.

Former employee v BUPA Care Homes (ANS) Limited

A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against BUPA Care Homes was dismissed because she presented it nearly seven months after her dismissal, well beyond the three-month time limit. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for her to have brought the claim in time.

Former employee v Elizabeth Cardy

A former employee's unfair dismissal and redundancy claims were struck out because she had less than two years' service. Her remaining claims were also struck out after she did not attend the final hearing.

Former employee v Best Time Limited

A former employee's unfair dismissal claim against Best Time Limited was struck out after she missed the time limit to contact ACAS and failed to explain the delay.

Former employee v Financial Ombudsman Service Limited

A former complainant who claimed to be an employee of the Financial Ombudsman Service had all his claims struck out after failing to attend a preliminary hearing and providing no evidence of an employment relationship.

Hotel manager (4 years' service) v Delfino Logic Limited

A tribunal dismissed a hotel manager's claims for unfair dismissal, disability discrimination and unpaid wages because they were presented over a month late. The judge found that his ADHD did not prevent him from bringing the claim on time.

Former employee (Pension Section, then Disabled Children's Department) v Hampshire County Council

A former employee who signed a COT3 settlement for £7,000 later tried to set it aside, alleging misrepresentation about redeployment rights. The tribunal struck out all claims as an abuse of process.

Locum physiotherapist (agency worker) v Hywel Dda University Local Health Board

A locum physiotherapist who claimed he was unfairly dismissed had his case thrown out after the tribunal found he was a worker, not an employee, and failed to comply with court orders.

Former Grade 7 nurse (cardiovascular health and rehabilitation) v University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust

A former Grade 7 nurse failed to prove constructive unfair dismissal after his role was removed in a restructure. The tribunal struck out his claim and refused to add a disability discrimination claim.

Cleaner (two sites, 11 hours per week) v KGB Cleaning & Support Services Ltd

A cleaner who was made redundant after her employer lost two cleaning contracts had her unfair dismissal and race discrimination claims struck out because she presented them to the tribunal more than three months after her dismissal.

Former employee v Revere Riverside Ltd

A former employee's unfair dismissal claim was struck out after her employer was dissolved and she could not afford the £585 fee to restore it to the register.

General maintenance worker (13 years' service) v A Mead & K Hawke Farming

A general maintenance worker with 13 years' service had his unfair dismissal claim thrown out after submitting it 35 days past the deadline. The tribunal ruled it was reasonably practicable for him to have claimed on time.

Waitress (zero-hours contract) v The Aviator Hotel Ltd

A waitress on a zero-hours contract who was excluded from a redundancy process has had her unfair dismissal claim dismissed, after a tribunal ruled she was never an employee.

Senior ER Adviser (4 years' service) v St George’s University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust

A senior ER adviser who claimed unfair dismissal and a redundancy payment had her case struck out because she presented the claim while still employed. The tribunal said it had no reasonable prospects of success.

Car mechanic v AJSHM Limited

A car mechanic who claimed unfair dismissal and redundancy pay had his case struck out after he failed to comply with a tribunal order and ignored a strike-out warning. The tribunal decided the claim should be dismissed due to non-compliance.

Former employee v Alma Ironcraft Limited (Creditors Voluntary Liquidation)

A former employee who waited over a year to claim a redundancy payment lost his case because he missed the strict six-month time limit. The tribunal refused to extend time.

Former employees v Seychell Engineering and Fabrication Limited (in voluntary liquidation)

Three former employees had their claims for unfair dismissal, redundancy pay and unpaid wages dismissed after they failed to attend the tribunal hearing and provided no evidence.

Former employee v EDF Energy Limited

A former employee's unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims were struck out after he repeatedly failed to comply with tribunal orders to provide a disability impact statement, and did not attend any hearings.

Teaching Assistant and Midday Supervisor (10 years' service) v Derbyshire County Council

A teaching assistant who was dismissed on ill-health grounds had her unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims struck out after presenting them 415 days late. The tribunal found no explanation for the delay and no jurisdiction to hear the case.

Former employee v Shaw Trust Ltd

A former employee of Shaw Trust had his unfair dismissal and redundancy claims struck out because he had less than two years' service. His race and sex discrimination claims were partially struck out and partially subject to a £5 deposit order.

Accountant (7 months' service) v Tiffany & Co. (UK) Holdings Limited

An accountant who resigned during a redundancy process had his unfair dismissal and redundancy pay claims struck out because he lacked the required two years' continuous service.

Business adviser / hotel manager (4 years' service) v Masteron Group of Companies

A business adviser who was made redundant after his employer went into liquidation had his unfair dismissal claim rejected because he named the wrong company as respondent. The tribunal refused his late attempt to add the correct entity.

Farm labourer (25 years' service) v Nodewell Farm Partners

A farm labourer with 25 years' service saw his unfair dismissal claim thrown out because he submitted it one day after the deadline, despite having previous tribunal experience.

Former employee v Ion Man Limited

A tribunal dismissed a former employee's claim for unpaid wages and holiday pay after he failed to attend the telephone hearing. His application for reconsideration was refused because the notice had been sent to his email address.

Medical Laboratory Assistant (22 years' service) v University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust

A Medical Laboratory Assistant with 22 years' service had his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims dismissed by an employment tribunal because they were presented about four months after the legal deadline, despite his serious health issues.

PR and Community Manager v Arjuna Seth Shoes Limited

An employment tribunal struck out a former PR and community manager's claims of sexual harassment and victimisation after she failed to pursue them for over two and a half years, following the respondent's liquidation.

Former employee v FPM Foods Ltd

An employment tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal claim after the former employee failed to attend the final hearing and made a last-minute adjournment request with no prior notice.

Kitchen Assistant/Relief Cook (16 years' service) v Thames Reach Charity

A kitchen assistant with 16 years' service had her disability discrimination claim struck out after failing to comply with a deposit order. The tribunal found no reasonable excuse for non-payment.

NHS employee (fixed-term contract) v King's College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust

An NHS employee on a fixed-term contract had their unfair dismissal and redundancy claims thrown out because they lacked the required continuous service. The tribunal had no jurisdiction to hear the case.

Social worker v Cumbria County Council

A social worker who waited over a year to bring an unfair dismissal claim after being summarily dismissed for gross misconduct had her case struck out as out of time. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable for her to have claimed within the three-month limit.

Cleaning supervisor (4 years' service) v Lewis & Graves Partnership Ltd

A cleaning supervisor with four years' service was unable to bring an unfair dismissal claim because her continuous service fell short of the two-year requirement after a TUPE transfer. The tribunal also dismissed her race discrimination and TUPE consultation claims as out of time.

AV Sales Manager (2 years' service) v Electec Electrical Ltd

A tribunal dismissed an unfair dismissal claim by an AV Sales Manager who had less than two years' service because his employment started later than he claimed.

Process Operator (16 years' service) v ATAG Cables & Tapes Limited (in liquidation)

Two process operators with 16 years' service who signed a mutual termination agreement after being caught stealing copper were not entitled to redundancy payments, the tribunal ruled.

Driver specialist (12 years' service) v Babcock Land Defence Limited

A driver specialist with 12 years' service had his unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claims thrown out after submitting his claim form four months late, despite having been warned of the time limit.

Statman and Induction Lead (NHS employee) v Barnet, Enfield and Haringey Mental Health NHS Trust

An NHS Statman and Induction Lead's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed because she started ACAS Early Conciliation after the three-month deadline, despite being wrongly told by Citizens Advice that pay in lieu of notice extended the time limit.

Branch manager (24 years' service) v Lancasters Property Services Limited

A branch manager who refused a suitable alternative role at a nearby office after 24 years' service has lost her claim for a redundancy payment. The tribunal found the offer was suitable and her refusal unreasonable.

Self-employed IT contractor (director of Consultco Ltd) v Investigo Ltd and Department for Education

A self-employed IT contractor who worked through his own limited company had his unfair dismissal claim struck out after the tribunal found he was neither an employee nor a worker of either respondent.

Support Practitioner v MacIntyre Care Limited

A tribunal found that a support practitioner with Mixed Connective Tissue Disease was not disabled under the Equality Act, striking out her discrimination claim for lack of medical evidence.

Former employee v University of Southampton NHS Foundation Trust

A former employee's unfair dismissal and discrimination claims were dismissed after the tribunal found they were presented more than three months after dismissal, without ACAS early conciliation having been started in time.

Foster carer (from August 2012) v Blackpool Council

A foster carer who claimed unfair dismissal after being deregistered by Blackpool Council had his case struck out. The tribunal ruled that foster carers are not employees under established case law.

Head of Security Services Management (14+ years' service) v The Health and Social Care Information Centre t/a NHS Digital

A head of security services with 14 years' service had all his claims dismissed because he presented them too late. The tribunal had no power to hear them.

Plumber (fixed-term contract) v Shepherd’s Bush Housing Association Limited

A plumber on a fixed-term contract had his unfair dismissal and wages claims thrown out for being presented too late, and was ordered to pay £6,800 in costs for continuing to pursue a weak case after warnings.

Hair salon employee v Mrs L Trill t/a Thairapy Hair Design

A hair salon employee was fairly dismissed after her husband sent 41 threatening texts to the owner. The tribunal dismissed her unfair dismissal and holiday pay claims, and considered a costs application.

Assistant Manager (3 years' service) v Casual Dining Services Limited

A protective award of 90 days' pay for 23 employees was revoked because the employer company had been dissolved before the original judgment was issued, leaving the Secretary of State with no liability as guarantor.

Estate Manager v Juniper Hill Ltd

An Estate Manager who was dismissed days before reaching two years' service lost his unfair dismissal claim because the tribunal found the effective date of termination was before the qualifying period.

Employee (37 years' service) v The Commissioners for Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs

An employee who resigned after 37 years' service and serious illness had her constructive dismissal claim dismissed because she missed the three-month time limit. The tribunal found it was reasonably practicable to bring the claim in time.

Cleaner (29 years' service) v Miss B Gurney, Merali's Limited, Fordover Services Limited

A cleaner who worked for 29 years cleaning common parts of a building was found to be genuinely self-employed, meaning the tribunal had no power to hear her unfair dismissal and discrimination claims.

Former employee (family relationship with managing director) v Netbit (UK) Limited

A former employee who resigned by text messages but continued working sporadically had his unfair dismissal claim struck out as out of time. The tribunal found his employment ended on 31 December 2018, not March 2019 as he argued.